Ionospheric characteristics above martian crustal magnetic anomalies Paul Withers, M Mendillo, H Rishbeth, D Hinson, and J Arkani-Hamed Abstract #33.02.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Seismology Forum Meeting 2014:
Advertisements

Introduction to the Ionosphere
1 Ionospheres of the Terrestrial Planets Stan Solomon High Altitude Observatory National Center for Atmospheric Research
Ionosphere Climate Studied by F3 / COSMIC Constellation C. H. Liu Academia Sinica In Collaboration with Tulasi Ram, C.H. Lin and S.Y. Su.
Annihilators at Mars: Are there alternative but reasonable magnetization distributions in the Martian crust that explain the MGS magnetic field observations?
Plasma layers in the terrestrial, martian and venusian ionospheres: Their origins and physical characteristics Martin Patzold (University of Cologne) and.
Space Weather Workshop, Boulder, CO, April 2013 No. 1 Ionospheric plasma irregularities at high latitudes as observed by CHAMP Hermann Lühr and.
Modeling the effects of solar flares on the ionosphere of Mars Paul Withers, Joei Wroten, Michael Mendillo, Phil Chamberlin, and Tom Woods
Observations of the Effects of Solar Flares on Earth and Mars Paul Withers, Michael Mendillo, Joei Wroten, Henry Rishbeth, Dave Hinson, Bodo Reinisch
Morphology of meteoric plasma layers in the ionosphere of Mars as observed by the Mars Global Surveyor Radio Science Experiment Withers, Mendillo, Hinson.
Measurements of Winds in the Martian Upper Atmosphere from the MGS Accelerometer Paul Withers*, Steve Bougher, and Gerry Keating 34th DPS Meeting
The Mars Ionosphere: More than a Chapman Layer
Meteor layers in the martian and venusian ionospheres: Their connection to meteor showers Paul Withers (Boston University), Martin Patzold (University.
Ionospheric Electric Field Variations during Geomagnetic Storms Simulated using CMIT W. Wang 1, A. D. Richmond 1, J. Lei 1, A. G. Burns 1, M. Wiltberger.
SCHOOL OF PHYSICS Space Weather in the Equatorial Ionosphere Robert Stening School of Physics, University of New South Wales Acknowledge help from Dr J.
Anomalous Ionospheric Profiles Association of Anomalous Profiles and Magnetic Fields The Effects of Solar Flares on Earth and Mars.
GG 450 Modeling Magnetics February 14, TOTAL FIELD ANOMALIES: Recall the components of the earth's field: We can define the field caused by induced.
Research at Boston University on the upper atmosphere of Mars Paul Withers and Majd Matta MEX Workshop ESTEC, The Netherlands.
Crustal Fields in the Solar Wind: Implications for Atmospheric Escape Dave Brain LASP University of Colorado July 24, 2003.
Comparative Aeronomy at Earth and Mars Paul Withers Boston University In collaboration with Michael Mendillo and BU colleagues, David.
Space Physics at Mars Paul Withers Journal Club Research Talk Center for Space Physics, Boston University Aims: Show students how principles.
Observations of Open and Closed Magnetic Field Lines at Mars: Implications for the Upper Atmosphere D.A. Brain, D.L. Mitchell, R. Lillis, R. Lin UC Berkeley.
Comparative meteor science – The effects of meteoroids on planetary atmospheres and ionospheres Paul Withers and Meers Oppenheim Boston University
New theoretical tools for studying ionospheric electrodynamics Paul Withers Boston University SA51A-0237 Friday :00-10:00.
Space weather effects on the Mars ionosphere due to solar flares and meteors Paul Withers 1, Michael Mendillo 1, and Dave Hinson Boston University,
The Influence of Solar Variability on the Ionospheres of Earth and Mars Paul Withers Interim CEDAR Postdoc Report Supervisor: Michael.
A better way of modeling ionospheric electrodynamics Paul Withers Boston University Center for Space Physics Journal Club Tuesday (Monday)
Use of Martian Magnetic Field Topology as an Indicator of the Influence of Crustal Sources on Atmospheric Loss D.A. Brain, D.L. Mitchell, R. Lillis, R.
MGS Accelerometer-derived profiles of Upper Atmospheric Pressures and Temperatures: Similarities, Differences, and Winds Withers, Bougher, and Keating.
Theoretical Simulations of the Martian Ionosphere and Comparisons to Observations (How do thermospheric tides and variations in solar flux affect ionospheric.
Determination of upper atmospheric properties on Mars and other bodies using satellite drag/aerobraking measurements Paul Withers Boston University, USA.
The Martian Ionosphere in Regions of Crustal Magnetic Fields Paul Withers, Michael Mendillo, Dave Hinson DPS 2004, Louisville, Kentucky,
V. M. Sorokin, V.M. Chmyrev, A. K. Yaschenko and M. Hayakawa Strong DC electric field formation in the ionosphere over typhoon and earthquake regions V.
How do gravity waves determine the global distributions of winds, temperature, density and turbulence within a planetary atmosphere? What is the fundamental.
Testing Simple Parameterizations for the Basic Characteristics of the Martian Ionosphere (How does the martian ionosphere respond to changes in solar flux?)
The Intrinsic Magnetic Field of Saturn: A Special One or an Averaged One? H. Cao, C. T. Russell, U. R. Christensen, M. K. Dougherty Magnetospheres of the.
Global Distribution of Equatorial Plasma Bubbles in the Pre-midnight Sector 3 Mar Jaeheung PARK.
1 Origin of Ion Cyclotron Waves in the Polar Cusp: Insights from Comparative Planetology Discovery by OGO-5 Ion cyclotron waves in other planetary magnetospheres.
For MCS E p analysis limited to km above the surface, a vertical domain similar to the MGS RS analysis, results differ from the MGS RS results (compare.
Simulations of the effects of extreme solar flares on technological systems at Mars Paul Withers, Boston University Sunday
Abstract: A simple representative model of the ionosphere of Mars is fit to the complete set of electron density profiles from the Mars Global Surveyor.
PAPER I. ENA DATA ANALYSIS RESULTS. The Imager for Magnetopause-to- Aurora Global Exploration (IMAGE) missionis the first NASA Mid-size Explorer (MIDEX)
The ionosphere of Mars never looked like this before Paul Withers Boston University Space Physics Group meeting, University of Michigan.
1 The effects of solar flares on planetary ionospheres Paul Withers and Michael Mendillo Boston University 725 Commonwealth Avenue, Boston MA 02215, USA.
Introduction to Space Weather Jie Zhang CSI 662 / PHYS 660 Spring, 2012 Copyright © Ionosphere II: Radio Waves April 19, 2012.
Ionospheric Current and Aurora CSI 662 / ASTR 769 Lect. 12 Spring 2007 April 24, 2007 References: Prolss: Chap , P (main) Tascione: Chap.
Gurnett, 2010 BqBq B tot Ring Current and Asymmetric Ring Current Magnetospheres of the Outer Planets - Boston, MA July 13, 2011 BRBqBfBtBRBqBfBt dB q.
Abstract Dust storms are well known to strongly perturb the state of the lower atmosphere of Mars, yet few studies have investigated their impact on the.
Observations of the effects of meteors on the ionospheres of Venus, Earth and Mars Paul Withers 1, A. A. Christou 2, M. Mendillo 1, M. Pätzold 3, K. Peter.
1 Observations of tides and temperatures in the martian atmosphere by Mars Express SPICAM stellar occultations Paul Withers 1, Jean-Loup Bertaux 2, Franck.
The identification of the fluctuation effects related to the turbulence and “permanent” layers in the atmosphere of Venus from radio occultation data V.N.Gubenko.
Characterizing the magnetic fields of Mars: What do the tell us about the history of Mars? Michael Purucker, Raytheon Planetary Geodyn. Laboratory,
An observational study of the response of the thermosphere of Mars to lower atmospheric dust storms Paul Withers and Robert Pratt Boston University – Abstract.
COSMIC Ionospheric measurements Jiuhou Lei NCAR ASP/HAO Research review, Boulder, March 8, 2007.
How the ionosphere of Mars works Paul Withers Boston University Department Lecture Series, EAPS, MIT Wednesday :00-17:00.
The 3rd Swarm Science Meeting, June 2014, Copenhagen, Denmark
Static Stability in the Global UTLS Observations of Long-term Mean Structure and Variability using GPS Radio Occultation Data Kevin M. Grise David W.
Planetary Ionospheres
The ionosphere is much more structured and variable than ever predicted. Solar Driven Model Since 2000, we have seen more, very clear evidence that the.
Physical Setting Mapping Terms Part 2.
Exploring the ionosphere of Mars
SA13A-1873 Numerical Simulations of the Ionosphere of Mars During a Solar Flare Lollo2, P. Withers1, 2 M. Mendillo1, 2, K. Fallows1,
Exploring the ionosphere of Mars
Comparisons and simulations of same-day observations of the ionosphere of Mars by radio occultation experiments on Mars Global Surveyor and Mars Express.
Recovery of Mars ionospheric electron density profiles acquired by the Mariner 9 radio occultation instrument N. Ferreri, Paul Withers, S. Weiner Abstract.
The Ionosphere Equatorial Anomaly.
Simulations of the response of the Mars ionosphere to solar flares and solar energetic particle events Paul Withers EGU meeting Vienna,
The Vertical Structure of the Martian Ionosphere
Radar Soundings of the Ionosphere of Mars
by Andreas Keiling, Scott Thaller, John Wygant, and John Dombeck
Presentation transcript:

Ionospheric characteristics above martian crustal magnetic anomalies Paul Withers, M Mendillo, H Rishbeth, D Hinson, and J Arkani-Hamed Abstract #33.02 DPS Conference We studied several thousand electron density profiles from the Mars Global Surveyor Radio Science experiment. Electron densities in some of these profiles change significantly over vertical distances as short as 1--2 km, often causing localized ``bite-outs''. These ``anomalous'' profiles are preferentially located above crustal magnetic anomalies. Anomalous features and their association with strong magnetic fields are also seen in profiles from Mariner 9. The probability of a profile being anomalous depends on the orientation of the magnetic field, suggesting localized electrodynamic effects upon otherwise global photochemical ionospheric processes. On Mars, unlike most other planets, the magnetic field has a short characteristic lengthscale, so its effects on the ionosphere will vary over short horizontal distances. We discuss possible ionospheric dynamo processes and encourage additional ionospheric observations over regions of strong crustal magnetic field.

MGS RS Coverage Several thousand profiles between 60N and 86N 220 profiles between 64S and 70S –6 to 29 May 1999 –69.1S to 64.7S –LST = 12.2 hrs to 12.0 hrs –SZA = 86.9 to 78.6 degrees –Ls = 135 to 146 degrees

Three MGS RS electron density profiles. Case 1 is 0320A58A, a typical NH profile, case 2 is 9132I11A, a typical SH profile, and case 3 is 9149E12A, a SH profile with an anomalous feature. For display purposes, electron densities in case 1 have been multiplied by 1, those in case 2 by 10, and those in case 3 by sigma uncertainties are marked by shaded regions.

Six anomalous electron density profiles. The height of each anomalous feature is marked by a thick horizontal bar.

Anomalous Profiles If (  N/  z) > N max / 6 km and  N/  N > 1/2, then we call the profile “anomalous” 5 of 3529 NH profiles are anomalous (0.14%) 20 of 220 SH profiles are anomalous (9.1%) –17 of 43 profiles in E range are anomalous –3 of 177 profiles outside E range are anomalous Some Mariner 9 profiles are anomalous, but no PVO profiles from Venus are anomalous

Spatial Correlations Cause of anomalous features must account for absence of anomalous profiles in NH and concentration in longitude of SH anomalous profiles. Only satisfactory explanation is magnetic field 16 of 20 anomalous SH profiles occur where B exceeds 100 nT at 150 km. B never exceeds this threshold between 60N and 86N

Anomalous MGS ionospheric profiles (crosses) and normal profiles (dots) from the Southern Hemisphere in The magnetic field at 150 km is shown by dotted contours at 100 nT and solid contours at 200 nT. Regions where the magnetic field is stronger than 200 nT are shaded.

Electron density profiles from Mariner 9. Some of these profiles appear anomalous after close inspection. The clearest examples, revolutions 19, 22, and 48, are circled. From Zhang et al. (1990)

Anomalous ionospheric profiles (crosses) and normal profiles (dots) from revolutions 1-79 of Mariner 9 in Profiles from revolutions 2, 3, 4, 8, 12, 19, 22, 25, 29, 31, 48, and 54 appear to be anomalous. The magnetic field at 150 km is shown by dotted contours at 100 nT and solid contours at 200 nT. Regions where the magnetic field is stronger than 200 nT are shaded.

Map of the magnetic field of Mars at MGS mapping altitude of 400 (+/-30) km. The radial component of the magnetic field associated with crustal sources is illustrated using the color scale shown. Isomagnetic contours are drawn for Br = +/- 10, 20, 50, 100, 200 nT.

Effects of Geometry of Magnetic Field and Occultation Inclination and azimuth affect whether a profile is anomalous or not. –Azimuthal dependence may be related to direction of the neutral wind or of the MGS-Earth ray path. Both have preferred directions. Models predict south-eastward to south-eastward winds of ms -1. The MGS-Earth ray path was always degrees west of north. Define azimuth, Az, such that 0<Az<180 and inclination, I, such that 0<I<90 23 profiles occur where B>100nT and I<30 at 150 km. 13 of the 23 have 45<Az<135, of which 1 is anomalous, whereas 6 of the 10 profiles outside this Az range are anomalous 41 profiles occur where B>100 nT and I> of the 41 have 45<Az<135, of which 7 are anomalous, whereas 2 of the 14 profiles outside this Az range are anomalous

Discussion Magnetic fields affect plasma transport within ionosphere, plasma instabilities (equatorial electrojet and equatorial instabilities near sunset), and influx of charged particles from space. All are possible causes of anomalous profiles. Anomalous profiles are sharp vertical changes in electron density, or horizontal changes, or both, that have a spatial scale of a few km. Modelling is needed to determine the cause of anomalous features, and the assumptions inherent in the data inversion should also be considered.

Magnetic fieldline that passes through the height of the anomalous feature (150.5 km) in profile 9129N30A at the profile’s latitude (68.6S) and longitude (165.6E). Magnetic fieldlines on Mars are very different from terrestrial dipolar fieldlines. In this example, the crest of the fieldline is only a scale height above the anomalous feature.

Martian Ionospheric Dynamo Mars has strong winds, magnetic fields, and plasma, so dynamo action could occur on Mars. This could be connected with the anomalous features. in /  i = 1 at h i, 190 km and en /  e at he, 120 km, when B=100 nT. Ions are bound to fieldlines above h i and electrons are bound to fieldlines above h e. The dynamo region, which is between h e and h i, can span the main ionospheric peak on Mars.

Conductivities Assume N = 3E4 cm -3 and H = 10 km  Ped peaks at h e and h i, has peak value Ne/2B, thickness 2H, and height- integrated value  Ped = 2NeH/B = 1000 mho, greater than the Earth’s 10 mho.  Hall is Ne/B between h e and h i, so  Hall = 3000 mho, greater than the Earth’s 20 mho.

Currents and Induced Field Neutral wind U induces electric field of BU, which drives a Hall current of  Hall BU = 30 A km -1, greater than Earth’s 10 A km -1 This current in turn induces a magnetic field of  0  Hall BU = (Ne/B) BU  0 (h i - h e ) = 40 nT, greater than Earth’s 10 nT. The induced field of 40 nT, which is independent of B, is comparable to magnetic field strength in martian ionosphere. Martian ionospheric currents may significantly modify the magnetic field that produces them

Conclusions Some martian ionospheric profiles have large changes in electron density over vertical distances as short as 1-2 km. These anomalous features are seen in MGS and Mariner 9 data, but not in Venus data. Anomalous profiles are concentrated over regions of strong magnetic field. The abundance of anomalous profiles is affected by the inclination and azimuth of the magnetic field The martian ionosphere should exhibit electrodynamic phenomena not seen at Earth, such as localized dynamo regions and local variations in transport processes