Presentation is loading. Please wait.

Presentation is loading. Please wait.

What IE is not and is not Male Circumcision Impact Evaluation Meeting Johannesburg, South Africa January 18-23, 2010 Nancy Padian UC Berkeley.

Published byShanna Lyons Modified over 8 years ago

Similar presentations

Presentation on theme: "What IE is not and is not Male Circumcision Impact Evaluation Meeting Johannesburg, South Africa January 18-23, 2010 Nancy Padian UC Berkeley."— Presentation transcript:

1 What IE is not and is not Male Circumcision Impact Evaluation Meeting Johannesburg, South Africa January 18-23, 2010 Nancy Padian UC Berkeley

2 Traditional randomized “eficacy” controlled trials (RCTs) Targets individuals or communities evaluator directly controls implementation Intensive in terms of cost, training Implementation is perfect Does not consider adherence, migration or other factors that might have diluted the effect Efficacy/ highest internal validity (not real world) 3/5/2016

3 How is IE different from M&E? M&E: Evaluating how a program is implemented –Is the program being implemented as designed? –Could the operations be more efficient? –Are the benefits getting to those intended? –Costing and accounting –Monitoring trends –Are indicators moving in the right direction? –No ability for intervention attribution IE: Estimating the effect of the program

4 M&E: monitoring & process evaluation Descriptiveanalysis Causalanalysis What was the effect of the program on outcomes? How would outcomes change under alternative program designs? Is the program cost-effective? Is program being implemented efficiently? Is program targeting the right population? Are outcomes moving in the right direction?  Impact Evaluation:

5 Monitoring and Evaluation Results Pyramid Source: UNAIDS, The World Bank. Monitoring and Evaluation Operations Manual. 2002 NUMBER OF PROJECTS LEVELS OF EVALUATION EFFORTS ALLMOSTSOMEFEW MONITORINGEVALUATION INPUTS OUTPUTS OUTCOMES IMPACT

6 Monitoring and Evaluation Results Pyramid Source: UNAIDS, The World Bank. Monitoring and Evaluation Operations Manual. 2002 NUMBER OF PROJECTS POTENTIAL FOR RESULTS ATTRIBUTION ALLMOSTSOMEFEW MONITORINGEVALUATION INPUTS OUTPUTS OUTCOMES IMPACT Resources (fixed or mobile) Staff Funds Supplies Training No. of procedures Condom availability Trained staff Service quality Short-term and intermediate effects: Behavior change STIs Long-term effects: HIV/AIDS Mortality Economic impact

7 Is MC being delivered as planned? Does outreach to women increase uptake? What are the trends in HIV prevalence? Does MC affect prevention behavior? What is a precise estimate of MC effectiveness?  M&E  IE  M&E  IE

Download ppt "What IE is not and is not Male Circumcision Impact Evaluation Meeting Johannesburg, South Africa January 18-23, 2010 Nancy Padian UC Berkeley."

Similar presentations

PAYING FOR PERFORMANCE In PUBLIC HEALTH: Opportunities and Obstacles Glen P. Mays, Ph.D., M.P.H. Department of Health Policy and Administration UAMS College.

PAYING FOR PERFORMANCE In PUBLIC HEALTH: Opportunities and Obstacles Glen P. Mays, Ph.D., M.P.H. Department of Health Policy and Administration UAMS College.
Explanation of slide: Logos, to show while the audience arrive.

Explanation of slide: Logos, to show while the audience arrive.
Women and ARV-based Prevention: Challenges and Opportunities Tim Mastro, MD, DTM&H AIDS 2014 Melbourne, Australia 24 July 2014.

Women and ARV-based Prevention: Challenges and Opportunities Tim Mastro, MD, DTM&H AIDS 2014 Melbourne, Australia 24 July 2014.
Integration: Intersection for Reproductive Health and HIV Programs: the Kenyan Experience Family Health International Sponsored Satellite Session World.

Integration: Intersection for Reproductive Health and HIV Programs: the Kenyan Experience Family Health International Sponsored Satellite Session World.
Health Impact Evaluation: An Introduction Temina Madon, PhD Executive Director Center of Evaluation for Global Action University of California, Berkeley.

Health Impact Evaluation: An Introduction Temina Madon, PhD Executive Director Center of Evaluation for Global Action University of California, Berkeley.
Developing a Logic Model

Developing a Logic Model
An Introduction to Monitoring and Evaluation for National TB Programs.

An Introduction to Monitoring and Evaluation for National TB Programs.
Introduction to Monitoring and Evaluation for National TB Programs 20 September 2005.

Introduction to Monitoring and Evaluation for National TB Programs 20 September 2005.
M&E Framework for Programmes for Most-at-Risk Populations

M&E Framework for Programmes for Most-at-Risk Populations
Objectives and Indicators for MCH Programs MCH in Developing Countries January 25, 2011.

Objectives and Indicators for MCH Programs MCH in Developing Countries January 25, 2011.
Results-Based Management: Logical Framework Approach

Results-Based Management: Logical Framework Approach
1 Designing a Monitoring and Evaluation System for a Rural Travel and Transport Project Michael Bamberger Gender and Development Group The World Bank RTTP.

1 Designing a Monitoring and Evaluation System for a Rural Travel and Transport Project Michael Bamberger Gender and Development Group The World Bank RTTP.
Objectives and Indicators for MCH Programs

Objectives and Indicators for MCH Programs
Teresa Guthrie M.PH (Health Economics) HIV modelling for in-country ownership solutions – generation of evidence IAS Conference, Washington DC, 19-20 July.

Teresa Guthrie M.PH (Health Economics) HIV modelling for in-country ownership solutions – generation of evidence IAS Conference, Washington DC, July.
Introduction to Impact Evaluation: What is it and why do we use it? Male Circumcision Impact Evaluation Meeting Johannesburg, South Africa January 18-23,

Introduction to Impact Evaluation: What is it and why do we use it? Male Circumcision Impact Evaluation Meeting Johannesburg, South Africa January 18-23,
Centre for University Continuing Education under mandate from the Federal Office of Public Health Universität Bern Evaluation in Public Health – Lessons.

Centre for University Continuing Education under mandate from the Federal Office of Public Health Universität Bern Evaluation in Public Health – Lessons.
Financial Incentives & HIV prevention in Sub-Saharan Africa: Evidence from Three Experimental Interventions Berk Özler & Damien de Walque Development Research.

Financial Incentives & HIV prevention in Sub-Saharan Africa: Evidence from Three Experimental Interventions Berk Özler & Damien de Walque Development Research.
Tracking Expenditure for HIV and AIDS in Africa ~ Cross-Country Comparisons Guthrie, T., Kioko, U. Inaugural Conference of the African Health Economics.

Tracking Expenditure for HIV and AIDS in Africa ~ Cross-Country Comparisons Guthrie, T., Kioko, U. Inaugural Conference of the African Health Economics.
Overview Burkina--- ART Population: 11 millions Prevalence: 6.6% (surveillance data) Estimate of 650,000 PLWHA 300 peoples with red cross 2000 people to.

Overview Burkina--- ART Population: 11 millions Prevalence: 6.6% (surveillance data) Estimate of 650,000 PLWHA 300 peoples with red cross 2000 people to.
Monitoring and Evaluation Module 12 – March 2010.

Monitoring and Evaluation Module 12 – March 2010.

Similar presentations

Ads by Google