Presentation is loading. Please wait.

Presentation is loading. Please wait.

Trade policy and food price volatility in LIFDCs by David Hallam Food and Agriculture Organization Discussion: Paulo Bastos World Bank.

Similar presentations


Presentation on theme: "Trade policy and food price volatility in LIFDCs by David Hallam Food and Agriculture Organization Discussion: Paulo Bastos World Bank."— Presentation transcript:

1 Trade policy and food price volatility in LIFDCs by David Hallam Food and Agriculture Organization Discussion: Paulo Bastos World Bank

2 Summary A. Public goods provided by FAO 1.GIEWS price tool 2.Food and Agriculture Policy Decision Analysis (FAPDA) 3.Reports, country-case studies B. Trade policy changes in response to the 2007-08 food price crisis and some of their impacts (focus on LIFDCs and cereals)

3 Trade policy responses to 2007/2008 food price crisis 1. Reduction of import tariffs -Dominant response in the face of price hikes (consistent with Martin and Anderson, 2012 AJAE; Bastos, Straume and Urrego, 2013 JIE) -Frequently led to permanent reductions in import tariffs (liberalizing effect) - interesting finding - would like to see more systematic research on this issue -Likely impacts: - all else equal, reduction of food prices faced by domestic consumers; - if all countries do this at the same time, world price spikes may be exacerbated (Martin and Anderson, 2012) - if permanent and generalized, tariff reductions would be expected to reduce price levels faced by consumers, increase trade volumes, and raise consumer welfare in a permanent way

4 Trade policy responses to 2007/2008 food price crisis 1. Reduction in import tariffs -If permanent, tariff reductions will cease to become a relevant stabilization instrument - In fact, import tariffs are already low in many LIFDCs

5 Trade policy responses to 2007/2008 food price crisis

6

7 1. Reduction in import tariffs -Need to consider other instruments to address food security -Temporary import subsidies are not targeted to the poor, are difficult to finance, and have collective action problems -Optimal storage policies appear to be difficult to implement in many countries and are also likely to have collective action problems -Food/cash subsidies in the context of social safety nets targeted to the poor appear to be a superior (first best) policy option -But several low income net food importers may lack institutional capacity to implement them effectively? (Needs to be part of longer term policy, not just designed/implemented in times of crises)

8 Trade policy responses to 2007/2008 food price crisis Methodological point: -A “macro definition” of net food importers hides a lot of within- country heterogeneity -A large share of food imports may be consumed by richer/urban households -Even in net food importing countries, incomes of the poorer households and regions are often directly or indirectly linked with agricultural production/prices (even in the short term?) -This within-country heterogeneity may be behind apparent schizophrenia of trade policies adopted in these countries (e.g. removing import tariffs and imposing import quotas) – warrants more research -Puts additional limits to the use of trade policy (macro instrument) to address issues of food security driven by price volatility

9 Trade policy responses to 2007/2008 food price crisis 2. Export restrictions -Used less frequently than import tariffs in these countries during 2007-08 crisis -Typically imposed temporarily (unlike reductions in import tariffs) -Often are an ineffective stabilization instruments -Even if apparently effective for domestic price stabilization, they are worrisome in terms of potential effects on world prices due to collective action problems -Negative impacts on local production, wrong signal to longer term supply and export decisions by firms -Firm-level literature trade literature points to high sunk costs of exporting and emphasizes negative role of trade policy uncertainty for export performance (Limao and Handley, 2012, 2013)


Download ppt "Trade policy and food price volatility in LIFDCs by David Hallam Food and Agriculture Organization Discussion: Paulo Bastos World Bank."

Similar presentations


Ads by Google