1. CPD Questionnaire Presentation of the Results

2. 2 Members organisations filled out the questionnaire Czech Republic Croatia Denmark Finland Hungary Malta Netherlands Poland Portugal Romania Slovenia Spain Sweden Turkey United Kingdom (did not fill out, provided a guidence note on maitaining competence to practice)

3. 3 Survey of different CPD Systems of the member organisations of the ACE

4. 4 1. Does a system of CPD for Architects exist in your organisation? 86% 14% Czech Republic, Croatia, Denmark, Finland, Hungary, Netherlands, Portugal, Romania, Slovenia, Spain, Sweden, Turkey Malta, Poland

5. 5 2. Is this CPD system required by law? 82% 18% Croatia, Hungary, Netherlands Czech Republic, Denmark, Finland, Portugal, Romania, Slovenia, Spain, Sweden, Turkey

6. 6 3. Is this CPD system an obligation built into your Code of Conduct? 38% 62% Croatia, Hungary, Netherlands, Romania, Slovenia Czech Republic, Denmark, Finland, Portugal, Spain, Sweden, Turkey

7. 7 4. Is it compulsory for professional practice? 33% 67% Croatia, Hungary, Netherlands, Romania ( from 2011 ) Czech Republic, Denmark, Finland, Portugal, Slovenia, Sweden, Turkey

8. 8 4. Is it compulsory for professional practice? ( continued ) If yes: CroatiaHungaryFinlandNetherlandsRomania How many hours/credits /points are compulsory for a defined period? 100 p10-20 hours + 20 p 105 hours 30 (BNA), 6 (law) 100 p What is the duration of the defined period? 5 years 7 years1 year5 years

9. 9 5. Who regulates the system? on national scale Czech Republic, Finland, Netherlands, Romania, Turkey Netherlands Croatia, Hungary Denmark, Portugal, Slovenia, Spain, Sweden 5 12 5

10. 10 6. Who provides the CPD courses? 12 Czech Republic, Croatia, Denmark, Finland, Hungary, Netherlands, Portugal, Romania, Slovenia, Spain, Sweden, Turkey 9 Czech Republic, Croatia, Denmark, Finland, Hungary, Netherlands, Romania, Slovenia, Spain 10 Czech Republic, Croatia, Denmark, Finland, Hungary, Netherlands, Portugal, Romania, Slovenia, Spain 1 Finland

11. 11 7. What level of training is provided? 12 Czech Republic Croatia, Denmark, Finland, Hungary, Netherlands, Portugal, Romania, Slovenia, Spain, Sweden, Turkey 12 Czech Republic Croatia, Denmark, Finland, Hungary, Netherlands, Portugal, Romania, Slovenia, Spain, Sweden, Turkey 12 Czech Republic Croatia, Denmark, Finland, Hungary, Netherlands, Portugal, Romania, Slovenia, Spain, Sweden, Turkey 10 Czech Republic Denmark, Hungary, Netherlands, Portugal, Romania, Slovenia, Spain, Sweden, Turkey 7 Denmark,Hungary, Portugal, Romania, Slovenia, Spain, Turkey Finland, Portugal 2

12. 12 8. How is the CPD delivered? 10 Czech Republic Croatia, Finland, Hungary, Netherlands, Portugal, Romania, Slovenia, Spain, Turkey 10 Czech Republic Denmark, Finland, Hungary, Netherlands, Portugal, Romania, Slovenia, Spain, Sweden, 11 Czech Republic Croatia, Denmark, Hungary, Netherlands, Portugal, Romania, Slovenia, Spain, Sweden, Turkey 10 Czech Republic Croatia, Hungary, Netherlands, Portugal, Romania, Slovenia, Spain, Sweden, Turkey 11 Czech Republic Croatia, Denmark, Finland, Hungary, Netherlands, Portugal, Romania, Slovenia, Spain, Turkey 4 4 Hungary, Romania, Slovenia, Spain, 1 Finland

13. 13 9. What methods are employed? 12 Czech Republic Croatia, Denmark, Finland, Hungary, Netherlands, Portugal, Romania, Slovenia, Spain, Sweden, Turkey 4 Hungary, Romania, Spain, Turkey (from 2011) 6 Czech Republic Croatia, Hungary, Netherlands, Portugal, Slovenia, 6 Czech Republic Netherlands, Romania, Slovenia, Sweden, Turkey 2 Czech Republic, Finland

14. 14 10. What fields are included? 12 Czech Republic Croatia, Denmark, Finland, Hungary, Netherlands, Portugal, Romania, Slovenia, Spain, Sweden, Turkey 12 Czech Republic Croatia, Denmark, Finland, Hungary, Netherlands, Portugal, Romania, Slovenia, Spain, Sweden, Turkey 11 Czech Republic Denmark, Finland, Hungary, Netherlands, Portugal, Romania, Slovenia, Spain, Sweden, Turkey 12 Czech Republic Croatia, Denmark, Finland, Hungary, Netherlands, Portugal, Romania, Slovenia, Spain, Sweden, Turkey

15. 15 10. What fields are included? (continued) 12 Czech Republic Croatia, Denmark, Finland, Hungary, Netherlands, Portugal, Romania, Slovenia, Spain, Sweden, Turkey 12 Czech Republic Croatia, Denmark, Finland, Hungary, Netherlands, Portugal, Romania, Slovenia, Spain, Sweden, Turkey 11 Czech Republic Croatia, Denmark, Finland, Hungary, Netherlands, Portugal, Romania, Slovenia, Spain, Turkey 9 Czech Republic Croatia, Denmark, Finland, Hungary, Romania, Slovenia, Spain, Turkey

16. 16 10. What fields are included? (continued) 9 Czech Republic Hungary, Netherlands, Portugal, Romania, Slovenia, Spain, Sweden, Turkey 9 Czech Republic Croatia, Hungary, Netherlands, Portugal, Romania, Slovenia, Spain, Turkey 11 Czech Republic Croatia, Denmark, Finland, Hungary, Netherlands, Portugal, Romania, Slovenia, Spain, Turkey 9 Czech Republic Croatia, Hungary, Netherlands, Portugal, Romania, Slovenia, Spain, Turkey

17. 17 10. What fields are included? (continued) 11 Czech Republic Croatia, Denmark, Finland, Hungary, Netherlands, Portugal, Romania, Slovenia, Spain, Turkey Czech Republic Croatia, Denmark, Finland, Hungary, Netherlands, Portugal, Romania, Slovenia, Spain, Turkey Czech Republic Croatia, Denmark, Finland, Hungary, Netherlands, Portugal, Romania, Slovenia, Spain, Turkey 11 Czech Republic Croatia, Denmark, Finland, Hungary, Netherlands, Portugal, Romania, Slovenia, Spain, Turkey 11

18. 18 10. What fields are included? (continued) 10 6 7 8 Czech Republic Croatia, Denmark, Hungary, Netherlands, Portugal, Romania, Slovenia, Spain, Turkey Czech Republic Croatia, Denmark, Hungary, Netherlands, Portugal, Romania, Slovenia, Spain, Turkey Netherlands, Portugal, Romania, Slovenia, Spain, Turkey Czech Republic Hungary, Netherlands, Romania, Slovenia, Spain, Turkey Czech Republic Denmark, Hungary, Netherlands, Romania, Slovenia, Spain, Turkey

19. 19 10. What fields are included? (continued) 8 11 3 Czech Republic Hungary, Netherlands, Portugal, Romania, Slovenia, Spain, Turkey Czech Republic Denmark,Finland, Hungary, Netherlands, Portugal, Romania, Slovenia, Spain, Sweden, Turkey Czech Republic Denmark,Finland, Hungary, Netherlands, Portugal, Romania, Slovenia, Spain, Sweden, Turkey Finland, Hungary, Turkey

20. 20 11. Do you have a database of the content of your CPD Programme? 4 6 2 Hungary, Czech Republic, Denmark, Netherlands Croatia, Portugal, Slovenia Spain, Sweden, Turkey Finland, Romania

21. 21 12. Do you regularly evaluate your CPD Programme? 9 2 1 Sweden Finland, Romania Czech Republic Croatia, Denmark, Hungary, Netherlands, Portugal,Slovenia, Spain, Turkey

22. 22 13. What are the profiles of the CPD teaching staff? 11 12 11 Czech Republic Croatia, Denmark, Finland, Hungary, Netherland, Portugal, Romania, Slovenia, Spain, Sweden, Turkey Czech Republic Croatia, Denmark, Finland, Hungary, Netherland, Portugal, Romania, Slovenia, Spain, Czech Republic Denmark,Finland, Hungary, Netherland, Portugal, Romania, Slovenia, Spain, Sweden, Turkey

23. 23 14. Is there any mechanism to assess progress? 6 8 23 5 5 13 Croatia, Hungary, Netherland, Portugal, Romania, Turkey Czech Republic Croatia, Hungary, Netherland, Portugal, Romania, Sweden, Turkey Hungary, Portugal Hungary, Portugal, Sweden Denmark, Finland ( in some cases ) Hungary,Portugal, Turkey Croatia, Hungary, Portugal, Sweden, Turkey Finland, Slovenia, Spain

24. 24 15. What kind of sanction is applied for the non- respect of a CPD obligation? 6 2 4 1 Croatia, Denmark, Netherlands, Romania, Sweden, Turkey Croatia, Netherlands Denmark ( not yet implemented ) Finland ( voluntary register ) Hungary Netherlands Spain

25. 25 16. Are there mechanisms for auditing satisfaction of participants in CPD courses? 10 2 Croatia, Czech Republic Denmark, Finland, Hungary, Netherland, Portugal, Romania, Slovenia, Spain, Sweden, Turkey

26. 26 17. Is there follow-up evaluation of the impact of CPD on the participants business success? (zero) 3 9 Croatia, Hungary, Romania Czech Republic Denmark,Finland, Netherlands, Portugal, Slovenia, Spain, Sweden, Turkey

27. 27 18. What proportion of courses are provided for free? 7 0 3 11 Croatia, Denmark, Finland, Netherlands, Portugal, Romania, Spain Czech Republic, Hungary, Turkey SwedenSlowenia

28. 28 19. In the case where the participants don’t pay for 100% of the CPD products, who pays for the rest? 4 2 7 3 Croatia, Finland, Hungary, Slovenia Slovénia, Spain Croatia, Czech Republic, Netherlands Portugal, Romania, Slovenia, Turkey Denmark, Romania, Spain

29. 29 20-22. Estimation of CPD courses (per year) Number of coursesNumber of participantsLesson hours Croatia85Hard to estimate Czech Republic1523050 Denmark35800n.a. Finland10400200 Hungary3506000n.a. Netherlands601200240 Portugal30600700 Romania2-460-12060-100 Slovenia2050060 Spain10022001600 Sweden580300 Turkey50100010000

30. 30 23. What is your personal appreciation of your national CPD system? 3 Portugal, Spain, Sweden 7 Croatia, Czech Republic, Denmark, Hungary, Netherlands, Slovenia, Turkey 1 Finland Romania (zero)

31. 31 MaltaPoland Do you plan to have a CPD system?yes Would you consider the possibility of a regionally organised CPD? yes What would be the three most important fields for courses Codes and standars Renovation and conservation Energy efficiency of building Legislation and regulation New technologies Energy efficiency of building Are architects taking courses from other countries?noyes Do courses from other countries have any effect on an architect’s professional practice? non.a. Would you use the ACE Guidelines for your CPD Program? yes Who will finance a potential CPD system in the future? Architect Profesional organisation Architect Profesional organisation Manufacturers Countries who do not have CPD at the moment