Download presentation
Presentation is loading. Please wait.
Published byKelley Archibald Sullivan Modified over 8 years ago
1
Fee Shifting: How to Get Paid in the Modern Contingent Fee Marketplace Andy Norman, Esq. attorneyfeeshifting.com (312)332-2400
2
Fee Shifting - Introduction Today thousands of causes of action are supported by fee-shifting. Federalization of standards throughout the country. The Congressional/legislative purpose for authorizing fee shifting: Ensuring competent representation for the impecunious plaintiff.
3
Fee Shifting Common Challenges Drafting the legal services agreement in keeping with the market.
4
Fee Shifting Common Challenges Drafting the legal services agreement in keeping with the market. The effect of retainers and percentage contingencies in addition to fee-shifting.
5
Fee Shifting Common Challenges Double standards for plaintiffs seeking fees versus defendants.
6
Fee Shifting Common Challenges Double standards for plaintiffs seeking fees versus defendants. No proportionality test between damages and fees.
7
Fee Shifting Injunctive Relief Fees are allowed for recovery of injunctive relief.
8
Fee Shifting Injunctive Relief 1. Interim fee-petitions. Fees are allowed for recovery of injunctive relief.
9
Fee Shifting Injunctive Relief 1. Interim fee-petitions. 2. Defeasible relief. Fees are allowed for recovery of injunctive relief.
10
Fee Shifting Injunctive Relief 1. Interim fee-petitions. 2. Defeasible relief. 3. Non-defeasible relief Fees are allowed for recovery of injunctive relief.
11
Fee Shifting Maximizing Recovery Maximize fee recoveries by keeping proper time records
12
Fee Shifting Keeping Time Records Absolutely avoid “clumping” or “block billing”.
13
Fee Shifting Keeping Time Records Absolutely avoid “clumping” or “block billing”. Eliminate all references to clerical work.
14
Fee Shifting Keeping Time Records Absolutely avoid “clumping” or “block billing”. Eliminate all references to clerical work. Bill in Tenths, Not Quarters of an Hour
15
Fee Shifting Keeping Time Records Absolutely avoid “clumping” or “block billing”. Eliminate all references to clerical work. Bill in Tenths, Not Quarters of an Hour
16
Fee Shifting Keeping Time Records Absolutely avoid “clumping” or “block billing”. Eliminate all references to clerical work. Bill in Tenths, Not Quarters of an Hour Over-describe rather than under- describe each service provided, and make clear who is involved.
17
Fee Shifting Keeping Time Records Carefully search for time entries which appear duplicative.
18
Fee Shifting Keeping Time Records Carefully search for time entries which appear duplicative. Demonstrate good faith by having an “adjusted time” column next to the original “time” column.
19
Fee Shifting Keeping Time Records Carefully search for time entries which appear duplicative. Demonstrate good faith by having an “adjusted time” column next to the original “time” column. Observe billing discipline.
20
Fee Shifting Keeping Time Records Carefully search for time entries which appear duplicative. Demonstrate good faith by having an “adjusted time” column next to the original “time” column. Observe billing discipline. Eliminate all typos.
21
Fee Shifting Prevailing Party Standards Hensley v. Eckerhart Farrar v. Hobby Buckhannon Board and Care v. Virginia Board of Health
22
Fee Shifting Principles of Hensley Calculation of the fee using The Lodestar Method Reasonable Hourly Rate (Determined Using Factors/Standards) Multiplied by Number of Hours Expended Lodestar Fee Amount
23
Fee Shifting Lodestar Method Standards for setting the reasonable hourly rate include:
24
Fee Shifting Lodestar Method Standards for setting the reasonable hourly rate include: Shift of the burden of proof/persuasion
25
Fee Shifting Lodestar Method Standards for setting the reasonable hourly rate include: Shift of the burden of proof/persuasion Effects of contingency and risk of loss on the hourly rate
26
Fee Shifting Lodestar Method Standards for setting the reasonable hourly rate include: Shift of the burden of proof/persuasion Effects of contingency and risk of loss on the hourly rate Adjustments for the cost of living in different parts of the country
27
Fee Shifting Lodestar Method Standards for setting the reasonable hourly rate include: Remote forum issues
28
Fee Shifting Lodestar Method Standards for setting the reasonable hourly rate include: Remote forum issues National forum issues
29
Fee Shifting Lodestar Method Standards for setting the reasonable hourly rate include: Remote forum issues National forum issues Relevance of previous fee awards
30
Fee Shifting Lodestar Method In applying the Lodestar Method, courts also consider: Standards for determining the amount of attorney hours expended
31
Fee Shifting Lodestar Method In applying the Lodestar Method, courts also consider: Standards for determining the amount of attorney hours expended Enhancement/reduction of the Lodestar
32
Fee Shifting Lodestar Method In applying the Lodestar Method, courts also consider: Standards for determining the amount of attorney hours expended Enhancement/reduction of the Lodestar Enhancement for delay in payment
33
Fee Shifting Hensley Factors Under the principles of Hensley, courts modify fee award calculations based upon: Excellent results/significant relief obtained
34
Fee Shifting Hensley Factors Under the principles of Hensley, courts modify fee award calculations based upon: Excellent results/significant relief obtained Partial success Related and unrelated claims Unsuccessful motions
35
Fee Shifting Hensley Factors Under the principles of Hensley, courts modify fee award calculations based upon: Excellent results/significant relief obtained Partial success Related and unrelated claims Unsuccessful motions Trends in the courts Line-item versus percentage cuts
36
Fee Shifting Miscellaneous Issues Fee-shifting and professional responsibility guidelines
37
Fee Shifting Miscellaneous Issues Fee-shifting and professional responsibility guidelines Rule 1.5
38
Fee Shifting Miscellaneous Issues Fee-shifting and professional responsibility guidelines Rule 1.5 Pleading: the Jaffe principle
39
Fee Shifting Miscellaneous Issues Fee-shifting and professional responsibility guidelines Rule 1.5 Pleading: the Jaffe principle Compensation of time expended on post- trial and appellate matters Fees on fees (Get paid to get paid)
40
Fee Shifting Miscellaneous Issues Should you ask for an evidentiary hearing? Plaintiff?
41
Fee Shifting Miscellaneous Issues Should you ask for an evidentiary hearing? Plaintiff? Defendant?
42
Fee Shifting Miscellaneous Issues Should you ask for an evidentiary hearing? Plaintiff? Defendant? Permissibility of discovery
43
Fee Shifting Miscellaneous Issues Should you ask for an evidentiary hearing? Plaintiff? Defendant? Permissibility of discovery Interim fee-petitions
44
Fee Shifting Miscellaneous Issues Should you ask for an evidentiary hearing? Plaintiff? Defendant? Permissibility of discovery Interim fee-petitions Relevance of opposing counsel’s hourly rate and hours expended.
45
Fee Shifting Miscellaneous Issues Compensation for paralegal time
46
Fee Shifting Miscellaneous Issues Compensation for paralegal time What is a paralegal?
47
Fee Shifting Miscellaneous Issues Compensation for paralegal time What is a paralegal? Public relations time
48
Fee Shifting Miscellaneous Issues Compensation for paralegal time What is a paralegal? Public relations time Travel time
49
Fee Shifting Miscellaneous Issues Compensation for paralegal time What is a paralegal? Public relations time Travel time Expert witness fees
50
Fee Shifting Miscellaneous Issues Compensation for paralegal time What is a paralegal? Public relations time Travel time Expert witness fees Federal
51
Fee Shifting Miscellaneous Issues Compensation for paralegal time What is a paralegal? Public relations time Travel time Expert witness fees FederalState
52
Fee Shifting Miscellaneous Issues Compensation for paralegal time What is a paralegal? Public relations time Travel time Expert witness fees FederalState Pro se attorney-plaintiffs generally cannot get fees.
53
Fee Shifting Miscellaneous Issues Compensation for paralegal time What is a paralegal? Public relations time Travel time Expert witness fees FederalState Pro se attorney-plaintiffs generally cannot get fees.
54
THANK YOU! Fee Shifting: How to Get Paid in the Modern Contingent Fee Marketplace Brought to you by Andy Norman, Esq. attorneyfeeshifting.com (312)332-2400
Similar presentations
© 2024 SlidePlayer.com Inc.
All rights reserved.