Presentation is loading. Please wait.

Presentation is loading. Please wait.

Suborna Shekhor Ahmed Department of Forest Resources Management Faculty of Forestry, UBC Western Mensurationists Conference Missoula, MT June 20 to 22,

Published byVictor Godwin McGee Modified over 8 years ago

Similar presentations

Presentation on theme: "Suborna Shekhor Ahmed Department of Forest Resources Management Faculty of Forestry, UBC Western Mensurationists Conference Missoula, MT June 20 to 22,"— Presentation transcript:

1 Suborna Shekhor Ahmed Department of Forest Resources Management Faculty of Forestry, UBC Western Mensurationists Conference Missoula, MT June 20 to 22, 2010 Modeling Tree Mortality for Large Regions Using Combined Estimators and Meta-Analysis Approaches

2 Objectives suborna.ahmed@gmail.com Modelling Tree Mortality Using Meta Modelling Slide-2 Develop mortality models for four target species of the Boreal Forest of Canada (aspen, white spruce, black spruce and jack pine) Data from Alberta, Ontario and Quebec will be used, along with a combined estimator and local mortality models. To select a combined estimator, several estimators will be proposed and tested using the PSP data from Alberta. For this presentation, I will present preliminary results of testing combined estimators using PSP data from Alberta for aspen.

3 Tree Mortality Tree Mortality suborna.ahmed@gmail.com Modelling Tree Mortality Using Meta Modelling Slide-3 Tree mortality is an important aspect of stand dynamics and is commonly expressed in terms of loss of volume or basal area per year. Cause and time of death are very important to model the tree mortality. The following variables are considered for modeling tree mortality: Diameter at breast height (DBH), Annual diameter increment during the preceding interval (DIN), Total basal area per hectare at the beginning of the growth interval (BAHA), Site productivity index, Species composition, Length of the growth interval (L), Other measures of competition.

4 Generalized Logistic Model Generalized Logistic Model suborna.ahmed@gmail.com Modelling Tree Mortality Using Meta Modelling Slide-4 For repeated measures where the time interval, L, is irregular, a generalized logistic model has been used to model survival where is the annual probability of survival. s are the unknown parameters with explanatory variables. From this, the annual probability of mortality is:

5 Published Mortality (or Survival) Models for Aspen suborna.ahmed@gmail.com Modelling Tree Mortality Using Meta Modelling Slide-5 Reference Study location Model Yao et al. (2001) Alberta mixed wood forests Lacerte et al. (2006) Ontario Senecal et al. (2004) Quebec’s boreal forest : white spruce (Picea glauca) species composition as a percentage of BAHA; SPI: site productivity index; canopy position: an ordinal variable of position of the tree within the canopy; growth: corresponds to the last year of radial growth (millimetres); All other variables are previously defined.

6 Meta Modelling Approaches Meta Modelling Approaches suborna.ahmed@gmail.com Modelling Tree Mortality Using Meta Modelling Slide-6 Combined Estimator Meta-modeling approaches use observational data to obtain weights for combining existing local scale models may result in improved precision over the naïve approaches. The general approach would be: : kth estimated parameter using the combination of parameter estimates from the r local spatial models; : kth estimated parameter for local scale model j; : weight between 0 and 1 applied to the kth estimated parameters for local scale model j; r : number of local scale models. Sum of the over all regions is 1 for each parameter. Where,

7 Meta Modelling Approaches Meta Modelling Approaches suborna.ahmed@gmail.com Modelling Tree Mortality Using Meta Modelling Slide-7 Native Approach 1: One of the native approaches is to use all available data to fit a large scale model Native Approach 2 ( Equal Weights ) : Giving equal weight to each estimate: Where, : weight between 0 and 1 applied to the estimated parameters for local scale model j; r : number of local scale models.

8 Meta Modelling Approaches Meta Modelling Approaches suborna.ahmed@gmail.com Modelling Tree Mortality Using Meta Modelling Slide-8 Based on Cochran (Inverse Variances): Weight the parameters by the inverse of their variances, based on Cochran (1977) and extending to r >2: where indicates variance of a particular parameter estimate.

9 Meta Modelling Approaches Meta Modelling Approaches suborna.ahmed@gmail.com Modelling Tree Mortality Using Meta Modelling Slide-9 Maximum Likelihood Optimal weights are found that meet a maximum likelihood objective function. Options include having the same weights for all parameters versus having differential weights by parameter.

10 Meta Modelling Approaches Meta Modelling Approaches suborna.ahmed@gmail.com Modelling Tree Mortality Using Meta Modelling Slide-10 Stein Rule Estimator (Shrinkage) Where, : vector of estimated parameter for combined model; : weight between 0 and 1 applied for local scale model j; : vector of estimated parameters for local scale model j. : number of observations in the jth region.

11 Alberta Data Study includes over 1,700 plots measured up to seven times with a variable number of years between measurements, dispersed over the forested land of Alberta. Each plot summarized at each measurement period to obtain explanatory variables for modeling for each species and all species combined. The tree-level variables were then merged with the plot-level variables. The summarized data were considered as census data at the large spatial scale for this research. Competition mortality of trees was taken into account. Plots that have a majority of aspen trees (greater than 30% by basal area per ha in any measurement period) were selected for use. suborna.ahmed@gmail.com Modelling Tree Mortality Using Meta Modelling Slide-11

12 Steps for Meta Modelling Using Aspen Data suborna.ahmed@gmail.com Modelling Tree Mortality Using Meta Modelling Slide-12 Fitted the generalized logistic survival model using all data combined. Split Alberta data into two regions using township and fitted the model separately. Implemented the combined estimators.

13 Natural Regions of Alberta Map source: http://www.royalalbertamuseum.ca/vexhibit/eggs/vexhome/regdesc.htm http://www.royalalbertamuseum.ca/vexhibit/eggs/vexhome/regdesc.htm suborna.ahmed@gmail.com Modelling Tree Mortality Using Meta Modelling Slide-13

14 Results: Fitted Model Results: Fitted Model suborna.ahmed@gmail.com Modelling Tree Mortality Using Meta Modelling Slide-14 The probability of survival model for the entire data set and for each region is: Where, : probability of survival to the end of the period. DIN: annual diameter increment during the preceding interval. BAL: basal area of all trees larger than the subject tree. L: length of the growth interval. SpOther: percentage of basal area per ha of all trees that were not aspen.

15 Results: Statistics for Tree- and Plot-Level Variables Results: Statistics for Tree- and Plot-Level Variables suborna.ahmed@gmail.com Modelling Tree Mortality Using Meta Modelling Slide-15 Data set Number of Plots Number of trees VariableMeanMinimumMaximum All data combined 26920835 DBH23.849.275.40 DIN0.17-0.502.28 L9.253.030.0 Region 122017611 DBH24.439.275.40 DIN0.17-0.502.28 L9.243.030.0 Region 2493224 DBH20.279.253.9 DIN0.16-0.471.06 L9.413.019.0

16 Results: Statistics for Tree- and Plot-Level Variables Results: Statistics for Tree- and Plot-Level Variables suborna.ahmed@gmail.com Modelling Tree Mortality Using Meta Modelling Slide-16 Data set Number of Plots Number of trees VariableMeanMinimumMaximum All data combined 26920835 DBH23.849.275.40 DIN0.17-0.502.28 L9.253.030.0 Region 1 22017611 DBH24.439.275.40 DIN0.17-0.502.28 L9.243.030.0 Region 2 493224 DBH20.279.253.9 DIN0.16-0.471.06 L9.413.019.0

17 Results: Statistics for Tree- and Plot-Level Variables Results: Statistics for Tree- and Plot-Level Variables suborna.ahmed@gmail.com Modelling Tree Mortality Using Meta Modelling Slide-17 Data set Number of Plots Number of trees VariableMeanMinimumMaximum All data combined 26920835 DBH23.849.275.40 DIN 0.17-0.502.28 L9.253.030.0 Region 122017611 DBH24.439.275.40 DIN 0.17-0.502.28 L9.243.030.0 Region 2493224 DBH20.279.253.9 DIN 0.16-0.471.06 L9.413.019.0

18 Results: Estimated Parameters (Standard Errors in Brackets) and Fit statistics Results: Estimated Parameters (Standard Errors in Brackets) and Fit statistics suborna.ahmed@gmail.com Modelling Tree Mortality Using Meta Modelling Slide-18 Parameter/ Fit Statistics All data combinedRegion 1Region 2 (Intercept) 2.728438 (0.0747) 2.610003 (0.0779) 3.851521 (0.2615) (DBH) 0.017387 (0.00205) 0.017897 (0.00215) 0.018665 (0.00801) (DIN) 10.77865 (0.2220) 10.83272 (0.2382) 10.37064 (0.6273) (BAL) -0.02488 (0.00146) -0.02222 (0.00152) -0.0404 (0.00566) (SpOther) 0.002286 (0.000533) 0.002675 (0.000614) -0.00768 (0.00246) -2logL1105698941128

19 Results: Estimated Parameters (Standard Errors in Brackets) and Fit statistics Results: Estimated Parameters (Standard Errors in Brackets) and Fit statistics suborna.ahmed@gmail.com Modelling Tree Mortality Using Meta Modelling Slide-19 Parameter/ Fit Statistics All data combinedRegion 1Region 2 (Intercept) 2.728438 (0.0747) 2.610003 (0.0779) 3.851521 (0.2615) (DBH) 0.017387 (0.00205) 0.017897 (0.00215) 0.018665 (0.00801) (DIN) 10.77865 (0.2220) 10.83272 (0.2382) 10.37064 (0.6273) (BAL) -0.02488 (0.00146) -0.02222 (0.00152) -0.0404 (0.00566) (SpOther) 0.002286 (0.000533) 0.002675 (0.000614) -0.00768 (0.00246) -2logL1105698941128

20 Results: Estimated Parameters (Standard Errors in Brackets) and Fit statistics Results: Estimated Parameters (Standard Errors in Brackets) and Fit statistics suborna.ahmed@gmail.com Modelling Tree Mortality Using Meta Modelling Slide-20 Parameter/ Fit Statistics All data combinedRegion 1Region 2 (Intercept) 2.728438 (0.0747) 2.610003 (0.0779) 3.851521 (0.2615) (DBH) 0.017387 (0.00205) 0.017897 (0.00215) 0.018665 (0.00801) (DIN) 10.77865 (0.2220) 10.83272 (0.2382) 10.37064 (0.6273) (BAL) -0.02488 (0.00146) -0.02222 (0.00152) -0.0404 (0.00566) (SpOther) 0.002286 (0.000533) 0.002675 (0.000614) -0.00768 (0.00246) -2logL1105698941128

21 Results: Weights of Parameters Using Meta- Regression for Aspen Results: Weights of Parameters Using Meta- Regression for Aspen suborna.ahmed@gmail.com Modelling Tree Mortality Using Meta Modelling Slide-21 MethodRegion Weights of parameters Equal weight Region 1 0.5 Region 2 0.5 Inverse Variances Region 1 0.920.930.870.930.94 Region 2 0.080.070.130.070.06 ML Region 1 0.85 Region 2 0.15 ML (Differential Weight) Region 1 0.910.001.000.970.88 Region 2 0.091.000.000.030.12 Stein Rule Region 1 0.85 Region 2 0.15

22 Results: Weights of Parameters Using Meta- Regression for Aspen Results: Weights of Parameters Using Meta- Regression for Aspen suborna.ahmed@gmail.com Modelling Tree Mortality Using Meta Modelling Slide-22 MethodRegion Weights of parameters Equal weight Region 1 0.5 Region 2 0.5 Inverse Variances Region 1 0.920.930.870.930.94 Region 2 0.080.070.130.070.06 ML Region 1 0.85 Region 2 0.15 ML (Differential Weight) Region 1 0.910.001.000.970.88 Region 2 0.091.000.000.030.12 Stein Rule Region 1 0.85 Region 2 0.15

23 Results: Weights of Parameters Using Meta- Regression for Aspen Results: Weights of Parameters Using Meta- Regression for Aspen suborna.ahmed@gmail.com Modelling Tree Mortality Using Meta Modelling Slide-23 MethodRegion Weights of parameters Equal weight Region 1 0.5 Region 2 0.5 Inverse Variances Region 1 0.920.930.870.930.94 Region 2 0.080.070.130.070.06 ML Region 1 0.85 Region 2 0.15 ML (Differential Weight) Region 1 0.910.001.000.970.88 Region 2 0.091.000.000.030.12 Stein Rule Region 1 0.85 Region 2 0.15

24 Results: Estimated Parameters Using Meta- Regression for Aspen Results: Estimated Parameters Using Meta- Regression for Aspen suborna.ahmed@gmail.com Modelling Tree Mortality Using Meta Modelling Slide-24 Method Combined Parameter Estimates Equal weight 3.23080.018310.6017-0.0313-0.0025 Inverse Variances 2.71120.0179410.7745-0.02340.0021 ML 2.79860.01810.7625-0.0250.0011 ML (Differential Weight) 2.72140.018710.8327-0.02280.0015 Stein Rule 2.79480.01810.7639-0.02490.0011

25 Results: Estimated Parameters Using Meta- Regression for Aspen Results: Estimated Parameters Using Meta- Regression for Aspen suborna.ahmed@gmail.com Modelling Tree Mortality Using Meta Modelling Slide-25 Method Combined Parameter Estimates Equal weight 3.2308 0.018310.6017-0.0313-0.0025 Inverse Variances 2.7112 0.0179410.7745-0.02340.0021 ML 2.7986 0.01810.7625-0.0250.0011 ML (Differential Weight) 2.7214 0.018710.8327-0.02280.0015 Stein Rule 2.7948 0.01810.7639-0.02490.0011

26 Results: Estimated Parameters Using Meta- Regression for Aspen Results: Estimated Parameters Using Meta- Regression for Aspen suborna.ahmed@gmail.com Modelling Tree Mortality Using Meta Modelling Slide-26 Method Combined Parameter Estimates Equal weight 3.23080.018310.6017-0.0313 -0.0025 Inverse Variances 2.71120.0179410.7745-0.0234 0.0021 ML 2.79860.01810.7625-0.025 0.0011 ML (Differential Weight) 2.72140.018710.8327-0.0228 0.0015 Stein Rule 2.79480.01810.7639-0.0249 0.0011

27 Results: Predicted Annual Probability of Survival and Likelihood Using Meta-Regression and All Data Combined for Aspen Results: Predicted Annual Probability of Survival and Likelihood Using Meta-Regression and All Data Combined for Aspen suborna.ahmed@gmail.com Modelling Tree Mortality Using Meta Modelling Slide-27 Method Predicted -2logL LiveDead Mean 25% (percentile) 75% (percentile) Mean 25% (percentile) 75% (percentile) Equal weight 0.890.860.980.700.550.8911074 Inverse Variances 0.880.830.980.670.510.8610996 ML 0.880.840.980.670.510.8710994 ML (Differential Weight) 0.880.840.980.680.520.8710990 Stein Rule 0.880.840.980.670.510.8710994 All data combined 0.880.830.980.660.500.8611056

28 Results: Predicted Annual Probability of Survival and Likelihood Using Meta-Regression and All Data Combined for Aspen Results: Predicted Annual Probability of Survival and Likelihood Using Meta-Regression and All Data Combined for Aspen suborna.ahmed@gmail.com Modelling Tree Mortality Using Meta Modelling Slide-28 Method Predicted -2logL LiveDead Mean 25% (percentile) 75% (percentile) Mean 25% (percentile) 75% (percentile) Equal weight 0.890.860.980.700.550.89 11074 Inverse Variances 0.880.830.980.670.510.8610996 ML 0.880.840.980.670.510.8710994 ML (Differential Weight) 0.880.840.980.680.520.8710990 Stein Rule 0.880.840.980.670.510.8710994 All data combined 0.880.830.980.660.500.8611056

29 Results: Predicted Annual Probability of Survival and Likelihood Using Meta-Regression and All Data Combined for Aspen Results: Predicted Annual Probability of Survival and Likelihood Using Meta-Regression and All Data Combined for Aspen suborna.ahmed@gmail.com Modelling Tree Mortality Using Meta Modelling Slide-29 Method Predicted -2logL LiveDead Mean 25% (percentile) 75% (percentile) Mean 25% (percentile) 75% (percentile) Equal weight 0.890.860.980.700.550.8911074 Inverse Variances 0.880.830.980.670.510.8610996 ML 0.880.840.980.670.510.8710994 ML (Differential Weight) 0.880.840.980.680.520.8710990 Stein Rule 0.880.840.980.670.510.8710994 All data combined 0.880.830.980.660.500.8611056

30 Discussion Discussion suborna.ahmed@gmail.com Modelling Tree Mortality Using Meta Modelling Slide-30 The simplest meta-regression approach would be to combine existing models using equal weights which resulted in the highest -2logL. Maximum likelihood (differential weight ) to find weights resulted in lower -2logL value than other meta-regression approaches.

31 Conclusion Conclusion suborna.ahmed@gmail.com Modelling Tree Mortality Using Meta Modelling Slide-31 Further research will include: Accuracy testing will be done for the estimators. One estimator will be selected for use. Regional models will be fitted for white spruce, black spruce and jack pine using Alberta, Ontario and Quebec PSP data.

32  Thanks to Alberta, Ontario and Quebec governments for providing PSP data.  Thanks to my committee members: Dr. Valerie Lemay, UBC. Dr. Steen Magnussen, Nrcan. Dr. Frank Berninger, UQAM. Dr. Peter Marshall, UBC. Dr. Andrew Robinson, U. Melbourne.  Thanks to NSERC and ForValueNet for providing the research funding. Acknowledgements Acknowledgements suborna.ahmed@gmail.com Modelling Tree Mortality Using Meta Modelling Slide-32

33 Modeling Tree Mortality for Large Regions Using Combined Estimators and Meta-Analysis Approaches suborna.ahmed@gmail.com Modelling Tree Mortality Using Meta Modelling Slide-33

Download ppt "Suborna Shekhor Ahmed Department of Forest Resources Management Faculty of Forestry, UBC Western Mensurationists Conference Missoula, MT June 20 to 22,"

Similar presentations

Site and Stocking and Other Related Measurements.

Site and Stocking and Other Related Measurements.
Modeling Tree Growth Under Varying Silvicultural Prescriptions Leah Rathbun University of British Columbia Presented at Western Mensurationists 2010.

Modeling Tree Growth Under Varying Silvicultural Prescriptions Leah Rathbun University of British Columbia Presented at Western Mensurationists 2010.
Modelling Mixedwoods at the Whole-Stand Level Oscar García University of Northern British Columbia.

Modelling Mixedwoods at the Whole-Stand Level Oscar García University of Northern British Columbia.
Dynamics of Alaska Boreal Forest under Climate Change Jingjing Liang, Jingjing Liang a, Mo Zhou a, Dave L. Verbyla b, Lianjun Zhang c, Anna L. Springsteen.

Dynamics of Alaska Boreal Forest under Climate Change Jingjing Liang, Jingjing Liang a, Mo Zhou a, Dave L. Verbyla b, Lianjun Zhang c, Anna L. Springsteen.
The Natural Disturbance Regime: Implications for Forest Management Glen W. Armstrong University of Alberta CIFFC Science Forum 4 November 1999.

The Natural Disturbance Regime: Implications for Forest Management Glen W. Armstrong University of Alberta CIFFC Science Forum 4 November 1999.
SENSITIVITY ANALYSIS of the FOREST VEGETATION SIMULATOR Southern Variant (FVS-Sn) Nathan D. Herring Dr. Philip J. Radtke Virginia Tech Department of Forestry.

SENSITIVITY ANALYSIS of the FOREST VEGETATION SIMULATOR Southern Variant (FVS-Sn) Nathan D. Herring Dr. Philip J. Radtke Virginia Tech Department of Forestry.
The Effects of Site and Soil on Fertilizer Response of Coastal Douglas-fir K.M. Littke, R.B. Harrison, and D.G. Briggs University of Washington Coast Fertilization.

The Effects of Site and Soil on Fertilizer Response of Coastal Douglas-fir K.M. Littke, R.B. Harrison, and D.G. Briggs University of Washington Coast Fertilization.
Douglas-fir mortality estimation with generalized linear mixed models Jeremy Groom, David Hann, Temesgen Hailemariam 2012 Western Mensurationists’ Meeting.

Douglas-fir mortality estimation with generalized linear mixed models Jeremy Groom, David Hann, Temesgen Hailemariam 2012 Western Mensurationists’ Meeting.
Thinning Impacts on Even-aged Stands of Eucalyptus in Brazil Thinning Impacts on Even-aged Stands of Eucalyptus in Brazil June 21, 2010 Missoula, MT Western.

Thinning Impacts on Even-aged Stands of Eucalyptus in Brazil Thinning Impacts on Even-aged Stands of Eucalyptus in Brazil June 21, 2010 Missoula, MT Western.
Integration of sensory modalities

Integration of sensory modalities
Development of a Forest Vegetation Simulator variant and application software for Ontario Murray Woods, Sr Analyst, Forested Landscapes, OMNR Don Robinson,

Development of a Forest Vegetation Simulator variant and application software for Ontario Murray Woods, Sr Analyst, Forested Landscapes, OMNR Don Robinson,
Company LOGO Western Mensurationists 2013 Leavenworth, WA, USA, PhD, RPF Tesera Systems Inc. Valerie LeMay, PhD, RPFUniversity of British Columbia Western.

Company LOGO Western Mensurationists 2013 Leavenworth, WA, USA, PhD, RPF Tesera Systems Inc. Valerie LeMay, PhD, RPFUniversity of British Columbia Western.
Modelling Natural Regeneration in Mountain Pine Beetle Affected Stands A Hybrid Model Approach Derek Sattler, M.Sc. Candidate Faculty of Forestry. University.

Modelling Natural Regeneration in Mountain Pine Beetle Affected Stands A Hybrid Model Approach Derek Sattler, M.Sc. Candidate Faculty of Forestry. University.
Metapopulation Research Group Survival of species in fragmented forest landscapes Ilkka Hanski.

Metapopulation Research Group Survival of species in fragmented forest landscapes Ilkka Hanski.
Impact of plot size on the effect of competition in individual-tree models and their applications Jari Hynynen & Risto Ojansuu Finnish Forest Research.

Impact of plot size on the effect of competition in individual-tree models and their applications Jari Hynynen & Risto Ojansuu Finnish Forest Research.
Structure and Demography of Tree Communities in Tropical Secondary Forest Recovering From Logging Keala Cummings and Dr. Diane Thomson 2007 Keala Cummings.

Structure and Demography of Tree Communities in Tropical Secondary Forest Recovering From Logging Keala Cummings and Dr. Diane Thomson 2007 Keala Cummings.
What is a Multi-Scale Analysis? Implications for Modeling Presence/Absence of Bird Species Kathryn M. Georgitis 1, Alix I. Gitelman 1, Don L. Stevens 1,

What is a Multi-Scale Analysis? Implications for Modeling Presence/Absence of Bird Species Kathryn M. Georgitis 1, Alix I. Gitelman 1, Don L. Stevens 1,
1.  Why understanding probability is important?  What is normal curve  How to compute and interpret z scores. 2.

1.  Why understanding probability is important?  What is normal curve  How to compute and interpret z scores. 2.
What Do You See? Message of the Day: The management objective determines whether a site is over, under, or fully stocked.

What Do You See? Message of the Day: The management objective determines whether a site is over, under, or fully stocked.
Estimating wood volume of the stem and commercial branches of hard maple using a taper model with latent variables Western Mensurationists’ Meeting June.

Estimating wood volume of the stem and commercial branches of hard maple using a taper model with latent variables Western Mensurationists’ Meeting June.

Similar presentations

Ads by Google