Presentation is loading. Please wait.

Presentation is loading. Please wait.

Prevention of Alcohol Purchase and Use Among Adolescents Design Two: Staggered Entry of 10 Intervention Sites Harold D. Holder, Ph.D. Senior Scientist,

Published byJack Rose Modified over 8 years ago

Similar presentations

Presentation on theme: "Prevention of Alcohol Purchase and Use Among Adolescents Design Two: Staggered Entry of 10 Intervention Sites Harold D. Holder, Ph.D. Senior Scientist,"— Presentation transcript:

1

2 Prevention of Alcohol Purchase and Use Among Adolescents Design Two: Staggered Entry of 10 Intervention Sites Harold D. Holder, Ph.D. Senior Scientist, Prevention Research Center, Pacific Institute for Research and Evaluation Berkeley, CA National Institutes of Health May 4-5, 2004

3 Design 2--Rationale (3) Reaction bias- Communities which are denied intervention can create their own intervention which confounds ability to be controls. (1) Documentation- Requirement of NIH reviewers to have signed agreements of participation creates local awareness and expectation. creates local awareness and expectation. (1) Documentation- Requirement of NIH reviewers to have signed agreements of participation creates local awareness and expectation. creates local awareness and expectation. (2) Ethics- Systematic denial of intervention, based upon selection criteria. (2) Ethics- Systematic denial of intervention, based upon selection criteria.

4 Design 2: Outline 3. 4. 1. 2. 10 communities with 5 selected for first wave of intervention Communities not included in first wave have delayed initiation, e.g., in pairs Selection for initiation waves can be random or purposeful. Requires parallel outcome measurement Essential to know dates of actual implementation and dosage/strength of implementation in all communities. 5. Enables test of sufficiency of intervention (short term compared to longer term) 6.

5 Design two T1 T2 T3 T4 T5. …...... Tn O 1 X O 2 O 3 O 4 O 5 ……….O n O 1 O 2 X O 3 O 4 O 5 O 1 O 2 O 3 X O 4 O 5 O 1 O 2 O 3 O 4 X O 5......

6 Trade Offs RCT Design 1 Design 2 Assignment (Permits effectiveness trial but requires large candidate pool) Permits trial with fewer cases and enables communities to develop interventions which match their values and norms. Controls (can be biased with mismatched trends) Can control for trending using matching May be difficult to obtain matching controls for trending Ethics (denial of intervention, moderate risk of contamination) Denial of intervention, moderate risk for contamination but less than Design 2 No denial of intervention but increased risk of contamination. Attribution (IF randomization fulfilled and no contamination, then easier to attribute effects) Requires greater complex analyses to increase confidence in attribution of effect.

Download ppt "Prevention of Alcohol Purchase and Use Among Adolescents Design Two: Staggered Entry of 10 Intervention Sites Harold D. Holder, Ph.D. Senior Scientist,"

Similar presentations

Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality (AHRQ)

Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality (AHRQ)
Research Study Designs

Research Study Designs
A Guide to Education Research in the Era of NCLB Brian Jacob University of Michigan December 5, 2007.

A Guide to Education Research in the Era of NCLB Brian Jacob University of Michigan December 5, 2007.
Overview of N-of-1 study suite – lessons learned from three aggregated N-of-1 trials. Geoff Mitchell*, Jane Nikles, Sue-Ann Carmont, Janet Hardy, Phillip.

Overview of N-of-1 study suite – lessons learned from three aggregated N-of-1 trials. Geoff Mitchell*, Jane Nikles, Sue-Ann Carmont, Janet Hardy, Phillip.
Designing Influential Evaluations Session 5 Quality of Evidence Uganda Evaluation Week - Pre-Conference Workshop 19 th and 20 th May 2014.

Designing Influential Evaluations Session 5 Quality of Evidence Uganda Evaluation Week - Pre-Conference Workshop 19 th and 20 th May 2014.
KINE 4565: The epidemiology of injury prevention Randomized controlled trials.

KINE 4565: The epidemiology of injury prevention Randomized controlled trials.
Mixed methods in health services research: Pitfalls and pragmatism Robyn McDermott Mixed Methods Seminar JCU 16-17 October 2014.

Mixed methods in health services research: Pitfalls and pragmatism Robyn McDermott Mixed Methods Seminar JCU October 2014.
Practical Issues in conducting multi-country studies by Ken Stanley, Ph.D. Harvard School of Public Health Collaboration Complexities 10 Basic Principles.

Practical Issues in conducting multi-country studies by Ken Stanley, Ph.D. Harvard School of Public Health Collaboration Complexities 10 Basic Principles.
Design and conduct of evaluations of CVD control programs (part I) Gilles Paradis, MD, MSc, FRCPC Jennifer O’Loughlin, PhD McGill University Health Center.

Design and conduct of evaluations of CVD control programs (part I) Gilles Paradis, MD, MSc, FRCPC Jennifer O’Loughlin, PhD McGill University Health Center.
Experimental Design making causal inferences. Causal and Effect The IV precedes the DV in time The IV precedes the DV in time The IV and DV are correlated.

Experimental Design making causal inferences. Causal and Effect The IV precedes the DV in time The IV precedes the DV in time The IV and DV are correlated.
Elements of a clinical trial research protocol

Elements of a clinical trial research protocol
Childhood Obesity Scenario: Quasi- Experiments and Natural Experiments Versus RCTs Steven Gortmaker, Ph.D. Harvard School of Public Health /Harvard Prevention.

Childhood Obesity Scenario: Quasi- Experiments and Natural Experiments Versus RCTs Steven Gortmaker, Ph.D. Harvard School of Public Health /Harvard Prevention.
Clinical trials methodology group Simon Gates 9 February 2006.

Clinical trials methodology group Simon Gates 9 February 2006.
Cancer Disparities Research Partnership Program Process & Outcome Evaluation Amanda Greene, PhD, MPH, RN Paul Young, MBA, MPH Natalie Stultz, MS NOVA Research.

Cancer Disparities Research Partnership Program Process & Outcome Evaluation Amanda Greene, PhD, MPH, RN Paul Young, MBA, MPH Natalie Stultz, MS NOVA Research.
What Is Quality by Design?. Quality by Design: QbD Defined Prospectively examining the objectives of a trial and defining factors critical to meeting.

What Is Quality by Design?. Quality by Design: QbD Defined Prospectively examining the objectives of a trial and defining factors critical to meeting.
Chapter 7. Getting Closer: Grading the Literature and Evaluating the Strength of the Evidence.

Chapter 7. Getting Closer: Grading the Literature and Evaluating the Strength of the Evidence.
Experimental Study.

Experimental Study.
BC Jung A Brief Introduction to Epidemiology - XI (Epidemiologic Research Designs: Experimental/Interventional Studies) Betty C. Jung, RN, MPH, CHES.

BC Jung A Brief Introduction to Epidemiology - XI (Epidemiologic Research Designs: Experimental/Interventional Studies) Betty C. Jung, RN, MPH, CHES.
Before and After Studies in Injury Research Thomas Songer, PhD University of Pittsburgh

Before and After Studies in Injury Research Thomas Songer, PhD University of Pittsburgh
Tobacco Control Interventions – Design Trade-Offs K. S. (Steve) Brown Department of Statistics and Actuarial Science Health Behaviour Research Group University.

Tobacco Control Interventions – Design Trade-Offs K. S. (Steve) Brown Department of Statistics and Actuarial Science Health Behaviour Research Group University.

Similar presentations

Ads by Google