1. Indigenous Knowledge: The San and the Hoodia Roger Chennells South African San Institute

2. The San Peoples 100,000 Five countries First Peoples Several languages

3. The Plant Succulent Kalahari Traditional Knowledge Patent P57 Other patents

4. The Product Appetite suppressant Still in development Huge black market Health foods additive/ supplement

5. Hoodia as ‚product‘ time Line 1933San provide medicinal information to researchers who record it in books 1963Hoodia plant research starts at CSIR 1980s Active ingredient identified 1996 Patent granted to CSIR 1997 CSIR licences to Phytopharm & Pfizer 2001 WIMSA challenges the CSIR 2003 1 st B/S Agreement signed with CSIR 2007 2 nd B/S “ signed with S A Hoodia Growers 2008 Bioprospecting regulations promulgated San begin struggle to enforce compliance

6. Policy Challenges Enforcing compliance with CBD Conservation of wild Hoodia Divergence in National Laws

7. More policy Challenges Implementation of Benefit Sharing Legal vulnerability of Indigenous Peoples

8. Compliance challenges Cites legislation Provincial and national competences Interprovincial and international piracy South Africa and Namibia not aligned Namibia not yet recognising San’s indigenous knowledge rights Hoodia Industry receives little national support in South Africa Success of Hoodia threatened by local failure to establish coherent strategy

9. Indigenous knowledge issues for the San peoples Whether to record indigenous knowledge on a “public domain” data base ? Rapid loss of indigenous knowledge systems Western knowledge systems do not encompass indigenous knowledge Whether to use IPR system (patents, copyright, etc) to manage and exploit Indigenous Knowledge How to protect vulnerable heritage?

10. THE SAN AS A “VULNERABLE” PEOPLE? Are indigenous peoples (IP) “vulnerable” by definition? Do “normal” rules of engagement apply for research or commerce? Should outsiders acknowledge and respect IP “cultural” rather than “western” approaches to a)leadership? b)private ownership? c)timing of negotiations and reaching of consensus? d)representation on legal issues? e)the “benefits” associated with benefit sharing? f) good governance ?

11. THE San Hoodia Benefit Sharing Trust

12. WHO OWNS HER KNOWLEDGE?

13. Thank you for your attention!