Download presentation
Presentation is loading. Please wait.
Published byAmelia Dixon Modified over 4 years ago
1
Approaches to ancient history 11: Reception and History of Scholarship
2
Reception Primarily a theory from literary criticism focusing on the way a text acquires meaning. Meaning not intrinsic in text (so no true meaning is possible) but is constructed in the process of reading (hence alternative name, reader-response criticism). Therefore meaning changes in relation to cultural contexts and in response to earlier readings – tradition of reception develops.
3
Implications for ancient history 1 Tradition of reception of key sources, e.g. Thucydides or Tacitus; read differently at different times. Clearly affects our own readings; influenced both by our own cultural context (effects of Iraq on reading the Melian dialogue?) and by earlier interpretations. Always aiming to get back to orginal meaning; is this possible?
4
Implications for ancient history 2 Subject largely based on tradition of reading and re-reading predecessors; agenda set by earlier generations. Inherited problems, e.g. racism underlying ideas of temporal and geographical scope of ancient history. Dangers of relying on old books – but also dangers of ignoring tradition altogether.
5
And further… Not just response to traditions within ancient history; wider context includes tradition of reception of antiquity at large. Popular portrayals: novels, films, art. Should historians play along or deliberately oppose? Tradition of using antiquity to critique modernity, set up as ideal model of art, politics, culture.
Similar presentations
© 2018 SlidePlayer.com Inc.
All rights reserved.
Ppt on air pollution by gas turbine Ppt on water pollution in india Ppt on introduction to object-oriented programming php Ppt on scheduling in production management Ppt on new zealand culture and customs Ppt on group development and change Ppt on buddhism and jainism Ppt on digital media piracy control Make ppt online Free ppt on self esteem