Presentation on theme: "The Economics of Multilingualism"— Presentation transcript:
1 The Economics of Multilingualism The Economics of Multilingualism. A Case Study Laura Onofri, FEEM, University of Venice"Valuing Cultural Diversity in Cities:Challenges to Cultural Economics",Procida (Naples, Italy),4th of September 2009
2 TABLE OF CONTENTS Definitions and background Cultural Economics and LanguagesCultural Economics, Languages and Sustainable Development and Diversity
3 DEFINITIONS AND BACKGROUND Economics is the science of choices in a world of scarce resources. In economics, choices have both a psychological and a monetary dimension. Every choice implies a trade-off. Every choice generates costs and benefits.The economist is the scientist that theoretically models and empirically measures costs and benefits of choices, in order to explain, predict and evaluate phrenomena.
4 DEFINITIONS AND BACKGROUND Cultural Economics is the economic studies of cultural markets and cultural goods and services.Cultural markets are institutions where demand and supply for cultural goods and services meet.Cultural markets are particular markets, charachterised by many “market failures”.Cultural goods and services are both production inputs and final outputs traded in cultural marketsCultural goods and services are not always exchanged in the market
5 DEFINITIONS AND BACKGROUND The peculiar features of cultural markets, goods and services refers to the fact they embody a“cultural added value”.Sometimes this value is expressed by a “price”, that approximately expresses the value of the good (in terms of production costs, firms mark-up and consumers’ “appreciation” or WTP).Sometimes this does not happen, therefore, economists needs to assess the value through non-market valuation methods.
6 DEFINITIONS AND BACKGROUND Cultural Economics is a vary broad field of research and applications, spanning, for instance, from the study of price formation in Old Masters paintings’auctions; to the non-market valuation of public goods; to the study of the ballet dancers market; to the understanding of the life-cycle of cultural exhibitions; to the microeconomic study of different funding instruments to cultural institutions….In this lectur, I will ONLY focus on the link between cultural and language economics.
7 CULTURAL ECONOMICS AND LANGUAGES Economics and Cultural Economics can be used to understand, explain, predict and evaluate/measure several aspects of linguistic dimensions and phenomena.For instance, cultural economics can help us to address the following issues:Why do people study different languages?How do individuals choose the foreign language they want to learn?Why should minority languages be protected?What is the value that individuals attach to the preservation of a minority language?Can we define the price/value of a (minority) language?…….Cultural Economics, in general, and language economics, in particular are very recent branches of the economic literature. There exist few seminal papers.
8 CULTURAL ECONOMICS AND LANGUAGES Cultural Economics, in general, and language economics, in particular are very recent branches of the economic literature. There exist few seminal papers.
9 CULTURAL ECONOMICS AND LANGUAGES (V. Ginsburgh, I. Ortuno-Ortin, S. Weber, 2005). Disenfranchisement In Linguistically Diverse Societies: The Case Of The European UnionThe authors consider a linguistically diversified society and examine the notion of language disenfran-chisement when some individuals are denied the full access to documents and political process in their native tongues. To calculate the disenfranchisement indices the Dyen percentage cognate matrix of linguistic distances between Indo-European languages is used and is applied to a survey and population data on language proficiency in the European Union.The optimal sets of official languages depends on society's sensitivity against disenfranchisement and comprehensiveness of the chosen language regime. The language situation in the European Union after its last enlargement is discussed.
10 CULTURAL ECONOMICS AND LANGUAGES (Fidrmuc J., Ginsburg V., 2007) Languages in the European Union: The Quest for Equality and its CostThe EU extends equal treatment to all member countries’ official languages. This is costly, especially since many Europeans speak one of the procedural languages, English, French or German, either as a native or a foreign language. The authors develop a simple theoretical model of linguistic-regime choice in a multilingual society and apply the model’s insights to the case of the EU: compute disenfranchisement rates that would result from using only the three procedural languages for all EU business and then proceed to quantify the average cost per person and cost per disenfranchised person associated with providing translations and interpreting into the remaining languages. Both the disenfranchisement rates and costs are shown to vary substantially across the different languages, raising important questions about the economic efficiency of equal treatment for all languages. A proposed, efficient solution would be to decentralize the provision of translations.
11 CULTURAL ECONOMICS AND LANGUAGES (Ginsburg V., Gabszewicz, J. Weber S. 2008) Bilingualism and Communicative BenefitsThe autors examine patterns of acquiring non-native languages in a model with two languages and two populations with heterogeneous learning skills, where every individual faces a binary choice of learning the foreign language or refraining from doing so. They show that both interior and corner linguistic equilibria can emerge in the framework, and that the fraction of learners of the foreign language is higher in the country with a higher gross cost adjusted communicative benefit. It turns out that this observation is consistent with the data on language proficiency in bilingual countries such as Belgium and Canada. Linguistic equilibria can exhibit insufficient learning which opens the door for government policies that are beneficial for both populations.
12 What is in the signs of a main shopping street? CULTURAL ECONOMICS AND LANGUAGES: AN APPLICATIONWhat is in the signs of a main shopping street?An econometric study of multilingualismJasone CenozDurk GorterPaulo A.L.D. NunesLaura Onofri
13 CULTURAL ECONOMICS AND LANGUAGES: AN APPLICATION MOTIVATION:The study of language signs can contribute to the study of linguistic diversity. It can reflect the different strengths of the languages and the relative integration of their speakers. The language signs are also related to identity and to language policy.Research question: how different characteristics (type of shop, branch, chain and so on) affect the choice of the language sign?
14 CULTURAL ECONOMICS AND LANGUAGES: AN APPLICATION The dataset contains information about the linguistic landscape in Ljouwert (Ljouwert) and San Sebastian (Donostia). In particular, observations were collected in the cities main shopping streets, in order to allow for a certain degree of comparability. The dataset for Ljouwert contains 103 observations (language signs) and related characteristics (typo of sign, language on the sign ans so on); the dataset for San Sebastian contains 104 observations (language signs) and related characteristics.The corpus of this study includes a complete inventory of the linguistic landscape of just one street in the Basque Country and one street in Friesland. The streets selected were main shopping streets and both had a length of approximately 600 meters. A total of 975 digital pictures of street signs were taken and 207 units were distinguished 207: 104 in Donostia and 103 in Ljouwert. Each establishment but not each sign was considered the unit of analysis (see Cenoz & Gorter 2006). The collected sign convey information about different characteristics of the sign
15 CULTURAL ECONOMICS AND LANGUAGES: AN APPLICATION
16 CULTURAL ECONOMICS AND LANGUAGES: AN APPLICATION After several checks, we estimate by ML the following probit empirical specification:Prob| LanguageTypej,k = β0 + βjcharachteristicsi + εi,k,jwhere, the dependent variable LanguageType representsthe k-th type of language (minority, official, internationalor a combination of them) for sign i; β0 is the costant;βj are estimators for the j-th considered characteristicscontained in the i-th sign and εi,k.j is the error term.
17 CULTURAL ECONOMICS AND LANGUAGES: AN APPLICATION
18 CULTURAL ECONOMICS AND LANGUAGES: AN APPLICATION
19 CULTURAL ECONOMICS AND LANGUAGES: AN APPLICATION
20 CULTURAL ECONOMICS AND LANGUAGES: AN APPLICATION Following Piller, the use of English in commercial signs does not seem to be intended to transmit factual information but is used for its connotational value because the audience can recognize that the message is in English and this activates values such as international orientation, future orientation, success, sophistication or fun orientation. This is particular evident in the Netherlands and Ljouwert, where English is very spread and broadly used for commercial purposes, but not in Donostia (the estimated coefficient for shop presents a negative sign).
21 CULTURAL ECONOMICS AND LANGUAGES: AN APPLICATION In Donostia, most commercial activities and street signs are bilingual (Basque and Spanish), whilst in Ljouwert, Frisian is used to indicate official buildings and some shops and is less broadly diffused. Frisian is a spontaneous language phenomenon. In our interpretation, Basque and Spanish have to be considered as complementary goods, whose crossed elasticity of demand is positive. On the contrary, Frisian and Dutch are (imperfect) substitutes (since some words overlaps), whose crossed elasticity of demand is negative. Alternatively, Basque and Spanish can be interpreted as two different markets offering different products, whilst Dutch and Frisian can be interpreted as differentiated products produced in the same market.The results corroborate the important assumption that multilingualism and the choice of the language (even in a street sign) is an individual and a social preference. Understanding individuals linguistic preference structures is preliminary to the target and design of proper linguistic and social policies.
22 CULTURAL ECONOMICS AND LANGUAGES: AN APPLICATION Finally, the linguistic and economic motivations of findings are beyond the objectives of this paper. However, in the stream of other economic works on multilingualism, the results corroborate the important assumption that multilingualism and the choice of the language (even in a street sign) is an individual and a social preference. Understanding individuals linguistic preference structures is preliminary to the target and design of proper linguistic and social policies.
23 CULTURAL ECONOMICS AND LANGUAGES: AN APPLICATION How do stakeholders value the possibility to have the street sign the way they want (mostly language choice) and how much are they willing to pay for it?Jasone CenozDurk GorterPaulo A.L.D. NunesLaura Onofri
24 CULTURAL ECONOMICS AND LANGUAGES: AN APPLICATION 1) TOURISTS(587 respondents in San Sebastian and Leeuwarden, different nationalities, gender, age, professions, nationality, proveniencse, spoken languages.)Question The local authorities are studying the behaviour of the tourists in detail. In order to assess and rank their priorities, we kindly ask you if you were given 100 Euro by the local authorities, how would you allocate this amount of money among the following activities:____ having the signs the way you want them____ having clean, public toilets in the city centre____ having more parking space in the city centre____ having more written information about the city for tourists____ having a private guided tour
25 CULTURAL ECONOMICS AND LANGUAGES: AN APPLICATION The significance of the estimates is indicated by ***, ** and *, referring to the 1%, 5% and 10% level, respectively; t-values are between brackets.
26 CULTURAL ECONOMICS AND LANGUAGES: AN APPLICATION we want to formally test the inverse relationship (price-quantity) typically expressed by the (inverse) demand curve. Therefore, we regress the following simple, linear model: Therefore, we regress the following simple, linear model:(1) WTPi = α1 + β2biddersi + εiwhere the dependent variable is the willingness to pay (bids) and the independent variable is the number of respondents. The model contains a constant and an error term.We regress the model using the OLS estimation method.
27 CULTURAL ECONOMICS AND LANGUAGES: AN APPLICATION
28 CULTURAL ECONOMICS AND LANGUAGES: AN APPLICATION
29 InterpretationQuestion 2: If the local government asks for your financial assistance to this program, via an overnight stay tax, how much is your maximum willingness to pay for?____ having the signs the way you want them____ having clean, public toilets in the city centre____ having more parking space in the city centre____ having more written information about the city for tourists____ having a private guided tourThe main difference with the above question is that we leave the respondents free to bid their preferred amount of money (open question). The respondent does not chose how to allocate a fixed amount of money received by the government, but chooses to contribute for the good “out of his pockets”.
30 CULTURAL ECONOMICS AND LANGUAGES: AN APPLICATION
31 CULTURAL ECONOMICS AND LANGUAGES: AN APPLICATION With respect to the above curve we can highlight some differences:the total benefits and individual average bids are lower;the curve is much more skewed, with a very inelastic segment for higher WTP levelsThis might imply that the payment vehicle for the SAME public good, really affects the individual willingness to pay.
32 CULTURAL ECONOMICS AND LANGUAGES: AN APPLICATION
33 CULTURAL ECONOMICS AND SUSTAINABLE DEVELOPMENT AND DIVERSITY Cultural economics, languages and sustainable developments and diversity is a much broader field of investigation. The crucial question, in this case, is: how far can multilingualism and language diversity improve and/or help sustainable development and sustainable diversity?
34 CULTURAL ECONOMICS AND SUSTAINABLE DEVELOPMENT AND DIVERSITY The question is very complex and difficult to address.Some attempts:Aghion and Howitt, 1992:endogenous growth theory. Investment in human capital formation positively increases national GDP.
35 CULTURAL ECONOMICS AND SUSTAINABLE DEVELOPMENT AND DIVERSITY (Ottaviano and Peri, 2004): The Economic Value of Cultural Diversity: Evidence from U.S. CitiesAuthors use data on wages and rents in different US cities to assess the amenity effects on production and consumption of cultural diversity as measured by diversity of countries of birth of city residents. Show that US-born citizens living in metropolitan areas where the share of foreign-born increased between 1970 and 1990 have experienced a significant average increase in their wage and in the rental price of their housing. Such finding is economically significant and robust to omitted variable bias and endogeneity bias..
36 CULTURAL ECONOMICS AND SUSTAINABLE DEVELOPMENT AND DIVERSITY The authors then present a model in which cultural diversity may have both production and consumption amenity or disamenity effects.As people and firms are mobile across cities in the long run, the model implies that the joint results from the wage and rent regressions are consistent with a dominant production amenity effect of cultural diversity
37 CULTURAL ECONOMICS AND SUSTAINABLE ECONOMICS AND DIVERSITY (Ottaviano and Peri, 2004): Cities and CulturesThe authors investigate the existence of wage premium due to cultural diversity across US cities. Using census data from 1970 to 1990, find that at the urban level richer diversity is systematically associated with higher average nominal wages for white US-born males. They measure cultural diversity in a city using the variety of languages spoken by city-residents. While the positive correlation between wages and diversity survives a battery of robustness checks, it seems to be larger once foreign cultures have been assimilated. Finally, instrumental variable estimation hints at causation going from diversity to wages. Comparing real and nominal wages across cities, they interpret these results as evidence that diversity enhances productivity.
38 CONCLUSIONSCultural economics and language economics are recent, though, promising fields of study, formation and research.They address many relevant cultural policy points and rely on the scientific method of economics, in order to explain, predict and evaluate choices in the field of multilingualism, linguistic landscapes and sustainable cultural (and linguistic) diversity.It is a challenge, that has just started…..!
39 email@example.com firstname.lastname@example.org Contact: Campo S. Maria Formosa 30122 Venezia - Italytel +39 | 041 |fax +39 | 041 |web