Presentation is loading. Please wait.

Presentation is loading. Please wait.

Contestability in Public Services Delivery Comprehension, Capacity and Detail. Jill Schofield, University of Edinburgh Business School.

Similar presentations


Presentation on theme: "Contestability in Public Services Delivery Comprehension, Capacity and Detail. Jill Schofield, University of Edinburgh Business School."— Presentation transcript:

1 Contestability in Public Services Delivery Comprehension, Capacity and Detail. Jill Schofield, University of Edinburgh Business School.

2 What Evaluation Framework ? Policy Evaluation Policy Evaluation Equity Equity Choice Choice Responsiveness Responsiveness Transaction costs ( Le Grand and Bartlett, 1993) Transaction costs ( Le Grand and Bartlett, 1993) Redistributive justice Redistributive justice Programme Evaluation Programme Evaluation Against Policy Objectives Against Policy Objectives KPIsKPIs Governance, Structural, leadership and performance management Governance, Structural, leadership and performance management

3 Project Evaluation Project Evaluation Typical capital project risk factors - overrun, completion to time and cost Typical capital project risk factors - overrun, completion to time and cost Partnering Relations Partnering Relations Brinkerhoff (2002) – in addition to programme outcomes look at the nature of the partnership Brinkerhoff (2002) – in addition to programme outcomes look at the nature of the partnership Appropriate behavioursAppropriate behaviours MutualityMutuality Organisational IdentityOrganisational Identity

4 Levels of Comprehension and Understanding Availability and usefulness of data and information available Availability and usefulness of data and information available Causality Causality Future stability of causal relationships Future stability of causal relationships Equal participation in the process Equal participation in the process From business case, ITN, due diligence, commercial and financial close From business case, ITN, due diligence, commercial and financial close The Balance sheets The Balance sheets

5 Decision making capacity and policy choices Decision making process types – Hickson et al,(1986) Decision making process types – Hickson et al,(1986) Constricted Constricted Sporadic Sporadic Fluid Fluid How PFI able is something ? How PFI able is something ? Cost of Capital ? Cost of Capital ?

6 Detail, Detail, Detail The Financial detail The Financial detail Affordability Affordability Risk Risk Ethical decisions Ethical decisions He need for advisors He need for advisors


Download ppt "Contestability in Public Services Delivery Comprehension, Capacity and Detail. Jill Schofield, University of Edinburgh Business School."

Similar presentations


Ads by Google