Presentation on theme: "Center for Psychosocial Health FORGIVENESS AND HIV Presentation by Will Hua and Luci Martin."— Presentation transcript:
Center for Psychosocial Health FORGIVENESS AND HIV Presentation by Will Hua and Luci Martin
Who We Are The Center for Psychosocial Health Focus on research on psychological phenomena involved in healthy living Multidisciplinary group Provide psychoeducational services to communities throughout DFW
Overview Our Research and Relevance to HIV+ Mothers Effects of Stress on HIV+ Mothers Definition of Forgiveness Current Research in Forgiveness Rationale for Project Forgive Project Forgive A Case Example Implications for Future Studies Q and A
Relevance to HIV+ Mothers What are some issues that HIV+ mothers face on a daily basis? How does the added stress of being HIV+ affect their parenting skills and styles? How can forgiveness help with these parenting issues?
How Stress Can Affect the HIV+ Mother Stress Depression Decreased medical adherence (Kalichman et al., 1999) Stress Post-partum Subsequent depression (Bernazzani et al., 1997) Stress Adverse birth outcomes Earlier delivery Lower birth weight Stress, social isolation, and behavioral disengagement greater depression (Blaney, 2004)
Effects of Unforgiveness Worthington et al. (2004) suggests four lines of evidence that support unforgiveness as a stressful event Brain activity patterns Hormonal patterns Patterns of SNS activity Blood chemistry
So…What is Forgiveness? What does it mean to you? Forgiveness is… Forgiveness is not… Forgiveness as a construct Forgive for Good (Luskin, 2002)
Forgiveness is… Two textbook answers- Dr. Luskin describes forgiveness as a trainable skill that teaches individuals to create a feeling of peace in the present moment. Further, its a process that helps individuals gain control over their feelings in order to take power back from the individuals who hurt them. Dr. Lydia Temoshok conceives forgiveness to be a multi- dimensional concept that extends beyond spiritual and existential meanings to have significant consequences for self-perceptions, coping, interpersonal relationships, as well as health and medical outcomes in the context of HIV/AIDS.
Forgiveness is… Conceptual answers- Forgiveness… is the feeling of peace that emerges when a person learns how to take hurt less personally. is taking responsibility for ones feelings. takes place by undoing each of the steps of the grievance process. is choosing to hurt and suffer less even when feeling wounded. is a complex experience that changes an offended persons feelings, emotions, thoughts, actions, and self-confidence level. (Luskin, 2002)
Forgiveness is not… Forgiveness, within the context of this intervention, differs from conventional definitions. Specifically, forgiveness is not… about reconciling with the offender forgetting something painful denying or minimizing hurt condoning unkindness excusing poor behavior It doesnt parallel any religious definition, but the concept is compatible with all religious beliefs. (Luskin, 2002)
Forgiveness as a Construct Forgiveness is a complex construct! Involves many aspects: Cognitive (Flanigan, 1992) Affective (Flanigan, 1992) Behavioral (Gordon et al., 2000 ) Motivational (McCullough et al., 1997) Decisional (DiBlasio, 1998) Interpersonal (Baumeister et al., 1998)
Current Research in Forgiveness The Forgiveness Intervention was pioneered by Dr. Fred Luskin Forgive for Good Intervention has shown success with other populations, but, to date, it has not been used in HIV+ populations Survivors of the Protestant/Catholic conflicts in Ireland Patients suffering from a range of chronic illnesses (Luskin, 2002)
Research on Forgiveness In multiple studies, the Forgiveness Intervention has shown success in: Improving the mental and physical health of people with chronic illness Reducing the physical symptoms of stress (e.g. anxiety and panic attacks) Improving the functioning of the cardiovascular, muscular, and nervous systems in people who practice forgiveness. (Luskin, 2002)
Research in Forgiveness (cont.) Forgiveness has been linked to Decreased depression (Brown & Phillips, 2005) Reduced levels of stress hormones Increased hope (Maltby et al., 2001) Increased self-esteem (McCullough, 2001) Greater life satisfaction (Brown & Phillips, 2005) Reduced hostility, anger Increased social support (Worthington & Drinkard, 2000) Overall: direct psychological benefits and indirect physical health benefits!
Study Design Randomized clinical trial of a Forgiveness Intervention designed for HIV+ women Based on the methods used by Dr. Luskin Consists of 6 group sessions using cognitive-behavioral group therapy that targets the concept of forgiveness The control group receives 6 group sessions of an educational intervention Each group consists of 7 diverse, HIV+ women Facilitated by two upper level graduate students
Study Design continued… Four group design: 2 treatment, 2 control with 7 participants per group Participants complete three computerized surveys: 1. Baseline 2. Post-Intervention 3. 3-month follow-up Group sessions and surveys conducted at the Resource Center of Dallas Participants paid for their participation
Psychosocial Changes Depression (CES-D; Radloff, 1977) Coping (COPE; Carver et al. 1989) Perceived Stress (PSS; Cohen et al., 1983) Quality of Life (MOS-HIV; Wu et al., 1999) UCLA Social Support Inventory (UCLA-SSI; Dunkel-Schetter et al., 1986)
Common Characteristics Among Sessions Handouts and In- session Activities Relaxation Exercises Homework Review of Previous Session Agenda Summary Practice
Three Key Ingredients 1. Stress management through RELAXATION 2. Changing negative emotions to POSITIVE emotions 3. Learning to THINK clearly
What is forgiveness? 1. Forgiveness is GOOD for you! 2. Forgiveness is about YOU! 3. You have CONTROL over Forgiveness! Not… - Condoning poor behavior - Giving up feelings - Reconciling with offender - Forgetting
The Grievance Process 1. The exaggerated taking of personal offense 2. The blaming of the offender for how you feel 3. The creation of a grievance story Taking up space in the mind rent free!
The Grievance Story (Yes or No) 1. Have you told your story more than twice to the same person? 2. Do you find yourself speaking to the person who hurt you even when they are not there? 3. Does your story focus primarily on your pain and what you have lost?
Positive Emotion Refocusing Technique (P.E.R.T) Utilizes breathing techniques, positive emotions, and the recognition of unresolved grievances. Helps the griever to stay calm and remain in control of his/her emotions. Helps to decrease the perceived threat of the situation. The power of the person who hurt the griever is decreased and replaced with self-confidence and feelings of peace and calm. Can be discretely employed anytime and anywhere for a variety of situations.
P.E.R.T. Demonstration Take two deep breaths, gently pushing your belly out as you inhale and consciously relaxing your belly (making it feel soft) as you exhale Take a third deep inhalation While continuing to breathe, bring to your mind an image of a loved one or a beautiful scene from nature that brings you a sense of peace Imagine these positive feelings centered in the area around the heart Continue to breath, making sure that your belly continues to rise and fall Ask the relaxed and peaceful part of you what you can do to resolve your difficulty
Changing the Channel Negative habits, thoughts and grievances compete with positive experiences Places us in the victim/martyr role Gives away personal power and choices Lowers our resistance to disease Robs us of joy 1. Gratitude Channel 2. Beauty Channel 3. Forgiveness Channel 4. Love Channel
Unenforceable Rules Think about the situation: 1. What did you want to happen? 2. What happened? 3. Did you have control over the situation? 4. What unenforceable rule was involved? RULES
From Unenforceable Rules to Wishes and Hopes We have limited power to control the behavior of another person. We can only hope that other people treat us well. We can not accurately label our own or anothers entire life. No one is truly a creep ALL of the time. To stay peaceful and be able to think straight, we can acknowledge that their rules are different from ours, and they have the right to choose not to follow ours.
The HEAL Method Mnemonic device that helps a person grasp the concepts and essentials of forgiveness Reinforces the goals of forgiveness and addresses specific hurtful experiences The first two stages focus on past events that caused grievances and ways to put them into a healing perspective, in order to move forward in life The latter two stages focus on the present and future state of forgiveness The method aims to reduce the influence that a grievance can have on a life and incorporates positive direction into ones actions
HEAL: Hope, Educate, Affirm, Long- Term Commitment Hope: a statement that represents a positive outcome desired in a hurtful situation Educate: your control over a situation or a person is limited and uncertain - Awareness that an outcome is not guaranteed Affirm: affirms a positive intention or long-term goal that was desired for a specific situation Long-term commitment: emphasizes the importance of practice and committing to ones well-being over time, by no longer dwelling on the grievance
Case Example: Jan Arrived 30 minutes late to 2 nd session Kept head down, hunched over Limited eye contact Would not participate in group activities Distrustful of others Not involved in Resource services Tearful Not aware of health terms
Jan continued… Posture Initiated conversations Had attended lunch/social groups and planned to continue Arrived on time Participated in Relaxation exercises Knowledgeable and helpful to other participants
Overview of Educational Intervention Sessions were designed to mirror the length and execution of the treatment intervention sessions A relaxation component was not included
Educational Intervention Session I: Challenges of being an HIV+ woman in todays society Session II: Nutrition and exercise specific to HIV+ women Session III: Cultural implications of HIV on Latina/Asian/African- Americans
Educational Intervention Session IV: HIV and pregnancy, childcare, parenthood, and adoption Session V: HIV and medical adherence, womens health, drug use, and alcohol consumption Session VI: HIV and dating, relationships, and disclosure
Challenges Recruitment History of Sexual Abuse Adherence Diversity within the group Diversity among Facilitators Imaging a positive or loving experience Language (i.e. Positive) Illiteracy
Implications for Future Studies Include physiological measures (CD4, cortisol, blood pressure) More diverse sample (men, Latino/a, Caucasian, SES) More diverse facilitators Variation in length of intervention Comparison to other cognitive-behavioral interventions
Conclusion What forgiveness is and is not Current research in Forgiveness and Health and Well-being Implications for research with forgiveness and HIV Project Forgive Future research and challenges
Questions and Answers
Contact Information Mark Vosvick, Ph.D. Luci A. Martin Will Hua
References Baumeister, R.F., Exline, J.J. and Sommer, K.L. (1998). The victim role, grudge theory, and two dimensions of forgiveness. In: Worthington, E.L. Jr. (Ed.), Dimensions of Forgiveness: Psychological Research and Theological Perspectives, pp Templeton Foundation Press, Philadelphia. Bernazzani, O., Saucier, J-F., David, H., Borgeat, F. (1997). Psychosocial predictors of depressive symptomatology level in postpartum women. Journal of Affect Disorders, 46, Blaney, N.T., Fernandez, M.I., Ethier, K.A., Wilson, T.E., Walter, E., Koenig, L.J. (2004). Psychosocial and Behavioral Correlates of Depression Among HIV-Infected Pregnant Women, AIDS Patient Care and STDs, 18, No. 7. Brown, R.P. & Phillips, A. (2005). Letting bygones be bygones: Further evidence for the validity of the Tendency to Forgive Scale. Personality and Individual Differences, 38, Carver, C. S., Scheier, M. F., & Weintraub, J. K. (1989). Assessing coping strategies: A theoretically based approach. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 56, Cohen, S., Kamarck, T., & Mermelstein, R. (1983). A Global Measure of Perceived Stress. Journal of Health and Social Behavior, 24, DiBlasio, F.A. (1998). The use of decision-based forgiveness intervention within intergenerational family therapy. Journal of Family Therapy, 20,
References continued… Flanigan, B. (1992). Forgiving the unforgivable. Macmillan, New York. Gordon, K.C., Baucom, D.H. and Snyder, D.K. (2000). The use of forgiveness in martial therapy. In: McCullough, M.E., Pargament, K.I. and Thoresen, C.E. (Eds.)., Forgiveness: Theory, Research, and Practice, pp Guilford Press, New York. Kalichman, S.C., Ramachandran, B., Catz S. (1999). Adherence to combination antiretroviral therapies in HIV patients of low health literacy. Journal of General Intern Medicine, 14, Maltby, J., Macaskill, A., & Day, L. (2001). Failure to forgive self and others: A replication and extension of the relationship between forgiveness, personality, social desirability and general health. Personality and Individual Differences, 30, McCullough, M.E. (2001). Forgiveness: Who does it and how do they do it? Current Directions in Psychological Science, 10, Worthington, E.L., Jr. and Drinkard, D.T. (2000). Promoting reconciliation through psychoeducational and therapeutic interventions. Journal of Marital and Family Therapy, 26, Worthington, E.L., Scherer, M. (2004). Forgiveness is an Emotion-Focused Coping Strategy that can Reduce Health Risks and Promote Health Resilience: : Theory, Review, and Hypotheses. Psychology and Health, 19,