Download presentation
Presentation is loading. Please wait.
Published byMarian Morrison Modified over 8 years ago
1
What is AR Management and Why Should I Care?
2
Not only the type of government, but whether there is sufficient government to uphold the rule of law (news report on Somali pirates)
3
Government receivables are unique as they relate to the shared responsibilities of society
4
When Government agencies are stiffed on the billing – who pays?
5
What makes some public agencies timid or neglectful in collecting their debt?
6
We all might complain about fines or fees, but don’t we also expect them to be collected?
7
50,000 Foot Fly Over Topics: WHY; HOW; WHAT and of Course WHO Results Collecting More Money Collecting More Money Faster Collecting More Money Faster for Less Cost Means (How to Do It) Restorative Recoveries Written communications Telephoning Skip tracing Credit reporting Other legal remedies
8
Stiffed on the Billing Why Should I Care?
9
Yale Law & Policy Review The Collection Gap: Underenforcement of Corporate and White-Collar Fines and Penalties By: Ezra Ross and Martin Pritikin
10
The modern administrative state depends in large part on fines, penalties, restitution orders, and similar sanctions. Contemporary policy assumes that the state, once it orders offenders to pay those sanctions, will collect them. This article suggests that we cannot depend on that assumption. Even where offenders are corporate or white- collar executives with the resources to pay, a fine imposed is in many cases not a fine collected. To the contrary, the available data shows a massive gap between penalties imposed “on the books” and penalties collected in reality.
11
.. existing scholarship has not seriously addressed what happens after the state orders offenders to pay these sanctions. Instead, the administrative enforcement literature has essentially ignored to what extent offenders actually pay the penalties imposed against them. This Article seeks to describe empirically, for the first time, the degree to which regulators follow through on enforcing corporate and white-collar fines and penalties.
12
…Administrative agencies never collect the vast brunt of regulatory and criminal penalties. The U.S. Department of Justice, for example, has collected in recent years less than 4% of criminal penalties and fines it imposes.
13
… The disconnect between enforcement expectations and enforcement reality extends to agency attitudes. According to scholars, regulators impose fines to deter misconduct, compensate victims, and generate government revenue. Ensuring offenders actually pay helps achieve those enforcement goals.
14
During a recession in which governments are slashing budgets, cutting back public services, and laying off workers, they are at the same time neglecting to recover huge sums from corporations and executives that have actually been found to have engaged in wrongdoing. Particularly in such an economic environment, one would expect a groundswell of support to push government agencies to improve their fine collection rates. End of Excerpt from Yale Law & Policy Review
15
Stiffed on the Billing Why Should I Care?
16
The incentive problems that undermine a commitment to collections at the personnel and management levels of administrative agencies likely lie at the heart of undercollection. Page 507
17
Fines collected by agencies typically go to general coffers rather than to the collecting agency. Page 467
18
Stiffed on the Billing Why Should I Care?
19
Why Should I Care? Very simply because society is relying on you to make it a functional reality!
20
50,000 Foot Fly Over Topics: WHY; HOW; WHAT and of Course WHO Results Collecting More Money Collecting More Money Faster Collecting More Money Faster for Less Cost Means (How to Do It) Restorative Recoveries Written communications Telephoning Skip tracing Credit reporting Other legal remedies
21
Stiffed on the Billing HOW Should I Proceed?
22
Stiffed on the Billing HOW Should I Proceed? Justly
23
Stiffed on the Billing HOW Should I Proceed? Knowledgeably
24
Stiffed on the Billing HOW Should I Proceed? Evenly
25
Stiffed on the Billing HOW Should I Proceed? A Citizen Friendly Approach
26
Stiffed on the Billing HOW Should I Proceed? With Equitable Process
27
Stiffed on the Billing HOW Should I Proceed? Justly
28
How Do I Collect Justly? What are the just tools, processes, and rules? Fair Debt Collection Practices Act Fair Credit Reporting Act No Preferential Treatment Address Any Complaints Head On Invite Inspection and Transparency
29
Stiffed on the Billing HOW Should I Proceed? Knowledgeably
30
How Do I Collect Knowledgeably? How Do I Go About Learning and Developing? Define Success in Your Collections Environment Learn to Measure What Matters Develop A Review Process Tap in to Best Practices Never Stop Learning and Growing
31
Stiffed on the Billing HOW Should I Proceed? Evenly
32
How Do I Collect Evenly? What is “Evenness” in Collections? Get in Control of Your Time Develop a Written Credit and Collections Policy Don’t Break Your Stride for Exceptions Use a Systematic Process
33
Stiffed on the Billing HOW Should I Proceed? A Citizen Friendly Approach
34
How Do I Make Collections Citizen Friendly? How Can I Set Up Citizen Friendly Collections? Put Yourself in the Other Person’s Shoes Expect the Best of People Educate, Counsel, and Advise for THEIR sake Know the Various Reasons People Do Not Pay Never Assume the Worst Customer Service is before a problem Damage control is after a problem has occurred
35
Stiffed on the Billing HOW Should I Proceed? With Equitable Process
36
What is Equitable Process in Collections? How Can I See Equitable Process in Collections? Are the Right People Paying? Are the Lawful Payers Being Well Represented? Is a Clear and Helpful Example Being Set? Are Those Out of Compliance Held Accountable? Are the Tax Payers Being Well Represented? Is the System Free of Favortism? Are Justice and Mercy in Balance?
37
50,000 Foot Fly Over Topics: WHY; HOW; WHAT and of Course WHO Results Collecting More Money Collecting More Money Faster Collecting More Money Faster for Less Cost Means (How to Do It) Restorative Recoveries Written communications Telephoning Skip tracing Credit reporting Other legal remedies
38
Stiffed on the Billing WHAT can be done?
39
Stiffed on the Billing WHAT can be done? Define Success
40
Stiffed on the Billing WHAT can be done? Optimize Processes
41
Stiffed on the Billing WHAT can be done? All That Should Be Done, Is Done
42
Stiffed on the Billing WHAT can be done? Employ Economy of Scale When Helpful
43
Stiffed on the Billing WHAT can be done? Define Success
44
You Get What You Measure
45
You Get What You Measure Your Receivables Dashboard
46
Value of a Dashboard
47
“Research in human psychology and crisis case studies have shown that even when the public doesn't know where a crisis is headed, if they are able to have confidence in the process, heart rates drop, physical stress is reduced, and emotional upset is calmed.” – Kaulkin Media
48
What Are The Deliverables in Receivables? 1.Do No Harm 2.Collect More Money 3.Collect More Money Faster 4.Collect More Money Faster for Less Cost Instruments on your dashboard should tell you the following: Citizen Friendly - Proven Collecting More Money Collecting More Money Faster – Placement to Receipt of Cash Collecting More Money Faster for Less Cost
49
Do No Harm Dashboard Citizen Friendly 100% 100% Transparent Process Complaints at Zero to None
50
Recovery Rate % of Total Batch Recovered % who Respond % Fully Worked
51
Time from Placed To Receipt # Months for Recovery Cash Flow Path to Your Hands Decay of Collectible Value
52
Collection Cost Net Back $ Paid to Collection Agency % Cost to Collect
53
Million Dollar Mountain One million in receivables are represented by this mountain. This is YOUR money, owed and past due.
54
Million Dollar Mountain Cherry Picked Accounts Identified for collections The rest of your receivables Typical Collections Approach
55
Million Dollar Mountain These accounts are worked intensely This loss is the hidden cost of typical approaches to collections These accounts, not worked or lightly worked, deteriorate by at least10% per month. This loss is the hidden cost of typical approaches to collections Typical Collections Approach
56
Restorative Recoveries Restore Communication Debtor to Creditor They Reconcile Amount Owed Both Parties Recover
57
Restorative Recoveries 100% Worked Systematically Direct Pay to Agency Fixed Fee Provides ROI
58
Restorative Recoveries 100% Worked Systematically Fastest to Money Minimum 400% ROI
59
Collecting More Money
60
Collect More Money
62
Collect it Faster
63
Collect More Money Collect it Faster Collect it for Less Cost
64
Do No Harm Dashboard Citizen Friendly 100% 100% Transparent Process Complaints at Zero to None
65
Collect More Money Use a Systematic Process
66
Start—30 to 60 Days Delinquent Month 1Month 2Month 3Month 4 Letter 1 -Day 1 -Audit -Demand -Bad Check Optional Letter -Day 30 -Employment Verification Letter 2 -Day 30 -Mailgram Letter 3 -Day 42 -Strong Demand Letter 4 -Day 56 -Attorney Demand Letter 5 -Day 70 -Final Demand Credit Reporting -Day 100 Telephone Predictive Dialing Secondary PhaseSecondary Phase Skip Tracing
67
Collect More Money Have a Written Credit and Collections Policy
68
Collect More Money Have a Written Credit and Collections Policy What do you do at 30 days? 60 days? 90 days?
69
Collect More Money Optimize Stages of Recovery
70
Traditional 2-Step Collection Process Late AccountLate Account Day 75 Day 240 Step 1- Internal Collection—Letters, Calls, Invoices, etc. EffectiveIneffective Step 2- Contingency
71
Recommended 3-Step Collection Process Late AccountLate Account Day 75 Day 195 Step 1- Internal Collection Effective Effective for 3 rd Party Step 2- Early Out/ Fixed Fee Step 3- Contingency
72
Collect More Money Be Ready to Negotiate
73
Collect More Money Be Ready to Negotiate First Payment
74
Collect More Money Be Ready to Negotiate First Payment 40%
75
Collect More Money Outsource the RIGHT Tasks
76
Restorative Recoveries 3 Recovery 1 Restoration 2 Reconciliation
77
Start—30 to 60 Days Delinquent Month 1Month 2Month 3Month 4 Letter 1 -Day 1 -Audit -Demand -Bad Check Optional Letter -Day 30 -Employment Verification Letter 2 -Day 30 -Mailgram Letter 3 -Day 42 -Strong Demand Letter 4 -Day 56 -Attorney Demand Letter 5 -Day 70 -Final Demand Credit Reporting -Day 100 Telephone Predictive Dialing Secondary PhaseSecondary Phase Skip Tracing
78
Faithfulness Works in Three Ways! It works, because we work, and you can see our works! Faithfulness Works! It is effective. A faithful and equitable process is better in every way. It stresses compliance, and recovers more money faster for less cost. Randomness is randomly effective. Faithfulness works! Faithfulness Works! It works and it works hard. A faithful process works every account in the same systematic way. Every account placed, WILL be worked. Working each and every account is a sustainable, transparent, and verifiable means of resolving every case to the maximum extent possible. Faithfulness Works! These "works" are faithfulness works. It works, because as we work, these are works of faithfulness. Send a series of fully compliant letters - each a work of faithfulness. Make a series of fully compliant phone calls. Skip trace with a system that tracks the untrackable. Credit report to incentivize payment and to protect other creditors from fraud. Works of faithfulness characterize system's components.
79
Collecting More Money FASTER
80
Collect More Money FASTER
81
Do No Harm Dashboard Citizen Friendly 100% 100% Transparent Process Complaints at Zero to None
82
Collect More Money
83
Collect it Faster
84
Collect More Money Collect it Faster Collect it for Less Cost
85
Collect More Money FASTER Collect More Money Collect it Faster Collect it for Less Cost
86
Collect More Money Use a Systematic Process
87
Start—30 to 60 Days Delinquent Month 1Month 2Month 3Month 4 Letter 1 -Day 1 -Audit -Demand -Bad Check Optional Letter -Day 30 -Employment Verification Letter 2 -Day 30 -Mailgram Letter 3 -Day 42 -Strong Demand Letter 4 -Day 56 -Attorney Demand Letter 5 -Day 70 -Final Demand Credit Reporting -Day 100 Telephone Predictive Dialing Secondary PhaseSecondary Phase Skip Tracing
88
Collect More Money Faster WHY? It’s What Works Justice Delayed is Justice Denied
89
Collect More Money Faster HOW?
90
Collect More Money Faster HOW? Don’t Let the Exception Become the Rule
91
Collect More Money Faster HOW? Don’t Let the Exception Become the Rule [Move now on the clear cases]
92
Collect More Money Faster HOW?
93
Collect More Money Faster HOW? Find and Eliminate Unnecessary Tasks
94
Collect More Money Faster HOW?
95
Collect More Money Faster HOW? Decide WHEN you will work on them and then do it
96
Collect More Money Faster WHAT?
97
Collect More Money Faster WHAT? Clarify and Notify
98
Faithfulness Works in Three Ways! It works, because we work, and you can see our works! Faithfulness Works! It is effective. A faithful and equitable process is better in every way. It stresses compliance, and recovers more money faster for less cost. Randomness is randomly effective. Faithfulness works! Faithfulness Works! It works and it works hard. A faithful process works every account in the same systematic way. Every account placed, WILL be worked. Working each and every account is a sustainable, transparent, and verifiable means of resolving every case to the maximum extent possible. Faithfulness Works! These "works" are faithfulness works. It works, because as we work, these are works of faithfulness. Send a series of fully compliant letters - each a work of faithfulness. Make a series of fully compliant phone calls. Skip trace with a system that tracks the untrackable. Credit report to incentivize payment and to protect other creditors from fraud. Works of faithfulness characterize system's components.
99
Collect More Money Faster WHAT?
100
Collect More Money Faster WHAT? Remind and Advance
101
Collect More Money Faster WHAT?
102
Collect More Money Faster WHAT? Use the tools faithfully and consistently
103
TAKE ACTION SOONER BEFORE: RESULTS $4968 BEFORE: $4968/MO BEFORE: AGE OF CLAIMS 180-400
104
TAKE ACTION SOONER AFTER: RESULTS EXCELLENT AFTER: $18,842/MO AFTER: AGE OF CLAIMS 75-150
105
TAKE ACTION SOONER BEFORE: RESULTS $4968 BEFORE: $4968/MO BEFORE: AGE OF CLAIMS 180-400
106
TAKE ACTION SOONER AFTER: RESULTS $18,842 INCREASE 379% AFTER: AGE OF CLAIMS 75-150
107
Start—30 to 60 Days Delinquent Month 1Month 2Month 3Month 4 Letter 1 -Day 1 -Audit -Demand -Bad Check Optional Letter -Day 30 -Employment Verification Letter 2 -Day 30 -Mailgram Letter 3 -Day 42 -Strong Demand Letter 4 -Day 56 -Attorney Demand Letter 5 -Day 70 -Final Demand Credit Reporting -Day 100 Telephone Predictive Dialing Secondary PhaseSecondary Phase Skip Tracing
108
Collecting More Money Faster FOR LESS COST
109
Collect More Money Faster FOR LESS COST
110
Do No Harm Dashboard Citizen Friendly 100% 100% Transparent Process Complaints at Zero to None
111
Collect More Money
112
Collect More Money Faster Collect More Money Collect it Faster
113
Collect More Money Faster FOR LESS COST Collect More Money Collect it Faster Collect it for Less Cost
114
To Lower Collection Costs Use a Systematic Process
115
Start—30 to 60 Days Delinquent Month 1Month 2Month 3Month 4 Letter 1 -Day 1 -Audit -Demand -Bad Check Optional Letter -Day 30 -Employment Verification Letter 2 -Day 30 -Mailgram Letter 3 -Day 42 -Strong Demand Letter 4 -Day 56 -Attorney Demand Letter 5 -Day 70 -Final Demand Credit Reporting -Day 100 Telephone Predictive Dialing Secondary PhaseSecondary Phase Skip Tracing
116
Collect More Money Faster FOR LESS COST Two approaches:
117
Collect More Money Faster FOR LESS COST Two approaches: 1. Cost cutting
118
Collect More Money Faster FOR LESS COST Two approaches: 1. Cost cutting 2. Productivity of assets
119
Collect More Money Faster FOR LESS COST Two approaches: 1. Cost cutting 2. Productivity of assets
120
To Lower Collection Costs Total Cost of Ownership
121
To Lower Collection Costs What is THE most expensive component in debt collection?
122
To Lower Collection Costs What is THE most expensive component in debt collection? TIME
123
To Lower Collection Costs What is THE most costly behavior in debt collection?
124
To Lower Collection Costs What is THE most costly behavior in debt collection? NEGLECT
125
To Lower Collection Costs A cliché because it is so helpful and true:
126
To Lower Collection Costs A cliché because it is so helpful and true: An ounce of prevention is worth a pound of cure
127
To Lower Collection Costs An ounce of prevention is worth a pound of cure That’s 16 to 1
128
To Lower Collection Costs Know the Value Oregon audit “…median return rate for collection costs was over eight dollars for each dollar spent.” Yale Law and Policy Review: Page 498 fn 299
129
To Lower Collection Costs Seize the Day! GAO “..average delay between entry of judgment and lien filing was 639 days” Yale Law and Policy Review: Page 489
130
To Lower Collection Costs Do the Math! Netback IS the key. Here’s how to calculate: Recovery rate – collection cost = netback
131
To Lower Collection Costs Do the Math! NETBACK 3% Recovery Rate 33% Cost to Collect 2% Netback
132
To Lower Collection Costs Do the Math! NETBACK 20% Recovery Rate 50% Cost to Collect 10% Netback
133
To Lower Collection Costs Do the Math! NETBACK 30.3% Recovery Rate 5.78% Cost to Collect 28.55% Netback
134
To Lower Collection Costs We Have Found Optimize Each Stage 30-75 days: work internally 75-120 days: fixed fee method 120 days+: sort into categories
135
Who Should Care? All Citizens, Financial Decision Makers, Elected Officials, Finance Officers, Budget Directors, Billing Managers
136
Who Gets it Done? Compliance Professionals
137
50,000 Foot Fly Over Topics: WHY; HOW; WHAT and of Course WHO Results Collecting More Money Collecting More Money Faster Collecting More Money Faster for Less Cost Means (How to Do It) Restorative Recoveries Written communications Telephoning Skip tracing Credit reporting Other legal remedies
138
Faithfulness Works in Three Ways! It works, because we work, and you can see our works! Faithfulness Works! It is effective. A faithful and equitable process is better in every way. It stresses compliance, and recovers more money faster for less cost. Randomness is randomly effective. Faithfulness works! Faithfulness Works! It works and it works hard. A faithful process works every account in the same systematic way. Every account placed, WILL be worked. Working each and every account is a sustainable, transparent, and verifiable means of resolving every case to the maximum extent possible. Faithfulness Works! These "works" are faithfulness works. It works, because as we work, these are works of faithfulness. Send a series of fully compliant letters - each a work of faithfulness. Make a series of fully compliant phone calls. Skip trace with a system that tracks the untrackable. Credit report to incentivize payment and to protect other creditors from fraud. Works of faithfulness characterize system's components.
139
“Research in human psychology and crisis case studies have shown that even when the public doesn't know where a crisis is headed, if they are able to have confidence in the process, heart rates drop, physical stress is reduced, and emotional upset is calmed.” – Kaulkin Media
Similar presentations
© 2024 SlidePlayer.com Inc.
All rights reserved.