1. Chandan Rupakheti Office: Moench Room F203 Phone: (812) 877-8390 Email: rupakhet@rose-hulman.edu These slides and others derived from Shawn Bohner, Curt Clifton, Alex Lo, and others involved in delivering 374. CSSE 374: Getting a Grasp on GRASP Q1 Steve Chenoweth Office: Moench Room F220 Phone: (812) 877-8974 Email: chenowet@rose-hulman.edu Left – Whose responsibility is it? Always a tough question, and the results vary! 

2. In the flow of programming… It’s a lot like playing music –  Combines effortless logic  With intuition  And “it” loves for us to do it! But…  “The flow” suppresses self- consciousness  Which is the part of the brain that’s supposed to remember what you did! So, when you come back to your own code –  You need to rely on its being logical, conceptual, and coherent!  Thus – OO… and Patterns! And anyone else reading it surely needs this, too! 

3. Mastering Object-Oriented Design A large set of soft principles It isn’t magic. We learn it with:  Patterns (named, explained, and applied)  Examples  Practice “The critical design tool for software development is a mind well- educated in design principles.” Q2 

4. Today SOLID  GRASP (From Uncle Bob back to Larman) SRP specifically – The basis for the Cohesion pattern, that we’ll study today SRP more generally – basis for today’s “Responsibility Driven Design” ideas   Bob Martin – Popularized SRP Craig Larman – Your Book’s Author

5. Responsibility-Driven Design Responsibility Driven Design (RDD)  Pioneered by Rebecca Wirfs-Brock in early 1990s Think of objects in terms of:  What they do or What they know …the human worker metaphor! An object’s obligation or contract that it offers to other objects 

6. Responsibilities for an Object Doing  a Sale is responsible for creating instances of SalesLineItem Knowing  a Sale is responsible for knowing its total cost 

7. Knowing and Doing Responsibilities “Doing” Responsibilities  Create another object  Perform a calculation  Initiate an action in an object  Control/coordinate activities of objects “Knowing” Responsibilities  Knowing it’s own encapsulated data  Knowing about other objects  Knowing things it can derive or calculate Q3,4 

8. Responsibilities Come in All Sizes BIG : provide access to a relational database small: create a Sale A responsibility is not the same thing as a method 

9. When Do We Assign Responsibilities? While coding While modeling  UML is a low-cost modeling tool  Can assign responsibilities with minimal investment 

10. General Responsibility Assignment Software Patterns (GRASP) 1/2 General Responsibility Assignment Software Patterns (or Principles)  A set of patterns for assigning responsibilities to software objects What is a Pattern?  A pattern is a named and well-known problem-solution pair that can be applied in a new context 

11. General Responsibility Assignment Software Patterns (GRASP) 2/2 Five Covered In Chapter 17 1. Creator 2. Information Expert 3. Controller 4. Low Coupling 5. High Cohesion Four Later In Chapter 25  PolymorphismPure Fabrication IndirectionProtected Variations 

12. Design: Floor Tiles The worst part is when sidewalk cracks are out-of- sync with your natural stride. 

13. Information Expert Pattern Pattern Name Information Expert Problem What is a basic principle by which to assign responsibilities to objects? Solution Assign a responsibility to the class that has the information needed to fulfill it. Names Matter! “New pattern” is an oxymoron! Q5,6 

14. Information Expert and Unique IDs Basic principle of RDD: Assign responsibility to the object that has the required information  “Tell the expert to do it!” Who should get a square given a unique ID?  Let the Board do it because it knows about the squares 

15. Creator Pattern Who should create object A? Solution (advice): Let B do it if:  B contains or aggregates A  B records A  B closely uses A  B has the initializing data for A Monopoly Board Example  When you start a game, who creates the squares for the board?  Let Board create them since it contains the squares Q7 

16. Monopoly Example 

17. Create “in Action” 

18. Composition 

19. Exercise on Creator Examples Break up into your project teams Given the following:  Domain Model for BBVS Identify Creator pattern examples (hint)  B contains or aggregates A  B records A  B closely uses A  B has the initializing data for A Q8 

20. Store Address Phone# Customer name address phone# Video ID Transaction date Payment /amount: Money type authorization Initiates   Records- rental-of Pays-for  Transacts  Rents-from, Buys-from  Stocks  Selects  *1 1 * * 1 * 1..*111 0..* 1 Makes- Authorizes  1 1..* Rental dueDate ReturnDate ReturnTime VideoDescription title subjectCategory VideoSupplier address name newVideos Basket Shelf location stock Membership ID startDate PricingPolicy perDayRentalCharge perDayLateCharge 1 Obtains  1 1  Maintains 1 * Determines- rental-charge  1 *  Contains 1 * * 1  Stores- video-on  Defines 1 *  Provides 1 * * Describes  Contains  1 0..*  Provides 1 0..* 1 1  Holds- videos-in 1 

21. GRASP Fits in with the Goals of Software Design In many areas of engineering: In software: Gather Requirements Design for Production Build & Sell It / Them Decide What to Do Next Gather Requirements Design & Deliver Rel 1 Design & Deliver Rel 10 Decide What to Do Next … Short engineering cycle. Maintenance is most of the engineering cycle. So, we need to keep coming back to the design. 

22. GRASP Fits in with Systems Engineering Principles Like top-down design that minimizes interface complexity: And having an understandable “design” to build the pieces into. 