Presentation on theme: "1 Large Research and Medical Databases Clinical Trial Registry and National Medical Database : Indian Initiatives Dr. Vijay Kumar Scientist F and Head,"— Presentation transcript:
1 Large Research and Medical Databases Clinical Trial Registry and National Medical Database : Indian Initiatives Dr. Vijay Kumar Scientist F and Head, Division of Basic Medical Sciences Indian Council of Medical Research (ICMR) New Delhi.
2 2 Biomedical Research Strength India 1.5lac sub-centres, 23,000 primary health centres, 4000 community health centres 1,600 urban family welfare centres Heterogeneous Population >1.2 billon Different Ethnic Groups Endogamous tribal population (conserved gene pool) above 270 Medical Colleges > 400 Research Institutes > 370 Universities 11,500 hospitals and 14,000 diagnostic laboratories 50 R&D labs in the public sector & 200 in Govt. Sector
3 Indian Council of Medical Research ( ICMR ) The apex body in India for the formulation, coordination and promotion of biomedical research under Department of Health Research, Ministry of Health and Family Welfare, Government of India Established in 1911, as Indian Research Fund Association (IRFA) Re-designated in 1949 as the Indian Council of Medical Research (ICMR) with considerably expanded scope of functions. Intramural research is carried out through the Council's theme oriented 33 permanent research institutes/centers and including 6 regional centers addressing to regional health problems Extramural research is done through center for advanced research, task force projects, ad hoc research schemes and fellowships in different universities, medical colleges in the country.
4 The Mandate of ICMR To undertake and support basic, epidemiological, applied and operational research in the areas of national public health importance using tools including those of modern biology.
5 FundamentalStrategicProduct development and evaluation Operational Research Communicable diseases Non-communicable diseases Reproductive health Nutrition Basic sciences Medicinal plants, Traditional Medicine Ethics, IPR, socio- behaviour sciences Thrust Areas
6 Clinical Trial Regulated under Schedule Y of Drugs and Cosmetic Act 1940 Human clinical trials are conducted To demonstrate the efficacy and safety of a new drug To explore new indication, New route of administration New combination of old drugs. Clinical trials form the basis for therapeutic decisions by all physicians, therefore, it is essential that they be able to evaluate the results and conclusions of such trials critically.
7 New Drug Development Clinical Evaluation-Good Clinical Practices Phase I (Safety / tolerance) Pharmacokinetic-Healthy volunteers/exceptions Phase II (Efficacy and dose range studies conducted on patients) Phase III (Clinical trials on large number of patients) Phase IV (Post marketing surveillance)
8 Need for Clinical Trials Registry Clinical trials hold enormous potential for benefiting patients, improving therapeutic regimens and ensuring advancement in medical practice that is evidence based. Unfortunately, the data and reports of various trials are often difficult to find and in some cases do not even exist as many trials abandoned or are not published due to "negative" or equivocal results. However, this tendency for availability of only selective information from the myriad clinical trials conducted is not commensurate with the practice of "evidence-based medicine. Today, world over, a need has been felt on the imperative for transparency, accountability and accessibility in order to re- establish public trust in clinical trial data. And this would be feasible only if all clinical trials conducted are registered in a centralized clinical trials registry. Registration of trials will ensure transparency, accountability and accessibility of clinical trials
9 Interactive workshop on Building and managing clinical trial capacity in India : Challenges in Ethics, Equity and Efficiency held on October 21-22, 2005 Recommendations A registry for all Clinical trials should be created with multiple stakeholders be part of the design process of such a registry for it to be meaningful. Such a registry should have a public and a confidential element. Some key items may need to be blocked from the public view (such as raw data pertaining to SAEs and proprietary information) but necessary for regulatory enforcement purposes and scientific research
12 Clinical Trials Registry of India The Clinical Trials Registry- India (CTRI), hosted at the ICMRs National Institute of Medical Statistics (NIMS), is a free and online public record system for registration of clinical trials being conducted in India that was launched on 20 th July 2007 (www.ctri.nic.in).www.ctri.nic.in Initiated as a voluntary measure, since 15 th June 2009, trial registration in the CTRI has been made mandatory by the Drugs Controller General (India) (DCGI) (www.cdsco.nic.in).www.cdsco.nic.in Moreover, Editors of Biomedical Journals of 11 major journals of India declared that only registered trials would be considered for publication 1, 2.
Clinical Trials Registry of India Multi-country trials, where India is a participating country, which have been registered in an international registry, are also expected to be registered in the CTRI. In the CTRI, details of Indian investigators, trial sites, Indian target sample size and date of enrollment are captured. 13
14 Mission Encourage all clinical trials to be prospectively registered before enrolment of first patient To comply with ICMJE and WHO-ICTRP requirements Vision To ensure that every clinical trial conducted in the region is prospectively registered with full disclosure of the trial data set items. While this register is meant primarily for trials conducted in India, the CTRI will also accept registration of trials conducted in other countries in the region, which do not have a Primary Registry of its own. To improve transparency To improve internal validity of trials Conform to accepted ethical standards Reporting of all relevant results of registered trials Mission and Vision
15 To establish a public record system by registering all clinical trials on health products that are drugs, devices, vaccines, herbal drugs and made available to both public and healthcare professionals in an unbiased, scientific and timely manner To create a more complete, authentic, and readily available data of all ongoing and completed clinical trials Increase awareness and accountability of all the participants of the clinical trials and also for public access. Objectives
16 Web based access from any computer with internet connectivity Scalable to cover more countries Designed and developed on Open Technologies Three levels of Access User (Authorized to submit Trials) Administrator (Responsible for administering the Registry) Public (Facility to search information) Features of Registry
17 The information collected is available to the general public at no cost. The Registry would be a searchable Primary register, which is to be linked to the WHOs ICTRP. Registration is voluntary To register a study, trialists need to submit information on the Data Set items before enrolment of the first patient Features of Registry
18 All interventional clinical trials conducted in India and involving Indian participants need to be registered. An interventional clinical trial is any research study that prospectively assigns people to one or more health-related interventions to evaluate their effects on health-related outcomes. Examples include but are not limited to: Preventive care, Drugs (including herbal), Surgical procedures, Behavioral treatments, Medical devices etc. Thus, early and late trials, trials of marketed or non- marketed products, randomized or non-randomized trials -- all should be registered. If in doubt about whether to register or not, registration is recommended. Trial Registration Criteria
19 Registration Data Set UTRN WHO * CTRI No WHO * Trial Registration Date WHO * Title of study WHO * Scientific Title of Study WHO * Secondary IDs, if any WHO Principal Investigators Name and Address Contact Person (Scientific Query) WHO Contact Person (Public Query) WHO Source/s of Monetary or Material Support WHO Primary Sponsor WHO Secondary Sponsor WHO Countries of Recruitment WHO Site/s of study Name of Ethics Committee and approval status* Regulatory Clearance obtained from DCGI* Health Condition/Problem studied WHO Study Type WHO Intervention & Comparator agent WHO Key inclusion /Exclusion Criteria WHO Method of generating randomization sequence Method of allocation concealment Blinding and masking Primary Outcome/s WHO Secondary Outcome/s WHO Target sample size WHO Phase of Trial * Date of first enrollment WHO Estimated duration of trial Status of Trial WHO * Brief Summary
20 Some fields are mandatory for registration to proceed. All WHO fields [marked] need to be completed if the trial is to receive a registration number and fulfill WHO/ICMJE requirements. Both date of submission and date of registration are recorded. Trialists are encouraged to include subsequent protocol amendments and give regular updates on the status of trial. All amendments and original entries will be recorded (audit trail) Trial Registration Requirements
21 Voluntary – ensuring compliance Improving quality of clinical trials Scaling up Sustainability Challenges
23 National Medical Research Database
24 Clinical Research Database A Clinical Research Database is a tool used as part of the data collection process. A database allows you to store your research data collected in the field in an organized fashion so that it can be easily analyzed in statistical programs. The steps involve the initial process of collecting corresponding clinical information in a database
25 National Medical Research Database ICMR initiative : Commissioning National Centre for Disease Informatics (NCDIR), Bangalore in March 2011 The new centre was the outcome of the sustained and successful run of the National Cancer Registry Programme since December The main objective of the NCDIR is To sustain and develop a national research data-base on cancer, diabetes, CVD and stroke through recent advances in electronic information technology with a national collaborative network, so as to undertake aetiological, epidemiological, clinical and control research in these areas.
26 National Centre for Disease Informatics (NCDIR) Current thrust areas of NCDIR: Cancer Registries - National Cancer Registry Programme (NCRP) Patterns of Cancer Patient Care and Survival Development of Software Applications Programmes The NCRP, as of now, has a network of - 27 population based, - 9 hospital based cancer registries and - 17 centres collaborating in the study on Patterns of Care and Survival Studies
27 National Centre for Disease Informatics (NCDIR) Major achievements Collection of disease data in a systematic way providing actual incidence (not estimates) as per international standards and quoted. Sustained programme for over 25 years providing valid estimates of the burden and patterns of cancer. The cancer atlas project helped map patterns of cancer in a cost effective way using recent advances in Electronic Information Technology. This gave a new concept in data collection and broadened the field of disease informatics. It identified many researchable areas; motivated pathologists and clinical oncologists across country to collaborate and participate in cancer research; with minimum effort provided critical base line information at district level. Finally it opened the entire North Eastern states for cancer registration and research
28 Other contributions of NCDIR Overall the contributions of the NCRP are the following: Towards Epidemiological and other Research Identification of geographic areas for site specific research; Identification of variation in sites of tobacco related cancers vis-à-vis geographic areas; laid a foundation for studies in molecular epidemiology Towards Cancer Control Identified especially through the cancer atlas different sites for priority towards cancer control; Provide an idea of the magnitude and trends over time in different sites of cancer; Provided information for doing evidence based cancer control activities through specific indicators.
29 Other contributions of NCDIR Towards Patient Care Identification of deficiencies in cancer patient care in the Indian setting in terms of standardised recording of clinical information, compliance to treatment and follow-up; Identification of proportion of patients presenting at late stage; Laid a framework towards clinical evaluation and multi-centric trials. The NCRP through its network of cancer registries has several national and international publications in Descriptive and Analytical Epidemiology that are of national relevance and importance.
31 Creation of Genetic disease registry, DNA banking and EBV transformed cell lines from informative families of rare genetic disorders at Department of Medical Genetics, SGPGI, Lucknow Under this project DNA samples of 3531 individuals have been collected and DNA has been / is being extracted and stored at C. This includes samples from 1299 probands with various genetic disorders and clinical presentations with possibly genetic etiology. The number of samples from family members of the patients with genetic disorders is The clinical data including clinical presentation and detailed investigation reports is stored.
32 Ethics provisions adopted
34 Ethical Guidelines on Biomedical Research (1980/2000/2006) Modifications Ethics committee review procedures Informed consent – re- consent, vulnerable populations & waiver Post – trial access Disaster & emergency research Clinical research including herbal/traditional drugs Stored tissue research Stem cell research
35 Ethical Guidelines on Biomedical Research on Human Participants 2006 General Statement Medical and related research using human beings as research participants must necessarily ensure that – (i) The PURPOSE, of such research is that it should be directed towards: The increase of knowledge about the human condition in relation to its social and natural environment Mindful that the human species is one of the many species in a planet in which the well being of all species is under threat, No less from the human species as any other, and that such research is for the betterment of all, Especially the least advantaged.
36 Ethical Guidelines on Biomedical Research on Human Participants 2006 (ii) Such research is CONDUCTED under conditions that No person or persons become a mere means for the betterment of others and that human beings who are subject to any medical research or scientific experimentation are dealt with in a manner conducive to and consistent with their dignity and well being, under conditions of professional fair treatment and transparency; and After ensuring that the participant is placed at no greater risk other than such risk commensurate with the well being of the participant in question in the light of the object to be achieved. Such research must be subjected to a regime of EVALUATION at all stages of the proposal i.e. research design and experimentation, declaration of results and use of results thereof.
37 Ethical Guidelines on Biomedical Research on Human Participants 2006 These 12 principles laid down under Statement on General Principles are common to all areas of biomedical research Essentiality Voluntariness, informed consent and community agreement Non-exploitation Privacy and confidentiality Precaution and risk minimisation Professional competence Accountability and transparency Maximisation of the public interest Institutional arrangements Public domain Totality of responsibility Compliance
38 Ethical Guidelines on Biomedical Research on Human Participants 2006 Principles of privacy and confidentiality whereby the identity and records of the human participants of the research or experiment are as far as possible kept confidential; -and that no details about identity of said human participants which would result in the disclosure of their identity, are disclosed without valid scientific and legal reasons which may be essential for the purposes of therapeutics or other interventions, without the specific consent in writing of the human participant concerned, or someone authorised on their behalf; -and after ensuring that the said human participant does not suffer from any form of hardship, discrimination or stigmatisation as a consequence of having participated in the research or experiment
39. Ethical Guidelines on Biomedical Research on Human Participants 2006 Principles of accountability and transparency whereby the research or experiment will be conducted in a fair, honest, impartial and transparent manner after full disclosure is made by those associated with the research or experiment of each aspect of their interest in the research, and any conflict of interest that may exist; and whereby, subject to the principles of privacy and confidentiality and the rights of the researcher, full and complete records of the research inclusive of data and notes are retained for such reasonable period as may be prescribed or considered necessary for the purposes of post-research monitoring, evaluation of the research, conducting further research (whether by the initial or otherwise) and in order to make such records available for scrutiny by the appropriate legal and administrative authority, if necessary
40 Ethical Guidelines on Biomedical Research on Human Participants 2006 Principles of public domain whereby the research and any further research, experimentation or evaluation in response to, and emanating from such research is brought into the public domain so that its results are generally made known through scientific and other publications subject to such rights as are available to the researcher and those associated with the research under the law in force at that time.
41 Specific Principles Clinical Trials of Drugs, Devices, Vaccines, Diagnostic agents, Herbal Drugs : Approval of DCGI is required. Epidemiological Studies Human Genetics Research Transplantation Research including Fetal tissue transplantation Assisted Reproductive Technologies
42 Expectation All institutions in the country which carry out any form of biomedical research involving human beings should follow these guidelines in letter and spirit to protect safety and well being of all individuals. Guidelines available at :
43 References Pandey A, Aggarwal AR, Seth SD, Maulik, M, Bano R. Juneja A. Clinical Trials Registry India: Redefining the conduct of clinical trials. Indian J Cancer 2008; 45 (3): Pandey A, Aggarwal A, Maulik, M, Seth SD. Clinical trial registration gains momentum in India. Indian J Med Res [Letter to Editor] 2009; 130: Pandey A, Aggarwal AR, Seth SD, Maulik, M. Clinical Trials Registry India: Raising the veil. Natl Med J India [Letter to Editor]2010; 23 (3): Schulz KF, Chalmers I, Hayes RJ, Altman D. Empirical evidence of bias. Dimensions of methodological quality associated with estimates of treatment effects in controlled clinical trials. JAMA 1995; 273: J ni P, Altman DG, Egger M. Assessing the quality of controlled clinical trials. BMJ 2001; 323: Altman DG, Schulz KF, Moher D for the CONSORT Group. The revised CONSORT statement for reporting randomized trials: explanation and elaboration. Ann Intern Med 2001; 134: International Committee of Medical Journal Editors (ICMJE). Uniform Requirements for Manuscripts Submitted to Biomedical Journals. Available at Indian Council of Medical Research. Ethical Guidelines for Biomedical Research on Human Subjects. New Delhi: Indian Council of Medical Research, 2000, 2006.
44 Acknowledgement Dr. Arvind Pandey, Scientist G and Director, National Institute of Medical Statistics, New Delhi. India Dr. Nanda Kumar, Scientist G and Director –in-Charge, National Centre for Disease Informatics (NCDIR), Bangalore. India