1. 26 July – 2 years Over Men – Money Missing Dr. KIRIT SOMAIYA, Ex-Member of Parliament Vice President, BJP Maharashtra 23July’ 07

2. 2 years over – Everything Missing Rs. 12,411 Cr. announced from the Centre Financial support for Mithi & BRIMSTOWAD Relief & Rehab of Victims Improvement & strengthening of Disaster Management System - 100 per cent Missing in Maharashtra Action on CAG Observations Fulfillment of Commitment of State Govt. Status Report on Relief & Rehabilitation

3. Damages-Maharashtra Govt. ( Statement in Legislature} Persons Died in Maharashtra1208 Animals Died34,435 Houses Damaged1,56,000 Crop Damaged10 lac htrs LossesRs.10,000 Cr. Damage to Commercial & such structures Rs.3,100 Cr.

4. Ex-gratia-Financial Help Announced Dead Adult Below 18 Year Govt of India Rs.1 Lac Rs.50,000 Rs 1 lac Ex-gratia per person (Houses Collapsed) Rs.1,000 Distribution of Food-grain per family 10 Kgs Distribution of Kerosene10 Litre

5. Financial Assistance Received from Govt. of India Flood Relief916 Disaster Management Measures / Relief 223 Emergency Relief Fund103 Total1,242 (Rs. In Crores) Relief Fund Demanded from GOI - Rs.12,411 Cr. (Statement Shri Narayan Rane, Revenue Minister in Vidhansabha on 16 Dec. 2005)

6. Damages in Mumbai Persons Died550 Animals Died Sheep / Goat Buffalows 15,000 1,200 Vehicles Damaged27,000

7. Financial Assistance asked from Govt. of India for Mumbai For Drainage System (BRIMSTOWAD) 1,600 For Mithi River1,250 For Special Grants1,000 For Damages5,000 Financial Assistance Received till now ‘NIL’

8. Relief ‘Ghotala’ Ghotala of food-grains & Kerosene Distribution Distributed to bogus – Ghost Increase in corruption of official & slum lords Affected Starved Investigation incomplete

9. Affected Families as per the official records of Mumbai CashFood- grains Kerosene Beneficiaries with proper records / authentication 473023 Bogus-Ghost Families -280850176612 TOTAL473023753873649635

10. Mumbai Suburban District - Damages Houses Collapsed772 Family Disturbed4,93,309 Persons Affected23,51,755 Financial Assistance Distributed Rs. 212.23 Cr.

11. Mumbai Suburban District Total Dead419 Unidentified Dead Bodies19 Ex-gratia Distributed375 Ex-gratia Pending25 Total Amount distributedRs.3.16 Cr. Status of Ex-gratia, Financial Help Distributed

12. Mumbai Suburban District – Damages …continue Wheat Distributed (Help) 28,427 qtl. Rice Distributed2,796 qtl. Kerosene Distributed27,96,000 Ltr Affected persons list not available with Collectorate

13. CAG Strictures Sample check - Observations Relief distributed without verification of eligibility 16.14 Diversion of Funds1.43 Non execution of urgent Repairs 10.49

14. Damages according to CAG Human lives lost1,100 Animals – Cattles Dead27,000 Amount Spent on Relief & Rehab Rs. 1,191 Cr.

15. Ex-gratia payment without proper identification In 10 districts selected, 929 persons (83 per cent of the total cases in the State) had either died or were missing during the flood 2005. The legal heirs of the deceased persons were paid Rs 8.29 crore. Out of this, assistance of Rs 5.05 crore made to 582 (63 per cent) beneficiaries was scrutinised and the following irregularities were observed.

16. Ex-gratia payment without proper identification…

17. Relief paid without identification as bogus Punchnamas Of the total relief assistance of Rs 413.21 crore paid to 9.44 lakh families in 10 test checked districts, payments of Rs 46.23 crore (11 per cent) made to 1.04 lakh (11 per cent) families were scrutinised. The following irregularities were observed:

18. Relief paid without identification as bogus Punchnamas…

19. Payment without ensuring identities Cross checking of 503 beneficiaries from three17 districts with the relevant voter lists showed that names of beneficiaries were not in the voter lists in 144 cases (29 per cent). On cross checking the serial numbers of 224 ration cards in five18 districts it was noticed that in 91 cases serial numbers of ration card mentioned in the Panchanama did not tally with the records of the Rationing Office. In 38 cases, family members considered for payment were more than the members noted in ration cards.

20. BJP wants Status Report on….. Relief-assistance provided to victim/affected People Relief, rehabilitation yet to be completed Financial assistance received from the Centre Total financial assistance provided by Govt. The commitments given after 26th July 2005 Status of investigation on corruption in relief Implementation of CAG’s recommendations.