1. China-Finland education Cooperation, Potentials and Challenges 2014 Finn-Sino Education Forum April 25, 2014 University of Tampere Seppo Hölttä Higher Education Group / School of Management University of Tampere seppo.holtta@uta.fi

2. Why We Want to Cooperate With Chinese Educational Institutions? Government Promotion of multicultural society Global responsibility Future Learning Finland – Competitiveness of Finland Global visibility of Finland – Reputation From centralised control towards a role of a facilitator Higher Education Institutions (HEI) Internationalisation – Academic cooperation Financial Returns – Export of Education International visibility and Institutional reputation From a traditional model towards a market based mode Look for opportunities Academic Units and Academics Academic interest/knowlede (research and academic programmes) Training of academic experts Academic prestige Companies Financial returns Non-Financial benefits of owners (HEIs and others) Municipalities/Schools Internationalisation Regional development

3. Why Chinese Want to Cooperate with Us?

4. Opportunities China would use Finland as one of the main models/benchmark in its 2020 educational reform China would use Finland’s academic expertise in the strategic fields supporting transformation and economic growth Finland’s strengths Reputation created mainly by PISA Experiences of decentralisation of the educational system and Government in general Smooth transition to market driven society Deep integration of Innovation policy and education and research policies Reputation of high technology Experiences in solving environmental problems … We need to understand better the Chinese view and strategies to be successful in educational cooperation

5. Little knowledge about Chinese higher education Ineffective approaches to promoting Finnish higher education Lack of trust building with Chinese partners Lack of successful experiences of developing joint degree programmes with Chinese partners and particularly education export Lack of coordination between Finnish higher education institutions Insufficient motivation and commitment (especially on education export) Unclear vision on international cooperation and education export Lack of national cooperation Challenges in Finland’s education coopeartion with China (Cai’s presentation)

6. Lessons learned from the yesterday’s Team Finland Seminar (TEKES) If you offer something, you need to have the product You need to invest (time and money) first before trying to go to the markets China cooperation needs active presence in China Importance of cultural understanding Heavy investments and economic growth in inland China offer new opportunities

7. Capacity Needed for Cooperation Human capacity Training Finnish and Chinese experts in PhD and Master programmes Tailored capacity by professional training Mutual mobility Technical and pedagogical capacity ICT based teaching and learning Pedagogy Understanding of the educational systems and policies (Joint) research on Chinese and Finnish educational systems (Balanced) mobility Cultural understanding and sensitivity Communication and interaction Institutional/organisational capacity Organisational structures Curricula (joint programmes, export programmes) Agreements and contracts Funding (for development) Inter-institutional interactive platforms

8. Resources/Instruments – Expected Outcomes – Processes in Educational Cooperation

9. Outcomes Resour ces/ Instrum ents e Academic (Basic and Applied) Research PhD Programmes/ Training MA & BA Program mes Professional Training Programmes School Programmes

10. Policy Dialogue Between Governme nts (MoE’s) Outcomes Resour ces/ Instrum ents ed Academic (Basic and Applied) Research PhD Programmes/ Training Exported & Imported Educatio nal Program mes MA & BA Program mes Professional Training Programmes Comparative Research Joint Academic Program mes Advisory & Consulting Services Networks (HEIs, Schools, Compani es, Public Organisat ions) School Programmes

11. Policy Dialogue Between Governme nts (MoE’s) Outcomes Resour ces/ Instrum ents ed Academic (Basic and Applied) Research PhD Programmes/ Training Information Delivery/Exchange Joint Research Agendas Linking the Actors (HEIs, Schools, Companies, Public Organisations) Curriculum Development Principles Principles of Degree Structures Quality Assurance Principles Exported & Imported Educatio nal Program mes MA & BA Program mes Professional Training Programmes Comparative Research Joint Academic Program mes Advisory & Consulting Services Networks (HEIs, Schools, Compani es, Public Organisat ions) School Programmes

12. Policy Dialogue Between Governme nts (MoE’s) Outcomes Resour ces/ Instrum ents ed Academic (Basic and Applied) Research PhD Programmes/ Training Information Delivery/Exchange Marketing Educational Systems and Opportunities Joint Research Agendas Linking the Actors (HEIs, Schools, Companies, Public Organisations) Curriculum Development Principles Principles of Degree Structures Quality Assurance Principles Exported & Imported Educatio nal Program mes MA & BA Program mes Professional Training Programmes Comparative Research Joint Academic Program mes Advisory & Consulting Services Networks (HEIs, Schools, Compani es, Public Organisat ions) School Programmes Who Will Take Care of These Supporting Functions? -HEIs -Governments -Companies -FERC-CEREC