1. 1 341st CONS Home of the Two-Time AFSPC Top Dollar Champions! “Takin Care of Business”

2. 2 Claims Claims definedClaims defined FAR ClausesFAR Clauses Basis for ClaimsBasis for Claims –Changes –Constructive Changes –Delays –Breach of Implied Duties –Mistake Allowable CompensationAllowable Compensation

3. 3 Claims Claim defined - FAR 33.201Claim defined - FAR 33.201 –“a written demand, as a matter of right” –seeking payment of a “sum certain” or adjustment or interpretation of contract terms –“arising under or relating to a contract” –certification required if over $100K Customer/requiring activity must be advised and involvedCustomer/requiring activity must be advised and involved CO required to respond w/i 60 daysCO required to respond w/i 60 days

4. 4 Claims Contract ClausesContract Clauses –FAR 52.233-1 Disputes (Contract Disputes Act of 1978) –FAR 52.243-1 Changes - Fixed-Price –FAR 52.243-4 Changes (used in construction contracts) –FAR 52.242-17 Government Delay of Work –FAR 52.242-14 Suspension of Work –FAR 52.236-2 Differing Site Conditions

5. 5 Claims The Changes Clause - FAR 52.243-1The Changes Clause - FAR 52.243-1 –The CO may, at any time, by written order, without notice to sureties make changes within the general scope of the contract in any one or more of the following: Drawings and specsDrawings and specs Method of shipment or packingMethod of shipment or packing Place of deliveryPlace of delivery

6. 6 Claims Changes - fixed-priceChanges - fixed-price –Contractor must assert its right to an adjustment within 30 days from receipt of a written order. What if -What if - –No written notice from contractor is received within 30 days? –No written order is given? –Change is outside the general scope of contract?

7. 7 Claims Constructive Change DoctrineConstructive Change Doctrine –Any oral direction, instruction, interpretation or determination which can be reasonably construed as a change to the contract. What if -What if - –The oral directive comes from someone other than a CO?

8. 8 Claims Changes Clause-Construction FAR 52.243-4Changes Clause-Construction FAR 52.243-4 –The CO may, at any time, without notice to sureties, by written order designated or indicated to be a change order, make changes within the general scope of the contract, including: Drawings and specsDrawings and specs Method or manner of performanceMethod or manner of performance In GFP, GFM or siteIn GFP, GFM or site Acceleration in performance of the workAcceleration in performance of the work

9. 9 Claims Changes Clause - ConstructionChanges Clause - Construction –Provides for adjustment based on oral “direction, instruction, interpretation or determination.” Contractor must provide written notice that it considers the action to be a changeContractor must provide written notice that it considers the action to be a change No adjustment shall be allowed for costs incurred more than 20 days before Contractor’s written notice to CO, except for an adjustment based on defective specs.No adjustment shall be allowed for costs incurred more than 20 days before Contractor’s written notice to CO, except for an adjustment based on defective specs.

10. 10 Claims Impact Under Changes ClauseImpact Under Changes Clause –“If any change increases or decreases a contractor’s cost of, or time required for, performance... the Contracting Officer shall make an equitable adjustment in the contract price, the delivery schedule, or both, and shall modify the contract.” Profit includedProfit included

11. 11 Claims Equitable adjustmentEquitable adjustment –What is it? –Claim? Failure to agree to an adjustment shall be a disputeFailure to agree to an adjustment shall be a dispute Contractor required to continue performanceContractor required to continue performance –Certification required? –DFARS 243.2

12. 12 Claims Impact under delay of work clausesImpact under delay of work clauses –An adjustment to the cost of performance (excluding profit) and delivery or performance dates

13. 13 Claims Differing Site Conditions - FAR 52.236-2Differing Site Conditions - FAR 52.236-2 –Allows for additional compensation when subsurface or unknown latent physical conditions are experienced that differ materially from those indicated in the contract. –Contractor must notify the Contracting Officer before conditions are disturbed.

14. 14 Claims Claims for Breach of ContractClaims for Breach of Contract –Breach of implied duties CooperationCooperation Good faith and fair dealingGood faith and fair dealing Implied warranty of adequacy of specificationsImplied warranty of adequacy of specifications –Cardinal Changes Claims for MistakeClaims for Mistake –Unilateral vs. Bilateral

15. 15 Claims Modifications in Settlement of ClaimsModifications in Settlement of Claims –Must include release language –Must have legal review and approval regardless of dollar value

16. 16 Claims What if -What if - – Contractor submits a legally deficient claim? – Contractor submits an unsupported claim? – Contractor understates cost impact and we know it?

17. 17 Claims ConclusionConclusion –Evaluate: Has a claim been submitted?Has a claim been submitted? –Are all legal requirements present? Has adequate supporting data been submitted?Has adequate supporting data been submitted? Has customer/requiring activity evaluated the claim?Has customer/requiring activity evaluated the claim? Has a valid basis for a claim been alleged?Has a valid basis for a claim been alleged? Has SJA reviewed claim?Has SJA reviewed claim? Does modification include release & satisfaction?Does modification include release & satisfaction?