1. Unit 2– PFM domains and sequencing of reforms Module 2.4: External control, legislative and regulatory framework and IT issues External Control

2. Day 2: Sub-systems of PFM and prioritsing reforms Module 2.1. Expenditure Classification, budget Preparation and the MTEF Module 2.2. Expenditure and accounting cycle Module 2.3. Program/Performance budget Module 2.4. External control, legislative and regulatory framework and IT (information technology)issues 2 2

3. Module 2.4 Two sub-modules: External Control(External Auditor, Parliament): Aims to put forward general principles and identify essential functions The information system: Aims to identify key questions to examine during the process of increasing computerisation 3

4. Module 2.4. Key Examined Points External control External audit Parliament Legislative and regulatory framework Information systems 4

5. External Audit Guaranteed by Supreme Audit Institution(SAI) Court of Audit, Court of Finances, National Audit Office, etc. The key point is the independence of the SAI Which must be guaranteed by the constitution according to INTOSAI (International Organization of Supreme Audit Institutions) 5

6. Basic Principles - INTOSAI(*) A legislative and regulatory framework must be established Independence of SAI members Financial independence of SAI All the operations related to public finance must be under their supervision Unrestriced access to information Right and obligation to present reports Freedom to decide the content and scope of publication of audit reports Effective implementation of the recommendations Adequate resources (human and financial) * International Organization of Supreme Audit Institutions 6

7. Different types of Audit Compliance audit consists in assessing compliance with legal and administrative rules, the integrity and suitability of administrative, financial and management control systems. Financial audit consists in reviewing the financial statements and the accounting systems on which they are based and report on them; Performance audits assesses management and operation performance of government programs as well as of some public departments and agencies i.e. to evaluate the effectiveness and efficiency with which the program or the organization uses various resources 7

8. End-of-year Accounts The end-of-year accounts are first submitted to the SAI, and then to the parliament Often with significant delays La loi de règlement (French System) Administrative account (Authorising Officer) and management account (Accountant) Report by Court of Audit/finance with certificate of compliance (or not) Major weaknesses Long delays; Administrative and management accounts are often incomplete and difficult to compare 8

9. The Basics  General Principles Functioning SAI, independent, covering all the financial transactions and public money, qualified accountants and use of standards consistent with the code of conduct of INTOSAI Regularity Audit End-of-the-year account Audit Public reports of SAI Respect of the recommendation by the executive A parliamentary commission examines SAI reports  Procedure: PEFA indicators../… 9

10. PEFA-PI 25. Quality and timliness of annual financial statements - Basics (i) Spectrum of coverage of financial statement: Grade C o A consolidated government statement is prepared annually….but the omission are not significant (ii) Timliness of submission of financial statements: Grade A; o The financial statement is submitted for external audit within 6 months of the end of the fiscal year. o The key is to ensure that the total period for the submission of year-end accounts (PI-25 (ii) and PI-26 (ii)) is a maximum of 10 months (iii) The accounting standards used: Score C 10

11. PEFA PI-26 Scope, nature and follow-up of external audit - Basics (i) Extent of audit performed (incl. adherence to auditing standards): Grade C o 50 % of the expenditures audited annually, the reports identify significant issues (ii) Timeliness of submission of audit reports to Parliament: Between Grade A and B o Audit reports are submitted to the Parliament within 4 months of the end of the period covered (note A). But the key is to ensure that the total period for the submission of end-of-year accounts (PI-25 (ii) et PI-26 (ii)) is a maximum of 10 months. o Audit reports are submitted to the Parliament within 8 months of the end of the period covered (Score B) (iii) Evidence of follow up on audit recommendations: Score B o A formal response is made in a timely manner, but there is little evidence of systematic follow up. 11

12. PEFA PI- 28. Legislative scrutiny of external audit reports - Basics (i) Timeliness of examination of audit reports : Grade C o Scrutiny of audit reports is usually completed by the legislature within 12 months from receipt of the reports. (ii) Extent of hearings : Grade C o In-depth hearings on key findings take place with responsible officers from the audited entities as a routine, but may cover only some of the entities... (Score C because priority is given to measures depending on the Executive) (iii) Issuance of recommended actions by the legislature and implementation by the executive: Grade B o Actions are recommended, and proof has been drawn that they were acted upon by the executive. 12

13. The Parliament  Basics Allow sufficient time for the Parliament to discuss the Finance Act Submission of the audited accounts within 10 months of the end of fiscal year (cf. PEFA PI-25 (ii) et PI-28 (ii))  Gradually reinforce the capacity of the parliament Importance of parliamentary commission 13

14. PI-27 Legislative scrutiny of the annual budget law. The basics i ) Scope of the legislature’s scrutiny : Grade B. o The Parliamentary control covers fiscal policies and aggregates for the coming year as well as detailed estimates of expenditure and revenue. ii) Extent to which the legislature’s procedures are well- established and respected : Grade B. o Simple procedures exist for the Parliament’s budget review and are respected. iii) Adequacy of the time devoted to providing a response to budget proposal iv) Rules for in-year amendments to the budget without ex- ante approval by the Parliament. 14

15. PEFA PI-27 Legislative scrutiny of the annual budget law. The Basics iii) Adequacy of time for the legislature to provide a response to budget proposals. Grade B. o The legislature has at least one month to review the budget proposals. iv) Rules for in-year amendments to the budget without ex- ante approval by the legislature. o Clear rules exist for in-year budget amendments by the executive, and are usually respected, but they allow extensive administrative reallocations. 15

16. Key messages An independent external audit of the Executive and with adequate capacity is an essential element of a good PFM Priority should be given to regularity audits and in particular to year-end audit The Finance Act draft must be tabled in Parliament at least two months before the beginning of the year Year-end audited accounts of year n-1 must be submitted to Parliament with the Finance Bill for year n +1 16

17. Module 2.4. Key Examined Point External Control External Audit Parliament Legislative and regulatory framework Information systems 17

18. Legislative and Regulatory framework Constitution [Organic] Budget Act (or Public Finance Management Act, Budget Framework Law, etc.) Other laws and regulations Audit Act Fiscal responsibility law Territorial Authorities Financial Act (French system) Decree on Public Accounting Financial regulations 18

19. Key points of the legislative framework Provide a framework for the parliamentary authority Establish responsibilities Countries in transition: strengthen the powers of the Minister of Finance Define the principles of sound fiscal management Define the reporting obligation 19

20. Organic laws governing financial laws: Key Elements General principles Unity, Universality, transparency Concepts and definition Scope of the Budget General principles for accounting and budget classification The budget authorisation The budget calendar Execution and revision of the budget Debt and liabilities Roles and responsibilities Relations with local communities External Audit Sanctions 20

21. Questions to be considered before reforming the legislative and regulatory framework What is the existing framework? Is it respected? If not, why? 21

22. Key Messages The legislative and regulatory framework must follow the basics discussed The first step is an organic law establishing principles for budget management and distribution of responsibilities It should be checked whether the existing legislative and regulatory framework is implemented 22

23. Module 2.4. Key Points examined External control External Audit Parliament Legislative and regulatory framework Information Systems 23

24. Information Management Systems Management information is necessary For scheduling, implementation and surveillance; For the Minister of finance and sectoral ministries It is not a mere collection of statistical data Financial and Physical Information Dashboard Must be available quickly in order to enable to take decisions It is not only IT, but It may be useful to classify, sort and publish the data in various formats. 24

25. Integrated Financial Management System “Heart” of the accounting system (General Accounting) Setting standard exchanges between systems Covers all financial transactions Other Systems: Budgetary module: Accounting and budgetary control Preparation of budget Treasury management Debt management Revenue Management modules for managers 25

26. 26

27. In practice (1)  A large majority of the integrated systems are only partially implemented  Yet, the implementation process is time consuming Dener. World Bank 2011 27

28. In practice (2)  The average cost of the World Bank projects is US $ 7.7 million Dener. World Bank 2011 28

29. 29 Software Package or in-house development ?  Enterprise Resource Planning(ERP) SAP, Oracle financials, etc. Less complex: Free Balance  Theoretical benefits of ERP No need to develop, setting that parameters suffices Improved data security: Less risk of bugs, facilitates after-sales services and documentation, etc.  Disadvantages Harmonization of ERP systems can be a mammoth task and requires a lot of time, planning, and money Reduced appropriation 29

30. Chorus : The Court of Auditors points a drop of 500 million euros …. While the Estimated cost of the Chorus project was Estimated in 2006 to be 1.01 billion Euros for the 2006-2015 period, the Agency for State Financial Data (ASFD) has updated its forecast because “adaptation cost of the departmental systems has been estimated to be € 220 million and that of the environment, which Chorus estimated to be € 280 million, bringing the total project cost of € 1.5 billion. " An integrated system : CHORUS- France 30

31.  According to an IMF study the computerized budget management system in Tanzania is one of the systems that give satisfactory results  This system has led to ad hoc development in Tanzania  It is not fully integrated. The following entities and systems are not integrated into the central system: (i) payroll and human resource management system, (ii) budget preparation system, (iii) computerized tax administration systems (iv) 21 sub-treasuries and regional ministries Tanzania – A partially-integrated but functional system 31

32. 32 Should an ERP dictate procedure ?  Proponents of ERP suggest to review budgetary procedures to adapt to a ERP This is a mechanism that enables to reduce the costs of setting the parameters  This approach should be avoided Questionable procedures should not be computerised BUT computerization must take into account the existing, ongoing reforms and administrative culture 32

33. Computerisation should not substitute for establishment of proper procedures to create a robust system Computerisation does not ensure integrity and regularity GIGO 33

34. Preparing a computerization project  Define the scope of the project  Prior review of the procedures (ex. Budgetary Classification)  Examine capacity constraints, ensuring political engagement  Choose the options (ERP, development)  Modalities of progressive extension to national territory and ministries  Project management apparatus  Budget & Funding  Change management 34

35. Sequencing (1) Basics: A manual system, a precise budget classification, charts of accounts, well defined procedures. Subsequently, choosing the implementation approach based on the existing system, planned reforms, etc Scope of ERP –In general, at least accounting and expenditure –But, starting with an auxiliary system such as payroll can provide with a better cost-benefit ratio Territorial coverage: An exhaustive territorial coverage can take time –The procedure MUST be functional with or without computerisation 35

36. Sequencing (2) Choosing the implementation process…. Technical aspects –ERP or application development? »Choice of ERP if ERP varies –National network or separate database? Change management Organisation and management of the project Training Other aspects of human resource management. 36

37. Computerisation provides important support to management But it carries risks, which increase when: o The project is more complex o The ability of local officials to critically evaluate all the aspects of the project is limited o The project is led or strongly influenced by external consultants o Political support is insufficient Integrated systems based on ERP can be very expensive and risky Key Message 37