Presentation is loading. Please wait.

Presentation is loading. Please wait.

The Platinum Journal COME SCRIVERE UN LAVORO SCIENTIFICO 85° Congresso SIU - Venezia 2012 Review Article: how to summarize the evidence.

Similar presentations


Presentation on theme: "The Platinum Journal COME SCRIVERE UN LAVORO SCIENTIFICO 85° Congresso SIU - Venezia 2012 Review Article: how to summarize the evidence."— Presentation transcript:

1 The Platinum Journal COME SCRIVERE UN LAVORO SCIENTIFICO 85° Congresso SIU - Venezia 2012 Review Article: how to summarize the evidence

2 The Platinum Journal COME SCRIVERE UN LAVORO SCIENTIFICO 85° Congresso SIU - Venezia 2012 PRISMA Checklist 17. Selecting the studies (flow diagram) 18. Characteristics of single studies number, PICOS, follow-up, etc. (narrative synthesis and/or table) 19. Analysis of bias risk in each study randomized (Jadad score, Cochrane risk of bias tool), observational (Newcastle-Ottawa scale) (table) Review Article: how to summarize the evidence

3 The Platinum Journal COME SCRIVERE UN LAVORO SCIENTIFICO 85° Congresso SIU - Venezia 2012 Review Article: how to summarize the evidence

4 The Platinum Journal COME SCRIVERE UN LAVORO SCIENTIFICO 85° Congresso SIU - Venezia 2012 Review Article: how to summarize the evidence

5 The Platinum Journal COME SCRIVERE UN LAVORO SCIENTIFICO 85° Congresso SIU - Venezia 2012 Review Article: how to summarize the evidence

6 The Platinum Journal COME SCRIVERE UN LAVORO SCIENTIFICO 85° Congresso SIU - Venezia 2012 Review Article: how to summarize the evidence

7 The Platinum Journal COME SCRIVERE UN LAVORO SCIENTIFICO 85° Congresso SIU - Venezia 2012 PRISMA Checklist 20. Results of single studies: a)essential data on all considered outcomes for each treatment group (table) b)estimates of efficacy and confidence intervals (forest plot) 21.Summary of results: meta-analisis with efficacy estimates, confidence intervals and measures of consistency (narrative sythesis and/or tables) Review Article: how to summarize the evidence

8 The Platinum Journal COME SCRIVERE UN LAVORO SCIENTIFICO 85° Congresso SIU - Venezia 2012 Review Article: how to summarize the evidence

9 The Platinum Journal COME SCRIVERE UN LAVORO SCIENTIFICO 85° Congresso SIU - Venezia 2012 Review Article: how to summarize the evidence

10 The Platinum Journal COME SCRIVERE UN LAVORO SCIENTIFICO 85° Congresso SIU - Venezia 2012 PRISMA Checklist 22.Analysis of bias risk among various studies: publication bias, heterogenity (funnel plot) 23. Secondary analises : of senstivity, for sub-groups, etc. Review Article: how to summarize the evidence

11 The Platinum Journal COME SCRIVERE UN LAVORO SCIENTIFICO 85° Congresso SIU - Venezia 2012 Review Article: how to summarize the evidence

12 The Platinum Journal COME SCRIVERE UN LAVORO SCIENTIFICO 85° Congresso SIU - Venezia 2012 Review Article: how to summarize the evidence

13 The Platinum Journal COME SCRIVERE UN LAVORO SCIENTIFICO 85° Congresso SIU - Venezia 2012 Review Article: how to summarize the evidence

14 The Platinum Journal COME SCRIVERE UN LAVORO SCIENTIFICO 85° Congresso SIU - Venezia 2012 Clear, objective and balanced presentation qualatative and quantatative descriptions Critical analysis of controversial points Critical analysis of the weakneses of the included studies How to summarize the results? Review Article: how to summarize the evidence


Download ppt "The Platinum Journal COME SCRIVERE UN LAVORO SCIENTIFICO 85° Congresso SIU - Venezia 2012 Review Article: how to summarize the evidence."

Similar presentations


Ads by Google