1. NSSE 2008

2. When?Spring, 2008 Who?Freshmen and Seniors random sample How?Electronic and Snail mail follow up Respondents?30% response rate 26% freshmen and 35% seniors Mostly full time, half transfers

3. NSSE 2008 Background: Engagement is time and energy devoted to educationally purposeful activities BEST SINGLE PREDICTOR OF LEARNING AND PERSONAL DEVELOPMENT

4. Seven Principles of Good Practice in Undergraduate Education 1. Student-faculty contact (SFI) 2. Cooperation among students (SCE) 3. Active Learning (ACL) 4. Prompt feedback 5. Time on task 6. High expectations (LAC) 7. Respect for diverse talents and ways of learning (EEE)

5. Validity of Self-reported Data People generally respond accurately about past behavior unless questions are sensitive or make them uncomfortable If information is known to respondents If questions are phrased clearly If questions refer to recent activities If respondents take questions seriously If questions do not threaten, embarrass or violate respondents’ privacy “Halo effect” – Inflating performance, grades or personal gains and efforts

6. Respondents Characteristics Buffalo State College: 30% response rate 26% freshmen,35% seniors Peers: 29% response rate 27% freshmen,30% seniors Sampling error: ±2.8%

7. NSSE 2008 Means-weighted arithmetic average of responses on items  Gender  Enrollment status  Size

8. NSSE 2008 Effect size: “practical significance” of mean differences:.2 small.5 moderate.8 large

9. NSSE 2008 Peers Comparison Group: Bridgewater State Salem State Slippery Rock U of Pa U Mass-Boston U Nebraska – Omaha West Chester U of Pa William Paterson of NJ

10. LAC (Level of Academic Challenge) Challenging intellectual and creative work is central to student learning and collegiate quality. Colleges and universities promote high levels of student achievement by emphasizing the importance of academic effort and setting high expectations for student performance. Fr Sr Preparing for class3.533.87 # assigned books3.243.09 # papers 20 pages or more1.361.57 # papers 5-19 pages2.382.45 # papers fewer than 5 pages3.082.91 Emphasize analysis3.053.04 Emphasize synthesizing2.852.95 Emphasize making judgments2.932.89 Emphasize applying theories/concepts2.993.10 Working harder than you thought2.702.84 Campus environment emphasizes studying/academics2.992.98

11. ACL (Active and Collaborative Learning) Students learn more when they are intensely involved in their education and asked to think about what they are learning in different settings. Collaborating with others in solving problems or mastering difficult material prepares students for the messy, unscripted problems they will encounter daily during and after college. Fr Sr Asked questions in class 2.753.06 Made a class presentation2.292.84 Worked with students during class2.432.60 Worked with classmates outside of class2.292.49 Tutored others1.551.78 Community based project in regular course1.521.89 Discussed ideas from class with others2.632.70

12. SFI (Student –Faculty Interaction) Students learn firsthand how experts think about and solve practical problems by interacting with faculty members inside and outside the classroom. As a result, their teachers become role models, mentors and guides for continuous, life-long learning. Fr Sr Discussed grades/assignments with instructor2.692.87 Talked about career plans with faculty/advisor2.292.46 Discussed ideas with faculty member1.992.11 Worked with faculty other than coursework1.741.76 Received prompt feedback from faculty2.732.78 Research project with faculty0.070.15

13. EEE (Enriching Education Environment) Complementary learning opportunities enhance academic programs. Diversity experiences teach students valuable things about themselves and others. Technology facilitates collaborations between peers and instructors. Internships, community service and senior capstone courses provide opp9ortunities to integrate and apply knowledge. Fr Sr Co-curricular activities2.251.84 Practicum, internship, filed experience0.100.54 Community service/volunteer work0.360.55 Foreign language coursework0.240.42 Study abroad0.020.06 Independent study/self-designed major0.040.16 Culminating senior experience0.020.25 Serious conversations with students (beliefs different)2.762.59 Serious conversations with different ethnicity2.662.62 Using electronic medium for assignment2.552.66 Environment encourages contact2.732.40 Learning community0.130.25

14. SCE (Supportive Campus Environment) Students perform better and are more satisfied at colleges that are committed to their success and cultivate positive working and social relations among different groups on campus. Fr Sr Environment provides support to succeed2.982.77 Environment helps with non-academic responsibilities2.351.90 Environment provides support to thrive socially2.492.11 Quality of relationships with other students5.045.28* Quality of relationships with faculty4.895.18** Quality of relationships with admin and offices4.274.28*** *1=unfriendly, unsupportive, alienated to 7=friendly, supportive, sense of belonging **1=unavailable, unhelpful, unsympathetic to 7=available, helpful, sympathetic ***1=unhelpful, inconsiderate, rigid to 7=helpful, considerate, flexible

15. Highest Performing Areas First Year Buffalo State Peers Did a community-based project as part of a regular course16%9% Spent more than 5 hrs/week in co-curricular activities21%14% Institution substantially encourages contacts among diverse peers56%46% Institution substantially helps students cope w/non-academic matters32%26% Institution provides substantial support for social needs40%34%

16. Highest Performing Areas Senior Buffalo State Peers Worked harder than expected to meet instructor’s expectations66%57% Talked about career plans with faculty member or advisor49%36% Did practicum, internship, field experience64%45% Participated in community service or volunteer work61%48% Completed foreign language coursework45%33%

17. Lowest Performing Areas First Year Buffalo State Peers Read more than 10 assigned books or book length readings23%29% Institution emphasizes studying and academic work67%73% Asked questions/contributed to class discussions48%59% Made a class presentation24%33% Worked with other students on projects during class37%46%

18. Lowest Performing Areas Senior Buffalo State Peers Courses emphasized analyzing ideas, experiences or theories78%82% Read more than 10 assigned books or book length readings25%30% Worked with classmates outside of class to prepare assignments46%51% Used an electronic medium to discuss or complete an assignment55%60% Positively rated their relationships with admin personnel and offices41%48%

19. Satisfaction How would you evaluate your entire educational experience at Buffalo State? Buffalo State SUNY CollegesPeers Mean Significance Level Effect Size Mean Significance Level Effect Size FY2.973.13***-.223.08**-.16 SR2.993.14***-.193.09**-.13 4 = Excellent, 1 = Poor

20. Satisfaction If you could start again, would you go to the same institution you are now attending? Buffalo State SUNY CollegesPeers Mean Significance Level Effect Size Mean Significance Level Effect Size FY2.963.13***-.213.11**-.18 SR2.993.12**-.143.05-.07 4 = Excellent, 1 = Poor

21. THE CHALLENGE: To rank in the top 50% of engaged schools in all benchmarks of engagement.

22. First Year Buffalo StateNSSE 2008 Mean Significance LevelEffect Size LAC51.956.4***-.34 ACL40.647.5***-.41 SFI37.239.7*-.13 EEE27.630.3***-.20 SCE58.065.8***-.42

23. Seniors Buffalo StateNSSE 2008 Mean Significance LevelEffect Size LAC53.559.9***-.46 ACL49.755.4***-.33 SFI41.449.3***-.37 EEE37.047.3***-.58 SCE53.763.5***-.52