Presentation is loading. Please wait.

Presentation is loading. Please wait.

HLS, July 3, 2002. free speech regulate speech.

Similar presentations


Presentation on theme: "HLS, July 3, 2002. free speech regulate speech."— Presentation transcript:

1 HLS, July 3, 2002

2

3 free speech

4 regulate speech

5 1st A “Congress shall make no law … abridging the freedom of speech”

6 1st A “Congress shall make not many laws … abridging the freedom of speech, at least without a good reason.”

7 levels of scrutiny

8 content/viewpoint based: strict content neutral: intermediate neither: rb

9 default: heightened review

10 the gov’t must justify

11

12 Law Market Architecture Norms

13 Law Market Architecture Norms

14 Mill, On Liberty

15 Law Market Architecture Norms

16

17

18 inversions

19 technological inversions

20 (1)

21 “persons, houses, papers, and effects, against unreasonable searches and seizures”

22 public private

23 public

24 (2)

25 “Congress has the power … to regulate commerce … among the several states”

26 inter intra

27 inter

28 first response: blinders

29 ultimate response: rebalance

30

31

32 ©

33 ©

34 © circa 1790

35 “map, chart, book or books”

36 “printing, reprinting, publishing and vending”

37 “fourteen years”

38 x2, if author lives

39 “if registered”

40 “if deposited”

41 13,000

42 <1,000

43 127

44

45

46 unregulated

47 freedom to disnify to counter-tell to tinker

48 freedom to…

49

50

51 © circa now

52 (1) changing law

53 from “map, chart, book or books”

54 to any creative work “reduced to a tangible form”

55 from “printing, reprinting, publishing and vending”

56 to any “copy”

57 from “fourteen years” maybe x2

58 to “forever minus a day”

59 “whether or not registered”

60 “without deposit”

61 (2) changing technology

62 book

63 eBook

64

65

66

67

68

69

70

71 changing law + changing code

72

73

74

75 regulated creativity

76 inversion

77 free regulated

78 free

79

80

81 “gov’t is our friend”

82 ACLU: “censorship”

83 spam

84 stage 1: abuse

85 stage 2: response public?

86 ACLU: “censorship”

87 stage 3: response private

88 rbl

89 if you don’t live by our email policies,

90 your email will be dropped into a black hole

91 MIT v. HP

92 gilmore

93 stage 4: response public

94 spam law 1. If you send UCE, you must tag it. 2. If you violate (1), then the first 5 people to track you down get $25,000.

95 regulation increases freedom


Download ppt "HLS, July 3, 2002. free speech regulate speech."

Similar presentations


Ads by Google