Download presentation

Presentation is loading. Please wait.

Published byCandice Casey Modified over 2 years ago

1
Misconceptions and Fallacies Concerning Probability Assessments

2
Law of Averages Toss coin many times. What happens as number of tosses increases? Law of Averages Says: n The percentage of heads should become very close to 50%.

3
John Kerrich’s Coin-tossing Experiment Number of Tosses Proportion Heads

4
Law of Averages IN GENERAL Law of Averages says: Averages and proportions vary less from the “expected” as sample size increases

5
Two Misconceptions

6
1. Question: A coin is tossed either 2 times or 100 times. You win $2 if # of heads = # of tails. Which has a better chance of winning ? n 2 times OR n 100 times

8
In fact: As # of tosses increases, the chance of “exactly 50% Heads” decreases

9
John Kerrich’s Coin-tossing Experiment (Text, p.274) Number of Number of Difference from Tosses Heads Expected 10 4 -1 20 10 0 30 17 2 40 21 1 50 25 0 8,000 4,034 34 9,000 4,538 38 10,000 5,067 67 :::: :::: ::::

10
John Kerrich’s Coin-tossing Experiment : Number of Tosses # Heads - Half the # of Tosses

11
# of Tosses Probability of between 49.9% and 50.1% HEADS 100.08 10,000.17 1,000,000.95 So - as the number of tosses increases, the chance that the % of HEADS is close to 50% INCREASES

12
Exercise 4, page 277 (a) there are more than 60% Heads. In each of the following situations, you will toss a coin 10 times or 100 times. Which is better if you win whenever: (b) there are more than 40% Heads. (c) there are between 40% and 60% Heads. (d) there are exactly 50% Heads. (c’) there are between 60% and 80% Heads.

13
2. How Does the Law of Averages Work? n By “compensation” or “adjustment” ? NO! Kerrich example: 130 instances of “HHHH” next toss: 69 H’s 61 T’s (no adjustment) –gambler’s fallacy !

14
2. How Does the Law of Averages Work? Actually, the Law of Averages works by swamping. –isolated discrepancies become unimportant as number of tosses increases

15
1. The Availability Heuristic -- probability assessment is based on instances that you can remember Example: deaths by homicide or from a stroke -- Which happen more often? (strokes cause about 11 times as many deaths as homicides) Distortion of Subjective Probabilities

16
2. Representative Heuristic -- assignment of higher probabilities than are realistic based on how one imagines things will happen Example: Bank Teller Linda is 31 yrs old, single, and outspoken. As a student she was involved with issues of discrimination and social justice, and she also participated in the anti-nuclear demonstrations. Which is more likely? (a) Linda is a bank teller (b) Linda is a bank teller who is active in the feminist movement.

17
Conjunction Fallacy -- when chance of 2 or more events both occurring is given a higher chance than the individual events.

18
3. Anchoring –risk perception can be distorted by providing an “anchor” or reference point Example: chance of nuclear war Questionnaire: (a) Do you think the chance of a nuclear war is higher or lower than 1% (b) Do you think the chance of a nuclear war is higher or lower than 90% Problem: conservatism in probability revision

19
4. Forgotten Base Rates –ignoring information concerning likelihood of an event Example: Physicians and Rare Diseases Situation: -- a patient may have a rare disease -- diagnostic test is positive -- what is chance the patient has the disease? Doctors often over-estimate the chance that the patient has the disease - in one such study the doctors’ estimates were 10 times too high

20
5. Overconfidence/Optimism –psychologists have found that people tend to have subjective probabilities about themselves that are unrealistically optimistic Example: “It’ll never happen to me” -- leads to foolish risk taking

21
6. Gambler’s Fallacy -- “I’m due”

Similar presentations

OK

Lecture 15 – Decision making 1 Decision making occurs when you have several alternatives and you choose among them. There are two characteristics of good.

Lecture 15 – Decision making 1 Decision making occurs when you have several alternatives and you choose among them. There are two characteristics of good.

© 2017 SlidePlayer.com Inc.

All rights reserved.

Ads by Google

Ppt on andrew file system Ppt on major types of industries Ppt on content development director Ppt on 2 stroke ic engine ppt Ppt on magnetic refrigeration technology Ppt on hp quality center Ppt on switching devices in ece Ppt on teachers day songs Ppt on ufo and aliens today Ppt on motion for class 9 free download