Download presentation

Presentation is loading. Please wait.

Published byWendy Franklin Modified over 2 years ago

1
Circuit Complexity and Derandomization Tokyo Institute of Technology Akinori Kawachi

2
Layout Randomized vs Determinsitic Algorithms – Primality Test General Framework for Derandomization – Circuit Complexity Derandomization Circuits – Circuit Complexity and NP vs. P Necessity of Circuit Complexity for Derandomization Summary

3
Deterministic v.s. Randomized Algorithms for (Decision) Problems Randomness is useful for real-world computation! Decision problem: PRIME “No” otherwise Elementary Det. algorithm: O(2 n/2 ) time [Eratosthenes, B.C. 2c] Rand. algorithm: O(n 3 ) time w/ succ. prob. 99% [Miller 1976, Rabin 1980] Exponential-time speed-up! n = input length

4
Deterministic v.s. Randomized Algorithms for (Decision) Problems How much randomness make computation strong? Gödel Prize Det. algorithm: O(n 12 ) time [Agrawal, Kayal & Saxena 2004 Gödel Prize] Rand. algorithm: O(n 3 ) time w/ succ. prob. 99% [Miller 1976, Rabin 1980] “No” otherwise Polynomial-time slow-down Decision problem: PRIME

5
Derandomization Conjecture BPP = P NO Randomization yields NO exponential speed-up! derandomization Always poly-time derandomization possible? Conjecture det. P = {problem: poly-time det. TM computes} prob. BPP = {problem: poly-time prob. TM computes w/ bounded errors w/ bounded errors}

6
Class BPP BPP Class BPP (Bounded-error Prob. Poly-time) L ∈ BPP x∊Lx∊L x∉Lx∉L Def Pr r [A(x,r) = Yes] > 2/3 r is uniform over {0,1} m m = |r| = poly(|x|) A( ・, ・ ): poly-time det. TM Pr r [A(x,r) = No] > 2/3

7
Nondeterministic Version AM = NP Conjecture AM Class AM (Arthur-Merlin Games) L ∈ AM x∊Lx∊L x∉Lx∉L Def |r|,|w| = poly(|x|) A( ・, ・, ・ ): poly-time det. TM

8
Hardness vs. Randomness Trade-offs [Yao ’82, Blum & Micali ’84] Hard problem exists Pseudo-Random Generator Good Pseudo-Random Generator (PRG) exists. Simulate randomized algorithms det.ly with PRG! Theorem [Impagliazzo & Wigderson 1998] BPP = P (L is computed in prob. poly-time w/ bounded errors L is computed in det. poly-time) Similar theorem holds in nondet. version (AM=NP) [Klivans & van Melkebeek 2001]

9
Circuit x3x3 ∧ x1x1 x2x2 0 ￢ ∨∧ ∧ ∨ Gate set = { ∧, ∨, ￢, 0, 1}

10
Circuit 0 ∧ 11 ￢ ∨∧ ∧ ∨ 1 ∧ 1 = 1 1 1 1 1 00 0 1 1 0 ￢ 0 = 1 1 ∧ 0 = 0 0 ∨ 1 = 1 0 ∧ 1 = 0 0 1 ∨ 0 = 1 1 Input = (1,1,0) 0 Size = 7 Depth = 5

11
Circuit Complexity Size of circuits is measure for computational resource! Circuit complexity of L := min { size of circuit family computing L } s(n)-size circuit family {C n :{0,1} n →{0,1}} n computes L Definition Def &

12
Computational Power of Circuits Circuit complexity of any problem = O(2 n /n) Theorem [Lupanov 1970] any (even non-recursive) problem can be computed by some O(2 n /n)-size circuit family. Theorem [Fisher & Pippenger 1979] Poly-time TM can be simulated by poly-size circuit family. SIZE(poly) = {problem: poly-size circuit family can compute}

13
NP vs. P and Circuits NP ≠ P Conjecture Some NP problem cannot be computed by any poly-time TM. NP ⊄ SIZE(poly) Conjecture Some NP problem has superpoly circuit complexity. Note: NP ⊄ SIZE(poly) NP ≠ P Proving super-poly circuit complexity in NP solves NP vs. P!

14
NEXP ⊄ SIZE(poly) MA-EXP ⊄ SIZE(poly) Current Status Theorem (Buhrman, Fortnow, & Thierauf 1998) NEXP ⊄ ACC 0 (poly) Theorem (Williams 2011) Randomized version of NEXP Const-depth poly-size w/ Modulo gates Grand Challenge Cf. H-R tradeoff for BPP=P requires at least EXP ⊄ SIZE(2.1n )!

15
Hardness vs. Randomness Trade-offs [Yao ’82, Blum & Micali ’84] Hard problem exists Pseudo-Random Generator Good Pseudo-Random Generator (PRG) exists. Simulate randomized algorithms det.ly with PRG! Theorem [Impagliazzo & Wigderson 1998] BPP = P (L is computed in prob. poly-time w/ bounded errors L is computed in det. poly-time)

16
Proof Sketch 1.Construct PRG from hard H. 2.Simulate rand. algo. w/ p-random bits.

17
Proof Sketch 1.Construct PRG from hard H. Goal: Construct G H : {0,1} O(log m) → {0,1} m Pseudo-random! truly random! # possible s = 2 O(log m) = poly(m) # possible r = 2 m Point For every poly-size circuit C,

18
Proof Sketch 2.Simulate rand. algo. w/ p-random bits. Goal: Det.ly simulate rand. algo. by G H L ∈ BPP x∊Lx∊L x∉Lx∉L Def Pr r [A(x,r) = Yes] > 2/3 |r| = poly(|x|) A( ・, ・ ): poly-time det. TM Pr r [A(x,r) = No] > 2/3

19
Proof Sketch 2.Simulate rand. algo. w/ p-random bits. Goal: Det.ly simulate rand. algo. by G H Trivial Simulation A(x,00…00) = Yes A(x,00…01) = No … A(x,11…10) = Yes A(x,11…11) = Yes x∊Lx∊L x∉Lx∉L Require O(2 m )=O(2 poly(n) ) time…

20
Proof Sketch 2.Simulate rand. algo. w/ p-random bits. Goal: Det.ly simulate rand. algo. by G H Simulation w/ G H A(x,G H (0…0)) = No … A(x,G H (1…1)) = Yes x∊Lx∊L x∉Lx∉L Require 2 O(log m) = poly(n) time! A(x, ・ ) = circuit C

21
Is Circuit Complexity Essential? Proving “some problem is really hard” is HARD! (e.g. NP≠P) ultimate goal – It’s the ultimate goal in complexity theory… Can avoid “proving hardness” for derandomization? NO! Derandomization implies proving hardness!! BPP=P Some problem is hard. Theorem [Kabanets & Impagliazzo ‘03] Theorem [Gutfreund & Kawachi ‘10, Aaronson, Aydinlioglu, Buhrman, Hitchcock, & van Melkebeek ‘11] Theorem [Gutfreund & Kawachi ‘10, Aaronson, Aydinlioglu, Buhrman, Hitchcock, & van Melkebeek ‘11]

22
Theorem [Kabanets & Impagliazzo ‘03] Resolving “arithmetic-circuit version of NP vs. P“ Theorem [Gutfreund & Kawachi ‘10, Aaronson, Aydinlioglu, Buhrman, Hitchcock, & van Melkebeek ‘11] Theorem [Gutfreund & Kawachi ‘10, Aaronson, Aydinlioglu, Buhrman, Hitchcock, & van Melkebeek ‘11]

23
Summary Proving circuit complexity Derandomization – through Pseudo-Random Generator – BPP = P, AM = NP, and more… Derandomization Proving circuit complexity

Similar presentations

Presentation is loading. Please wait....

OK

CS151 Complexity Theory Lecture 8 April 22, 2004.

CS151 Complexity Theory Lecture 8 April 22, 2004.

© 2018 SlidePlayer.com Inc.

All rights reserved.

Ads by Google

Ppt on new delhi tourism Ppt on cloud service providers Ppt on condition based maintenance army Ppt on online shopping in php Ppt on forward rate agreement pricing Ppt on business communication skills Ppt on wind as alternative source of energy Ppt on agriculture in india for class 10 Ppt on periscope tv How to make ppt on macbook pro