Presentation is loading. Please wait.

Presentation is loading. Please wait.

The Role of Diagnostic Imaging in Appendicitis D. Joseph Grunz, MD Department of Radiology Mercy Children’s Hospital- St. Louis.

Similar presentations


Presentation on theme: "The Role of Diagnostic Imaging in Appendicitis D. Joseph Grunz, MD Department of Radiology Mercy Children’s Hospital- St. Louis."— Presentation transcript:

1 The Role of Diagnostic Imaging in Appendicitis D. Joseph Grunz, MD Department of Radiology Mercy Children’s Hospital- St. Louis

2 Objectives Discuss current topics and role of diagnostic imaging for evaluation of appendicitis Discuss current topics and role of diagnostic imaging for evaluation of appendicitis Discuss controversies regarding specific imaging techniques, especially regarding multi-detector computed tomography and ultrasound Discuss controversies regarding specific imaging techniques, especially regarding multi-detector computed tomography and ultrasound Discuss current preferences and imaging strategies Discuss current preferences and imaging strategies

3 CT vs. US Benefits of CT studies Benefits of CT studies Rapid evaluation Rapid evaluation High degree of diagnostic confidence High degree of diagnostic confidence High degree of reproducibility High degree of reproducibility Evaluation of other etiologies Evaluation of other etiologies Decreased negative laparotomy and perforation rates Decreased negative laparotomy and perforation rates Downside of CT studies Downside of CT studies Radiation concerns Radiation concerns IV contrast usage IV contrast usage

4 CT vs. US Benefits of ultrasound Benefits of ultrasound No use of radiation No use of radiation Evaluation of pelvic disease in girls Evaluation of pelvic disease in girls Can localize to site of pain Can localize to site of pain Downside of ultrasound Downside of ultrasound Not on site after hours Not on site after hours Lower degree of diagnostic confidence Lower degree of diagnostic confidence Lower degree of reproducibility Lower degree of reproducibility Limited evaluation of other etiologies Limited evaluation of other etiologies

5 CT Findings Normal appendix- blind ending tubular structure with air Normal appendix- blind ending tubular structure with air

6 CT Findings Dilated tubular fluid structure with contrast- enhancing walls, possible appendicolith Dilated tubular fluid structure with contrast- enhancing walls, possible appendicolith

7 US Findings Normal appendix, compressible, less than 6 mm in thickness Normal appendix, compressible, less than 6 mm in thickness

8 US Findings Abnormal appendix, non-compressible, increased vascular flow, fluid-filled Abnormal appendix, non-compressible, increased vascular flow, fluid-filled

9 Choosing Wisely American College of Radiology- Five Things Physicians and Patients Should Question American College of Radiology- Five Things Physicians and Patients Should Question 1. Don’t do imaging for uncomplicated headache. 1. Don’t do imaging for uncomplicated headache. 2. Don’t image for suspected pulmonary embolism (PE) without moderate or high pre-test probability. 2. Don’t image for suspected pulmonary embolism (PE) without moderate or high pre-test probability. 3. Avoid admission or preoperative chest x-rays 3. Avoid admission or preoperative chest x-rays 4. Don’t do computed tomography (CT) for the evaluation of suspected appendicitis in children until after ultrasound has been considered as an option. 5. Don’t recommend follow-up imaging for clinically inconsequential adnexal cysts. 5. Don’t recommend follow-up imaging for clinically inconsequential adnexal cysts.

10 ACR-Choosing Wisely Although CT is accurate in the evaluation of suspected appendicitis in the pediatric population, ultrasound is nearly as good in experienced hands. Since ultrasound will reduce radiation exposure, ultrasound is the preferred initial consideration for imaging examination in children. If the results of the ultrasound exam are equivocal, it may be followed by CT. This approach is cost-effective, reduces potential radiation risks and has excellent accuracy, with reported sensitivity and specificity of 94 percent. Although CT is accurate in the evaluation of suspected appendicitis in the pediatric population, ultrasound is nearly as good in experienced hands. Since ultrasound will reduce radiation exposure, ultrasound is the preferred initial consideration for imaging examination in children. If the results of the ultrasound exam are equivocal, it may be followed by CT. This approach is cost-effective, reduces potential radiation risks and has excellent accuracy, with reported sensitivity and specificity of 94 percent.

11 The way we were 1981 Computed tomography? It will never last! 1988 R. Brooke Jeffrey- early US advocate Goal was to reduce unnecessary laparotomy rates Establish criteria to exclude appendicitis Take home point- US appendix has been around a long time.

12 Are We Resistant to New Technology? PACS technology CT angiography PACS technology CT angiography CT perfusion CT urography CT perfusion CT urography CT 3D reformat CT coronary artery CT 3D reformat CT coronary artery MR enterography MR angiography MR enterography MR angiography MR cholangiogram US pyloric channel MR cholangiogram US pyloric channel US sonohysterography US musculoskeletal US sonohysterography US musculoskeletal

13 Intussusception Standard of care was barium enema reduction Standard of care was barium enema reduction

14 Intussusception Air insufflation enema adopted Air insufflation enema adopted

15 Intussusception Ultrasound Ultrasound

16 Come and gone Intravenous pyelography Intravenous pyelography Plain film tomography Plain film tomography Herniography Herniography Venography Venography CT colonoscopy CT colonoscopy CT screening for cancer CT screening for cancer

17 Not yet or never were US gastro-esophageal reflux US gastro-esophageal reflux US voiding cystourethrography US voiding cystourethrography US malrotation/midgut volvulus US malrotation/midgut volvulus US intussusception reduction US intussusception reduction US with IV contrast US with IV contrast

18 It’s not over until … CT pulmonary angiogram vs. V/Q scan CT pulmonary angiogram vs. V/Q scan Fluoroscopic voiding cystourethrogram vs. nuclear medicine voiding cystourethrogram Fluoroscopic voiding cystourethrogram vs. nuclear medicine voiding cystourethrogram CT angiography vs. MR angiography vs. conventional angiography CT angiography vs. MR angiography vs. conventional angiography MR lumbar spine vs. CT lumbar spine myelography MR lumbar spine vs. CT lumbar spine myelography

19 “When the facts change, I change my mind. What do you do, sir?” “When the facts change, I change my mind. What do you do, sir?” ― John Maynard Keynes

20 Increased reliance on CT for diagnosis of pediatric appendicitis Increased reliance on CT for diagnosis of pediatric appendicitis 95 % sensitivity, 94 % specificity 95 % sensitivity, 94 % specificity Alternate diagnosis in 34 % Alternate diagnosis in 34 %

21

22 USA Today 2001 Children are exposed to unnecessary radiation doses for CT studies. Children are exposed to unnecessary radiation doses for CT studies. Children are receiving adult radiation settings for CT studies Children are receiving adult radiation settings for CT studies CT studies should be calibrated for child age/size CT studies should be calibrated for child age/size

23

24 New England Journal of Medicine, Nov “The largest increases in CT use have been in the categories of pediatric diagnosis and adult screening.” “There is direct evidence from epidemiologic studies that the organ doses corresponding to a common CT study (two or three scans, resulting in a dose in the range of 30 to 90 mSv) result in an increased risk of cancer. The evidence is reasonably convincing for adults and very convincing for children.”

25 Children are at higher risk to develop cancer because… Children are more radiosensitive Children are more radiosensitive Children have a longer lifespan for cancer to develop Children have a longer lifespan for cancer to develop

26 Increased ED utilization

27 Public Awareness (?)

28

29 2011 Articles There has been significantly increased utilization of CT scans in the pediatric emergency room setting. There has been significantly increased utilization of CT scans in the pediatric emergency room setting. Based upon population studies, if 1.6 million CT studies are performed, there is a theoretical risk that 1,500 children will develop a fatal neoplasm as a result Based upon population studies, if 1.6 million CT studies are performed, there is a theoretical risk that 1,500 children will develop a fatal neoplasm as a result Did not conclude these exams were unnecessary, but such was the implication Did not conclude these exams were unnecessary, but such was the implication

30 Back to Ultrasound Stats

31 Sweden (2002) Children US sensitivity 86%, specificity 95% US sensitivity 86%, specificity 95% CT sensitivity 80%, specificity 97% CT sensitivity 80%, specificity 97% Prevalence of 41% Prevalence of 41% Negative predictive value of 92% Negative predictive value of 92%

32 High sensitivity study- Kessler, France (2004) 125 patients, appendicitis prevalence of 46% 125 patients, appendicitis prevalence of 46% Appendix identified in 86% of patients Appendix identified in 86% of patients Appendix identified in 96% of patients with appendicitis Appendix identified in 96% of patients with appendicitis Appendix identified in 72% of patients without appendicitis Appendix identified in 72% of patients without appendicitis Negative predictive value of 90% if appendix not visualized Negative predictive value of 90% if appendix not visualized

33 Meta-analysis study (2006) US sensitivity 88%, specificity 94% for children US sensitivity 88%, specificity 94% for children CT sensitivity 94%, specificity 95% for children CT sensitivity 94%, specificity 95% for children

34 Our experience Matches CT experience of other institutions Matches CT experience of other institutions Nowhere close to the ultrasound percentages for finding the appendix, making the diagnosis, or excluding the diagnosis Nowhere close to the ultrasound percentages for finding the appendix, making the diagnosis, or excluding the diagnosis

35 "When you unwrap a Reggie bar, it tells you how good it is." - Catfish Hunter

36 University of Michigan, Pediatric Radiology, March 2012 Observed their experience doesn’t correspond as well as described in the literature Identified the appendix 24% of the time.

37

38

39

40 What to do?

41 Understand the Issues for the ED physicians

42 ED Issues Safe, reliable, available diagnostic exam for appendicitis is highly desirable Safe, reliable, available diagnostic exam for appendicitis is highly desirable Discharge home or admission for observation is frequently undesirable Discharge home or admission for observation is frequently undesirable Unstable social situation Unstable social situation Long travel distance Long travel distance Rapid clinical deterioration Rapid clinical deterioration Pain control Pain control Limited hospital beds Limited hospital beds Malpractice issues Malpractice issues

43 Risks of Appendicitis Most common acute abdominal condition requiring childhood surgery Most common acute abdominal condition requiring childhood surgery Commonly missed or delayed diagnosis Commonly missed or delayed diagnosis Complications include peritonitis, sepsis, bowel obstruction, death Complications include peritonitis, sepsis, bowel obstruction, death Second most common cause for litigation, and one third of claims involve diagnostic error Second most common cause for litigation, and one third of claims involve diagnostic error

44 Put risks into perspective Lifetime cancer risk is 44.00% for men, 38.00% for women Lifetime cancer risk is 44.00% for men, 38.00% for women Single CT scan for a child age five theoretically increases that risk 00.02% Single CT scan for a child age five theoretically increases that risk 00.02% Physicians need to understand the risk/benefit Physicians need to understand the risk/benefit Risk of missed diagnosis is immediate and real Risk of missed diagnosis is immediate and real Risk of radiation exposure is delayed and theoretical Risk of radiation exposure is delayed and theoretical Eliminate unnecessary exams, not necessary exams Eliminate unnecessary exams, not necessary exams

45 Estimated Lifetime Risk of Death Lightning strike Lightning strike Bicycle accident Bicycle accident Drowning Drowning Motor vehicle accident Motor vehicle accident Cancer (natural causes) Cancer (natural causes) Cancer, pediatric (single CT) Cancer, pediatric (single CT) 1 in 100,000 1 in 100,000 1 in 10,000 1 in 10,000 1 in 1,000 1 in 1,000 1 in in in in in ,000 1 in ,000

46 Understand institutional/population bias Patient population Patient population Prevalence of obesity Prevalence of obesity Relevant for US vs. CT Relevant for US vs. CT Social/cultural conditions Social/cultural conditions Time of presentation/need for follow-up Time of presentation/need for follow-up Age/gender of patients Age/gender of patients Younger children/adolescent females Younger children/adolescent females Institution resources/support Institution resources/support

47 My biases Awareness of cancer risks associated with pediatric CT need to be raised Awareness of cancer risks associated with pediatric CT need to be raised Alternatives to CT studies need to be explored Alternatives to CT studies need to be explored If there is a low pre-test probability, neither ultrasound nor CT study is an appropriate diagnostic imaging examination If there is a low pre-test probability, neither ultrasound nor CT study is an appropriate diagnostic imaging examination If there is mid to high pre-test probability, and it will likely change the course of treatment, CT is the study of choice for appendicitis If there is mid to high pre-test probability, and it will likely change the course of treatment, CT is the study of choice for appendicitis

48 Pre-test probability

49 My bias against ultrasound There is still controversy about this exam, decades after introduction, even among highly qualified radiologists The appendix is not found in ¾ of all examinations When the appendix is not found, appendicitis can’t be excluded When the appendix is found and appendicitis suspected, there is still a false positive rate of 25% The immediate risk of patient harm from missed ultrasound diagnosis is much more compelling than the theoretical risk (and lower) long-term risk from medical radiation

50 My bias in favor of CT studies If the appendix is seen and normal, no appendicitis If the appendix is seen and normal, no appendicitis If the appendix is not seen, but no other abnormalities identified, very low chance of appendicitis If the appendix is not seen, but no other abnormalities identified, very low chance of appendicitis If the appendix is inflamed, then surgery If the appendix is inflamed, then surgery If the appendix is not seen but inflammation present, follow closely If the appendix is not seen but inflammation present, follow closely

51 Trends for the future Better physician and patient education Better physician and patient education Clinical decision rules to minimize need for imaging Clinical decision rules to minimize need for imaging Awareness of the issues and time constraints upon ED physicians for rapid diagnosis Awareness of the issues and time constraints upon ED physicians for rapid diagnosis Development of alternatives to CT studies Development of alternatives to CT studies Technical alteration of CT protocols to minimize radiation exposure Technical alteration of CT protocols to minimize radiation exposure

52 Conclusions

53 Conclusions There is still controversy concerning diagnostic imaging for appendicitis in pediatric patients There is still controversy concerning diagnostic imaging for appendicitis in pediatric patients We are pro-active in keeping medical radiation exposure as low as reasonable achievable We are pro-active in keeping medical radiation exposure as low as reasonable achievable The experience with our pediatric population, emergency room physician expectations for accuracy, and surgical follow-up has led us to recommend CT studies for appendicitis in the appropriate clinical setting The experience with our pediatric population, emergency room physician expectations for accuracy, and surgical follow-up has led us to recommend CT studies for appendicitis in the appropriate clinical setting

54


Download ppt "The Role of Diagnostic Imaging in Appendicitis D. Joseph Grunz, MD Department of Radiology Mercy Children’s Hospital- St. Louis."

Similar presentations


Ads by Google