Presentation on theme: "Behavioural and Psychological Symptoms of Dementia in Turkey Engin EKER, MD Istanbul University, Cerrahpaşa Medical School Dept. of Geriatric Psychiatry."— Presentation transcript:
Behavioural and Psychological Symptoms of Dementia in Turkey Engin EKER, MD Istanbul University, Cerrahpaşa Medical School Dept. of Geriatric Psychiatry Regional Symposium on Alzheimer’s Disease and Related Disorders in the Middle East October 1-2,2005 Istanbul,Turkey
Expected population of Turkey (million) (OECD projections 1997, SIS 1990 & 2000, DPA 2003)
Elderly Population in Turkey: Highlights Ertan T. IPA Congress.2003 The proportion of elderly in total population in Turkey is rapidly growing. >60 y: 1990: 7,1%2003: 10,8% >65 y:1990: 4,3%2003: 8% OECD Projection 7,7% in 2020
Behavioral and Psychological Symptoms of Alzheimer Disease Behavioral -Agression, hostility, agitation: 60% -Apathy: 70% -Wandering and other motor behavior: 30%- 40% Psychological -Depression: 20%-50% -Anxiety: 40%-50% -Hallucinations or delusions: 10%-20% Mega Ms et al. Neurology. 1996;46: ; Rubin EH etal. J Geriatr Psychiatry Neurol. 1988;1:16-20; Tariot PN et al. Am J Psychiatry. 1993;150:
Why are BPSD Important Diminish patient quality of life Increase caregiver distress: decrease caregiver quality of life( most of the caregivers may have depressive symptoms) Increase cost of care Precipitate nursing home placement
Behavioral Precipitants of Nursing- Home Admission Physical aggression16% Restlessness13% Verbal outbursts, nonaggressive13% Verbal outbursts, aggressive 9% Wandering 9% Pacing 3% Other19% Behaviors that are unlikely to respond to pharmacotherapy: wandering, pacing, screaming, hypersexuality Cohen-Mansfield J 2001; Cohen-Mansfield J. J 1995
The Reasons of Prevalence and Presentation of BPSD in Different Cultures Culturally related factors The concepts of dementia and behavioural disturbances in society (The typical features of dementia are widely recognized and named “Chinnan (literally childishness) in Kerala (Shaji et al. 2003) The tolerance of symptoms in dementia Not always possible direct observation of the patient by clinician No cultural appropriateness of rating scales Availabity of primary and secondary care services for demented patients with BPS A
Beds for Demented Patients in Turkey 10% of the beds in all old age homes run by the Health Ministry and Municipalities are spared for demented and physically debilated patients These patients are separated from the rest of the building Some voluntary groups are engaged in looking after these patients The staff working in these parts of old age is well trained
Services for Elderly People With Acute Psychiatric Problems There are three specialist geropsychiatric unit in Istanbul The first geropsychiatric unit was organized in Cerrahpaşa Medical School,Istanbul University in 1993 The elderly with psychiatric problems are mostly placed in general psychiatry departments and are treated by general psychiatrists
Older People and the Informal Health Care System in Turkey In Turkey, families, friends and neighbours are extensively involved in the care of older people Demented patients are cared for mostly by their spouses,eldest daughters,or daughter in-law Families approach instutional care as a last resort (Eker,1995) The Directoriate of Social Work and Care has developed a project recently “taking care of the elderly at home”
BPSD in Turkish AD (Eker; Ertan; Engin, 2003) SAMPLE: 213 probable and possible AD cases EVALUATION: DSM-IV (APA, 1994) The Turkish vers. MMSE (Güngen, Ertan, Eker, 1998) GDS (Reisberg et al. 1982) Behave-AD (Reisberg et al. 1987) Neuroimagine technics (CT, MRI) Genetic studies (Apo E4)
Age, Gender, Educational Level, Total BEHAVE-AD Score, the MMSE Turkish Score (in 213 AD Cases) Age, years74,01±8(45-95) Female, %68.5 Education, years7.6 ±5(0-17) Disease duration4.3 ±3(1-20) The MMSE score15.6 ±7(0-30) Behave-AD scorel0.8 ± 9 (0-47) Patients with symptoms91.9%
Stage specific severity of each Behave AD subcategory in Turkish AD patiens
RESULTS (III) Most Frequent Symptoms in Turkish AD Patients (in 213 cases) %n Purposeless activity49.3(105) “People are stealing things” delusion44.6(95) Wandering42.7(91) Fear of being left alone40.8(87) Tearfulness40.4(86) Inappropriate activity38.5(82) Depressed mood: other37.6(80) Anxiety regarding upcoming events 36.6(78) Verbal outbursts36.2(77) Day/night disturbances33.8(72) Visual halucinations26.3(56)
The 10/66 Dementia Group: Behavioral and Psychologiacal Symptom of Dementia in developing Countries (Int. Psychogeratrics 2004) Method: Mild and moderate cases (CDR) Main care giver 21 centers in 17 developing countries Community screening Interview for dementia and geriatric mental state schedule (GMS) Result: At least one BPS was reported in 70,9% of the 555 participants.
The 10/66 Dementia Group: Behavioral and Psychologiacal Symptom of Dementia in developing Countries (Int. Psychogeratrics 2004) Results: There were regional differences for individual behaviours High rates of agitation, wandering and sleep distrurbances among Indian participants. High rates of vocalization among Latin American people with dementia.
The 10/66 Dementia Group: Behavioral and Psychologiacal Symptom of Dementia in developing Countries (Int. Psychogeratrics 2004) Results: Overall, numbers of reported BSD were highest in India, intermediate in Latin America and lowest in China. Depression, anxiety and schizophreniform, paranoid psychosis were commonest among people from Latin America and least common in China.
Delusions in Turkish Patients with AD :Could Analysing Specific Delusions be More Helpful ErtanT, Eker E, Engin F et al.2005(I) Aim: To analyse factors associated with presence of delusions to find out whether in individual analysis of delusions in the same group would be more informative Method :n:185 AD patiens(DSM-IV) MMSE, GDS,Behave-AD Dependent variable :one of the delusions Independent variables: gender,age, education,disease duration,GDS stage,and presence of each type hallucination,and remaining types of delusions Logistic regression analysis was used
Delusions in Turkish Patients with AD: Could Analysing Specific Delusions be More helpful (Ertan T,Eker E,Engin F.et al 2005)(II) Result and Conclusions: None of the delusions was associated with age,duration of disease,and education Female gender was associated with only one delusion (delusions of theft) Disease stage(GDS :Stage 6) was associated with two delusions(delusion of home is not home and delusion of infidelity( negative association) Delusions of theft were also independently predicted by delusions imposter and visual hallucination
Conclusions (I) BPSD is still a novel subject in Turkey. Lack of experienced medical staff in Turkey Psychiatrists, neurologists, GPs are just having necessary information on the subject AD patients are seen by the psychiatrists and neurologists at late stage (stage 5&6) Absence of formal services for demented patient No regular home visit system
Conclusions (II) Rating scales (Such as GDS;CDR) and measurements for noncognitive symptoms (Behave-AD; NPI; ADAS-non cognitive) are used only by minority neurologists and psychiatrists
Conclusions (III) There are no trained GP, community nurses, social workers We should educate family and professional caregivers We need more validation studies of observer –rated BPSD screening scale We need cross cultural studies on BPSD developing countries