Presentation is loading. Please wait.

Presentation is loading. Please wait.

1 September 2003 IEEE 802.17 Draft 2.5 OAM Comment Resolution Las Vegas, NV - September 2003 Section Editor: Glenn Parsons Technical Editors: Leon Bruckman,

Similar presentations


Presentation on theme: "1 September 2003 IEEE 802.17 Draft 2.5 OAM Comment Resolution Las Vegas, NV - September 2003 Section Editor: Glenn Parsons Technical Editors: Leon Bruckman,"— Presentation transcript:

1 1 September 2003 IEEE Draft 2.5 OAM Comment Resolution Las Vegas, NV - September 2003 Section Editor: Glenn Parsons Technical Editors: Leon Bruckman, Gal Mor

2 2 September 2003 RPR OAM Met in 1 session (3 long hours) for: 72 comments reviewed Did not deal with most Editorials –Will ask for editorial license for 41 remaining editorials Punted 2 comments to WG Punted 2 comments to clause 0 Highlight of CRG resolutions Response to IETF on MIB

3 3 September 2003 OAM Comments Summary Clause 11: OAM41 –Accepted17 –Rejected3 –Withdrawn1 –Remaining Editorial22 Annex L: Echo & Flush OAM5 –Accepted2 –Remaining Editorial3 Clause 12: Management18 –Accepted12 –Withdrawn1 –Remaining Editorial5 Annex D: MIB26 –Accepted17 –Withdrawn1 –Rejected1 –Remaining Editorial3 All Technical done

4 4 September 2003 Clause 11 & L Highlights Fix RPR alarms references Fix PICS Various binding editorials Various wording clarifications Fix state machine routines Align frame/payload format with new clause 0 resolution

5 5 September 2003 Clause 12 Highlights Complete parameters Clarify & add reference for HC Various clarifications

6 6 September 2003 Clause D Highlights Various binding editorials Clarify security section Delicate text on clearing intervals Table D.2 improvements Change running counters back to counter64

7 7 September 2003 Rejected Clause 11 –391 - Table 11.2 Delete This table is useful clarification of a complex figure. It should stay. Annex D –Editorial rejection

8 8 September 2003 Punt to WG EUI vs OUI –Topology & OAM Organization specific protocol identifiers –Was OUI, currently EUI, comment to make OUI –EUI rejected for similar use in 802.3ah –Propose liaison to IEEE RAC DELAY_TO_CHECK, DELAY_TO_RESTORE –Clause 6 uses as constant –MIB uses as read/write

9 9 September 2003 Ongoing review Issues OAM Editors need some extra time at the end of the draft writing to align the MIB cross-references IETF MIB experts will be informed of the disposition of their comments and continue to be offered to provide comments on future WG ballots


Download ppt "1 September 2003 IEEE 802.17 Draft 2.5 OAM Comment Resolution Las Vegas, NV - September 2003 Section Editor: Glenn Parsons Technical Editors: Leon Bruckman,"

Similar presentations


Ads by Google