Download presentation

Presentation is loading. Please wait.

Published byOmar Edward Modified over 2 years ago

1
DESIGN ANALYSIS for a SMALL SCALE ENGINE by Tim van Wageningen

2
Contents - Motivation - Concepts - Performance Analysis - Conclusions - Questions ±40 min 2 MOTIVATIONS - CONCEPTS – PERFORMANCE I / II / III - CONCLUSIONS

3
NatureTechnology scale → smalllarge Atalantaproject 3 MOTIVATIONS - CONCEPTS – PERFORMANCE I / II / III - CONCLUSIONS

4
Micro Air Vehicle Flapping Wing Mechanism - Designed by Casper Bolsman - 0.6 gram - Performance estimate: - 0.5 W power output - Needed power density of system: 125 W/kg system: 125 W/kg - 6 minutes of flight time with 5% efficiency 5% efficiency MAV 4 MOTIVATIONS - CONCEPTS – PERFORMANCE I / II / III - CONCLUSIONS

5
MAV in Action 5 MOTIVATIONS - CONCEPTS – PERFORMANCE I / II / III - CONCLUSIONS

6
Hydrogen Peroxide - Master thesis of Arjan Meskers at the PME department, TU Delft department, TU Delft - Chemical energy: high energy density - Monopropellant - Clean products: oxygen and water vapor - Example catalysts: -Manganese oxide -Silver-Platinum 6 MOTIVATIONS - CONCEPTS – PERFORMANCE I / II / III - CONCLUSIONS

7
Catalytic Reaction in Action 7 MOTIVATIONS - CONCEPTS – PERFORMANCE I / II / III - CONCLUSIONS

8
Thesis Assignment Find an engine concept that: - is suitable for the MAV - 125 W/kg - 5% efficiency - uses hydrogen peroxide as fuel 8 MOTIVATIONS - CONCEPTS – PERFORMANCE I / II / III - CONCLUSIONS

9
Possibilities 9 MOTIVATIONS - CONCEPTS - PERFORMANCE I / II / III - CONCLUSIONS

10
3 different approaches Turbine Piston Cylinder + + + + + 10 MOTIVATIONS - CONCEPTS - PERFORMANCE I / II / III - CONCLUSIONS

11
Concept I: Tesla Turbine Engine + Easy implementation + Theory of Tesla Turbine predicts good efficiency at predicts good efficiency at small scale small scale - Conversion from rotation to linear motion to linear motion + + 11 MOTIVATIONS - CONCEPTS - PERFORMANCE I / II / III - CONCLUSIONS

12
Concept I: Tesla Turbine Engine + + 12 MOTIVATIONS - CONCEPTS - PERFORMANCE I / II / III - CONCLUSIONS

13
Concept II: Otto Engine + Proven concept on regular scale scale - Projects in literature show bad performance because of bad performance because of fluid leakage problem fluid leakage problem - Implementation difficult + 13 MOTIVATIONS - CONCEPTS - PERFORMANCE I / II / III - CONCLUSIONS

14
Concept II: Otto engine + 14 MOTIVATIONS - CONCEPTS - PERFORMANCE I / II / III - CONCLUSIONS

15
Concept III: Hot Air Engine + Easy implementation + Promising scaling aspects because heat transfer is more because heat transfer is more effective effective - Poor performance on regular scale scale + + 15 MOTIVATIONS - CONCEPTS – PERFORMANCE I / II / III - CONCLUSIONS

16
Concept III: Hot Air Engine + + 16 MOTIVATIONS - CONCEPTS - PERFORMANCE I / II / III - CONCLUSIONS

17
Performance - What influences the performance of these concepts? these concepts? - Concept I - Concept II - Concept III - Are the concepts suited for the MAV? -Power density -Efficiency 17 MOTIVATIONS - CONCEPTS - PERFORMANCE I / II / III - CONCLUSIONS

18
Concept I: Tesla Turbine Engine 18 MOTIVATIONS - CONCEPTS - PERFORMANCE I / II / III - CONCLUSIONS

19
Concept I: Tesla Turbine Engine: model Assumptions: Laminar flow No entrance effects Incompressible fluid 19 MOTIVATIONS - CONCEPTS - PERFORMANCE I / II / III - CONCLUSIONS

20
Power Efficiency Pressure difference Length of belts (radius of discs) Height of gap (spacing between discs) 20 MOTIVATIONS - CONCEPTS - PERFORMANCE I / II / III - CONCLUSIONS

21
[2] V.G. Krishnan et al. A micro Tesla turbine for power generation from low pressure heads and evaporation driven flows. Transducers, 11:1851 – 1854, June 2011. Measurements with small scale Tesla turbines Pressure difference: ~20 kPa Measured Performance 45 mW 18% efficiency Estimated power density: 2 W/kg 21 MOTIVATIONS - CONCEPTS - PERFORMANCE I / II / III - CONCLUSIONS

22
- Power density is too low: pressure difference pressure difference must be increased must be increased considerably considerably - Simple model + measurements show that TTE is not suitable for the show that TTE is not suitable for the current size MAV current size MAV Concept I, Tesla Turbine Engine: conclusions 22 MOTIVATIONS - CONCEPTS - PERFORMANCE I / II / III - CONCLUSIONS

23
Concept II: Otto Engine 23 MOTIVATIONS - CONCEPTS - PERFORMANCE I / II / III - CONCLUSIONS

24
Concept II, Otto Engine: combining 3 models Catalytic Reaction HeatLoss Exhaust Flow ++ 24 MOTIVATIONS - CONCEPTS - PERFORMANCE I / II / III - CONCLUSIONS

25
Catalytic Reaction: model 25 MOTIVATIONS - CONCEPTS - PERFORMANCE I / II / III - CONCLUSIONS Drop on a catalytic surface Similar conditions as during experiments Energy Balance:

26
Catalytic Reaction: model [1] A.J.H. Meskers. High energy density micro-actuation based on gas generation by means of catalyst of liquid chemical energy. Masters thesis, TU Delft, 2010. 26 MOTIVATIONS - CONCEPTS - PERFORMANCE I / II / III - CONCLUSIONS

27
Catalytic Reaction: high fuel concentrations 27 MOTIVATIONS - CONCEPTS - PERFORMANCE I / II / III - CONCLUSIONS

28
Exhaust Flow: model Compressible flow through a round nozzle round nozzle Based on momentum equation 28 MOTIVATIONS - CONCEPTS - PERFORMANCE I / II / III - CONCLUSIONS

29
Heat transfer Heat is transferred via -conduction-convection-radiation 29 MOTIVATIONS - CONCEPTS - PERFORMANCE I / II / III - CONCLUSIONS

30
Concept II, Otto Engine: combining models + + = - Dealing with model uncertainties: 30 MOTIVATIONS - CONCEPTS - PERFORMANCE I / II / III - CONCLUSIONS

31
Otto Engine: observations -Reaction times are fast enough -Trade off for fuel used per cycle -Condensation in cylinder 31 MOTIVATIONS - CONCEPTS - PERFORMANCE I / II / III - CONCLUSIONS

32
Concept II, Otto Engine: Results - Model shows performance above the current requirements of the the current requirements of the MAV (125 W/kg @ 5% efficiency) MAV (125 W/kg @ 5% efficiency) 32 MOTIVATIONS - CONCEPTS - PERFORMANCE I / II / III - CONCLUSIONS

33
Concept II, Otto Engine: considerations - Model neglects: - fluid leakage through cylinder/piston gap - fluid friction at exhaust - fuel delivery system - Condensation in cylinder problem needs to be addressed needs to be addressed 33 MOTIVATIONS - CONCEPTS - PERFORMANCE I / II / III - CONCLUSIONS

34
Concept III: Hot Air Engine 34 MOTIVATIONS - CONCEPTS - PERFORMANCE I / II / III - CONCLUSIONS

35
Concept III, Hot Air Engine: models ++ Catalytic Reaction HeatLoss Heat Reservoir s 35 MOTIVATIONS - CONCEPTS - PERFORMANCE I / II / III - CONCLUSIONS

36
Concept III, Hot Air Engine: Catalytic Reaction Constant temperature Mass balance 36 MOTIVATIONS - CONCEPTS - PERFORMANCE I / II / III - CONCLUSIONS

37
Concept III, Hot Air Engine: Heat Reservoirs Schemati c Under reversible conditions Estimate for heat transfer rates - Using definition Fouriers law Fouriers law -Optimistic and pessimistic value pessimistic value 37 MOTIVATIONS - CONCEPTS - PERFORMANCE I / II / III - CONCLUSIONS

38
Model Results Resulting performance of model ++= 38 MOTIVATIONS - CONCEPTS - PERFORMANCE I / II / III - CONCLUSIONS

39
Considerations for Small Scale Hot Air Engine - Model neglects losses of - fluid flow between piston cylinder gap - heat leakage of Decomposition Unit to the working fluid the working fluid 39 MOTIVATIONS - CONCEPTS - PERFORMANCE I / II / III - CONCLUSIONS

40
Conclusions for Small Scale Hot Air Engine - Heat transfer is not yet fast enough on this scale, which results in low on this scale, which results in low performance performance 40 MOTIVATIONS - CONCEPTS - PERFORMANCE I / II / III - CONCLUSIONS - Concept III is not suited for the MAV

41
Overall Conclusions - Of the considered possibilities, the small scale Otto engine is the best small scale Otto engine is the best option for the MAV: option for the MAV: Power density at 5% efficiency: Concept 1: << 2 W/kg Concept 2: 245 – 440 W/kg Concept 3: 0.5 – 8 W/kg 41 MOTIVATIONS - CONCEPTS - PERFORMANCE I / II / III - CONCLUSIONS

42
42 MOTIVATIONS - CONCEPTS - PERFORMANCE I / II / III - CONCLUSIONS Overall Conclusions Actual implementation of concept II requires more detailed analysis: - Solving the fluid leakage problem - Fuel pump -Exhaust port -Condensation

43
Thank You!

44
44 DETAILED SLIDES Detailed slides

45
16 PERFORMANCE Scaling? Engine 1 S = 1 L = 10 A = 10 V = 10 Engine 2 S = 0.5 L = 5 A = 2.5 V = 1.25 Scaling factor LengthAreaVolume

46
6 PREMILAIRY RESEARCH Approach of others?

47
7 PREMILAIRY REASEARCH Possibilities

48
40 PERFORMANCE Power Efficiency Pressure difference Length of belts (radius of disks) Height of gap (spacing between disks)

49
7 CONCEPTS Energy flow in concepts Carnot cycle =

50
8 PERFORMANCE Carnot Cycle zero power output!

51
9 PERFORMANCE Curzon Ahlborn Cycle

52
10 PERFORMANCE Curzon Ahlborn Cycle

53
11 PERFORMANCE ND Curzon Ahlborn Cycle

54
17 PERFORMANCE Basic thermodynamic engine model - Two constant temperature reservoirs: reservoirs: - Energy flows modeled with Fouriers law of heat conduction: Fouriers law of heat conduction: -Carnot cycle between the working fluid temperatures: working fluid temperatures:

55
ND Curzon Ahlborn Cycle 18 PERFORMANCE

56
19 PERFORMANCE Scaling of performance

57
20 PERFORMANCE Intermediate Conclusions - Efficiency of engine is independent of scale, if the cycle time is adjusted correctly scale, if the cycle time is adjusted correctly - Optimal power output can be found by finding the optimal cycle time finding the optimal cycle time - Assuming an optimal engine configuration:

58
12 PERFORMANCE Energy Balance Model

59
13 PERFORMANCE

60
14 PERFORMANCE Energy Balance Model

61
13 PERFORMANCE Scaling of optimal cycle time concept 3 opti pessi

62
16 DETAILS Heat transfer - Heat is transferred via -conduction-convection-radiation - FEM model in COMSOL

63
Heat transfer: FEM model results 16 DETAILS

64
Heat transfer: facts for MAV engine - Low Biot number situations: not much use for insulation. for insulation. - Difficult to maintain a temperature difference within the system difference within the system - Loss term scaling exponent = 1.5

65
Intermediate Conclusions 15 PERFORMANCE - The performance of depends on a potential and the utilization potential and the utilization - Utilization is independent of scale - How does this apply to the concepts?

66
16 DETAILS Catalytic Reaction: fundamentals - Decomposition rate proportional to the effective contact area between fuel and effective contact area between fuel and catalyst catalyst - Large Damköhler number: rate temperature independent temperature independent - First order reaction:

67
32 DETAILS Exhaust Flow: model Flow through a nozzle nozzle Based on momentum equation Neglects friction

68
Exhaust Flow: characteristics 33 DETAILS

69
Model Results: scaling 24 PERFORMANCE Assumingunrestricted cycle time!

70
41 PERFORMANCE What about scaling? Catalytic Reaction: Fluid Flow: Power Density at reference scale (S=1): Power: Power Density: Power: Power Density: Power Density when size is 10 times smaller (S=0.1):

Similar presentations

Presentation is loading. Please wait....

OK

Chapter 12 Compressible Flow

Chapter 12 Compressible Flow

© 2017 SlidePlayer.com Inc.

All rights reserved.

Ads by Google

Free ppt on brain machine interface project Hrm ppt on recruitment process Ppt on tcp ip protocol suite Download ppt on water pollution in hindi Ppt on industrial revolution in england Ppt on image compression using matlab Ppt on the road not taken analysis Ppt on etiquettes of life Ppt on retail marketing strategy Ppt on bluetooth communications