Download presentation

Presentation is loading. Please wait.

Published bySara Nickle Modified over 2 years ago

1
Finite universe and cosmic coincidences Kari Enqvist, University of Helsinki COSMO 05 Bonn, Germany, August 28 - September 01, 2005

2
cosmic coincidences dark energy –why now: ~ (H 0 M P ) 2 ? CMB –why supression at largest scales: k ~1/H 0 ? UV problem IR problem

3
Do we live in a finite Universe? large box: closed universe 1 → L >> 1/H small box – periodic boundary conditions non-trivial topology: R > few 1/H – non-periodic boundary conditions does this make sense at all? maybe – if QFT is not the full story (not interesting)

4
CMB & multiply connected manifolds discrete spectrum with an IR cutoff along a given direction (”topological scale”) suppression at low l geometric patterns encrypted in spatial correlators (”topological lensing” – rings etc.) correlators depend on the location of the observer and the orientation of the manifold (increased uncertainty for C l ) See e.g. Levin, Phys.Rept.365,2002

5
a pair of matched circles, Weeks topology (Cornish) - many possible multiple connected spaces - typically size of the topological domain restricted to be > 1/H 0 explains the suppression of low multipoles with another coincidence

6
spherical box IR cutoff L ground state wave function j 0 ~ sin(kr)/kr for r < r B radius of the box which boundary conditions? 1)Dirichlet wave function vanishes at r = r B → max. wavelength c = 2r B = 2L → allowed wave numbers k nl = (l /2 + n )/r B 2) Neumann derivative of wave function vanishes allowed modes given through j l (kr B ) l/kr B – j l+1 (kr B ) = 0 for each l, a discrete set of k no current out of U. KE, Sloth, Hannestad

7
Power spectrum: continuous → discrete IR cutoff shows up in the Sachs-Wolfe effect C l = N k k c j l (k nl r) P R (k nl ) / k nl CMB spectrum depends on: - IR cutoff L ( ~ r B ) - boundary conditions - note: no geometric patterns IR cutoff → oscillations of power in CMB at low l

8
Sachs-Wolfe with IR cutoff at l = 10

9
WHY A FINITE UNIVERSE? - observations: suppression, features in CMB at low l - cosmological horizon: effectively finite universe holography?

10
HOLOGRAPHY Black hole thermodynamics Bekenstein bound on entropy classical black hole: dA 0, suggests that S BH ~ A generalized 2nd law dS total = d(S matter + A BH /4) 0 R matter with energy E, S ~ volume spherical collapse S ~ area either give up: 1) unitarity (information loss) 2) locality violation of 2nd law unless S matter 2 ER Bekenstein bound

11
QFT: dofs ~ Volume; gravitating system: dofs ~ Area QFT with gravity overcounts the true dofs QFT breaks down in a large enough V QFT as an effective theory: must incorporate (non-local) constraints to remove overcounting QFT as an effective theory: must incorporate (non-local) constraints to remove overcounting Cohen et al; M. Li; Hsu; ’t Hooft; Susskind argue: locally, in the UV, QFT should be OK constraint should manifest itself in the IR argue:

12
WHAT IS THE SIZE OF THE INFRARED CUT-OFF L? - maximum energy density in the effective theory: 4 Require that the energy of the system confined to box L 3 should be less than the energy of a black hole of the same size: (4 /3)L 3 4 < LM P 2 Cohen, Kaplan, Nelson - assume: L defines the volume that a given observer can ever observe future event horizon R H = a t dt/a R H ~ 1/H in a Universe dominated by dark energy ’causal patch’ more restrictive than Bekenstein: S max ~ (S BH ) 3/4 Li Susskind, Banks

13
the effectively finite size of the observable Universe constrains dark energy: 4 < 1/L 2 dark energy = zero point quantum fluctuation ~

14
for phenomenological purposes, assume: 1) IR cutoff is related to future event horizon: R H = cL, c is constant 2) the energy bound is saturated: = 3c 2 (M P /R H ) 2 a relation between IR and UV cut-offs = a relation between dark energy equation of state and CMB power spectrum at low l Friedmann eq. + = 1: R H = c / ( H) now ½

15
dark energy equation of state w = -1/3 - 2/(3c) ½ predicts a time dependent w with -(1+2/c) < 3w < -1 Note: if c < 1, then w < -1 phantom; OK? - e.g. for Dirichlet the smallest allowed wave number k c = 1.2/( H 0 ) - the distance to last scattering depends on w, hence the relative position of cut-off in CMB spectrum depends on w

16
translating k into multipoles: l = k l ( 0 - ) comoving distance to last scattering 0 - = dz/H(z) 0 z*z* H(z) 2 = H 0 2 [ (1+z) (3+3w) +(1- )(1+z) 3 ] 0 0 w = w(c, ) l c = l c (c)

17
Parameter Prior Distribution Ω = Ω m + Ω X 1 Fixed h 0.72 ± 0.08 Gaussian Ω b h 2 0.014-0.040 Top hat n s 0.6-1.4 Top hat 0-1 Top hat Q - Free b - Free strategy: 1) choose a boundary condition: 2) calculate 2 for each set of c and k cut, marginalising over all other cosmological parameters fits to data: we do not fix k c but take it instead as a free parameter k cut

18
Neumann

19
Dirichlet fits to WMAP + SDSS data 95% CL68% CL 2 = 1444.8 2 = 1441.4 Best fit CDM: 2 = 1447.5

20
95% CL68% CL Likelihood contours for SNI data WMAP, SDSS + SNI bad fit, SNI favours w ~ -1

21
other fits: Zhang and Wu, SN+CMB+LSS: c = 0.81 w 0 = - 1.03 but: fit to some features of CMB, not the full spectrum; no discretization

22
conclusions ’cosmic coincidences’ might exist both in the UV (dark energy) and IR (low l CMB features) finite universe suppression of low l holographic ideas connection between UV and IR toy model: CMB+LSS favours, SN data disfavours – but is c constant? very speculative, but worth watching! E.g. time dependence of w

Similar presentations

OK

Macroscopic Quantum Geometry Craig Hogan University of Chicago and Fermilab.

Macroscopic Quantum Geometry Craig Hogan University of Chicago and Fermilab.

© 2017 SlidePlayer.com Inc.

All rights reserved.

Ads by Google

Ppt on operant conditioning Muscular system anatomy and physiology ppt on cells Ppt on network theory communication Ppt on library management system free download Ppt on relations and functions for class 11th Ppt on revolt of 1857 causes Ppt on 3 r's of environment Morphological opening ppt on mac Ppt on condition based maintenance of underground cable systems Ppt on principles of peace building in afghanistan