Presentation on theme: "Prof. P. Myler & B.Pederson Composite Design and Analysis Training and Education (CoDATE) The wider benefits."— Presentation transcript:
Prof. P. Myler & B.Pederson Composite Design and Analysis Training and Education (CoDATE) The wider benefits
Prof. P. Myler & B.Pederson Current development team ( School of Built Environment, University of Bolton) Professor Peter Myler – Head of Research & Enterprise, Brian Pederson - Senior Lecturer & Enterprise Champion Jim Banks – Director Aero-Composites Design Limited Ivan Dean – Chair IMechE NW Region. Industrial support – NWAA BAE Systems Aircelle Morson International Bombardier Aerospace Brookhouse Engineering Middleton Sheet Metal Lufthansa Academic Support – nwUa University of Manchester
Prof. P. Myler & B.Pederson Industrial skills and technology needs. Growing demand for engineers with skills in newer technologies (Composites) Expansion in use of composites across business sectors (aerospace, automotive, marine, wind energy and civil engineering). Demand at all levels for multi-skilled design/structural engineers. Need for topical training/qualifications - validated and accredited. Chartered and Incorporated engineers to apply skills & knowledge industry/university links reflecting best practice Need to address CPD/MPD and company focused training courses.
Prof. P. Myler & B.Pederson Academic/university requirements Course must achieve academic validation and professional institute recognition/accreditation Mixed mode and flexible delivery of learning material Courses must be capable of delivery to diverse student body All learning outcomes clearly identified and met. IPR for learning material agreed.
Prof. P. Myler & B.Pederson Programme Launch - ANAF Conference Oct 2006 The Future Of The Aerospace Industry In North West Of England Sir Dick Evans, formally chairman of BAE Systems, now Chairman of United Utilities Derek Marshall, Director (Defence and Homeland Security) SBAC, and Martin Wright, Executive Director NWAA.
Prof. P. Myler & B.Pederson 4 Working Groups launched – one had specific objective of “Education, Skills and Training Challenge” “...to address the future of the aerospace industry in the North West and the ‘Global Challenge “.. unanimously accepted that there was (sic) and still is, a major challenge to be faced in the education, training and skills of the engineers in the aerospace industry. “It is... important that Industry and Academia take much greater steps than hitherto to establish closer relationships to formulate... future needs so that relevant curricula can be created. “ Steering group had industrial, academic and regional development membership
Prof. P. Myler & B.Pederson Development Matrix of needs
Prof. P. Myler & B.Pederson Early stages (2009) Review of existing provisions – Use of internationally available courses would not meet UK requirements (course content, course availability, costs, professional institute recognition) Locally the picture very mixed. Some leading companies had bespoke in-house courses. courses fully met particular in-house, delivered by experienced (and in some cases world recognised) subject matter experts, it was becoming more difficult to keep training material up to date due to business demands availability of the subject matter experts for training was becoming restricted. courses did NOT carry formal academic qualifications, and not formally recognised by any professional body.
Prof. P. Myler & B.Pederson Early stages (2009) Review of existing provisions (continued) – Most nationally available courses provided for the training of manufacturing operators Many university courses were aligned to materials science and not applied engineering. CONCLUSION - A major gap existed and confirmed the need for focused academic and CPD programmes
Prof. P. Myler & B.Pederson Course development Strategic issue - Joint university and industrial working group established and working closely. Capability matrix populated with key learning points. Strategy map developed for current programme and sustainable future
Prof. P. Myler & B.Pederson
Course development Some of the jointly agreed guiding principles at this early phase were – Critical for future plans that we know and understand both the target populations and their target roles. Portfolios need to be capable of being focused and tailored to population groupings Development ladders must cater for a mixture of formal learning and “on-the-job” training Engineering knowledge needs to be common core. Active interaction between universities of Bolton and Manchester using design eng’g strengths of Bolton and materials science strengths of Manchester.
Prof. P. Myler & B.Pederson Course development (continued) At the end of this phase the working had developed – a fully populated matrix of specific module topics an assessment criteria that would meet the university’s academic standards a structured set of topics and sub-topics for the modules plus academic schemes of work a complete introductory course including lecture material, class based practical investigations and real life worked case studies Next step was to pilot the courses off campus with partner companies. (2) companies volunteered Bombardier (Belfast) BAE Systems (Warton/Samlesbury unit)
Prof. P. Myler & B.Pederson Course Building (MSc and CPD/MPD) (4) successful pilot introductory courses presented (2 nd quarter of 2009). Over 100 candidates chosen by the participating companies – no academic vetting Most student feedback very supportive with suggestions for improvements Some feedback emphasising importance of class based practical investigations 2 comments that the course did not fit with their jobs but that it was worthwhile. Business feedback very supportive especially regarding work-based location – less disruptive to on-going business – BUT BEWARE!
Prof. P. Myler & B.Pederson MSc and CPD/MPD Following the pilots’ focus put on development of MSc to deliver academic rigour and industrial best practice. Exchange of developed modules between Bolton and Manchester. Joint team fully engaged with weekly progress meetings to meet target dates. Significant step forward with full joint development of detailed lesson content – also available via e-learning facility. Successful audits carried out by nwUa (funding body) – auditor comment ‘..the programme has delivered beyond expectations...’. In conjunction with IMechE team member the course content and detailed modules design to meet UK Spec to meet chartered engineering status requirements Mixed mode learning (on-campus, e-learning and on-work base )meets industrialists requirements
Prof. P. Myler & B.Pederson Validation MSc successful in gaining academic validation in November 2009 Validation review fully supported by the academic and industrial team members Comments from 1 st review board were minor in nature All comments successfully addressed within 4 weeks. Module credit values and assessment criteria validated – on-going evaluations of student achievements throughout course no traditional end of year examinations IMechE have ‘endorsed’ the course and will review outcomes from course after first intake with a view to fully endorsing it. CPD/MPD modules provide modular learning plus ability to address ‘gaps’ in engineers and companies’ strategic technology capabilities.
Prof. P. Myler & B.Pederson Current Programme status All programme deliverables achieved on time & to budget Joint academic/industrialists TEAM working very closely – ‘best practice’ CPD modules – first course were ready by the end of May 2010 CPD course was ready by December 2010 MSc course was ready for delivery in Oct 2010 MSc bridging courses ready by July Multi-mode learning experiences ready On-going discussions with local FE college to ensure programme deliverables (especially CPD modules) do not overlap plus mutual support
Prof. P. Myler & B.Pederson Current Programme status continued… Identification of a gap between HND/Foundation degree and MSc Programme has strong theme to support mature practicing engineers Marketing Key activity – multi formats used. Banners and large scale presentation material for conferences, trade shows, etc Separate flyers for MSc and CPD so that focused deliver can be made.
Prof. P. Myler & B.Pederson Lessons learnt- Academic & industrial requirements MUST be clear and agreed at outset. Flexibility by collaborators essential Diverse student capability – outside the experience of industrialists? Mutual respect and openness in team essential Regular interface meetings critical Terminological and perceptual will arise amongst team (academic speak and industrial speak) Membership continuity of working group essential Number of subject matter experts limited – “train the trainers” using material under licence?.
Prof. P. Myler & B.Pederson Lessons learnt Put course material up review, comment and change Focus and be selective in course material – don’t be overambitious! Pilot modules wherever possible – there is no substitute Do what you say and deliver on it Right mix of academic rigour/standards and industrial practice essential Sharing IPR is vital – Copyright issues can be divisive and block progress – look to building up UK Ltd Difficult to attract UK based engineers
Prof. P. Myler & B.Pederson Conclusions Close and regular liaison with the funding provider is essential there were no surprises & no disappointments On-going support from nwUa within and outside the working group Supportive response regarding the use of funding and further funding A good reputation meant other funding bodies (e.g. NWDA) had trust in the team Continued….
Prof. P. Myler & B.Pederson Conclusions continued…. The ‘right mix’ of academic rigour, teaching experience, technology expertise and industrial experience was had to be invested to get the course to where it is now – ready to harvest the fruits of the labours. In terms of the technology – delivering training and learning is one thing – subsequent on-going support to the engineers will be required! The modular approach with mixed mode delivery that meets industry and university requirements has proven popular with the companies. Attracting UK students is frustratingly difficult – current economic constraints may be influencing this
Prof. P. Myler & B.Pederson A key industrial contributor was quoted as saying: “ One of the MOST interesting and rewarding programmes of work I have ever done!”
Prof. P. Myler & B.Pederson Main Problems: Managing expectations- Industrialists require “Oven ready Chickens”, Academic Institutions aim to develop “rounded individuals with skills for life long learning” and so cultivate and hatch eggs! Many Industrialists put great emphasis on knowledge and skills (vertical thinking approach) but academic institutions aim to develop people to seek and produce new techniques (lateral thinking approach). Learners returning to education sometimes lack confidence when working with recent graduates and underestimate their experience in relation to course delivery
Prof. P. Myler & B.Pederson Problems cont: Same industrial sectors are protective of what is essentially commonly available information - much is on the “web”. Educational providers preferred even if the product is not really fit for purpose E-learning is not the panacea for education, personal contact is still important for rapid learning especially in highly technical design processes Understanding industrial terminology and the academic process
Prof. P. Myler & B.Pederson Real Benefits: Transferable case studies developed in conjunction with academics and industrialists Cross sector involvement-using good practice Many aspects of the material is transferable across academic levels, especially videos and material data Building blocks for future bids. Post codate as developed: NWDA-Comphet, Royal Academy of Engineering-Industrial Dissertation/PDP and Flying Skills
Prof. P. Myler & B.Pederson Marketing Benefits
Prof. P. Myler & B.Pederson Acknowledgements & special thanks to: Celia Brigg NWUA, Clare Lowe NWUA Jim Banks AeroComposites/BAE systems Ivan Dean (formally Aircelle Safron) IMechE Iain Minton Aircelle Safron Arthur Wilkinson University of Manchester NWCC Alan Groves DSTL Sofi Datoney Freelance Graphic Designer Eric Carswell University of Bolton
Thank you for your attention Any Questions? Prof. P. Myler & B.Pederson