Presentation on theme: "Intimate Partner Violence / Domestic Violence A Public Health Issue"— Presentation transcript:
1 Intimate Partner Violence / Domestic Violence A Public Health Issue
2 Boston Public Health Commission (BPHC) The Mission of the BPHC is “To protect, preserve, and promote the health and well-being of all Boston residents, particularly those who are most vulnerable.”The Domestic Violence Program (DVP) is one of about 30 BPHC programs, and was created in 1992 to address domestic violence as a serious public health problem. Our mission is to raise awareness of DV as a health issue in the City of Boston, and to support community efforts to address the problem.
3 Why is Domestic Violence a Public Health Issue? It is prevalent in our societyIt is a leading cause of injury and death, and has a serious impact on healthIt affects the health of individuals, families, and the whole communitySome groups are at higher risk and have less access to help due to language, cultural, economic, physical, and other barriersIPV/DV and its health effects are preventable!!
4 What does it look like, sound like, feel like ExerciseUnintended Pregnancy: A means of controlRape by partner, preventing or forcing use of contraception, Belittling her request to use contraception, Refusing to use condoms or other agreed-upon means of birth control, Pressuring her into an unwanted pregnancy, Using multiple pregnancies as a means of control
5 IPV/DV DefinedA pattern of behaviors perpetrated in a private or family context intended to exert coercive control over another person, can include physical, sexual, psychological, and/or economic forms of abuse. in the context of a current or former intimate relationship.Elder and child abuse are perpetrated against an individual age 60+ or under 18, usually by a caretaker, family member, or someone in a position of power over the victim. Either could also be IPVLook for confusion about the definition of domestic violence; escalating control, physical force, intimidation, threats, pattern, multiple episodes over time, range of tacticsStress - control is the issue
6 Actual physical abuse and/or An attempt to harm someone and/or Legal Definition: The Massachusetts Abuse Prevention Act, Chapter 209 A, defines abuse as:Actual physical abuse and/orAn attempt to harm someone and/orPlacing someone in fear of serious physical harm and/or causing someone to engage in sexual relations by force, threat of force or duress.Economic and emotional abuse
7 DV/IPV: The DataApproximately 1.3 million women and 835,000 men are physically assaulted by an intimate partner annually in the US. Patricia Tjaden & Nancy Thoennes, U.S. Dep't of Just., NCJ , Full Report of the Prevalence, Incidence, and Consequences of Intimate Partner Violence Against Women: Findings from the National Violence Against Women Survey, at iv (2000), available at2.2 million women physically assaulted by partner/ex- every year. The Commonwealth Fund,In a study conducted in the 50 States and the District of Columbia, nearly 25% of women and 7.6% of men were raped and/or physically assaulted by a current or former spouse, cohabiting partner, or dating partner/acquaintance at some time in their lifetime Patricia Tjaden & Nancy Thoennes, U.S. Dep't of Just., NCJ , Extent, Nature, and Consequences of Intimate Partner Violence, at iii (2000), available atBoston Police Dept served over 2000 restraining orders in 2009Domestic Violence statistics are often confusing. Suffice it to say that the numbers vary in large part, according to the definition of domestic violence used.(based on survey of 16,000 participants, equally male and female).
8 IPV - Epidemiology 25.5% lifetime prevalence (women) 7.6% lifetime prevalence (men)Women overall at significantly greater risk than men and more likely to sustain injuries.Women are significantly more likely than men to be injured during an assault: 31.5% of female rape victims, compared with 16.1% of male rape victims, reported being injured during their most recent rape, and 39-42% percent of female physical assault victims, compared with 20-25% of male physical assault victims, reported being injured during their most recent physical assault.Most IPV victimizations never reported to police, especially those committed against men
9 Commonwealth Homicides DV/IPV deaths tripled between 2005 & 20072005 there were 15 murders and 4 suicides related to ipv/dv2006, 28 murders and 3 suicides2007, 42 murders and 13 suicides2008, 28 murders, 1 suicide2009, 22 murders, 5 suicides2010, 32 murders, 12 suicides32 murders, 2 suicides in Massachusetts this year – 10/11 (Jane Doe, Inc.)the vast majority of victims are women, and nearly all the killers were men.Most male domestic violence homicide victims were killed by men. They were friends, family members or new partners of the domestic violence victims. In the majority of cases where the homicide perpetrator is a woman, there is evidence to suggest that she was the victim of domestic violence who acted in a self-defense. In approximately 9% of the cases from 2003 to 2008, the male homicide victim was the intimate partner of the male domestic violence homicide perpetrator.Our analysis of the homicides over the past 5 years shows that despite histories of domestic violence, very few victims of domestic violence homicide had received services from a local domestic violence programs and that few if any of the murderers, ever participated in batterer’s intervention programs.
10 IPV/DV includes:Physical violence that increases in severity and frequency;Abusive behaviors that are followed by apologies and promises of change;Increased danger when the victim tries to leave.
11 IPV/DV is the abuse of power in a relationship Individuals use various types of power/authority to harm/control another:GenderRacial/ethnic identitySocioeconomic statusEducational levelClass privilegeSexual orientation
13 PHYSICAL ABUSE INCLUDES... slapping, punching, choking, pinching, biting, shoving, burning, kicking, beating, stabbing, shootingSEXUAL ABUSE INCLUDES...forcing you to have sex or perform sexual acts you don’t like, refusing to practice safe sex, preventing you from using birth controlUSING COERCIONAND THREATSThreatening to hurt or kill you; Threatening to leave you;Threatening to commit suicide; Threatening to report you to welfare or immigration;Making you drop charges;Making you do illegal thingsUSING INTIMIDATIONScaring you with looks, actions, or gestures;Smashing things, destroying your property, abusing pets;Displaying weapons;Using HIV status as a way to control youUSING ECONOMIC ABUSEPreventing you from getting or keeping a job;Making you ask for money;Giving you an allowance;Taking your money;Not giving you access to family incomeUSING EMOTIONAL ABUSEPutting you down;Making you feel bad about yourself;Calling you names;Making you think you’re crazy;Playing mind games;Humiliating you;Making you feel guiltyPOWERAndCONTROLUSING ENTITLEMENTTreating you as inferior because of your gender, race, education, religion, political views, sexual orientation, age, or physical characteristics;Not letting you make bigdecisions;Treating you like a servantUSING ISOLATIONControlling what you do, who you see and talk to, where you go;Withholding medical/social services, limiting outside activities;Using jealousy to justify actionsAbuse may include assault, but there are special dynamics which differentiate it:The abuser violates trust, The abuser threatens to repeat the assault, The individual who is being abused feels trapped, The abused person is blamed.Increasingly researchers and practitioners are learning additional forms of controlling behavior which cross genders in greater ways:Earning power, Educational status, Immigration status, Attitude about sexual orientationUSING CHILDRENMaking you feel guilty or responsible for children’s problems;Using children to relay messages or putting them in the middle of arguments;Threatening to take your children away, claim you are an unfit parent, or have you deportedMINIMIZING, DENYING, AND BLAMINGMaking light of the abuse and not taking your concerns seriously;Saying the abuse didn’t happen;Blaming behavior on other things, like being drunk or under stress;Saying you caused the abuseDeveloped by: Domestic Abuse Intervention Project202 East Superior Street, Duluth, MN 55802
14 IPV - DynamicsAbuser tends to view ‘partner’ as inferior adversary, not as equalAbusive behavior to gain compliance from, or control over anotherAbuser may seem ‘healthier’ than survivorMany perpetrators do not see their behavior as wrong in any way
15 Wave of Abuse Abusive Incident Abusive Incident Remorse Carping Hearts & FlowersWave of AbuseThere is a pattern of abuse within an abusive relationship. We are not talking about arguments and conflicts within a relationship. This is the difference between healthy intimate relationships and abusive ones.Same Old Stuff
16 Race, culture, community— intersections with ipv/dv The ethnic/cultural background of the family may influenceThe batterer’s tacticsThe survivor’s coping strategiesCommunity responseInstitutional responseThe individual meaning of violenceThe quality of the provider-client relationshipShelter from the Storm, Child Witness to Violence Project, Boston Medical Center, 2000
17 Immigrant & refugee survivors’ fears Deportation;Worries, lack of knowledge, & misinformation about the legal system;Kidnapping of children, loss of custody;Finances;Harm to family at homeLosing connections with family/community here & in home country
18 Working with immigrant & refugee survivors Be clear about your role: what you can & will do, what you will not do (ie: contact INS);Listen carefully;Speak slowly, take your time;Interview with the assistance of a bilingual, bicultural interpreter;Do not use family members to translate.
19 Effects of domestic violence Traumatic injuryExacerbation of chronic complaintsDecreased attention to self-care, including difficulty maintaining medical and dietary regimensOverall negative health effects, esp. with increased smoking, alcohol use.
20 Effects on victim Fear for own safety & that of other family members Anxiety/painAngerSense of shame & humiliationConfusionDepressionEating & sleep disruptions/disordersSuicidal thoughts /attemptsHigh risk behaviorsHypervigilance
21 Health Effects of Abuse FATALHomicideSuicideMaternal mortalityAIDS relatedAny death resulting from issues at rightSource: Center for Health and Gender EquityNON-FATALPhysical injury, disabilityChronic conditionsMental IllnessReproductive health problemsNegative health Behaviors
22 Trauma in the lives of battered women “Traumatic events overwhelm the ordinary systems of care that give people a sense of control, connection, and meaning.”The core of trauma is disconnection and disempowerment.Herman J, 1990The commonly held definitions of trauma as shattering one’s assumptions in the goodness of people, justice, safety are not always shared by all people in our culture. People of color, those who have been terrorized in their homes at a young age, or in war-torn home countries, know that the world is not safe nor just. In considering the trauma of domestic violence, or in any form, other aspects of their lives, past and present, must be considered.
23 Intimate Partner Violence during Pregnancy Pregnancy can be an especially vulnerable time of life - Between 4% and 8% of women experience IPV during pregnancy, including women from all walks of life in every age, racial and ethnic group. Experiencing IPV during pregnancy has been associated with pregnancy complications, pre- term labor, prematurity, low birthweight infants, neonatal intensive care admissions and even neonatal death. Among pregnant women, IPV is linked to depression, post-partum depression, eating an unhealthy diet and engaging in unhealthy behaviors, such as alcohol or drug abuse.IPV during pregnancy is a serious health concern, since the effects extend beyond the victim. Some physical abusers not only aim their blows at their partner but also at a pregnant woman's belly, placing the fetus in danger.
24 Intimate Partner Violence during Pregnancy Partners may become abusive (or more abusive) during pregnancy because they feel:upset over an unplanned pregnancyincreased stress at the thought of supporting a new baby (or an additional child)jealous that a partner's attention may shift to the new baby (or a new relationship)Unintended Pregnancy: A means of controlRape by partner, preventing or forcing use of contraception, Belittling her request to use contraception, Refusing to use condoms or other agreed-upon means of birth control, Pressuring her into an unwanted pregnancy, Using multiple pregnancies as a means of control
25 Mental Health Problems Poverty/Homelessness Potential Pathways of Co-occurrence (Adapted from the Institute For Health and Recovery “Working with Women with DV, MH and SA Problems”)Physical, Financial,Mental Health ProblemsVictimizationTrauma sequelaePoverty/HomelessnessLow Self-esteemDependence on abuserSelf-MedicationUnhealthy copingPerpetration,Illegal activity,IncarcerationAddiction
26 IPV - Barriers to Disclosure FearPerceptions of health care systemLanguage, culture and religionImmigration statusSexual orientationAbuser threats and controlEmphasize cultural competency and sensitivity to needs of special populations
27 Mandatory Reporting Laws State's mandatory reporting law & response to mandatory reportsIf you suspect children are being neglected or harmedAdvocate on behalf of adult victim/survivor’s safetyIf patient is over 65 or a dependent adult
28 The ConversationTalking with clients is about dialogue, not simply screeningOnly discuss domestic violence with client aloneLet the client know the limits of confidentialityDiscuss documentationUse your clinical skills here. I’m not telling you to do anything outside your normal practice in engaging clients
29 The Conversation Use gender-neutral or gender-appropriate language Prepare yourself for the client’s responseRecognize the client’s attachment to his/her partner
30 Ways to Respond I believe you. I’m concerned about your safety. No matter what your partner says, you don’t deserve to be treated this way.I would like to give you the name and number of an advocate who is quite knowledgeable about these issues. (Can you safely carry this information home?)
31 Safety AssessmentAre there any weapons (or access to weapons) in the home?Is there or has there ever been domestic violence?Is there or has there ever been a Restraining Order filed against the client?Is anyone in the home at risk of harm?Are there any other safety concerns?
32 Client Safety: Immediate safety needs Are you in immediate danger?Where is the perpetrator now? Is he/she at this facility now?Is it safe for you to go home?Do you want the police or security to be notified?Is it safe to take this written information with you?Will it be safe for you to meet with advocates in the community or would you like to meet with them in one of our offices?
33 Client Safety: Pattern & History of Abuse What was the most serious thing he/she ever did to you?Has your partner forced you to have sex? Hurt you sexually? Forced you into sexual acts that made you uncomfortable?Does your partner control what you do? Whom you see?
34 Client Safety: Additional risks to consider Partner risksRisks related to sexual violenceRisks related to self harm
35 Client Safety Assess current access to advocacy and support resources Has the client used community resources? Why? Why not?How helpful were they?What else does client need?
36 AdvocacyListening to the client’s story, their experience, including their efforts to resist, seek help, and copeSupport the client with their struggle in their feelings/attachment to her partnerConsider their context: i.e. cultural, socio- economic, religiousDiscuss immediate safety, developing plan which will be considered and modified in ongoing way
37 Empowerment Validate client’s experiences; Explore options/advocate for safetyBuild on client’s strengths/avoid victim- blamingRespect client’s right to make own decisions
38 Defining SuccessSuccess is NOT “fixing” DV or telling survivors what to do…Success ISproviding them an opportunity to talk to a trusted provider, get information, reduce isolation and increase optionsEnsuring access to highest quality health care possible
39 Criminal JusticeEmployersDV/SAProgramsHealth CareFaithCommunityhave available a current list of local resources with names of specially trained individuals.We are not—and don’t have to be—experts in all fields. It is better to refer to an expert than to try to handle it ourselves if we are not equipped to do so.Local shelters can help you establish a referral network, and they are eager to assist you. Often the phone numbers can be found in your telephone directory. These local numbers will fit on small cards that can be placed in patient restrooms where women can read them discreetly.Office and hospital personnel with special training, Law enforcement (police, lawyers, advocates), Shelters (housing, support groups, advocates), Local hotlinesOther communityresponses
40 24-hr hotlines Massachusetts SafeLink DV Hotline - 877.785.2020 (TTY)Boston Area Rape Crisis Center RAPE(TTY)National Domestic Violence Hotline: SAFE (7233)(TTY)Domestic Abuse Helpline for Men & WomenHELPLINE - spec. resources for men who are victims
41 IPV/DV FactsDV occurs around the world, in all countries, cultures, religious groups, and classes.Around the world and in the US, about one out of three women has been physically or sexually assaulted by someone close to her in her lifetime.DV occurs in same-sex as well as opposite-sex relationships.Women are assaulted more frequently and are more seriously injured by the assaults than are men DV is a pattern of coercive control involving physical, sexual, psychological, and/or economic abuse.DV is perpetrated in the context of a current or former intimate relationship.DV is a learned behavior, chosen by the abuser b/c it works.Cultural differences exist in how violence is perpetrated, how/when services are sought, etc.
42 IPV/DV is NOT… an isolated incident a random act of violence a loss of controlcaused by alcohol, drugs or stressthe victim’s faultgeneticlimited to physical assaults
43 Defining Secondary Traumatic Stress “…the natural consequent behaviors and emotions resulting from knowing about a traumatizing event experienced by another…the stress resulting from helping or wanting to help a traumatized or suffering person.”Figley 1995
44 STAND UP Who had 8 hours of sleep? ate breakfast this AM? exercise this week?spend time with family?