We think you have liked this presentation. If you wish to download it, please recommend it to your friends in any social system. Share buttons are a little bit lower. Thank you!
Presentation is loading. Please wait.
Published byRaphael Franklyn
Modified over 2 years ago
SEMSEM Phoenix 2006 AACRAO SEM Conference © Gottheil, Smith LEVERAGING ENROLLMENT WITH FINANCIAL AID: MERIT & NEED-BASED STRATEGIES USED IN THE U.S. & CANADA SEM Conference November 12, 2006 Phoenix, Arizona
SEMSEM Phoenix 2006 AACRAO SEM Conference © Gottheil, Smith Presenters Susan Gottheil, M.A. Executive Director, Enrollment Management & Registrar Mount Royal College, Calgary, Alberta, Canada email@example.com Clayton Smith, Ed.D. Vice-Provost, Students & Registrar University of Windsor, Ontario, Canada firstname.lastname@example.org
SEMSEM Phoenix 2006 AACRAO SEM Conference © Gottheil, Smith The Schedule Introduction: The SEM Role for Financial AidIntroduction: The SEM Role for Financial Aid The Financial Aid EnvironmentThe Financial Aid Environment Financial Aid StrategiesFinancial Aid Strategies What Strategies are Best: Pitfalls and SolutionsWhat Strategies are Best: Pitfalls and Solutions Discussion, Questions & CommentsDiscussion, Questions & Comments
SEMSEM Phoenix 2006 AACRAO SEM Conference © Gottheil, Smith Introduction: The SEM Role for Financial Aid
SEMSEM Phoenix 2006 AACRAO SEM Conference © Gottheil, Smith Introduction Before the late 1970’s: Financial aid generally used to meet students’ demonstrated financial need An incentive for enrollment Modern financial aid practices focus on: Both students’ willingness to pay & ability to pay Increasing institutional brand, reputation & rankings
SEMSEM Phoenix 2006 AACRAO SEM Conference © Gottheil, Smith Introduction College costs increasing Increased competition Student consumer behavior increasing The Result: Financial aid has shifted from being a student support service to a key SEM activity
SEMSEM Phoenix 2006 AACRAO SEM Conference © Gottheil, Smith The Financial Aid Environment
SEMSEM Phoenix 2006 AACRAO SEM Conference © Gottheil, Smith Canada & the U.S. Cuts in public funding coupled with larger tuition increases Differences in the use of financial aid becoming fewer Competitive student recruitment environment Growing perception by low income students that they cannot afford college
SEMSEM Phoenix 2006 AACRAO SEM Conference © Gottheil, Smith Canada & the U.S. Rising tuition has become a public concern, although varying economics by sector Tuition relatively small share of total costs for students attending community college Tuition most significant expense at private institutions Americans see the Canadian university tuition/quality ratio attractive ~ 5,000 U.S. students enrolled in Canadian schools 86% increase over last 3 years
SEMSEM Phoenix 2006 AACRAO SEM Conference © Gottheil, Smith Canada & the U.S. Tuition costs mask affordability Difference in affordability varies less between Canada & U.S. than within the 2 countries: Geographic neighbors: Quebec (1) & Ontario (40); Nevada (3) & Oregon (38) 5 most affordable jurisdictions: South Carolina, Vermont, Ohio, Rhode Island & Pennsylvania The least affordable: Nova Scotia Poorer states more affordable than poorer provinces
SEMSEM Phoenix 2006 AACRAO SEM Conference © Gottheil, Smith Canada & the U.S. In Canada, poorer provinces tend to be less affordable because: Tuition is higher than in other provinces Wealthier provinces spend more heavily on student aid which counteracts the equalizing effects of federal student aid programs American institutions more affordable because U.S. students receive more financial aid Grant aid: $1,288 vs. $955 (US$) per student Loans: $7,248 vs. $4,601 (US$) per student U.S. provides 58% more in form of grants per student than Canada (“Welfare state”)
SEMSEM Phoenix 2006 AACRAO SEM Conference © Gottheil, Smith In Canada Tuition has been rising—by 70% over the past 10 years Taking both tax credits & inflation into account, tuition has increased by only 25% since 1995-96 Decreases in grants means net tuition for poorer students has increased much faster than for wealthier students Burden of funding post-secondary education shifted from government sources to students and their families
SEMSEM Phoenix 2006 AACRAO SEM Conference © Gottheil, Smith In Canada Much misinformation about costs/financial aid Low income Canadians overestimate costs of post-secondary education by 75% & underestimate benefits by 40% 64% of parents believe their child will receive Government assistance, but only 28% of students entering university do
SEMSEM Phoenix 2006 AACRAO SEM Conference © Gottheil, Smith In Canada In 2000 federal government established new grants (Canadian Millennium Scholarship Foundation) $350 million/year Some provinces provide resources based on family income rather than on basis of educational expenses (Prince Edward Island, Manitoba) Examining impact of grants on low-income students’ ability to access & complete postsecondary studies Has found significant retention gap between those who receive a loan & a grant vs. those who receive only loans
SEMSEM Phoenix 2006 AACRAO SEM Conference © Gottheil, Smith In Canada Concern that rising interest rates & planned aid reductions for federal programs will lead to cuts in student aid Canada Millennium Scholarship Foundation slated to wind down activities in 2009 Increased Government use of tax credits & tuition freezes/reductions have spread money thinly -Substantially increased costs have left little for important targeted loans & grant programs Federal Government may abandon the field of student financial assistance as part of a general program of rebalancing Student Access Guarantee - Ontario
SEMSEM Phoenix 2006 AACRAO SEM Conference © Gottheil, Smith In the U.S. Over past 5 years, major cuts in state higher education funding resulted in dramatic tuition increases Tuition increased the most in Iowa (52%), Massachusetts (49%) & Minnesota (47%) Nationwide fees rose by 32.3% In 2005-06, public colleges & universities increased tuition & fees by 7.1% An improvement over the double-digit increases in past years but still outpacing inflation, wages, or financial aid
SEMSEM Phoenix 2006 AACRAO SEM Conference © Gottheil, Smith In the U.S. Over half of institutional grants (2003-04) went to students without consideration of financial need $2 billion went to families with incomes in excess of $108,000 Earlier this year, Congress cut over $12 billion in student aid as part of the budget reconciliation bill, amounting to 32% of the reconciliation Even though student aid accounts for less than 1% of federal spending Almost 2/3 of U.S. students at 4-year colleges now borrow to pay for their education (in 1993 less than half did) Higher cost private loans increased from 10% of total borrowing to 18% in last 6 years (College Board)
SEMSEM Phoenix 2006 AACRAO SEM Conference © Gottheil, Smith In the U.S. Tax breaks have provided greater assistance to wealthier students Although total aid spending has increased over past few years, low-income students receiving smaller share of the pie States distributed a total of $7.9 billion in financial aid in 2004-05, 8% more than the prior year…but need-based aid dropped from 81% of the total aid (1999) to 73% In Florida, $61 million more was provided for the Bright Futures Scholarship program where students who achieve a 3.0 high school average & get at least 970 on SAT have 100% of their tuition covered at the state’s community colleges
SEMSEM Phoenix 2006 AACRAO SEM Conference © Gottheil, Smith In the U.S. Increasing public attention to accessibility for lower socio- economic groups 74% of students with top math scores in high school, who are in the top quintile of family income, go on to receive a bachelor’s degree Only 29% of students with top math scores coming from low-income families earn a bachelor’s degree Spellings Commission report calls for major expansion of need- based financial aid, especially the Pell Grant (to 70% of in-state tuition; now only 48%) Supported by 6 national educational organizations Would increase maximum award from $4,050 to $6,150 Would result in increased spending of $10 – 25 billion annually Oregon plans to increase need-based aid by 77% to $78 million from $44 million Most of the increase will benefit part-time students attending community colleges
SEMSEM Phoenix 2006 AACRAO SEM Conference © Gottheil, Smith Financial Aid Strategies
SEMSEM Phoenix 2006 AACRAO SEM Conference © Gottheil, Smith Awarding Philosophies Preferential packaging Increased aid to students enrolling in low-enrollment & high cost programs Gapping Strategically narrowing the unmet need gap Separates have & have not institutions…generally requires endowment cash Keeps students’ short-term financial worries under control Front-loading Renewable entrance awards with high GPA renewal requirements
SEMSEM Phoenix 2006 AACRAO SEM Conference © Gottheil, Smith Awarding Timetable U.S.: financial aid awards (containing combinations of scholarships, grants, work-study & loans) sent to students with offer of admission or shortly afterwards (March/April) Canada: scholarship awards distributed with admission offers (April) but need-based grants/loans awarded during summer & work-study in September Canadian federal government does needs assessment (same award no matter what university student attends) Aid varies in U.S. based on institutional student budgets
SEMSEM Phoenix 2006 AACRAO SEM Conference © Gottheil, Smith Tuition Discounting Use of institutionally funded grants to help defray college costs Standard practice at U.S. 4-year colleges since the late 1970’s Increasingly used in Canada, especially last 10 years Results in lowering the net price for eligible students Hoping to raise net revenue, institutions offer funding where it will attract the most students Used as a tool to strategically tailor enrollment -Geographic diversity, academic quality, representation of first generation students, or fill empty seats in low demand academic programs
SEMSEM Phoenix 2006 AACRAO SEM Conference © Gottheil, Smith Tuition Discounting Some institutions have improved their enrollment & financial situations & have become stronger Stops working when large number of institutions get in game & simply drive one another’s costs up by competing with one another Tuition discount rate: total grant aid awarded by an institution divided by the total gross revenue it receives from tuition/fees Currently 38.6% at independent institutions
SEMSEM Phoenix 2006 AACRAO SEM Conference © Gottheil, Smith Tuition Discounting Critique: restricts access for low-income students to grant aid & reduces college choice Trend toward awarding increasing amounts of aid to affluent students Recent moves to guarantee low-income students enough grant money to cover their expenses: Harvard University eliminated family contribution for students with family incomes under $40,000 University of Pennsylvania pays tuition & room/board for students with family incomes under $50,000 MIT will match Pell grants Columbia University will replace loans with grants for financially needy students Similar programs at Universities of North Carolina, Virginia, Michigan, Maryland & Nebraska, among others
SEMSEM Phoenix 2006 AACRAO SEM Conference © Gottheil, Smith Tuition Discounting Potential to negatively impact institution if continue to lose net tuition revenue to discounting Institutions with greatest increases in discount rates raised their spending on grants by an average of $4,475 per FTE student, but their tuition & fee revenue grew by $3,069 per student Institutions that pay for discounting by shifting funds from instructional & student services may impede efforts to improve student retention Tuition discounting does not always increase student quality (fewer than 2 in 10 colleges increased their SAT verbal scores by 11 points or more) Price sensitivity is complex & can’t be explained solely by parental education & incomes…other factors include students’ perceptions, expectations & preferences
SEMSEM Phoenix 2006 AACRAO SEM Conference © Gottheil, Smith Financial Aid Leveraging Mostly private institutions A more “scientific” approach to tuition discounting Applies a matrix principle Ability to pay (no need, low need, moderate need, high need) on one axis Willingness to pay (academic indicators, geographic proximity, ethnicity, or any other variable where reliable & valid yield rate differences exist) on the other axis Premise: Yield rates can be influenced by the aid offered in each cell of the matrix Warning: Different awards for similar quality sometimes produces a few phone calls to the president
SEMSEM Phoenix 2006 AACRAO SEM Conference © Gottheil, Smith Leveraging…an example Student Quality Level No NeedLow NeedModerate Need High Need Low SAT/ACT No aid Moderate SAT/ACT No aidUniversity grant University grant plus Dean’s scholarship High SAT/ACT Merit scholarship Dean’s scholarship Presidential scholarship Very High SAT/ACT Merit scholarship Dean’s scholarship Presidential scholarship plus room waiver
SEMSEM Phoenix 2006 AACRAO SEM Conference © Gottheil, Smith Athletic Scholarships Plays a significant role at U.S. colleges (16% of institutional financial aid at public flagships; 18% at other public 4-years), most of which do not go to financially needy students Awarded by athletic departments/coaches Exist in Canada, but much more limited: British Columbia, Ontario, Atlantic Canada Usually limited to tuition/fees Nothing similar to U.S. for top-tier athletes
SEMSEM Phoenix 2006 AACRAO SEM Conference © Gottheil, Smith Merit Scholarships Can strengthen an institution’s brand/reputation This can then attract more full-tuition paying students whose money can be used for need-based aid Size of endowments much smaller in Canada Many institutions relying on operating budgets to fund merit scholarships Recent increases in Canada fueled by tuition reinvestment fund in Ontario & oil money in Alberta
SEMSEM Phoenix 2006 AACRAO SEM Conference © Gottheil, Smith Work-Study Programs Federal, state & provincial need-based programs Institutional need-based program Institutional non-need-based programs Co-op & work-placement programs -Students work (paid) & study in alternating semesters (2-4 work terms) Carolina “Covenant” -Federal Grant recipients work 10-12 hours per week SUNY College of Agriculture & Technology at Cobleskill -Student Ambassador scholarship recipients work 5-6 hours per week in Admissions Office as telecounselors & tour guides University of Windsor -“Outstanding Scholars” scholarship program: students work 10 hours per week for their academic department -Focused on increasing student-faculty engagement
SEMSEM Phoenix 2006 AACRAO SEM Conference © Gottheil, Smith Tuition Policies U.S. has in-state & out-of-state tuition Only province with out-of-province tuition is Quebec All provinces & states have international student tuition rates Tuition freezes in Manitoba & Quebec; previously in Ontario & British Columbia Tuition cut for Nova Scotia students attending in- province institutions; result of a transfer from the Federal Government
SEMSEM Phoenix 2006 AACRAO SEM Conference © Gottheil, Smith Tuition Policies Can be used as retention as well as recruitment tool Georgia state colleges guarantee tuition for 4 years to encourage students to graduate in 4 years Western Oregon University’s “Western Tuition Promise” Guarantee incoming students fixed tuition rate for 4 years -Students returning for 5 th year assessed tuition rate of class that entered in year immediately after them
SEMSEM Phoenix 2006 AACRAO SEM Conference © Gottheil, Smith Tuition Policies Tuition reduction – Muskingum College Reduced tuition by $4,000 Enhanced image (US News & World Report, Washington Post, New York Times, CBS News) Immediate admissions impact -First-year class goal: 335 -Enrolled: 394 -Transfer #s grew from 35 to 57
SEMSEM Phoenix 2006 AACRAO SEM Conference © Gottheil, Smith Tuition Payment Plans Institutional payment plans Minimum payment plus installments, often interest free (usually an enrollment fee) Deferral payment plan for students who have not finalized their financial aid by the tuition due date External payment plans Sallie Mae AMS Tuition Pay 10 month payment plan (enrollment fee, but no interest) Tuition Management Systems payment plan (enrollment fee, but no interest)
SEMSEM Phoenix 2006 AACRAO SEM Conference © Gottheil, Smith Tuition Tax Credits Canada: In 1995, worth $80/month, limited to tuition In 2000 raised to $400/month, can be used for extras - In Alberta & Ontario, indexed to inflation & now worth $445/month US: tax breaks relatively small share of student aid for low income students, but majority of aid for wealthier students Less than $32,000: $600 $32,000 - $59,000: $900 $60,000 - $91,999: $1,100 $92,000 +: $1,700
SEMSEM Phoenix 2006 AACRAO SEM Conference © Gottheil, Smith Income-contingent repayment loan repayment programs Borrowers repay loans as % of their incomes after graduation Used in Australia, New Zealand, UK & US In US, students have several options for repayment (standard repayment, extended repayment, graduated payment plan or income-contingent repayment) Repayment tied to income & calculated on basis of adjusted gross income, family size & total borrowed Payments cover at least monthly accrued interest Borrower must reapply each year Rejected in Canada Proposed in Ontario in 1996 to accompany a 20% funding cut to post- secondary education Widespread opposition from student groups & lenders Seen as a guise for increasing tuition & leading to greater indebtedness for low-income students
SEMSEM Phoenix 2006 AACRAO SEM Conference © Gottheil, Smith Debt Relief Concern over unmanageable & rapidly rising student debt loads Growing view that loans aren’t relieving burden for low-income groups, merely deferring it Debt seen as barrier/deterrent to recruitment & negative impact on retention Steers students away from careers such as teaching, social work, & other professions that require a degree but may not be high paying Critique that delays life decisions such as marriage, home purchases, etc. In U.S. more than 20% of borrowers drop out Nova Scotia has increased student debt relief bonuses Graduates must stay in the province with a full-time job for at least 50 weeks over a 3-year span Will result in a reduction of up to 51% of loan debt
SEMSEM Phoenix 2006 AACRAO SEM Conference © Gottheil, Smith Putting it All Together Establish your institutional enrollment goals Determine the role financial aid will play in supporting SEM at your institution Establish financial aid objectives Select the financial aid tools that will help you reach your financial aid objectives
SEMSEM Phoenix 2006 AACRAO SEM Conference © Gottheil, Smith What Strategies are Best: Pitfalls and Solutions
SEMSEM Phoenix 2006 AACRAO SEM Conference © Gottheil, Smith Solutions…or Questions? Is higher education a private gain or a public good? How much of the “bill” should students be reasonably expected to pay? How do we square pressure to increase institution’s brand/reputation/rankings with maintaining the social goal of remaining accessible to students from all socio- economic backgrounds? How do we keep our integrity while still making the class? Our response to these questions is critical!
SEMSEM Phoenix 2006 AACRAO SEM Conference © Gottheil, Smith Discussion, Comments & Questions
How Much Debt Is Too Much Debt?
Financial Aid / Student Loans. Student Loans a loan obtained to pay for education bills in which the payments are delayed until after graduation.
College Board TRENDS IN STUDENT AID Total Aid Awarded $134.8 Billion Graduate & Undergraduate 51% or 69 Billion in Loans (FFELP and Direct) –Undergrad.
Making the Case for Private Universities: Keep in Mind “Best Fit” Senior AVID September 9, 2015.
Financing a University Education CSU-UC Joint Counselor Conference September
Investing in Value Financing a College Education.
Slides by Pamela L. Hall Western Washington University 1 Financing a College Education Chapter 15.
Counseling Students To Minimize Borrowing Tracy N. Drechsler Manager, Higher Education Partnerships American Student Assistance.
Financial Aid: An Informational Tool for Middle School Students and Families.
Dan Weaver Assistant Commissioner July 26,
FINANCIAL AID 101 MSUSA OCTOBER 27, 2007 Chris Halling MnSCU Office of the Chancellor System Director for Student Financial Aid.
Presented by: Beth Howard Financial Assistance Meredith College.
Debunking the Myths of Financial Aid Information for students and parents.
Financing a University Education CSU-UC Joint Counselor Conference September DRAFT.
Financial Assistance Overview Presented by Joanne Graziano Executive Director for Enrollment Services LIU Post.
1 October 16 th, Topics: Completing the FAFSA Eligibility Common Mistakes when completing the FAFSA Different types of Federal Aid Scholarships.
Welcome to Financial Aid Night An overview of financial aid and the application process. Presented by the Ascension Parish Career Coaches.
Strategic Enrolment Management: Core Concepts 1 SEM Summit April 24, 2008.
Your Financial Aid Journey Investing in Your Future 5 Steps to Prepare for College College Financing Options Financial Aid Terms.
WHAT IS FEDERAL STUDENT AID? Federal Student Aid, a part of the U.S. Department of Education, is the largest provider of student financial aid in the.
Help students pay for college Achieved by: - Evaluating family's ability to pay for educational costs - Distributing limited resources in a fair and equitable.
Financial Assistance Overview Presented by Joanne Graziano Executive Director for Student Financial Services LIU Post
Financing Your Wellesley Education Spring Open Campus 2013 Wellesley College Student Financial Services.
Financial Aid Discussion December 13, Discussion Topics Forms and Deadlines Net Price Calculator IRS Data Retrieval Expected Family Contribution.
Financing Higher Education IBM Objectives Students will: Define Higher Education Define Higher Education Discuss Higher Education as an Investment.
Using Financial Aid to Meet Enrollment Goals Pamela W. Fowler Executive Director, Office of Financial Aid University of Michigan NeASFAA Spring Conference.
MAPLA Conference – October 25, 2013 Assistant Dean Cari Haaland and Professor Jerry Organ University of St. Thomas School of Law (Minn.)
Changes to Grants November What is CFNC? CFNC is a free service of the state of North Carolina Pathways of North Carolina College Foundation,
HOW DO I PAY FOR COLLEGE? FUNDING SOURCES “When it comes to saving for college, many parents and families don’t know where to start—and when they do, they.
Tulane University Financial Aid Information
FINANCIAL AID Ms.Escoto. ancial_aid_in_the_bag.
Student Loans Information from
SHEEO Prof. Dev. Conference THECB August 13, 2004 Philadelphia 1 Affordability Strategies in the States Moderator: Laura King (Minnesota) Presenter: Deborah.
D1407: Enrollment Management: A Game of Trade-Offs, Compromises, and Occasional Victories Paul Hamborg, Enrollment Research Associates, TX Bambi Burgard,
Session 35 AWARDING AID Linda Coffey Jamie Malone.
The Rising Price of a College Education Sandy Baum Michael McPherson Skidmore College & The Spencer Foundation The College Board The College Board College.
Covenant Christian School Guidance Meeting FINANCIAL AID 101.
Presentation Outline Introductions Why are “price sensitivity” and “value” important? Strategic pricing & value enhancement framework From research.
Financial Aid for College SHPE Foundation. Sources of Aid Government Federal State Institutional Varies by schools Private SHPE Foundation.
The Role of Financial Aid in Enrolment Management A Canadian Perspective SEM Canada Conference Toronto, April 23-25, 2008 Peter Dueck, University of Manitoba.
Paul Calme Xavier University
Financial Aid Basics Ric Dwenger Student Services Coordinator January 21, 2016.
Sandy Baum Higher Education Policy Analyst Professor of Economics Emerita, Skidmore College AGB March 2010 Colleges and Students in Difficult Economic.
1 Celebrating 30 years of Excellence Planning, Saving & Paying for College College Financing MEFA’s Guide to Today’s Presenter : Joe Farragher, Ed.D.
Presented by Joanne Graziano Assistant Provost and Executive Director of Admissions and Recruitment Long Island University- C.W. Post.
Student Contribution to the Cost of Higher Education in the United States Multinational Higher Education Forum March 17, 2006 Paul Lingenfelter, President,
Warm Up I can estimate my tuition cost and understand student loans.
PICKING A COLLEGE….. AND PAYING FOR IT. WELCOME John Martin: University of Virginia Assistant Director Financial Aid.
EASFAA Puerto Rico May 18-21, 2014 Waves of Change, Oceans of Opportunity Cost Containment and Price Sensitivity: the Perfect Storm.
Financial Aid Overview Marion Meadows I Know I Can MorraLee Keller Ohio College Access Network
© 2017 SlidePlayer.com Inc. All rights reserved.