KINDS OF CLAIMS GENERAL DAMAGES SPECIAL DAMAGES PUNITIVE DAMAGES NOMINAL SPECIFIC PERFORMANCE INJUNCTIONS
GENERAL DAMAGES I Pecuniary – monetary compensation for losses that can be calculated based on how much money the plaintiff lost. Example: car accident victim that confines the victim to a wheelchair for life. You can sue for damages to replace the car and also loss of future earnings. Q: How would age play a factor in complicating this matter?
GENERAL DAMAGES II Non-pecuniary – terrible personal loss which does not involve an actual loss of money and is difficult to quantify. Example: pain and suffering, loss of a loved one, mental anguish, aggravated damages (humiliation or distress) CAN A PRICE BE PUT ON THESE? Judges will usually make the monetary compensation based on rule of precedent. However, there is a maximum of $280 000 (recently increased from $100 000 due to inflation) WHAT DO YOU THINK?
SPECIAL DAMAGES -compensation for out of pocket expenses Example: medication, therapy, ambulance services, medical expenses, lost income (fixed period of time), car repairs
PUNITIVE DAMAGES – punish the defendant for reprehensible /malicious conduct Example: false imprisonment or arrest, assault, battery, libel and slander
NOMINAL -minimal compensation to acknowledge a moral victory Example: someone was using your land and you wanted them to stay off, you may be awarded $1 for you suffered no loss but merely wanted to assert your rights
SPECIFIC PERFORMANCE -court order compelling someone to fulfill the terms of a contract Example: buy a puppy from a breeder but the breeder changes her mind and gives you your deposit back. You don’t want the deposit, you want the puppy!
INJUNCTIONS a court order requiring someone to do or not do something Mandatory injunction – to do Prohibitory injunction – forbid to do *These may be permanent or temporary Example: apply dangerous chemicals, copyright trademarks, force striking workers to return to work
ENFORCING A JUDGEMENT You are on your own. The court doesn’t cut a cheque. But….if the defendant doesn’t pay you can take the following steps:
ENFORCING A JUDGEMENT Examination of a Judgment Debtor – being questioned under oath to find out about the debtor’s assets Garnishment – courts can order a % of wages, bank accounts be deducted to pay to plaintiff Execution or Seizure – sheriff seizes assets of debtor and sells them
Alternative Sources of Compensation I Motor Vehicle Liability Insurance – money from the insurer of the defendant’s vehicle (only in motor vehicle accidents) Problem: not everyone has liability insurance II No Fault Insurance – provides immediate funds without evidence of fault III Worker’s Compensation – provincial Workers Compensation Fund IV Criminal Injuries Compensation – criminal injuries compensation boards have been created to compensate innocent victims when the assailant doesn’t have any assets or insurance.
How does the Trial Work? In a trial by jury the judge instructs the jury on the law applicable to the facts of the case. The jury must consider this as well as other considerations: Who was at fault? Is that person totally at fault? (%) How should damages be determined? How much should they be?
Class action suit – a lawsuit initiated by a group of people over a complaint common to all. Examples? Page 369-370 Google Class Action Google Class Action
Benefits Avoid the necessity for many similar lawsuits Similar claims are treated similarly Eliminated barriers like economic barriers that prevent people from pursuing legal action