We think you have liked this presentation. If you wish to download it, please recommend it to your friends in any social system. Share buttons are a little bit lower. Thank you!
Presentation is loading. Please wait.
Published byAlex Sherrod
Modified over 2 years ago
© 2012 - Albers and Albers, All Rights Reserved1 CUSTOMER RULES & REGULATIONS: KEEPING UP WITH THE LAW Rural Community Conference August 15, 2012
© 2012 - Albers and Albers, All Rights Reserved2 Presented by the Law Firm of Prepared by: John B. Albers Eric J. Luckage Anita T. Doran ALBERS & ALBERS 88 North Fifth Street Columbus, Ohio 43215 (614) 464-4414 email@example.com firstname.lastname@example.org anita.doran@Alberslaw.com WWW.ALBERSLAW.COM
© 2012 - Albers and Albers, All Rights Reserved3 The information contained in this presentation should not be considered legal advice. Please consult your legal counsel to ensure compliance with the law.
© 2012 - Albers and Albers, All Rights Reserved4 1. SERVICE DISCONNECTION PROCEDURES, DUE PROCESS RIGHTS & RELATED ISSUES Everybody has to pay their bills – even public water and sewer providers! If no payment, provider has no choice but to terminate those services. However, customers are entitled to certain due process protections prior to termination of their water and sewer services.
© 2012 - Albers and Albers, All Rights Reserved5 DUE PROCESS REQUIREMENTS UNDER FEDERAL LAW Memphis Light, Gas & Water Division v. Craft, 436 U.S. 1 (U.S., 1978) Supreme Court ruled that customers who have an entitlement to continued utility service as a result of state or local law, or by contract, are entitled to certain due process rights prior to the termination of their utility services.
© 2012 - Albers and Albers, All Rights Reserved6 DUE PROCESS REQUIREMENTS UNDER OHIO LAW Midkiff. v. Athens County Regional Water District, 409 F.3d 758 (6th Cir., 2005). For Regional Districts, there is no state law which entitles customers to continued utility service under Chapter 6119. Therefore, the Court declined to extend the Craft ruling to Chapter 6119 Districts unless there is a contractual agreement between the District and Customer. - Same for Counties and Municipalities? - What constitutes a contractual agreement with a customer? A permit? - What about tenants v. landlords? Notice to both?
© 2012 - Albers and Albers, All Rights Reserved7 DUE PROCESS NOTICE TO A LANDLORD, EXCEPTION Fierro v. Greater Cincinnati Water Works, 2010-Ohio-4314 (1st Dist., 2010) Property owner alleged a due process violation based on insufficient notice of her tenant’s delinquent charges. Even with $40,000 in overdue charges, the Court here did not find a due process violation - City ordinance gives a property owner the opportunity to provide GCWW with a second address so that the owner can receive a duplicate bill. - Fierro failed to give GCWW an alternate address. Court ruled that a property owner bears some burden to monitor a tenant's activity, especially when the law makes the owner liable for the tenant's actions.
© 2012 - Albers and Albers, All Rights Reserved8 SUMMARY OF DUE PROCESS REQUIREMENTS PRIOR TO TERMINATION: Written notice. Notices must clearly and plainly - Inform customer of opportunity to object to termination - Identify the person(s) who will handle the complaint with their contact information Provide opportunity to request a hearing in advance of the termination date. Employee or official responding to the customer must have authority to review the facts and take corrective action if needed.
© 2012 - Albers and Albers, All Rights Reserved9 DUE PROCESS = PROTECTION FOR THE PROVIDER: Avoids any later claim of lack of due process Opportunity to correct any errors Opportunity to hear other potentially relevant circumstances. Bottom line: All governmental providers of utility services should adopt clear policies to insure that due process is provided prior to termination of services.
© 2012 - Albers and Albers, All Rights Reserved10 ADDITIONAL PROCEDURAL CONSIDERATIONS: 1. Who will preside at disconnection hearing?. 2. Who should hold the hearing (Manager, Board, Attorneys)? 3. Comply with public records requirements, but quasi-judicial hearing is not a public meeting and deliberations can held be in closed meeting. 4. Adhere to hearing formalities to avoid a new trial later under R.C. 2506.03. 5. Whether to establish a reconnection fee, and, if so, on what basis? 6. Special considerations for sewer disconnections only (where no water services are provided).
© 2012 - Albers and Albers, All Rights Reserved11 2. DEPOSITS, FINES AND PENALTIES Service Deposits Consider whether to require from new Customers, and/or Customers with delinquency history. Think about how much of a deposit the Board would require. Other utility providers often use a 2 or 3 month's worth of average service fees as the deposit amount.
© 2012 - Albers and Albers, All Rights Reserved12 ISSUES PRESENTED BY CUSTOMER’S BANKRUPTCY Federal Bankruptcy Code provides that a public utility cannot alter, refuse, or discontinue service because of a bankruptcy filing or because of an unpaid pre-bankruptcy petition utility bill. Avoid violating a customer’s bankruptcy protection by separating pre-petition charges from charges for service after the filing. Penalties imposed for violation of the automatic stay! Utility service provider should take steps to avoid any collection attempts of pre-petition charges.
© 2012 - Albers and Albers, All Rights Reserved13 BANKRUPTCY CODE PROTECTION FOR UTILITY PROVIDER Utility may require "adequate assurance of payment.“ -Typically, cash deposit. No set formula for what is considered “adequate assurance” but a utility may require a deposit from “debtor customers”. - Standard is generally what type of assurance is needed to protect a utility from an unreasonable risk of future loss. Separate “pre-petition” service charges from those incurred after filing.
© 2012 - Albers and Albers, All Rights Reserved14 3.INTEREST RATES/ PENALTIES/ LATE FEES AND FINES When does an interest rate or other charge imposed as part of a late fee become a illegal penalty? Recent case challenging a Regional District’s late fees as excessive Late fee based on 10% interest on total account balance (current and delinquent amounts). District won the case on procedural matters but case raised the issues: - How interest is calculated? - When does it become “clearly excessive” and “unrelated to the cost of providing service”? What are limits? - What method is likely to withstand a legal challenge? Consider whether to institute escalating late fees!
© 2012 - Albers and Albers, All Rights Reserved15 4.ISSUES TO WORK THROUGH WITH COUNTY AUDITORS CERTIFICATION OF DELINQUENCIES County Auditor can only change the tax duplicate one time per year No limit on how many times Auditor can accept the certification of delinquent water and sewer bills. - Important distinction! Certification of the delinquent amount that creates the lien on the property versus the actual placement on the tax duplicate. Develop a system with the Auditor. - Arrange to certify delinquent balances on some periodic basis – ie, quarterly.
© 2012 - Albers and Albers, All Rights Reserved16 OTHER COUNTY AUDITOR ISSUES Special assessments are also sometimes confused with certifications of delinquent water and sewer bills. - Educate the County Auditor’s office. County Auditor may fail to provide a “settlement report” showing the name and amounts included in the auditor’s payment. - Insist on this report so that accurate billing information can be maintained.
© 2012 - Albers and Albers, All Rights Reserved17 5. HARDSHIP POLICY Not a change in the law, but recognition of changed economic times. Several clients have requested assistance in drafting a Hardship Policy to assist in determining how to address delinquent customer who is facing difficult life problems. Consider utility provider’s and customers economic circumstances. One option is to make no allowance for reduction of amounts due. Another option is for the Board to make reductions in certain “extreme hardship” situations.
© 2012 - Albers and Albers, All Rights Reserved18 Hardship Policy Guidelines Define what is a “hardship” - Example: loss of employment, death of spouse, serious illness or any other unusual circumstance that the District deems as a hardship. Provide flexibility to reduce amounts owed. -The Board can decide to forgive certain charges (ie., late fees), and not others, set a payment plan, or allow requests for the forgiveness of any charges. - Stress that any action is discretionary. Set limit for submission of hardship request. Have written policy for Auditor.
© 2012 - Albers and Albers, All Rights Reserved19 6.REFUNDS and UNCLAIMED FUNDS Recently, issue raised as to whether moneys held in an inactive or closed account needed to be reported to the State as “unclaimed funds.” - For our client, a regional water & sewer district, we determined that it did not have to submit an Unclaimed Funds Report.
© 2012 - Albers and Albers, All Rights Reserved20 7. PRIVACY RIGHTS - COMPLYING WITH “RED FLAGS RULE” “Red Flags Rule” was passed by the Federal Trade Commission based on the Fair and Accurate Credit Transaction Act of 2003 (FACTA) and finally became effective at the end of 2010. The Red Flags Rule requires many entities, including utility service providers, to implement a written Identity Theft Prevention Program designed to detect the warning signs of identity theft in their day-to-day operations. - Applies to "financial institutions" and "creditors" that hold consumer accounts designed to permit multiple payments or transactions -- or any other account for which there reasonably foreseeable risk of identity theft. Idea is that businesses will be better equipped to spot suspicious patterns that may arise -- and take steps to prevent a red flag from escalating into a costly episode of identity theft.
© 2012 - Albers and Albers, All Rights Reserved21 Identity Theft Prevention Program Guidance Program must be designed to detect, prevent, and mitigate identity theft in connection with the opening of a covered account or any existing covered account. Program must contain ‘‘reasonable policies and procedures’’ to: - Identify relevant Red Flags for covered accounts and incorporate into Program; - Detect Red Flags that have been incorporated into the Program; - Respond appropriately to any Red Flags that are detected to prevent and mitigate identity theft; and, - Update Program periodically. See http://www.ftc.gov/bcp/edu/microsites/redflagsrule/index.shtml for more information.
© 2012 - Albers and Albers, All Rights Reserved22 7. PRIVACY RIGHTS (CONT’D) OHIO PRIVACY PROTECTION R.C. Chapter 1347 (Personal Information Systems Act or “PISA”) governs the maintenance of personal information systems by state and local agencies. PISA applies to those items to which the Ohio Public Records Act does not apply; that is, records that have been determined to be non-public, and items and information that are not “records” as defined by the Ohio Public Records Act. For most utility service providers, the records it maintains only include public information or are public records, such as the name of the property owner and address. Therefore, PISA may not apply. NOTE: PISA does apply to personnel files.
© 2012 - Albers and Albers, All Rights Reserved23 8. OTHER RECENT CASES State ex rel. Voleck et al. v. Village of Powhatan Point, 2010-Ohio-5679 (Ohio, 2010). Supreme Court denied a writ of mandamus to compel the Village to provide “visually clean and chemically pure water” to village residents. The Village proved that it met the State EPA requirements for safe, potable water, but these residents wanted to hold it to a higher standard. The Court declined to issue a writ, in part, because mandamus case requires that the Court order the government to do something it is statutorily required to do, and here, the residents could not establish that there is requirement to provide “visually clean and chemically pure water.”
© 2012 - Albers and Albers, All Rights Reserved24 9.GROUNDWATER PROTECTION FOR YOUR CUSTOMER’S WATER IN OHIO’S NEW FRACKING ENVIRONMENT In 2010, Ohio voters approved an amendment to the Ohio Constitution (Art. 1, Section 19b) which created a constitutional right of property owner’s to “reasonable use of groundwater underlying their land or of the water in a lake or watercourse located on or flowing through or along their riparian land”. This was essentially the ruling in McNamara v. Rittman, 107 Ohio St.3d 243, 246-247; 838 N.E. 2d 640, 646 (2005) which first recognized a property owner’s groundwater use rights.
© 2012 - Albers and Albers, All Rights Reserved25 9. GROUNDWATER PROTECTION (CONT’D) Current required setbacks for oil and gas wells is 300 feet from private or public water walls and 50 feet from streams and lakes. - OAC also prohibits “the movement of fluid containing any contaminant into an underground source of drinking water, if the presence of that contaminant may cause an exceedance in the underground source of drinking water of any primary drinking water standard established under Chapter 3745-81 of the Administrative Code or may otherwise adversely affect the health of persons.” OAC 3745-34-07. RC 1509.17 of the Ohio Revised Code, all underground sources of drinking water must be isolated and protected from potential contamination when drilling oil, gas and brine wells in the state.
© 2012 - Albers and Albers, All Rights Reserved26 9. GROUNDWATER PROTECTION (CONT’D) S.B. 315 - New Regulation for Oil & Gas Drilling including "Fracking” Passed in June, 2012; effective September 10, 2012. New Oil & Gas Permit Requirements - Legislation requires more information to be submitted with drilling permit applications including: - Road Use Maintenance Agreements (“RUMAs”) - Road Use Maintenance Affidavit (Good Faith Effort) - Identification of the proposed source of surface or ground water - Water well sampling in the neighboring area prior to drilling expands testing requirements to 1,500 feet and applies this standard to both urban and rural areas.
© 2012 - Albers and Albers, All Rights Reserved27 9. GROUNDWATER PROTECTION (CONT’D) S.B. 315 Disclosure of Chemical Used in Drilling- Upon well completion, the well owner must supply information regarding the amount of products, fluids, and substances used to facilitate drilling or stimulate the well. However, broad trade secret provision that exempts certain chemicals or materials. Despite these new public and private water protections from SB 315, conflicts are foreseeable in the use of groundwater and mineral rights – no cases yet, but they are sure to come!
© 2012 - Albers and Albers, All Rights Reserved28 QUESTIONS? THINK OF ONE LATER? CONTACT US: John B. Albers Eric J. Luckage Anita T. Doran ALBERS & ALBERS 88 North Fifth Street Columbus, Ohio 43215 (614) 464-4414 WWW.ALBERSLAW.COM
© 2012 - Albers and Albers, All Rights Reserved29 ADDITIONAL MATERIALS PROVIDED Albers Speech Handout, including: Delinquent Water/Sewer Bill Collection Options Water Service Termination Checklist
Red Flags Rule & Municipal Utilities
Understanding the Fair and Accurate Credit Transaction Act, the “Red Flag” Regulations, and their impact on Health Care Providers Raising a “Red Flag”
IRSDA Conference What Do the Amendments to Indiana Code Section Mean to You? Kristina Kern Wheeler, General Counsel Ja-Deen L. Johnson, Consumer.
Tiffany George Attorney, Division of Privacy & Identity Protection Federal Trade Commission COMPLYING WITH THE RED FLAGS RULE & ADDRESS DISCREPANCY RULE.
Discontinuance of Utility Service and Wastewater Lien Process Cities and Towns June School 2013.
Improving Compliance with ISAs Presenters: Al Johnson & Pat Hayle.
WATER QUALITY TOPICS ENFORCEMENT – ARE FINES BECOMING A WAY OF LIFE AT THE DEQ By:Donald D. Maisch Supervising Attorney, Water Quality Division Office.
The Virginia Freedom of Information Act (FOIA). FOIA Topics of Discussion Public Meetings Closed Meetings Meeting Notices & Agendas Electronic Communication.
Health Insurance in New York Laura Dillon, Principal Examiner New York Insurance Department Consumer Services Bureau One Commerce Plaza Albany NY
Unit 9 Seminar Business Organizations. Things to do this unit: UNIT 9 – Read Chapter 13 and 14 – Respond to the Discussion Board – Attend the Weekly Seminar.
COMPLYING WITH HIPAA PRIVACY RULES Presented by: Larry Grudzien, Attorney at Law.
SUPPLEMENTAL ENVIRONMENTAL PROJECTS. KEY CHARACTERISTICS OF A SEP Projects must improve, protect or reduce risks to public health or environment. Projects.
Fiscal Monitoring and Oversight Tecumseh Local School District January 8, 2013 Roger Hardin, Assistant Director Finance Program Services (614)
1 Identity Theft Prevention and the Red Flag Rules.
IDENTITY THEFT & THE RED FLAGS RULE Presented by Brady Keith, Assistant General Counsel CREDIT MANAGEMENT SERVICES, INC.
New Identity Theft Rules Rodney J. Petersen, J.D. Government Relations Officer Security Task Force Coordinator EDUCAUSE.
FleetBoston Financial HIPAA Privacy Compliance Agnes Bundy Scanlan Managing Director and Chief Privacy Officer FleetBoston Financial.
HIPAA PRIVACY AND SECURITY AWARENESS.
HIPAA Privacy Rule Positive Changes Affecting Hospitals’ Implementation of the Rule.
By: Clare Dewan and Associates This presentation is subject to copyright and is not to be reproduced except by express permission.
Section 3 Steed Robinson – Office of Community Development 9/4/2014.
Presentation to the Oversight Board Santa Clara County Auditor-Controller 1.
Who’s Who Despositary Bank – the first to take check. Payor Bank – the bank that pays the issuer’s check. Intermediary Bank – any bank that handles a.
Red-Flag Identity Theft Requirements February 19th 2009 Cathy Casagrande, Privacy Officer.
Legal Document Preparation Class 9Slide 1 Basic Debtor-Creditor Terminology Debtor: person who owes the money Creditor: person to whom the money is owed.
Legal Responsibilities for Board Members of Nonprofit Organizations Or…all you need to know to stay out of trouble. Presented: July 2007 Prepared by: Elsbeth.
BACK TO BASICS Indiana Prosecuting Attorneys Council May 2013.
Chapter 27 Your Credit and the Law pp Learning Targets 1.Explain 1.Explain how government protects credit rights. 2. Name 2. Name federal laws.
CONSUMER CREDIT LEGISLATION Carl Johnson Financial Literacy Jenks High School.
Chapter 27 Your Credit and the Law pp Learning Objectives 1.Explain 1.Explain how government protects credit rights. 2. Name 2. Name federal.
NC CFW Expenditure reports How to complete and submit an expenditure report Expenditure reports How to complete and submit an expenditure report.
Are You Ready? Identity fraud and identity management are quickly becoming critical operational concerns for the financial industry. The Red Flags Guidelines.
Red Flags Rule BAS Forum August 18, What is the Red Flags Rule? Requires implementation of a written Identity Theft Prevention Program designed.
Association Management, Inc.. AMI College of Community Association Management Course 103 Rules Enforcement.
Ratepayer and Customer Rights Energy Regulatory Partnership Program Abuja, Nigeria July 14-18, 2008 Presented by Robert W. Kehres.
Sharing Low-Income Customer Information Water & Energy Utilities LIOB Meeting - January 2009 Seaneen M Wilson Division of Water & Audits.
Massachusetts Department of Elementary & Secondary Education
August’s Top Performers Most new Listings; Most Units Sold; Top producer; Agent name Renee Jean.
Security of Payment workshop Andrew Robertson Important Disclaimer: The material contained in this publication is comment of a general nature only and.
Presented By: D. Kevin Davis, Partner. Why are employment agreements useful for an employer? - incorporating personnel policies into the employment relationship.
Administrative Foreclosure A RECOMMENDED MECHANISM TO ADDRESS BLIGHTED AND ABANDONED PROPERTIES WITHIN THE CITY OF HALLANDALE BEACH 1.
Medicare Advantage Plans. What are Medicare Advantage Plans? 1. Required by law to provide their members the same or greater coverage as regular Medicare.
Unit 9: Legal Issues. Legal Issues Video Time length 11:13.
GOVERNMENT LAWYER’S REPRESENTATION OF GOVERNMENT EMPLOYEES Craig E. Leen City Attorney City of Coral Gables *** With special thanks to Yaneris Figueroa,
S.B Municipality Fees. S.B – Environment Budget Reconciliation Bill Enacted during the 2011 regular legislative session and becomes effective.
Idaho Conjunctive Management Rules & Ground Water District Formation
THE FEDERAL RESERVE BOARD'S OVERDRAFT RULES “Outlook Live” Audio Conference Dana Miller, Attorney David Stein, Managing Counsel Division of Consumer and.
10 MYTHS About the 403(b) Regulations Gregg Libutti September 25, 2008 SAVING : INVESTING : PLANNING.
© 2017 SlidePlayer.com Inc. All rights reserved.