Presentation on theme: "The Focus Project Soumen Chakrabarti (IIT Bombay) David Gibson (Berkeley) Piotr Indyk (Stanford) Kevin McCurley (IBM Almaden) Martin van Den Berg (Xerox)"— Presentation transcript:
The Focus Project Soumen Chakrabarti (IIT Bombay) David Gibson (Berkeley) Piotr Indyk (Stanford) Kevin McCurley (IBM Almaden) Martin van Den Berg (Xerox) Byron Dom (IBM Almaden)
Focused Crawling: A New Approach to Topic-Specific Web Resource Discovery Soumen Chakrabarti (IIT Bombay) Martin van Den Berg (Xerox) Byron Dom (IBM Almaden)
Soumen Chakrabarti IIT Bombay 1999 3 Quote 1 Portals and search pages are changing rapidly, in part because their biggest strength — massive size and reach — can also be a drawback. The most interesting trend is the growing sense of natural limits, a recognition that covering a single galaxy can be more practical — and useful — than trying to cover the entire universe. Dan Gillmore, San Jose Mercury News
Soumen Chakrabarti IIT Bombay 1999 4 Scenario Disk drive research group wants to track magnetic surface technologies Compiler research group wants to trawl the web for graduate student resumés ____ wants to enhance his/her collection of bookmarks about ____ with prominent and relevant links Virtual libraries like Yahoo!, the Open Directory Project and the Mining Co.Yahoo!Open Directory ProjectMining Co.
Soumen Chakrabarti IIT Bombay 1999 5 Structured web queries How many links were found from an environment protection agency site to a site about oil and natural gas in the last year? Apart from cycling, what is the most common topic cited by pages on cycling? Find Web research pages which are widely cited by Hawaiian vacation pages Answer: “first-aid”
Soumen Chakrabarti IIT Bombay 1999 6 Quote 2 As people become more savvy users of the Net, they want things which are better focused on meeting their specific needs. We're going to see a whole lot more of this, and it's going to potentially erode the user base of some of the big portals. Jim Hake Founder, Global Information Infrastructure http://www.gii-awards.com/ http://www.gii-awards.com/
Soumen Chakrabarti IIT Bombay 1999 7 Goals Spontaneous, decentralized formation of topical communities Automatic construction of a “focused portal” containing resources that are Relevant to the user’s focus of interest Of high influence and quality Collectively comprehensive Discovery that combine structure and content
Soumen Chakrabarti IIT Bombay 1999 8 Taxonomy with some ‘chosen’ topics Each page has a relevance score w.r.t. chosen topics Mendelzon and Milo’s web access cost model Goal is to ‘expand’ start set to maximize average relevance Model All ScienceSports Cycling Hiking Physics Zoology
Soumen Chakrabarti IIT Bombay 1999 9 Properties to be exploited A page with high relevance tends to link to at least some other relevant pages (radius- one rule) Given that a page u links to relevant page(s), chances are increased that u points to other relevant pages (radius-two rule) ?
Soumen Chakrabarti IIT Bombay 1999 10 Syntactic “query-by-example” If part of the answer is known, trivial search techniques may do quite well E.g., “European airlines” +swissair +iberia +klm E.g., “Car makers” Which pages link to www.honda.com and www.toyota.com ?
Soumen Chakrabarti IIT Bombay 1999 11
Soumen Chakrabarti IIT Bombay 1999 12 The backlink architecture S1 C http://S1/P1 http://S2/P2 S2 GET /P2 HTTP/1.0 Referer: http://S1/P1 Local Backlink Database C’ Who points to S2/P2? www.cs.berkeley.edu/~soumen/doc/www99back/userstudy
Soumen Chakrabarti IIT Bombay 1999 13 Backlink rationale Centralized backlink service does not scale Limited additional storage per server Turn hyperlinks into undirected edges A series of forward and backward ‘clicks’ can quickly build a topical community Can be used to boot-strap the focused crawler
Soumen Chakrabarti IIT Bombay 1999 14 Backlink example 1
Soumen Chakrabarti IIT Bombay 1999 15 Backlink example 2
Soumen Chakrabarti IIT Bombay 1999 16 Backlink example 3
Soumen Chakrabarti IIT Bombay 1999 17 Backlink example 4
Soumen Chakrabarti IIT Bombay 1999 18 Estimating popularity Extensive research on social network theory Wasserman and Faust Hyperlink based Large in-degree indicates popularity/authority Not all votes are worth the same Several similar ideas and refinements Googol (Page and Brin) and HITS (Kleinberg) Resource compilation (Chakrabarti et al) Topic distillation (Bharat and Henzinger)
Soumen Chakrabarti IIT Bombay 1999 19 Topic distillation overview Given web graph and query Search engine selects sub-graph Expansion, pruning and edge weights Nodes iteratively transfer authority to cited neighbors Search Engine Query The Web Selected subgraph
Soumen Chakrabarti IIT Bombay 1999 20 Preliminary distillation-based approach Design a keyword query to represent topics of focus Using a large web crawl, run topic distillation on the query Refine query by inspecting result and trial- and-error
Soumen Chakrabarti IIT Bombay 1999 21 Problems with preliminary approach Unreliability of keyword match Engines differ significantly on a given query due to small overlap [Bharat and Bröder] Narrow, arbitrary view of relevant subgraph Topic model does not improve over time Dependence on large web crawl and index (lack of “output sensitivity”) Difficulty of query construction
Soumen Chakrabarti IIT Bombay 1999 22 Output sensitivity Say the goal is to find a comprehensive collection of recreational and competitive bicycling sites and pages Ideally effort should scale with size of the result Time spent crawling and indexing sites unrelated to the topic is wasted Likewise, time that does not improve comprehensiveness is wasted
Soumen Chakrabarti IIT Bombay 1999 24 Query complexity Complex queries needed for distillation Typical Alta Vista queries are much simpler (Silverstein, Henzinger, Marais and Moricz) Forcing a hub or authority helps 86% of the time
Soumen Chakrabarti IIT Bombay 1999 25 Proposed solution Resource discovery system that can be customized to crawl for any topic by giving examples Hypertext mining algorithms learn to recognize pages and sites about the given topic, and a measure of their centrality Crawler has guidance hooks controlled by these two scores
Soumen Chakrabarti IIT Bombay 1999 27 Relevance All Bus&EconRecreation CompaniesCycling Bike Shops Mt.Biking Clubs Arts... Path nodes Good nodes Subsumed nodes
Soumen Chakrabarti IIT Bombay 1999 28 Classification How relevant is a document w.r.t. a class? Supervised learning, filtering, classification, categorization Many types of classifiers Bayesian, nearest neighbor, rule-based Hypertext Both text and links are class-dependent clues How to model link-based features?
Soumen Chakrabarti IIT Bombay 1999 29 The “bag-of-words” document model Decide topic; topic c is picked with prior probability (c); c (c) = 1 Each c has parameters (c,t) for terms t Coin with face probabilities t (c,t) = 1 Fix document length and keep tossing coin Given c, probability of document is
Soumen Chakrabarti IIT Bombay 1999 30 Exploiting link features c=class, t=text, N=neighbors Text-only model: Pr[t|c] Using neighbors’ text to judge my topic: Pr[t, t(N) | c] Better model: Pr[t, c(N) | c] Non-linear relaxation ?
Soumen Chakrabarti IIT Bombay 1999 31 Improvement using link features 9600 patents from 12 classes marked by USPTO Patents have text and cite other patents Expand test patent to include neighborhood ‘Forget’ fraction of neighbors’ classes
Soumen Chakrabarti IIT Bombay 1999 33 Monitoring the crawler Time Relevance One URL Moving Average
Soumen Chakrabarti IIT Bombay 1999 34 Measures of success Harvest rate What fraction of crawled pages are relevant Robustness across seed sets Separate crawls with random disjoint samples Measure overlap in URLs and servers crawled Measure agreement in best-rated resources Evidence of non-trivial work #Links from start set to the best resources
Soumen Chakrabarti IIT Bombay 1999 37 Top resources after one hour Recreational and competitive cycling http://www.truesport.com/Bike/links.htm http://www.truesport.com/Bike/links.htm http://reality.sgi.com/billh_hampton/jrvs/links.html http://reality.sgi.com/billh_hampton/jrvs/links.html http://www.acs.ucalgary.ca/~bentley/mark_links.html http://www.acs.ucalgary.ca/~bentley/mark_links.html HIV/AIDS research and treatment http://www.stopaids.org/Otherorgs.html http://www.stopaids.org/Otherorgs.html http://www-hsl.mcmaster.ca/tomflem/aids.html http://www-hsl.mcmaster.ca/tomflem/aids.html http://www.iohk.com/UserPages/mlau/aidsinfo.html http://www.iohk.com/UserPages/mlau/aidsinfo.html Purer and better than root set
Soumen Chakrabarti IIT Bombay 1999 38
Soumen Chakrabarti IIT Bombay 1999 39
Soumen Chakrabarti IIT Bombay 1999 40 Robustness of resource discovery Sample disjoint sets of starting URL’s Two separate crawls Find best authorities Order by rank Find overlap in the top-rated resources
Soumen Chakrabarti IIT Bombay 1999 41 Distance to best resources Cycling: cooperativeMutual funds: competitive
Soumen Chakrabarti IIT Bombay 1999 42 Observations Random walk on the Web “rapidly mixes” topics Yet, there are large coherent paths and clusters Focused crawling gives topic distillation richer data to work on Combining content with link structure eliminates the need to tune link-based heuristics
Soumen Chakrabarti IIT Bombay 1999 43 Related work WebWatcher, HotList and ColdList Filtering as post-processing, not acquisition ReferralWeb Social network on the Web Ahoy!, Cora Hand-crafted to find home pages and papers WebCrawler, Fish, Shark, Fetuccino, agents Crawler guided by query keyword matches
Soumen Chakrabarti IIT Bombay 1999 44 Comparison with agents Agents usually look for keywords and hand-crafted patterns Cannot learn new vocabulary dynamically Do not use distance-2 centrality information Client-side assistant We use taxonomy with statistical topic models Models can evolve as crawl proceeds Combine relevance and centrality Broader scope: inter- community linkage analysis and querying
Soumen Chakrabarti IIT Bombay 1999 45 Conclusion New architecture for example-driven topic- specific web resource discovery No dependence on full web crawl and index Modest desktop hardware adequate Variable radius goal-directed crawling High harvest rate High quality resources found far from keyword query response nodes