Download presentation
Presentation is loading. Please wait.
Published byDustin Edge Modified over 3 years ago
1
EFFECTS OF CO-FIRING BIOMASS WITH COAL ON THE RETAIL PRICE OF ELECTRICITY David Bransby Professor, Energy Crops Auburn University bransdi@auburn.edu
2
BACKGROUND
3
Why energy crops? - High efficiency is the biggest problem in US Agriculture today. - Overproduction of corn, cotton, soybeans, wheat and livestock requires federal farm programs that cost 10 to 20 billion dollars every year! - Energy crops can help agriculture and reduce harmful emissions from coal.
4
Biofuels vs. Biopower ? Biofuels: - Need more research - Expensive, capital needed Biopower: - Limited research needed - Little capital needed
6
Coal and Power Production in Alabama 60%-70% of the electricity in Alabama is produced from burning coal. In 1990 Alabama produced more coal than it used. In 2002, 62% (about 18 million tons) of coal was imported from other states to produce electricity
7
Coal Production continued From 1990 to 1999 a total of 2,351 (36%) mining jobs were lost in Alabama At $25/ton, $450 million leaves the state each year to buy coal for production of electricity.
8
Coal Summary Advantages: - Cheap Disadvantages: - A large proportion imported - Emissions, including carbon dioxide, nitrogen oxides, sulfur dioxide, mercury, and radio-active compounds
9
Economic Development - State Level If: 10% of the coal were replaced with biomass and all that coal was imported, Then: $72 million would be kept from leaving the state each year, and there would be a new biomass market of $234 million per year.
10
Economic Development - Local Level If: The Alabama Power plant at Demopolis in the impoverished Black Belt region of the state co-fired 10% biomass with coal, Then: 316,000 tons of biomass and 63,000 acres would be needed, and a new market of $15.8 million annually would be created.
11
POFITABILITY ? Assume $50/ac fertilizer costs, $20/ton for custom harvesting and baling, and a price of $40/ton on the farm for biomass. Yield (tons/ac) Return over above costs ($/ac) 3 10.00 4 30.00 5 50.00 6 70.00 7 90.00 For no work!
17
The higher cost of biomass compared to coal appears to be a major disincentive. At $50/dry ton, biomass costs about $3.57/MMBtu, while coal usually costs $1.50 to $1.80/MMBtu. Why are utilities not co-firing on a continuous basis?
18
Possible approaches for mitigation of the higher cost of biomass 1)Subsidies such as a tax credit. 2)Pass the cost on to the consumer. 3)Market green energy at a premium. 4)Locate suitable host facilities.
19
Table 1. Economic projections for power produced from coal or biomass with a 1.8 cents/kWh tax credit or with green pricing. _______________________________________________________________________ Biomass/Tax credit Coal Biomass/Green Pricing ------------------------ cents/kWh ---------------------- Fuel cost 4.04 (+176%) 1.46 4.04 Prodn. & Distribution 3.00 3.00 3.00 Total cost 7.04 (+58%) 4.46 7.04 Retail Price 7.50 7.50 10.08 (+43%) Return before tax 0.46 3.04 3.04 Less 35% tax 0.16 1.06 1.06 Return after tax 0.30 1.98 1.98 Tax credit 1.80 0.00 0.00 Net return 2.10 (+6%) 1.98 1.98 _______________________________________________________________________
20
Table 2. Returns from co-firing 10% biomass with coal compared to coal alone. ________________________________________________________ 100% Coal 90% Coal/10% Biomass ----------------cents/kWh------------------- Fuel cost 1.461.72 Production & Distribution 3.003.00 Total cost 4.464.72 Retail price 7.507.76 (+3.5%) Return before tax 3.043.04 ________________________________________________________
21
CONCLUSIONS 1) If 10% biomass was co-fired with coal it would increase the retail price of electricity by only 3.5%. 2) If this was done over 10 years, the price increase would be only 0.35%/year, and would probably go unnoticed by consumers. 3) With all the other benefits, co-firing biomass with coal would not cost, it would pay, even without a tax credit!
Similar presentations
© 2018 SlidePlayer.com Inc.
All rights reserved.
Ppt on resources of nature Ppt on limitation act malaysia Ppt on content development pros Ppt on business cycle phases in order Ppt on event driven programming in c# Ppt on rbi reforms define Ppt on transportation in human beings what is the largest Ppt on 60 years of indian parliament house Ppt on real numbers for class 9th question Ppt on nitrogen cycle and nitrogen fixation formula