Presentation on theme: "Clinical Practice Guidelines"— Presentation transcript:
1Clinical Practice Guidelines Sudigdo Sastroasmoro Konsorsium Upaya Kesehartan Ditjen BUK Kemenkes RI
2Peningkatan Mutu Pelayanan Telah dilakukan sejak zaman prasejarahCenderung sektoral, tidak komprehensifKonsep di UK: Clinical governanceDiadopsi / dikembangkan di semua negara dengan pelbagai nama
3Clinical Governance"A framework through which NHS organizations are accountable for continuously improving the quality of their services and safeguarding high standards of care, by creating an environment in which excellence in clinical care will flourish."
5IntroductionImprovement of quality of care should be continuously planned, implemented, and evaluatedRapid science and technology development has tremendous effects on its implementationsEBM is a good paradigm (originally) at the level of individual professional caring individual patientFor certain diseases or problems, standardized patient care is mandatory
6“Hierarchy” in clinical medicine Researchers offer what we can do to solve problem in clinical medicineHealth technology assessment (HTA) assesses which of the offers can be implemented (which we can do)Clinical practice guidelines select one to implement in a particular hospital or clinic (what we should do)Practitioners implement what we should do (doing what we should do)Clinical audits assess if we have done what we should do (did we do what we should do)
8The EBM Paradigm Health care problem Formulate Recom- in answerable questionRecom-mendationCriticallyappraisethe evidenceSearch theevidence
9Taxonomy of health system standards (Ashton, 2002) Clinical practice guidelinesClinical pathwaysProtocolsProceduresAlgorithmsStanding ordersMust be:# Evidence-based# Periodicallyrevised
10The jungle of termsStandar pelayanan, standar pelayanan kedokteran, standar pelayanan kesehatan, standar prosedur operasional, prosedur operasional standar, standar profesi, standar fasilitas, standar pelayanan medis, pedoman pelayanan medis, panduan pelayanan medis, panduan praktik klinis, prosedur baku, etc etc.
11Juliet Capulet: What’s in a name? A rose by any other name would smell as sweetThe Merchant of Venice – W. Shakespeare
12Standardization of terms Taxonomy of Health System Standards (modification):National Guidelines / Pedoman Nasional Pelayanan Kedokteran (PNPK)Clinical Practice Guidelines /Panduan Praktik Klinis (PPK)Clinical pathwaysAlgorithmsProtocolsProceduresStanding orders.Please note thatthere is no “standard”term at the levelof healthcarefacilities
13Note: In the following slides: PNPK (Pedoman Nasional Pelayanan Kedokteran) refers to National Clinical Guidelines, while PPK (Panduan Praktik Klinis) refers to Clinical Guidelines at healthcare facility level
14Pedoman Nasional Pelayanan Kedokteran (PNPK) PNPK is a systematic statement, evidence-based, to help practitioners and patients to cope with certain clinical conditions. Synonyms: clinical guidelines, clinical practice guidelines, practice parameters.In the literature the term Clinical (Practice) Guidelines are used to national / global a as well as local settingIn Indonesia:Documents developed by experts and endorsed by the Government are called National Guidelines (PNPK),After adaptation to specific healthcare facility is called Clinical Practice Guidelines (PPK) and other local instruments, which are as a whole called as standard operating procedures (UUPK) .
15Who should develop PNPK? In theory everyone can do it: Minister, Dean, Director, professional organization, etc”US Model” – experts, without government endorsement”British Model” – experts, with government endorsementIndonesia - British Model
16When is PNPK needed? PNPK is needed in conditions with: Large number of subjects (high volume)Tends to have a high risk (high risk)Requires high resources, esp. cost (high cost)especially when there are large variations among the practicing professionals in the management of the same disease or problem (high variability).
17Characteristics of PNPK ValidReproducibleEffective and cost-effectiveRepresentative, frequently multidisciplinaryCan be applied in daily practiceFlexibleClearScheduled for revisionsCan be used as a parameter for clinical audits
18PNPK Development Process Selection of topic of interestMOH sends letter to Deans, Directors of Teaching Hospitals, professional organizations to submit the topicInitial selectionComplete proposalDetermine priorities
19PNPK Development Process Developing Expert PanelAcademicians, Professional organizationsIntroducing process:Purpose of PNPK developmentFormat of PNPKMethods, time-table, etcAppointments of Chair, Co-Chair, Secretary, etc
20PNPK Development Process Initial drafting, follow-up, and meetingsInitial draft is usually prepared by assistants (newly graduated doctors under the supervision of Chair)Further developed by means of sMonthly meetingsCompleted after 2-4 meetingsDirector General / MOH
21PNPK formatA standardized book of PNPK is available, subject for modification of color, fonts, etcLogo of MOH is displayed on the coverLogos of professional organizations involved are printed on the coverExperts directly involved in the process are written as contributors
22Content of PNPK (may be modified as needed) Executive SummaryBackgroundJustification why PNPK is neededMethodsSearch Strategy, keywords etcCriteria for Inclusion and ExclusionLevels of EvidenceGrades of RecommendationsResults and DiscussionConclusions / RecommendationsReferencesAppendices
24ACC/AHA 2008 Guidelines for the Management of Adults With Congenital Heart Disease: Executive Summary. 49 halaman, 202 rujukan.Americal College of Cardiology / American Heart Association (2002): Guideline update for the management of chronic stable angina. 136 halaman, 1053 rujukanMOH Malaysia. Clinical Practice Guidelines Management of Dengue Fever in Children, halaman, 33 rujukan.Malaysian Society of Neurosciences, Academy of Medicine Malaysia, Ministry of Health Malaysia. Clinical practice guidline. Management of stroke. 37 halaman, 150 rujukan.Indeks untuk pelbagai jenis CPG di Malaysia dapat diakses melaluiSingapore MOH Clinical Practice Guideline Management of atrial fibrillation. 70 halaman total, 83 rujukan.
34Clinical Practice Guidelines (PPK) PNPK must be translated into specific conditions of the local settings; the result is PPKPPK may similar or differ in different hospitalsPPK for DHF without shock maybe similar in type A, B, C, D hospitals or community health centersIn one Type A Hospital PPK for congenital heart disease includes diagnosis until surgery, but in other type A hospital only limited to diagnosisPPK for stroke in type B hospital who has neurosurgeon differs from those who does not have neurosurgeon.PPK is hospital specific.
35Objectives of PPKTo improve quality of care in certain clinical conditions and environmentTo reduce unnecessary procedures or interventionsTo provide best treatment with maximal benefits to patientsTo provide treatment option with minimal riskPatient management with appropriate cost
36PPK for other diseases or conditions For diseases or conditions which do not meet the PNPK criteria, or no PNPK is available, the medical staff should develop PPK referring to:Recent literature (primary reports, systematic review / metaanalysis, etc)Textbooks / Evidence-based textbooksCGL from other countriesGuidelines of professional organizations, certain directorates of MOH, etcMedical staff consencusPPK is developed under the coordination of Medical Staff Committee, and valid after Director’s approval
37Specific instruments to support PPK PPK may require specific instruments:Ischemic stroke: need multidisciplinary care with predictable clinical course: clinical pathwayChronic kidney disease requiring hemodialysis: protocol for hemodialysisComplex febrile convulsion subject for lumbar puncture: lumbar puncture procedureSimple febrile convulsion requiring rectal diazepam by nurse in the absence of physician: standing orders.
38Clinical Pathway (CP)CP = care pathway, care map, critical pathway, integrated care pathways, multidisciplinary pathways of care, pathways of care, collaborative care pathways.CP details what should be done in certain clinical condition. CP is a day to day plan of patient managementCPs use multidisciplinary approach, so that averyone could use the same formatPatient’s progression can be monitored on daily basis, including intervention and its outcomesCP is best suite for conditions with predictable clinical course and need multidisciplinary careAny deviation from the expected outcome = variance
39A clinical pathway (CP) is a “task-oriented care plan that details essential steps in the care of patients with a specific clinical problem and describes the patient’s expected clinical course.”The term CP is often used interchangeably with clinical guideline and clinical protocol. While the differences between pathways, guidelines and protocols are subtle, the distinction is important. Five characteristics of clinical pathways have been agreed upon that differentiate them from guidelines and protocols:
40A CP is a structured multidisciplinary plan of care; CPs are used to channel the translation of guidelines or evidence to the bedside;A CP details the steps in a course of treatment or care in a decision tree or other inventory of actions;CPs have timeframes or criteria-based progression (i.e., steps are taken if designated criteria are met), andCPs are intended to standardize care for a specific clinical problem, procedure or episode of healthcare in a specific population.
41What is a Clinical Pathway? A Clinical Pathway is a plan of care, drafted in advance for predictable patient groups which is developed and used by multidisciplinary team.It forms part of the written documentation, includes outcomes to be achieved and the capacity for recording and analysing variance.The Royal Children’s HospitalMelbourne, Australia
42Should CP be develop for all diseases? NoApproximately 30% of hospitalized patients are managed using CP; the rest are managed using usual careCP is most appropriate when applied to conditions that need multidisciplinary care and the clinical course is predictable
43Are CPs developed to fit financial needs? NoCP may reduce hospital costCP data could be used for other programs related to finance, e.g., diagnostic related group (DRG), case-based group (CBG), etcCP should not be developed to determine hospital cost so that all diagnosis should have CP. Otherwise CP is not patient-oriented but DRG-oriented or length of stay oriented.
44Can we develop CP for other diseases or problems? CP - is a standardized management for certain group of patientsIf the clinical course varies, it is impossible to develop day-to-day plan of careHowever CP can be develop provided:Clear inclusion and exclusion criteria,Patient being managed using CP should be switch to usual care if tehre is co-morbidity or complicationThe decision lies on the professionals.
45Example: CP for acute diarrhea Inclusion criteria (all must be met)Age 1-5 yearsAcute diarrhea without complication / co-morbidityDehydration <10%No indication for surgeryExclusion criteria (any of these):Immunocompromized patientsVomiting or abdominal pain without diarrheaDiarrhea >5 daysShould be excluded from CP if:No clinical improvement in 48 hrsBiliary vomiting wirh abdominal painQuestionable diagnosis
46Algorithms“Algorithms are written in the format of a flowchart or decision tree. This format provides a quick visual reference for responding to a situation. For instance, algorithms are effective in emergency departments and critical care units. When staff are faced with an emergency, such as a patient hemorrhaging, they can treat the patient rapidly by following the algorithm”.Ashton, 2002
47ProtocolsProtocols define patient care management for specific situations or conditions. Protocols may be written for the care of patients who have indwelling tubes (e.g., nasogastric, urinary catheter). Thus, the procedure would describe how to insert the tube and the protocol would describe how to care for the patient with a tube in place. Standards might include how often to assess the patient, what to assess, and what types of treatments are needed. Protocols may also be written for patient categories, e.g., maternity care.
48Procedures“Procedures are step-by-step instructions on how to perform a technical skill. This format often involves the use of equipment, medication, or treatment. Examples of procedures include how to administer blood, insert tubes (nasogastric, urinary catheters), administer medication (oral, rectal, intravenous), administer tube feedings, perform suctioning, and wound care”.
49Standing ordersStanding orders are set of physician’s instructions to nurses or other health professionals to do something in the absemce of the doctor. Standing oder can be directed to specific patients or in general with the approval of medical committee. Example: certain postsurgical care, administration of paracetamol in a child with high fever, intrarectal diazepam for children with seizure, etc.
50Implementing guidelines in patient care PPK should be implemented according to patient’s condition. PPK should be viewed as advice or recommendation, not to be implemented in all patients.PPK is developed for ’average patients’.PPK is meant for single disease / conditionIndividual variation to diagnostic and therapeutic proceduresPPK is vaild when printedModern medical practice requires the accommodation of patient’s and familiy’s role in clinical decision making
51Disclaimer PPK is developed for average patients Penggunaan Standar Pelayanan Medis / Panduan PMini harus disesuaikan secara individual:PPK is developed for average patientsPPK is developed for single isolated disease/conditionIndividual response to Dx & Rx proceduresValid at the time of printingShared clinical decision making process
52Applying guidelines to the care of an individual patient always requires judgment
53Additional points for disclaimer CPG is meant to patient care so it does not contain complete information on disease/health conditionCPG is not the best for all patientsThe caring physician should consult to other professional whenever he or she feels that he or she is not very confident in establishing diagnosis and administer treatmentThe authors of CPG will not hold responsibility for whatever results may be by using the CPG
54MOH Singapore, Statement of Intent These guidelines are not intended to serve as a standard of medical care (SMC).SMC are determined on the basis of all clinical data for an individual case and are subject to change as scientific knowledge advances and patterns of care evolve.Adherence to these guidelines may not ensure a successful outcome in every case. These guidelines should neither be construed as including all proper methods of care, nor exclude other acceptable methods of care.
55Disclaimer, RWH Melbourne Whilst appreciable care has been taken in the preparation of clinical guidelines which appear on this web page, The RWH provides these as a service only and does not warrant the accuracy of these guidelines.Any representation implied or expressed concerning the efficacy, appropriateness or suitability of any treatment or product is expressly negated.In view of the possibility of human error and / or advances in medical knowledge, The RWH cannot and does not warrant that the information contained in the guidelines is in every respect accurate or complete.
56Disclaimer, RWH Melbourne Accordingly, The RWH will not be held responsible or liable for any errors or omissions that may be found in any of the information at this site.You are encouraged to consult other sources in order to confirm the information contained in any of the guidelines and in the event that medical treatment is required to take professional, expert advice from a legally qualified and appropriately experienced medical practitioner.
57Disclaimer, RCH Melbourne The emergency paediatric guidelines presented on this site were developed by RCH clinicians primarily for use within the inpatient wards and emergency dept of RCHThey detail the initial assessment and management of many common (and some rare but important) conditions ……They do not constitute a text-book and therefore deliberately provide little, if any, explanation or background to the conditions and treatment outlined. They are however designed to acquaint the reader rapidly with the clinical problem and provide practical advice regarding assessment and management.
58Disclaimer, RCH Melbourne These CPG were produced by staff of The Depts. of General & Emergency …..… The CPGs do not necessarily represent the views of all the clinicians in the RCH.The recommendations contained in these guidelines do not indicate an exclusive course of action, or serve as a standard of medical care. Variations, taking individual circumstances into account, may be appropriate.The authors of these CGL have made considerable efforts to ensure the information is accurate and up to date…... The authors accept no responsibility for any inaccuracies, information perceived as misleading, or the success of any treatment regimen detailed in the guidelines.
59Who should decide?The most responsible person who comprehensively evaluate the patient’s condition is the doctor in charge. He or she should determine whether CPG is applied or not. In the case that the doctor in charge did not follow the CPG, he or she should write clearly the reason why in the medical record.If he/she did not write the reason for not giving the reason then he / she is committed to neglect the patient.
60The cardinal rule in medical records: If it isn’t written down,it didn’t happen
61Revisions of PPK Recent evidence Periodic revisions Usually every 2 yearsUse of intranet may save money
63Textbook, Professional Organization Guidelines, etc LiteraturePrimary articlesSystematic reviewsGuidelinesTextbook, Professional Organization Guidelines, etcConsensusPNPKStandard Operating Procedures = PPKCan be developedWithout awaitingPNPKPathwaysAlgoritmsProtocolsProseduresStanding ordersAccording toType and strata(hospital specific)
64Beberapa pengertian yang perlu diluruskan/disepakati/kesamaan persepsi: PNPKHigh volume, high risk, high cost, high variabilityDibuat oleh tim pakar, hampir selalu multidisiplinInformasi mutakhir, ideal, evidence-basedDisahkan MenteriHarus diterjemahkan ke fasilitas pelayanan menjadi PPK (dalam UU-PK disebut sebagai Standar Prosedur Operasional)
65PNPK Format Ringkasan Eksekutif Pendahuluan: mengapa diperlukan PNPK Metodologi: search strategy, keywords, levels of evidence, grades of recommendationsHasil dan pembahasanRekomendasiDaftar pustakaLampiran bila perluPerlu waktu beberapa bulan untuk 1 PNPKTerjadwal untuk revisi
66PPK Bersifat hospital specific Dibuat dengan rujukan utama PNPK (bila tersedia)Bila PNPK belum / tidak / tidak perlu ada, PPK dibuat oleh fasilitas pelayanan dengan merujuk padaLiteratur mutakhir (artikel asli, SR/meta-analisis, dll)Clinical guidelines asingBuku ajar, evidence-based textbooksPanduan dari organisasi profesi, direktorat tertentu Kemenkes dll [Usul nama: Panduan Umum PPK]Kesepakatan profesional
67Clinical pathwaysMerupakan bagian atau pelengkap PPK karenanya memiliki karakteristik PPK termasuk:Hospital specificMerujuk PNPK atau sumber pustaka lainTerbaik untuk penyakit / kondisi yang perlu penanganan multidisiplin, dan perjalanan klinisnya predictableJangan dipaksakan, hindarkan“mentalitas menerabas”Tidak menggantikan clinical judgmentHarus patient oriented, jangan sampai DRG-oriented atau length of stay oriented