Presentation on theme: "T RANSITION TO A DULTHOOD – P RACTICAL AND L EGAL S TRATEGIES TO S UPPORT THE P LANNING P ROCESS Katie Hornberger Attorney Supervising Clients’ Rights."— Presentation transcript:
T RANSITION TO A DULTHOOD – P RACTICAL AND L EGAL S TRATEGIES TO S UPPORT THE P LANNING P ROCESS Katie Hornberger Attorney Supervising Clients’ Rights Advocate OCRA Disability Rights California April 21, 2012
T RAINING G OALS Know what transition services are. Understand the obligations of the local school district. Understand the obligations of the regional center. Know the different appeal processes.
A GENCIES I NVOLVED IN T RANSITION School Regional Center Department of Rehabilitation Mental Health Post-Secondary Schools Health Care Providers
S PECIAL E DUCATION
All students are entitled to a Free Appropriate Public Education (FAPE) in the Least Restrictive Environment (LRE). Free – no cost to the parents Appropriate – an education reasonably calculated to give the student educational benefit, ie making progress toward goals and objectives on the IEP. Public – Publicly paid for. Education – specialized instruction and transition services. This includes ESY, AT, and Transition.
T RANSITION A CTIVITIES U NDER IDEA Instruction. Community experiences. Development of employment and other post- school adult living objectives. If appropriate, acquisition of daily living skills and functional vocational evaluation.
T RANSITION S ERVICES Transition Planning Employment Preparation Specialized Job Development Job Coaching Case Management Travel Training Benefits Planning & Management Self-Advocacy Skills training Preparing for Post-Secondary Education Participation Skill development to support adult self- sufficiency
T HREE MAIN COMPONENTS : Transitioning from school to post-secondary activities, Planning based upon student’s needs and preferences, and Identifying post-secondary educational, community, employment, and independent living objectives.
M EMBERS OF A T RANSITION T EAM Peers Advocates Parents Teacher Counselors Independent Living Center Disabled Students Programs Employer Other resources
T HE I NDIVIDUALIZED T RANSITION P LAN (ITP) Purpose – to help transition into adulthood Student’s preference and needs taken into consideration Student included as a member of the IEP Vocational and daily living skills assessments Include representatives from local agencies who are responsible for providing and/or paying for services. No later than age 16
T HE ITP M UST I NCLUDE : Shall identify which agencies will be responsible for transition services Document that other agencies have accepted the student for post-secondary school services Document the participation of other agencies in planning and service delivery.
O PTIONS C AN I NCLUDE : Community experiences Development of employment and other post- school adult living objectives If appropriate, acquisition of daily living skills and functional vocational evaluation. Project Workability Programs see Mobility Training, Job Coach, Classes at a Community College, and Involvement with DOR.
W ORKABILITY The WorkAbility I program is funded and administered by the California Department of Education The WorkAbility I project was initiated in November 1981 as a pilot project to test the concept of work experience for youth with disabilities. WorkAbility I continues today to successfully conduct interagency coordination of services. The WorkAbility I program provides comprehensive pre-employment training, employment placement and follow up for junior high and high school students and adults with disabilities.
M ISSION OF W ORKABILITY I The Mission of WorkAbility 1 is to promote the involvement of key stakeholders including students, families, educators, employers and other agencies in planning and implementing an array of services that will culminate in successful student transition to employment, lifelong learning and quality of life.
A SSESSMENT OF I NTERESTS › Social Do you like to work with people to inform, help, train, enlighten, develop or cure or are you skilled with words? › Investigative Are you interested in jobs with people who like to observe, learn investigate, analyze, evaluate, or solve problems? › Realistic Are you interested in jobs that require athletic or mechanical ability, working with objects, machines, tools, plants, or animals, or being outdoors? › Artistic Are you interested in jobs involving artistic, innovating, or institutional abilities, and like to work in unstructured creative situations? › Conventional Are you interested in jobs that involve working with data, clerical tasks, or creative ability, carrying out things in detail, or following instructions? › Enterprising Are you interested in jobs where you work with people to influence, perform, persuade, or lead for organizational goals or economic gain?
T RANSITION R ESOURCES Transition planning CDE Book “Transition to Adulthood: A Guide for Secondary Education” (2003) available at Jobs Vocational Assessment
E XITING S PECIAL E DUCATION In CA, special education continues without qualifications through a student’s 18 th year if they have not received a diploma. Individuals who are 19, 20, or 21, who were enrolled in or were eligible for special education prior to their 19 th birthday, continue to be eligible during those years if they have not completed their prescribed course of study, or if they have not met proficiency standards, or if they have not graduated with a regular diploma. Compensatory education is different, ie failure to do appropriate transition planning results in compensatory services which will extend eligibility past the age or study criteria.
S TANDARDIZED T ESTING IN S PECIAL E DUCATION CA High School Exit Exam (CAHSEE) Requirement for a Diploma has been postponed. STAR Testing – In CA, Stanford Achievement Test 9 th Edition or SAT- 9 is used by educators to determine a retention policy for students. Special education students utilize the IEP process to determine retention/promotion. Students can also be exempted out of the testing. California Alternate Performance Assessment (CAPA) Modifications of tests are also available see For more information on testing see
D UE P ROCESS WITH THE S CHOOL D ISTRICT
D ISAGREEING WITH THE IEP Goals Placement Services Supports
S IGNING IN D ISAGREEMENT You must give permission for those services/supports/placement that you wish to be implemented. An unsigned IEP cannot be implemented. You can agree with parts and disagree with parts. You can ask that a service be implemented while still disagreeing with it.
S TAY P UT Except in limited circumstances, your child must remain in her then current educational placement and have her current IEP fully implemented from the time you request a hearing until the due process proceedings are completed.
A LTERNATE D UE P ROCESS P ROCEEDINGS “Pre-Due Process” Mediation – is conducted like a due process mediation but parents cannot have an attorney participate. There is also concern about whether “stay-put” applies during this time period. “Informal” Meeting – many school districts offer a meeting with a representative to attempt to resolve the problem before due process is filed.
R EQUEST FOR D UE P ROCESS Generally, you have 2 years to file. Requests for Due Process must include the following information: Name of the child, Residential address of the child – or contact information for a homeless child, A description of the problem or problems the child has as they relate to something the school has done or has not done. The description must give enough facts to clearly describe the problem, and A description of the proposed resolution to the problem to the extent the parent knows what would resolve the problem when s/he asks for a due process hearing. Requests for Due Process should be sent to: Office of Administrative Hearings Special Education Unit 1102 Q Street, 4 th Floor Sacramento, CA Phone (916) // Fax (916)
P RIOR W RITTEN N OTICE BY THE S CHOOL D ISTRICT The school must give the parents prior written notice of the reasons why the school has decided to do or not do whatever it is that is causing the problem. Prior written notice must include: A description of the action proposed or refused by the school; An explanation of why the school proposes or refuses to take that action and of each evaluation, procedure, test report, etc. the school used as a basis for the action or inaction; A copy of the parent’s rights to challenge the action or inaction; Sources of advocacy assistance for parents; Other options to the action or inaction which the school considered and why those other options were rejected; and Other reasons for the school’s action or inaction.
D ISTRICT M UST P ROVIDE W RITTEN N OTICE Once a parent requests a fair hearing, if the school never sent the prior written notice described in (b) above, it must, within 10 days of getting a copy of the parent’s fair hearing request, send the parent a response which includes all of the following information: An explanation of why the school proposes or refuses to take that action and of each evaluation, procedure, test report, etc. the school used as a basis for the action or inaction; Other options to the action or inaction which the school considered and why those other options were rejected; and Other reasons for the school’s action or inaction.
D ISTRICT R ESPONSE TO DUE PROCESS R EQUEST Even if the school has to send the parent a response, because it never sent the parent a prior written notice, the school can still claim that the parent’s request for hearing is not clear enough. The school must make this claim within 15 days of receiving the parent’s request for due process. A hearing officer also receives a copy of the school’s objection to the parent’s due process request and must rule on it within 5 days. If the hearing officer agrees with the school, the parent can change and clarify the due process hearing request, but only if the school agrees to let the parent do so and is also given a chance to resolve the more clearly stated request, or if the hearing officer grants the parent permission to file a new request. A hearing officer must grants this permission at least 5 days before the scheduled hearing. If the time that has gone by while the school was objecting to the parent’s first request for a hearing and while the parent was filing a more complete due process request does not count toward the total number of days that the state has to complete the hearing and write a final decision. That time limit is currently 45 days.
P RE -H EARING D ISPUTE R ESOLUTION S ESSION The resolution session must occur within 15 days of the school getting the parent’s request for due process and it must be finished within 30 days. The new resolution session involves the parents and a representative of the school district who has the authority to commit the school district to a resolution. The session may not involve attorneys for the school district unless the parent is represented by an attorney. At the resolution session, the parents must be able to discuss the basis for their complaint and the school is given an opportunity to resolve it. If the resolution session does lead to a solution, the solution must be put into writing and must be signed by both sides, The agreement is legally binding on the parties and can be enforced in both federal and state court. The parties have 3 days after signing the agreement to back out of it. A party cannot have a hearing without going through this resolution session unless both sides waive the resolution session in writing or both agree to use mediation instead.
M EDIATION An ALJ trained in mediation informally meets with you and a school district representative. All discussions which took place in reaching an agreement stay confidential and cannot be disclosed in a subsequent hearing or court case, The mediator tries to find common ground and new solutions. The mediator has no power to force an agreement. If you reach agreement, you sign a private agreement and the appeal process stops. Attorneys fees may be recovered from the district by the attorney for the parent. If you do not reach agreement you proceed to due process with a different ALJ.
P REPARING FOR DUE PROCESS Hearing is held before an Administrative Law Judge. 10 days before the hearing you and the school district must submit an issue statement and proposed resolution to the hearing office. 5 business days before the hearing you and the school district send each other your exhibits and a list of witnesses.
I N D UE P ROCESS Each side will present their evidence and witnesses. The proceedings are tape recorded. Hearing officers can be involved in the proceedings – not just listening. The hearing officer will issue a written decision. Attorneys fees can be awarded to the parents attorneys if they are the prevailing party.
A FTER D UE P ROCESS Hearing decisions can be appealed to superior court within 90 days of the decision.
S PECIAL E DUCATION AND R EGIONAL C ENTER
IDEA AND L ANTERMAN S ERVICES Community experiences Development of employment and other post-school adult living objectives If appropriate, acquisition of daily living skills and functional vocational evaluation. Community integration services Sheltered employment Travel training Special living arrangements Daily living skills Recreation Follow along services Adaptive equipment and supplies
IDEA AND L ANTERMAN A CT R ESPONSIBILITIES If another agency is responsible for providing a related service, the IEP should indicate that it is being provided by another agency. Service coordination shall include those activities necessary to implement an IPP, including obtaining from generic agencies or other resources, services and supports specified.
I NVOLVEMENT OF RC During the exit years (18-22) Assist in encouraging other agencies to attend the IEP/ITP meetings. Assist families to explore adult agencies, tour them, so families and students can make informed decisions. Service coordinators attending IEPs for transition and assisting with the smooth transition to the adult service system.
R EGIONAL C ENTER
R OLE OF THE R EGIONAL C ENTER Securing services and supports which maximize opportunities and choices for living, working, learning and recreating in the community. Provide specialized services and supports or adapt generic services and supports. The determination of which services and supports are necessary for each consumer shall be made on the basis of the needs and preferences of the consumer.
R EGIONAL C ENTER S ERVICES Relationship Services Emergency and Crisis Intervention Specialized Equipment Transportation Services Facilitation Services Self-Advocacy Advocacy Family Support Services Assessment Services Habilitation and Training Treatment and Therapy Preventive Services Living Arrangements Community Integration Employment/Day Programs List from WIC § 4512(b)
P URCHASE OF S ERVICE P OLICIES Guidelines for purchasing services and supports. Explain the requirements for receiving services and sometimes set limits. Policy not law. Vary from regional center to regional center. Must be cost-effective. Can only request payment from parents Day Care, A portion of 24 hour out of home care for minors, Family Cost Participation Program, and Annual Program Fee.
G ENERIC S ERVICES Generic services are services you can get from another agency that serves the general public. WIC § 4644(b). The law says you must use generic services before the regional center pays for similar services. WIC § 4648(a)(8) and WIC § 4659.
U SE OF G ENERICS If you or your family are eligible for Medi-Cal, Medicare, the Civilian Health and Medical Program for Uniform Services (CHAMPUS-otherwise known as TRICARE), In-Home Support Services (IHSS), California Children’s Services (CCS), private insurance, or a health care service plan, and you or your family choose not to apply for these services, then the regional center cannot purchase those services for you.
L ACK OF G ENERICS If you or your family does not meet the criteria for the generic services above, then the regional center can purchase these types of services for you. The regional center can also help you access generic services. If you, or where appropriate, your parents, legal guardians, or conservators, have no such benefits, the regional center cannot use that fact to negatively impact the services you may or may not receive from the regional center.
M EDICAL AND D ENTAL S ERVICES A regional center can only buy medical or dental services for you if you are over age 3 and: You or your family show the regional center that Medi-Cal, private insurance, or a health care service plan has denied the medical or dental service; and The regional center decides that an appeal would not have merit. The regional center may pay for medical or dental services: While you or your family are trying to get medical or dental service from another agency or private insurance and you have not yet been given a denial; While you or your family are waiting for a final administrative decision and you already provided the regional center with information that you are appealing; or Until Medi-Cal, private insurance or a health care service plan begins to provide the services.
S ECURING S ERVICES The regional center must investigate and use creative and innovative ways to meet the family’s need and keep the child in the family home. WIC § 4685(c)(2) There shall be no gaps in service. It is the regional center’s responsibility to ensure that all needed services are being provided.
2011 C HANGES TO THE L ANTERMAN A CT In some situations, the regional center is barred from purchasing these services for year olds. Day program Vocational education Work services Independent living program Mobility training and related transportation services Welfare & Institutions Code Section
E XCLUSION year olds who have graduated with a Diploma or a Certificate of Completion/Achievement.
T HREE G ROUPS Group #1. If you are and you are still in school and you are either receiving or you want/need to receive one or more of the services listed previously. Group #2. If you are and you are not in school but are currently receiving one of the services previously listed from the regional center. Group #3. If you are and you are not in school and you are not getting - either from the school or from the regional center - any of the previously listed services.
G ROUP #1 – A TTENDING S CHOOL If you are and still in school, the IPP team has to determine whether the school can meet your needs for the previously listed services. If the school can, regional center must help you access those services. If the school can’t, or you meet an exception, the regional center can purchase those services.
G ROUP #2 – L EFT S CHOOL AND C URRENTLY R ECEIVING S ERVICES If you are and have left school, the IPP team has to determine whether the school can meet your needs for the previously listed services. If the school can, regional center must help you access those services. If the school can’t, or you meet an exception, the regional center can purchase those services. If you are currently receiving the services, you are entitled to a NOA and eligible for aid paid pending.
G ROUP #3 – L EFT S CHOOL AND NOT R ECEIVING S ERVICES If you are and have left school, the IPP team has to determine whether the school can meet your needs for the previously listed services. If the school can, regional center must help you access those services. If the school can’t, or you meet an exception, the regional center can purchase those services.
E XEMPTION There are 2 ways to get an exemption: An exemption may be granted if there was an individualized determination that an extraordinary circumstance exists that justifies granting an exemption; or An exemption must be granted if, through the IPP process, it is determined that the school cannot appropriately meet your needs for services.
E XAMPLES OF E XTRAORDINARY C IRCUMSTANCES Health and Safety Least Restrictive Environment IEP Services are NOT Available Extraordinary Family Circumstances
H EARING D ECISIONS Christian G. v. FNRC – Transportation Denied for student to/from his part-time job. David R. v. ACRC – Consumer left school with a Certificate of Completion at age 18. Then at age 20 he requested a day program. ALJ denied funding for day program under generic resources provisions following testimony about available programs from the local school district. Derek C. v. HRC – Student request “community participation training” and ALJ granted it because it is not on the list of services in the statute.
R EGIONAL C ENTER A PPEAL P ROCESS
A PPEAL P ROCESS FOR R EGIONAL C ENTER Written Notice of Action/Hearing Request Informal Meeting Mediation Fair Hearing
W RITTEN N OTICE OF A CTION If you disagree with a Regional Center decision you have the following rights which should be outlined in the notice: Notice of the decision, Notice of hearing, Have an authorized representative, Examine the agency’s file about you. Examine the records that the agency used in making the decision, and To a timely and adequate hearing
A ID P AID P ENDING If you appeal a reduction or cancellation of services within 10 days of your receipt of the notice of action your services will continue during the appeal process.
I NFORMAL M EETING The first step in the hearing process. A meeting between you (and your representative, if you have one) and a regional center representative. The purpose is to resolve the issue or at least clarify or reduce the disagreement for hearing. The decision will go into effect in 10 days after the meeting, unless you indicate disagreement by requesting mediation or a hearing. You do not have to participate in an informal.
M EDIATION Voluntary for both parties. An independent, trained mediator informally meets with you and a regional center representative. Takes place within 20 days of your request for hearing. The mediator tries to find common ground and new solutions. The mediator has no power to force an agreement. If you reach agreement, you sign a private agreement and the appeal process stops. If you do not reach agreement, you proceed to fair hearing.
F AIR H EARING Must take place within 50 days of your hearing request unless a delay is requested for good cause. 5 days before hearing you and the regional center send each other your exhibits and a list of witnesses. Hearing is held before an Administrative Law Judge from the Office of Administrative Hearings.
A T THE H EARING The regional center has to go first. The burden of proof is on you if it is a new service or an increase in services. You have to prove why you should get the service.
A FTER THE H EARING The judge will issue a decision within 10 days of the end of the hearing.
O THER A GENCIES
D EPARTMENT OF R EHABILITATION DR assists people with disabilities in obtaining and retaining meaningful employment and living independently in their communities. DR provides for vocational and independent living services to people with disabilities if: You have a physical or mental disability which is a substantial impediment to employment; and You require services to prepare, secure, retain or regain employment. DR usually begins working with students 2 years prior to their scheduled graduation.
E LIGIBILITY Eligibility is based on: A review of the individual’s daily life; Their ability to participate in major life activities as they impact an employment outcome; The impact of an individual’s impairment in each of the functional capacity areas: Communication, Interpersonal skills, Mobility, Self-care, Work skills and Work tolerance. DR services are required to prepare for, secure, retain, or regain employment; and The individual can benefit from the provision of vocational rehabilitation services.
L EVEL OF S IGNIFICANCE OF D ISABILITY (LSOD) DR will review an application and information obtained about the individual’s disability and assess how it limits them in five areas of functioning. Based on this assessment, DR will give them a LSOD score that represents the significance of their work-related limitations. The LSOD assessment score, will usually be completed within 90 days from the date of application.
S ERVICES A VAILABLE FROM DR Diagnostic and related services Vocational testing Skills assessment Vocational counseling Vocational training Placement assistance Tools, equipment for job placement Physical restoration Transportation allowance Occupation licenses Supported employment services Reader services for the blind Interpreter services for the deaf
I NDIVIDUALIZED P LAN FOR E MPLOYMENT (IPE) Equipment and services must be described in a written document, called an Individualized Plan for Employment (IPE). If you need technology, your IPE must include the following: The specific rehabilitation technology services you need; How the technology will be provided to you in the most integrated setting; and Who will provide the technology and any services related to its acquisition and use. 34 C.F.R. §361.22(a)(2) requires that students with disabilities who are eligible for DR services have a properly signed IPE in place prior to the students’ exit from school.
D EVELOPING AN IPE Select an employment outcome Specify the DR services to be provided under the plan Specify the entity that will provide the vocational rehabilitation services Specifies the methods used to provide the services Services must be authorized and approved by DR prior to their purchase
R OLES AND R ESPONSIBILITIES FOR DR AND S CHOOL The Local Education Agency (LEA) and Department of Rehabilitation (DR) use a collaborative team process Both the IEP and the Individual Plan of Employment (IPE) include a statement of interagency responsibilities detailing how the services shall be provided The school district is the lead agency for providing transition services to the point of exit from school. DR is designated as the lead agency responsible for providing services after the point of exit.
D EPARTMENT OF M ENTAL H EALTH The legislature decided to utilize state and county agencies to provide certain related services (Mental Health, OT, and PT) in lieu of the local school districts. CCS provides OT and PT. CMH provides Mental Health services. However, the local school district remains responsible for ensuring the services are provided.
2010 E RADICATION OF F UNDING In 2010, the funding for MH services under 3632 was eradicated. School districts remain responsible for ensuring that IEPs are implemented. Any change to a service must go through the IEP process. Go to for more information and updates.http://www.cde.ca.gov/sp/se/ac/
P OST S ECONDARY E DUCATION PSE is education beyond what is considered typical of high school education (ages 18-22) Options for students with intellectual disabilities include: Transition Programs Community Colleges Four-year Colleges and Institutions Vocational-Technical Colleges Various forms of Adult-Education
ROP There are 72 Regional Occupational Center/Programs (ROC/P) in California that offer: community classroom programs and unpaid on-the- job training related to the students’ instructional programs paid work experience related to the student’s classroom instruction under the supervision of the employers
H EALTH C ARE P ROVIDERS Partial Hospitalization Programs Adaptive Equipment Health Services
R ESOURCES Websites Disability Rights California Office of Administrative Hearings California Code of Regulations – Title 17 California Laws at Findlaw http.//ca.findlaw.com/
OCRA O FFICES If you know the name and phone number of your local OCRA office, you may contact that office directly. If you do not know the name of the staff in your local OCRA office, call toll-free: Northern CA (800) or Southern CA (866) TTY (800) On-line staff directory at