Presentation on theme: "Data Requirements for Biodiversity Indicators"— Presentation transcript:
1 Data Requirements for Biodiversity Indicators Carlo HeipCentre for Estuarine and Marine EcologyNetherlands Institute of EcologyGhent University, BelgiumState University of Groningen, The Netherlands
2 Biodiversity: what is it? The variability among living organisms from all sources, including inter alia, terrestrial, marine and other aquatic ecosystems and the ecological complexes of which they are part; this includes diversity within species, between species and of ecosystems.The totality of genes, species and ecosystems in a region.Biological variation
3 Why marine biodiversity matters Species are disappearing at a rate never observed since life began on earth. The extinction crisis ranks with global climate change as the greatest threat to the integrity of the biosphere in the 21st centurySpecies extinction is not just an aesthetic or moral problem. Marine organisms play a crucial role in almost all biogeochemical processes that sustain the biosphere, and provide a variety of products (goods) and functions (services) which are essential to mankind’s well-being
4 The rate and efficiency of any of the processes that marine organisms mediate, as well as the range of goods and services that they provide, are determined by interactions, between organisms, and between organisms and their environment, and therefore by biodiversity.These relationships have not yet been quantified, and we are at present unable to predict the consequences of loss of biodiversity resulting from environmental change in ecological, economic or social terms.
5 Marine Biodiversity: what are the threats? Overexploitation of resourcesPhysical alteration of the coastlinePollution and eutrophicationIntroduction of ‘exotic’ speciesGlobal climate change
6 What is at stake? Marine resources (goods) Genetic resources Example: Pompei wormSpeciesFisheries, aquaculture: 100 MT of foodHabitatTourismFunctioning of marine ecosystems (services)Relationship between species and biogeochemical processes
7 A better understanding of marine biodiversity requires Knowledge of existing biodiversity: inventoriesUnderstanding of how biodiversity changes in space and through time, both now and in the pastErgo: surveys and monitoringInterpreting these changes in terms of a theoryExperiments and modelling
9 FUNDAMENTAL QUESTIONS For a targeted range of environments and field sites, environmental genomics can address:Which genes are turned on, and what do they do?Is there intraspecific variation in gene expression in response to environmental change, and is this variation adaptive?What are the ecosystem-, community-, and population-level consequences of the molecular transformations performed by these genes?Which taxa are involved?What happens if the system is experimentally perturbed
10 NSF Press Release November 2001 Scientists funded in part by the National Science Foundation (NSF) and affiliated from the University of Delaware and Amersham Biosciences, Inc., in Piscataway, New Jersey, have succeeded in conducting the first-ever DNA sequencing experiments at sea. Using the research vessel Atlantis and submersible Alvin, the team carried out a pioneering environmental genomic study of the strange life that inhabits super-hot hydrothermal vents almost two miles deep in the Pacific Ocean
12 Genome Science and Bioinformatics One of the core activities in genomics is to establish integrated Web-based databases and research interfaces.Bioinformatics deals with the computational management of all kinds of biological information. It develops the mathematical tools required for analysing and processing the information in those databasesAt some stage as the data obtained in genomics research will be linked to information on species, including geographical and environmental information and using methods developed in bioinformatics
13 Inventorying and Monitoring of Species Diversity The rational use and conservation of marine biodiversity requires programmes of inventorying and monitoring that allow understanding the past and present states of biodiversity and the causes of its change.Inventories establish a baseline distribution of biodiversity for a particular place at a particular time.Monitoring addresses the issue of change or lack of change of biodiversity through time at particular places.Ideally, modelling should allow for predicting future states of biodiversity
14 Why surveys and monitoring are required. Inventories and monitoring serve to set the baseline against which changes can be evaluated.Monitoring is the only way to keep track of the state of the system, which is necessary becauseMuch change is triggered by random events.Accidents will happen.Monitoring is required to evaluate effects of policy measures.Time series data become more valuable when they are longer. Much variation is in the longer time periodsValidation and calibration of ecological models can only be done on the basis of real data. The longer the time series the better the models perform.
15 Inventorying and Monitoring: How? The goal of an inventorying and monitoring program of biodiversity is to document patterns of change in order to understand the impact of natural or anthropogenic disturbance on species composition and abundance in communities and ecosystems.An inventory establishes a baseline for the distribution of biodiversity at a particular place and a particular time.Monitoring addresses the issue of change or lack of change of biodiversity through time at particular places, against the baseline
16 Setting up a baseline by a network of sites A network of sites can survey and monitor biodiversity in space and in time simultaneouslyAn ideal network of sites would cover a selection of critical ecosystems and cover:Areas with marginal or undetectable impact versus (heavily) impacted areasTransition zones between biogeographical regions and sites which are aligned along gradients such as longitude, latitude, salinitySites which have been intensively studied and have well established species lists, coupled with meteorological and ecological data sets.
17 European Marine Biodiversity Research Sites ATBIFocal sitesImpactedReference sitesNon-impactedLTBR
18 European Marine Biodiversity Research Sites148 research sites, of which 38 are reference sitesWP1: Candidate Reference and Focal sites:- ATBI (red dots)- other sites (blue dots)
19 Direct indicators of Biodiversity at Different levels Within a research siteWithin a habitat or communityWithin a populationHabitat diversity as measured by remote sensing, acoustic or imaging methods All Taxon Biodiversity Inventory Diversity indices e.g. Hill or Renyi numbers (Species richness, Shannon-Wiener etc) of selected taxonomic groups Taxonomic distinctness Benthic community analysis Diversity of ecosystem engineers Invading Species Population structure Genetic diversity
21 Existing DataTaxonomic collections: information on taxa with or without geographical information or reference to authorsLocal and Regional Faunas and Floras: lists with geographical referencesBiogeographical researchPaleo-ecologyEnvironmental research and MonitoringFisheries and aquaculture dataEcological research: quantitative and qualitativeProxies…
22 Problems No systematic collection No reference to sites No standardization in collecting methodsNo quality controlNot electronically available
23 Requirements for new data A standard minimum set and sampling methodology of environmental variablesSpace (geographical location) and TimeTemperature, light, nutrients (salinity) regimeSubstrate for benthic populations, water column structure for pelagic populations….Standard methodologies for biodiversity measurementElectronically available on the Web using adequate data-base structureApplication and Development of Bioinformatics (data mining software, ….)
25 Key features of ‘indicators’ Biological RelevanceChanges in the indicator can be measuredThe indicator changes in response to stressIntensity of changes relate to intensity of stressorsChanges are biologically important and can be detected early enough to prevent catastrophic effectsMethodological RequirementsEasy to use in the fieldEasy to analyze and interpret dataMeasures what it is supposed to measureCan be used to test management questionsCan be used for hypothesis testingSocietal RelevanceOf interest to the publicEasily understood by the publicMeasures aspects of the environment that relate to human health or ecological services provided by the environmentCost-effective
26 The Pressure-State-Response model The PSR model was developed in the 1970s by the Canadian statistician Anthony Friend, and subsequently adopted by the OECD’s State of the Environment (SOE) group. The European Commission’s indicator development follows this framework.Some organisations prefer variants of the PSR model; for example, the UN Commission for Sustainable Development (UN CSD) bases its indicator set on the Driving force-State-Response model (DSR) model, which allows for a better inclusion of non-environmental variables.Statistical Office of the European Commission (EUROSTAT).
27 For practical purposes, the PSR model is sufficient. The Driving force-Pressure-State-Impact-Response modelFor practical purposes, the PSR model is sufficient.However, for compatibility reasons (e.g. to the DSR model), and for a better description of underlying economic trends, the indicator community has formulated the Drivers-Pressure-State-Impact-Response model, which includes PSR as special cases.The UN CSD indicator process uses the DSR model, where the term “Driving Forces” is used synonymous for “Pressure”.
29 Marine Biodiversity Biodiversity data Socio-economic Ecosystem data Inventories and explorationEnvironmental genomicsMechanisms of origin and maintenanceRole in ecosystem functioningInvading speciesEtc.etc.Scientific prioritiesMarine BiodiversityGlobalEuropeanRegionalLocalKey issuesEutrophicationFishingPollutionConservationetc.ManagementprioritiesLong term (10+)Ph.D. term (3-4)Short term (<1)Biodiversity dataSocio-economicEcosystem dataDNA sequencesSpecies abundancesBenthic mappingRemote SensingSocio-economic driversPrimary productionMineralisationNitrogen fixationEtc.Chemical and Physical Processes
30 Can we do it?Need for handling massive data of very different nature, origin, quality, …Bioinformatics: a quantum jump in the level of expertise and sophistication requiredBest start with a number of Pilot projectsNetworking within Europe (6th framework programme) and globally (Census of Marine Life)
31 ESF Research Objectives To characterise marine biodiversity at a range of biological, spatial and temporal scales.To quantify the role of marine biodiversity in providing goods and services in both relatively natural and more human-impacted environments.To determine the probable effects of natural and man-made changes in biodiversity on ecosystem goods and services.To provide a scientific rationale and tools for the proper management of living resources in European seas.
32 MARBEF EoI Research Objectives 1. Exploring marine biodiversity in Europe.2. Determining the relationship between ecosystem functioning and biodiversity.3. Exploring the relationship between species and the stability of ecosystems, including functional groups and the role of rare species4. What determines the success or failure of invasive species.5. What are the large-scale gradients in species richness and how do they change in time.6. What is the relationship between ecosystem functioning and the sustainable use of marine biodiversity across Europe and globally.
35 BioinformaticsBioinformatics is the study of the inherent structure of biological information and biological systems. It brings together the avalanche of systematic biological data (e.g. genomes, but going on to ecosystems) with the analytic theory and practical tools of mathematics and computer science
36 First, the data produced by the thousands of research teams all over the world are collected and organized in databases specialized for particular subjects. Well-known examples are: GDB , SWISS-PROT , GenBank , and PDB. The latter - for example - deals with three-dimensional structures of biological molecules.
37 In the next step, computational tools are needed to analyse the collected data in the most efficient manner. For example, many bioinformaticists are working on the prediction of the biological functions of genes and proteins (or parts of them) based on structural data
38 Bioinformatics is a newly emerging interdisciplinary research area which may be defined as the interface between biological and computational sciences. Although the term 'Bioinformatics' is not really well-defined, you could say that this scientific field deals with the computational management of all kinds of biological information, whether it may be about genes and their products, whole organisms or even ecological systems.
40 Species diversity Its structure: life has originated in the sea and is much older in the sea than on land. As a consequence, the diversity of higher taxonomic levels is much greater in the sea where there are 14 endemic (unique) animal phyla whereas only 1 phylum is endemic to landIts function: Marine organisms play crucial roles in many biogeochemical processes that sustain the biosphere, and provide a variety of products (goods) and functions (services) which are essential to mankind’s well-being, including the production of food and natural substances, the assimilation of waste and regulation of the world’s climate