Presentation is loading. Please wait.

Presentation is loading. Please wait.

What are the prospects for publishing online scholarly journals in Malaysia? The cultural constraint Jamay’ah Zakaria and Fytton Rowland Paper given at.

Similar presentations

Presentation on theme: "What are the prospects for publishing online scholarly journals in Malaysia? The cultural constraint Jamay’ah Zakaria and Fytton Rowland Paper given at."— Presentation transcript:

1 What are the prospects for publishing online scholarly journals in Malaysia? The cultural constraint Jamay’ah Zakaria and Fytton Rowland Paper given at ElPub 2006, Bansko, Bulgaria, 16 June 2006

2 2 Scholarly publishing in developing countries  Most studies of scholarly publishing have looked at the ‘international’ industry based in the developed North, mostly in Western Europe and North America  Concerns exist about the visibility of scholarly research undertaken in developing countries, and in other small or Southern-Hemisphere countries  SciElo (South America) and INASP (Africa) help – no such initiative for Asia, though

3 3 Malaysia  A developing country aiming to become fully developed by 2020  A predominantly Muslim country, with most education conducted in the Malay language  Heavy government emphasis on ICT; the IT infrastructure is good, and there is widespread availability of Internet access  Small scholarly publishing industry, almost entirely not-for-profit

4 4 Aims of J.Z.’s PhD Study  To measure the current state of the scholarly publishing industry in Malaysia  To gauge the extent to which it has converted or is converting itself to the electronic medium  To survey Malaysian academics, researchers and scholars, to ascertain their publishing and reading habits and their attitudes to the scholarly literature  To make recommendations regarding the future of online scholarly publishing in Malaysia

5 5 Research Methods Adopted  A questionnaire survey of Malaysian scientists, researchers and academics  Conducted by J.Z. in the Malay language; excellent response rate achieved, permitting full statistical analysis  Interviews with directors of university presses in Malaysia  Representatives of thirteen presses were interviewed, and their responses analysed by qualitative analysis techniques

6 6 Who were the Malaysian respondents?  They were aged 26-55, with an even spread between the decades  60% were men – slight over-representation  84% were ethnic Malays  80% in universities; 20% in research institutes  42% had doctorates, another 55% master’s  52% had attended Western universities  98% had Internet access – 70% of them at home

7 7 Attitudes (1)  No difference between the genders in their attitudes towards online publishing  Those who used ICT more were significantly more positive towards online publishing  Almost all said they published both for career advancement and to disseminate knowledge  70%+ said (in 2004) that they never used a digital repository, an online-only journal, or even a parallel print & electronic journal to disseminate their results

8 8 Attitudes (2)  67% often publish in conference proceedings, 33% in local journals, 27% in locally-based journals with an international scope, 20% in foreign journals, and 10% in books. Mean number of publications 1998-2003 was 15.  Those who published more frequently were significantly more positive in their attitude towards online scholarly publishing; so were those who published their work in English or had had a Western education

9 9 Attitudes (3)  In deciding where to submit a paper, the most important considerations were the perceived reputation of the journals and its impact factor  Traditional refereeing procedures are still strongly supported  A large group still favours transfer of copyright to the publisher, but this group is negative in attitude towards online publishing  77% said repositories are important, but only 10% had ever deposited a paper in one

10 10 Helping and hindering factors towards electronic publishing  Factors that would help to persuade Malaysian scholars to publish electronically are recognition, support from their institution, and a policy towards e-publishing  Factors seen to be holding back the progress of e-publishing were a lack of funding for it, copyright concerns, a lack of recognition from the employer, a lack of technological know- how on the part of the author, and perceived low quality of electronic-only journals

11 11 Interview results: the presses  Most of the presses are small, with only a handful of staff. In universities, editorial control is with academics, but in research institutes, press staff undertake editing as well as production work  All but one of the presses had at least one journal title; they also publish books and conference proceedings

12 12 Interview results: their journals  The journals are small – 1-4 issues/year, 12-15 articles per issue  Print runs usually about 300  Fewer than 100 paying subscribers  Provided free to other Malaysian universities and research institutes  Most accept papers in Malay or English  A few papers are from outside Malaysia  Peer-reviewed, but usually by referees all within the one university where the journal is published

13 13 Interview results: the authors  The Malaysian journals struggle to get papers  Authors prefer to give conference papers as they get their travel to the conference paid for  Prestige attaches to ‘international’ journals  But Malay-speaking authors may have difficulty in getting English-language papers accepted in Western journals (70% rejection)  Inclusion in ISI’s WoK is key to success

14 14 Interview results: e-publishing  The only Malaysian e-only journal is not published by a University press  Most Malaysian journals are print-only – only one university press produces print & e- versions of its titles  E-versions of back issues are produced by scanning the print by some publishers  Reason for lack of activity here – difficulty in convincing university paymasters

15 15 Interview results: hindering factors  Lack of ICT skills in the presses  Lack of enthusiasm for e-publishing among influential academics  University managements’ preference for their academics to publish internationally  Tenure/promotion issues for e-journals  Some younger researchers don’t write at all  Uncertainty about business models

16 16 Conclusion – a cultural resistance?  Hofstede’s Power Distance Index – a measure of deferential attitudes – shows Malaysia to be a high-deference country  Malaysians are unwilling to disagree with their superiors. And both authors and press staff report lack of enthusiasm for electronic publishing by university senior managers  Senior scientists, Western educated, with lots of publications in English, are the most likely to be positive to e-publishing; they are the best placed to overcome this cultural trait.

17 17 What is to be done?  The government has provided the physical infrastructure but now needs to encourage its use – perhaps by granting full recognition for tenure and promotion purposes in public universities to papers published in local e-journals  University presses should collaborate to provide a national electronic scholarly information system instead of their current fragmented efforts  Journal publication should be granted higher status relative to conference proceedings  Senior scholars with international status need to give a lead

Download ppt "What are the prospects for publishing online scholarly journals in Malaysia? The cultural constraint Jamay’ah Zakaria and Fytton Rowland Paper given at."

Similar presentations

Ads by Google