We think you have liked this presentation. If you wish to download it, please recommend it to your friends in any social system. Share buttons are a little bit lower. Thank you!
Presentation is loading. Please wait.
Published byMina Ogle
Modified over 2 years ago
Arguing with People Arguing With People By Michael A. Gilbert Professor of Philosophy York University Canada Broadview Press 2014
Arguing with People Part 2 All About Arguers
Arguing with People 3 Familiars We almost always argue with people we know. Opening stage generally set ages ago. If an unusual move, may return there. Share a language. Literally, as in English or Cantonese. But also in the sense of slang, terminology, vocabulary and short cuts. © M.A. Gilbert 2014
Arguing with People 4 Context Defines many things: Power relations Word meaning Context disambiguates meaning Look here at the word ‘”dude” Bud Light Dude Commercial Bud Light Dude Commercial © M.A. Gilbert 2014
Arguing with People 5 Goals Facts about goals: 1. Goals are always manifold. 2. Most people are not fully aware of their goals. 3. Goals are often confused with claims. Goals are about: 1. What we want. 2. Our relationships. 3. Hidden or unknown feelings or desires. © M.A. Gilbert 2014
Arguing with People 6 The Four Modes The logical mode linear, patterned, deductive The emotional mode feelings, attitudes, expressives The visceral mode physical, situational, social The kisceral mode intuitive, religious, mystical © M.A. Gilbert 2014
Arguing with People 7 The Logical Mode Component in virtually every argument. Most arguments can be reduced to a logical form but that is not “ the ” form of the argument: Translation is not proof of reduction. Vastly studied and categorized. Easiest communicative mode to pin down and track. It is more rule-following than other modes. Heart of the critical-logical model © M.A. Gilbert 2014
Arguing with People 8 The Emotional Mode Emotions are present in all human interactions. Often the most crucial element in our beliefs is how and why we believe in them. Believing concerns more than just our minds. To persuade someone is to make them believe in both the correctness and rightness of a position. © M.A. Gilbert 2014
Arguing with People 9 The Visceral Mode Covers arguments that are primarily physical, where the actions or the physical or social context are the predominant features. The expression “ Actions speak louder than words, ” acknowledges the importance of the visceral mode. © M.A. Gilbert 2014
Arguing with People 10 The Kisceral Mode The mode that relies on the intuitive, religious, imaginative, spiritual, and mystical. Derives from Japanese word ‘ ki ’ meaning “ energy. ” Used by many people for many arguments. Everyone believes in something invisible, even if it’s just love or friendship. © M.A. Gilbert 2014
Arguing with People 11 Coalescence Generally, we want arguments to end in agreement. In an inquiry we want to agree we have the best answer. In a negotiation we both want to feel we came out well. In persuasion we want to be satisfied that what we accept is good. © M.A. Gilbert 2014
Arguing with People 12 Merging Begin with agreement Find a common point, goal or value. Move forward until there is divergence. Try and find commonality to merge the divergent views. If there truly is none, then there is no hope. It is almost always possible to find some agreement. © M.A. Gilbert 2014
Arguing with People 13 Humans Actions, expressions, body language all communicate your partner’s reality. You know instantly if your romantic partner is upset. We have to pay attention to far more than words. This is deep listening. © M.A. Gilbert 2014
Arguing with People 14 Audiences All audiences share certain values and beliefs. It may be an audience at work or school, home or pub. You and your friends share certain values – that’s why you’re friends. These form the beginning of avenues for agreement. © M.A. Gilbert 2014
Arguing with People 15 Be Heuristic Being heuristic means having an open and listening attitude. If you are heuristic, being positive and seeking agreement, then, You may be met with aggression. But you are more likely to be met with support. If you are being eristic, i.e., aggressive, you will always be met with aggression. © M.A. Gilbert 2014
Arguing with People 16 Argumentativeness People have traits that social psychologists can measure. One is “argumentativeness.” Just how much is one attracted to arguing? How much does one avoid confrontation of ideas? This is your degree of argumentativeness. © M.A. Gilbert 2014
Arguing with People 17 Aggressivity Some people avoid aggression while others do not mind it. Reasons for this may be personal or cultural. The combination of argumentativeness and aggressivity can be important in how someone approaches argument. You need to pay attention to how your partner approaches or avoids argument. © M.A. Gilbert 2014
Arguing with People 18 TFD TFD = tolerance for disagreement Most people can handle a degree of disagreement Those who can’t have a low TFD – they hate being disagreed with. Low TFDs take argument as a personal attack. The best arguers are those with a high level for argumentativeness and a high TFD. Pay attention to you partners! © M.A. Gilbert 2014
Arguing with People 19 Gender & Argument Women express but do not feel more emotions. Men are only “allowed” to express anger. We play the roles we are expected to play. We see what is there through those lenses. Aggressive men are confident. Aggressive women are bossy. © M.A. Gilbert 2014
Arguing with People 20 Gender as culture We are acculturated to communicate in different ways. Women have different communicative values: Narrative, i.e.., story, is more important. Listening and sympathizing is more important than problem solving. Sharing and concern for community is paramount. (These are grand generalizations, so be careful.) © M.A. Gilbert 2014
Arguing with People 21 End of Part 2 © M.A. Gilbert 2014
Arguing with People Arguing With People By Michael A. Gilbert Professor of Philosophy York University Canada Broadview Press 2014.
Speaking to Persuade Communicating to External Stakeholders.
Building Healthy Relationships Chapter 11 (Grade level: 9-12) (Age 14-18) Rochelle Rich AyawtaTaylor Kristi Caruso.
Use communication skills to influence others.. Persuasion is an important part of communication Want others to understand your message and agree with.
Part I begins: Components of Conflict Chapter 1: Perspectives on Conflict.
ARISTOTLE’S THREE MODES OF RHETORIC
PERSUASION. “Everybody Hates Chris” https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FBlJn99Hrbw.
The Art of Persuasion Communication with a Purpose.
Lecturer: Gareth Jones Class 8: Persuasive Messages.
Lecturer: Gareth Jones Class 12: Persuasive Messages.
What’s in your tool box? “If all you have is a hammer, you will see every problem as a nail.” unknown.
FISH PHILOSOPHY The FISH! Philosophy® emerged in 1998 from Seattle's world-famous Pike Place Fish Market.
A GUIDE TO WRITING WITH READINGS Chapter 13 Persuasion.
What is rhetoric? What you need to know for AP Language.
Relationships. Relationships are the bonds formed between people based on common interests, and often, on affection. People who you have relationships.
Healthy Relationships 6th Grade Health
Assertive Conflict Resolution Win-Win Solutions. Aggressive Behavior When I take my own rights into account and not the other person’s. Everyone should.
LCCC ENG 111 KimAlyse Popkave, M.Ed., CMI, CPPC Instructor1.
What is Persuasive Writing? English 9 Honors November 6 th, 2012.
ARGUMENTATIVE ESSAY A How To Guide. What is an Argumentative Essay? In persuasive or argumentative writing, we try to convince others to agree with our.
Persuasion Is All Around You
Healthy Relationships 6 th Grade Health Bell Ringer Journal Question: Think of someone you like talking with. In a short paragraph, explain why you enjoy.
Effective Public Speaking CHAPTER#5 ANALYZING THE AUDIENCE AND OCCASION.
Communication Skills Personal Commitment Programs or Services Interaction Processes Context.
Public Speaking: ANALYZING AUDIENCE AND SITUATION.
A Lesson on Rhetorical Devices: Ethos, Pathos, Logos
Critical Thinking A key academic skill Required for successful study.
Mr. Valanzano Business Communications. Persuasion – the effort to influence attitudes or behavior Persuasion may reinforce a belief or convince someone.
Looking Out/Looking In Thirteenth Edition 11 Interpersonal Conflicts CHAPTER TOPICS The Nature of Conflict Conflict Styles Conflict in Relational Systems.
Chapter 5 Communications in Intimate Relationships.
Rhetoric In the study of rhetoric, the focus should be how a writer uses elements of language – diction, detail, image, tone, syntax, logical ordering,
Lesson 2 People use many different ways to communicate their feelings. Writing a note Facial expressions Communication is critical to healthy relationships.
READING PERSUASIVE TEXTS What is persuasion? What is persuasion? Persuasion is the act of influencing someone to believe or consider a certain point.
P RESCHOOLERS. I NTELLECTUAL D EVELOPMENT Preschoolers find it hard to look at things from another person’s point of view. Their favorite question it.
Social-Emotional Development of the preschooler
Chapter four Types of Language Functions At the Intermediate stage we deal with only functional language i.e., the language which we use for communication.
Persuasive Speaking How to Give a Persuasive Speech.
IMPROVING INTERPERSONAL RELATIONSHIPS
The technique or study of communication and persuasion The art of creating a text using the most appropriate language to help you achieve your desired.
Managing Interpersonal Conflicts
02 Truth and Rationality Philosophy. 2 Part I: Sentences and Propositions.
Q. ________ refers to the ways in which you send and receive messages.
THE ARGUMENTATIVE OR PERSUASIVE ESSAY Mr.Wilson – LMAC - English.
Persuasive Speeches To persuade is to advocate, to ask others to accept your views. A Pocket Guide to Public Speaking.
Skills for Healthy Relationships
© 2017 SlidePlayer.com Inc. All rights reserved.