Presentation on theme: "Eagle Scout Board of Review"— Presentation transcript:
1 Eagle Scout Board of Review Blackhawk Area Council Advancement CommitteeDr. Roland J. Barnes, Committee Member & Life to Eagle Co-ChairMichael R. Lumpp, Committee Member & Life to Eagle Co-ChairRevised 07/22/14Click to advance
2 Council ApprovalThe Boy Scouts of America has placed the Eagle Scout board of review in the hands of the local council to decide how reviews will be conducted; i.e., the unit, district, or council level.
3 Council ApprovalThe Council Advancement Committee of the Blackhawk Area Council has decided that Eagle Scout reviews will be conducted on the unit level under the direction of the Council Advancement Committee.
4 By Your 18th Birthday Complete all merit badges 13 required and 8 electiveComplete 6 month Position of ResponsibilityComplete Eagle Scout ApplicationComplete Eagle Scout Service ProjectComplete Life Ambitions StatementComplete Scoutmaster Conference
5 Before a BOR is Scheduled All Eagle Scout paperwork must be sent to council for review.Completed Eagle Scout ApplicationCompleted Eagle Scout Service Project WorkbookCompleted Life Ambitions StatementEagle Scout Reference Letters (unopened)Council verifies that all requirements have been met.Once completed the Scout is entitled to an Eagle Scout Board of Review.Both the Scoutmaster and the Committee Chair should sign the Eagle Scout application. If one or both refuse to sign the application, the Scout is still entitled to a board of review. However, this circumstance may be considered by the board of review, and could affect the outcome.
6 Reference LettersThe Eagle Scout application requires that 6 letters be listed.Parents or GuardiansReligiousMay be signed by parent if the Scout does not belong to an organized religion.EducationalMay be signed by parent if the Scout is home schooled.Employer (if any, otherwise omitted)Two other references
7 Reference LettersLetters from references are confidential information and their contents are not to be disclosed to any person who is not a member of the board of review.If the Eagle Scout rank is approved, the district representative will collect and destroy the letters.If the Eagle Scout rank is denied, all reference letters are to be filed at the council service center until a final decision is reached.
8 Board of Review Members The board of review for an Eagle Scout candidate is composed of a minimum of 3 members and a maximum of 6 members, 21 years of age or older.With the exception of the District or Council Advancement representative the remaining members do not have to be registered in Scouting, but they must have an understanding of the importance and purpose of the Eagle Scout rank and the Eagle Scout Board of Review.
9 Board of Review Members At least one district or council advancement committee representative, approved by the district advancement chair, must be a member of the Eagle Scout board of review and may serve as chairperson if so requested by the unit.The unit leader may be present in the room, but does not participate in the board of review.The unit leader may be called upon to clarify a point in question.
10 Board of Review Members A parent, guardian or relative of the candidate should not attend the review, even as a unit leader.Exception may be allowed for Scouts with special needs ( ).Unit leaders, assistant unit leaders, or individuals representing the group for which the Eagle service project was performed may not serve as members of the board of review.It is generally not recommended that, an individual who has written a letter of recommendation, sit on the board of review.The Scout his parents or guardians may have no input into the selection of the board of review members.
11 Clarifying the Active Member Requirement Be active in your troop and patrol for 6 months as a Life Scout means exactly that!To serve as a Life Scout in a leadership position for 6 months.The approved definition of “Active” is found in section on pages of the Guide to Advancement 2013 (#33088).Units may not create their own definition of active.
12 National BSA Definition of Active A Scout will be considered “active” in his unit if:The Scout is registered. The youth is registered in his unit for at least the time period indicated in the requirement, and he has indicated in some way, through word or action, that he considers himself a member.The Scout is in good standing. A Scout is considered in “good standing” with his unit as long as he has not been dismissed for disciplinary reasons. He must also be in good standing with the local council and BSA.The Scout meets the unit’s reasonable expectations; or, if not, a lesser level of activity is explained. Time counted as “active” need not be consecutive.
13 National BSA Definition of Active Alternative to the third test if expectations are not met:If a young man has fallen below his unit’s activity-oriented expectations, then it must be due to other positive endeavors—in or out of Scouting—or to noteworthy circumstances that have prevented a higher level of participation.Would the Scout have been more active if he could have been?It is not so much about what a Scout has done but what he is able to do and how he has grown.
14 Determine Fair Questions There is no standard set of questions that an Eagle candidate should be asked.It is not appropriate to ask questions that probe a Scout’s political views, ethnic background, sexual orientation, or religious practices.Questions such as; “Are you under any scrutiny from any law enforcement agency, your school, or any other such entity that the board may be aware of?”, are fair in helping the board determine the character of a questionable candidate.
15 Board of ReviewBecause of the importance of the Eagle Scout Rank, the decision of the board must be unanimous.If not, a new review may be convened at the request of the applicant, his parents or guardians.Initiating Eagle Scout Board of Review under disputed circumstances, or,Appeals processThe review process should take approximately 30 to 60 minutes to complete.
16 Purpose of the Board of Review To make sure that the Scout has done what he was supposed to do.To see how good an experience the Scout has had in Scouting.To encourage the Scout to remain active in Scouting and provide mentoring to younger Scouts.
17 Purpose of the Board of Review The review is not an examination!The board does not retest the candidate!The board should attempt to determine the Scout’s attitude and his acceptance of Scouting’s ideals with respect to:Experiences with project,Leadership provided,Changes needed,Obstacles encountered and solutions.
18 Purpose of the Board of Review To make sure that good standards have been met in all phases of the Scout’s life.To make sure the candidate understands and lives daily the Scout Oath and Law.To make sure the candidate recognizes the value of Scouting in his home, unit, school, and community.
19 Conducting the Board of Review The board should meet 30 minutes before the candidate appears to review:The application,The service project workbook,The life ambitions statement, andThe reference letters.The board should be held in a relaxed atmosphere.
20 Conducting the Board of Review It is preferred a Scout be in full field uniform for any board of review. If wearing all or part of the uniform is impractical for whatever reason, the candidate should be clean and neat in his appearance and dressed appropriately, according to his means, for the milestone marked by the occasion. (Guide to Advancement 2013, section , page 55.)The board should encourage the Scout to talk so that the review can be a learning experience for him and the members of the board.The Scout reviews what he did for the Eagle rank.From this review, it is determined whether he did what he was supposed to do and what kind of experience he has had in Scouting.
21 Conducting the Board of Review The board should determine the Scout’s ideals and goals.The board should make sure that a good standard of performance has been met.At the conclusion of the board the Scout and his unit leader are asked to step out while the board deliberates.
22 Conducting the Board of Review The decision of the board is arrived at through discussion and must be unanimous.Once the board is satisfied that the Scout has qualified he is called back in and congratulated.He is encouraged to continue his advancement in earning Palms (if time will permit).He is informed that it is not final until approved by National.
23 Advancement ReportThe completed Eagle Scout application and the Advancement Report are sent to council.Council forwards to National.The Scout cannot be recognized until National approves.Do not plan the Court of Honor until application returns from National.
24 WHAT IF?Initiating Eagle Scout Board of Review Under Disputed Circumstances, section , page 59 of Guide to Advancement 2013.Held at the District or Council level.Initiated by Scout, parents or guardians. A letter is written and attached to the Eagle Scout Application and the complete Eagle Packet is sent to Council.Indicated when:A unit Leader or Committee Chair does not sign the application.A Scoutmaster Conference is denied.If it is thought a unit will not provide a fair hearing.If the unit Leader or Project Beneficiary refuses to sign final approval for what might be considered a satisfactory service project.Background and facts are researched including written statements and interview summaries.Can be denied if deemed frivolous. Scout may then appeal the decision.
25 What If?If the board decides that the Scout has not earned the Eagle Scout Rank, the Scout has to be told why.The members of the board should specify what must be done to rework his weaknesses and reconvene the board of review at a later date.A follow-up letter must be sent to the Scout confirming the agreements reached on the actions necessary to satisfactorily complete his work.
26 What If?Should a Scout disagree with the decision, he has the right to appeal.The appeals process should be explained.Guide to Advancement 2013, section , page 60.The Scout and his leader should not be aware of who voted negatively.
27 Appealing the Decision The decision may be appealed to the next higher level.District Advancement Committee, thenCouncil Advancement Committee, thenNational Advancement Team.Only the Scout, his parents or guardians may appeal.
28 Appealing the Decision A letter requesting the appeal is to be mailed to the:Blackhawk Area CouncilCouncil Program Director2820 McFarland RoadRockford, ILThe letter should give as much detail as possible explaining the reason for the appeal.There will be an odd number of appeal board members, either 3 or 5.An appeal board is not another board of review. It focuses only on the issues that brought about rejection at the lower level(s).
29 Scouts 18 Years of Age or Older Scouts who have completed all requirements prior to their 18th birthday should submit their application and be reviewed within 90 days after that date.Boards of review conducted between 90 to 180 days after the Scout’s 18th birthday require a statement explaining the reason for the delay.This letter is attached to the Eagle Scout Application when it is submitted to council.If accepted by council they will grant the extension and the Council Eagle processor will proceed with processing the application.
30 Scouts 18 Years of Age or Older If an Eagle Scout Board of Review will be held after the 180 days following the Scout’s 18th birthday, the candidate must petition the National Advancement Team for an extension.The petition must be processed through the council detailing the extenuating circumstances.The petition is attached to the Eagle Scout Application.If approved National will inform the Council Scout Executive of a timeframe by which the Board of Review is to take place.
31 Resources Guide to Advancement 2013, No. 33088 Scoutmaster Handbook, NoBoy Scout Handbook, NoBoy Scout Requirements Book (Latest Revision), NoEagle Scout Leadership Service Project Workbook (Latest Revision available only online), NoEagle Scout Rank Application (Latest Revision available only online), NoBSA National Website:NESA Website:
32 Blackhawk Area Council Districts ArrowheadSycamoreWanchanagiWetassaWhite Eagle
33 Arrowhead District Contact InformationArrowhead District Advancement ChairDaniel M. FrommeltPhone:Arrowhead District Life to Eagle CoordinatorChris BrunettePhone:
34 Sycamore District Contact InformationSycamore District Advancement ChairGrace EschePhone:Sycamore District Life to Eagle Coordinatorsame
35 Wanchanagi District Contact InformationWanchanagi District Advancement ChairConnie SnyderPhone:Wanchanagi District Life to Eagle CoordinatorIda BolenPhone:
36 Wetassa District Contact InformationWetassa District Advancement ChairLiz HollisPhone:Wetassa District Life to Eagle Coordinatorsame
37 White Eagle District Contact InformationWhite Eagle District Advancement ChairRay GruberPhone:White Eagle Life to Eagle CoordinatorDeb SlagerPhone:
38 Contact InformationBlackhawk Area Council Advancement Committee & Life to Eagle Co-ChairDr. Roland J. BarnesPhone:Michael R. LumppPhone:
39 Thanks for your attention. rjb (SCTEF) 2008Revised 07/22/14