We think you have liked this presentation. If you wish to download it, please recommend it to your friends in any social system. Share buttons are a little bit lower. Thank you!
Presentation is loading. Please wait.
Published byCraig Brann
Modified about 1 year ago
2008 © ChengXiang Zhai Dragon Star Lecture at Beijing University, June 21-30, 2008 1 Write and Publish an IR Paper ChengXiang Zhai Department of Computer Science Graduate School of Library & Information Science Institute for Genomic Biology, Statistics University of Illinois, Urbana-Champaign http://www-faculty.cs.uiuc.edu/~czhai, firstname.lastname@example.org
2008 © ChengXiang Zhai Dragon Star Lecture at Beijing University, June 21-30, 2008 2 When to Write a Paper? Survey/Review paper: –An emerging field or topic has appeared (i.e., a hot topic) but no survey is available, or sufficient new development has occurred such that existing surveys are out of date –You’ve read and digested enough papers about the topic Original research paper: when you have sufficient results to draw an interesting conclusion or answer an interesting research question, i.e., you’ve got a basic story to tell: –A new problem, a solution, and results showing how good the solution is –An old problem, a new solution, and results showing advantage(s) of the new solution over the old ones –An old problem, many old solutions, and results showing an understanding of their relative performance –In general, a research question and an answer
2008 © ChengXiang Zhai Dragon Star Lecture at Beijing University, June 21-30, 2008 3 Before you write any paper, be clear about the targeted readers
2008 © ChengXiang Zhai Dragon Star Lecture at Beijing University, June 21-30, 2008 4 Typical Structure of a Survey Paper Introduction: –Motivation for the survey An emerging field/topic, but no survey available Surveys exist, but they are out of date (e.g., due to new development in a field/topic) –Scope of the survey Background (if necessary) Conceptual framework ( based on synthesis of the literature) –Define basic concepts, terminology, etc –Give a big picture of the topic so that your survey is coherent
2008 © ChengXiang Zhai Dragon Star Lecture at Beijing University, June 21-30, 2008 5 Typical Structure of a Survey Paper (cont.) Systematic review of existing work –It’s very important that you have some clear structure for this part The structure is usually your conceptual framework, or other meaningful structures (e.g., by time or some way to classify all the work) –Be critical! Add your opinions about the work surveyed –Don’t treat every work equally; elaborate on some representative work and simply give pointers to other work Summary –Summarize the progress and the state of the art –Give recommendations if any (e.g., for practitioners) –Outlook (remaining challenges, future directions) References
2008 © ChengXiang Zhai Dragon Star Lecture at Beijing University, June 21-30, 2008 6 Typical Structure of a Research Paper 1. Introduction –Background discussion to motivate your problem –Define your problem –Argue why it’s important to solve the problem –Identify knowledge gap in existing work or point out deficiency of existing answers/solutions –Summarize your contributions –Briefly mention potential impact Tips: –Start with sentences understandable to almost everyone –Tell the story at a high-level so that the entire introduction is understandable to people with no/little technical background in the topic –Use examples if possible
2008 © ChengXiang Zhai Dragon Star Lecture at Beijing University, June 21-30, 2008 7 Typical Structure of a Research Paper (cont.) 2. Previous/Related work –Sometimes this part is included in the introduction or appears later –Previous work = work that you extend (readers must be familiar with it to understand your contribution) –Related work = work related to your work (readers can until later in the paper to know about it) Tips: –Make sure not to miss important related work –Always safer to include more related work –Discuss the existing work and its connection to your work Your work extends … Your work is similar to … but differs in that … Your work represents an alternative way of … –Whenever possible, explicitly discuss your contribution in the context of existing work
2008 © ChengXiang Zhai Dragon Star Lecture at Beijing University, June 21-30, 2008 8 Typical Structure of a Research Paper (cont.) 3. Problem definition/formulation –Clearly define your problem If it’s a new problem, discuss its relation to existing related problems If it’s an old problem, cite the previous work –Justify why you define the problem in this way –Discuss challenges in solving the problem Tips: –Give both an informal description and a formal description if possible –Make sure that you mention any assumption you make when defining the problem (e.g., your focus may be on studying the problem in certain conditions)
2008 © ChengXiang Zhai Dragon Star Lecture at Beijing University, June 21-30, 2008 9 Typical Structure of a Research Paper (cont.) 4. Overview of the solution(s) (can be merged with the next part) –Give a high-level information description of the proposed solutions or solutions you study –Use examples if possible 5. Specific components of your solution(s) –Be precise (formal description helps) –Use intuitive descriptions to help people understand it Tips: –make sure that you organize this part so that it’s understandable to people with various backgrounds –Don’t just throw in formulas; include high-level intuitive desciptions whenever possible
2008 © ChengXiang Zhai Dragon Star Lecture at Beijing University, June 21-30, 2008 10 Typical Structure of a Research Paper (cont.) 6. Experiment design: make sure you justify it –Data set –Measures –Experiment procedure Tips: –Given enough details so that people can reproduce your experiments –Discuss limitation/bias if any, and discuss its potential influence on your study
2008 © ChengXiang Zhai Dragon Star Lecture at Beijing University, June 21-30, 2008 11 Typical Structure of a Research Paper (cont.) 7. Result analysis: –Organized based on research questions to be answered or hypotheses tested –Be comprehensive, but focus on the major conclusions –Include “standard” components Baseline comparison Individual component analysis Parameter sensitivity analysis Individual query analysis Significance test –Discuss the influence of any bias or limitation Tips –Don’t leave any question unanswered (try to provide an explanation for all the observed results) –Discuss your findings in the context of existing work if possible Similar observations have also been made in … This is in contrast to … observed in … One explanation is ….
2008 © ChengXiang Zhai Dragon Star Lecture at Beijing University, June 21-30, 2008 12 Typical Structure of a Research Paper (cont.) 8. Conclusions and future work –Summarize your contributions –Discuss its potential impact –Discuss its limitation and point out directions for future work 9. References
2008 © ChengXiang Zhai Dragon Star Lecture at Beijing University, June 21-30, 2008 13 Where to Publish IR Papers Core IR conferences: –ACM SIGIR, ACM CIKM –ECIR, AIRS Core IR journals –ACM TOIS, IRJ –IPM, JASIS Web Applications –WWW, WSDM Other related conferences –Natural Language Processing: HLT, ACL, NAACL, COLING, EMNLP –Machine Learning: ICML, NIPS –Data Mining: KDD, ICDM –Databases: SIGMOD, VLDB, ICDE …
2008 © ChengXiang Zhai Dragon Star Lecture at Beijing University, June 21-30, 2008 14 What an IR reviewer often looks for Most important factors: –Realistic setup of a retrieval problem What kind of users would benefit from your research? –Solid evaluation of methods Truly state of the art baseline Careful selection of data sets –Use as many representative data sets as possible –Always use a standard data set (e.g., TREC) if possible Careful definition of measures Unbiased experiment procedure General factors: –Quality of argument, novelty, writing, … –Avoid all kinds of careless mistakes! (If you aren’t careful about writing, it’s possible you aren’t careful about your experiments either.)
2008 © ChengXiang Zhai Dragon Star Lecture at Beijing University, June 21-30, 2008 15 After You Get Reviews Back Carefully classify comments into: –Unreasonable comments (e.g., misunderstanding): Try to improve the clarity of your writing –Reasonable comments Constructive: easy to implement Non-constructive: think about it, either argue the other way or mention weakness of your work in the paper If paper is accepted –Take the last chance to polish the paper as much as you can –You’ll regret if later you discover an inaccurate statement of a typo in your published paper If paper is rejected –Digest comments and try to improve the research work and the paper –Run more experiments if necessary –Don’t try to please reviewers (the next reviewer might say something opposite); instead use your own judgments and use their comments to help improve your judgments –Reposition the paper if necessary (again, don’t reposition it just because a reviewer rejected your original positioning)
2008 © ChengXiang Zhai Dragon Star Lecture at Beijing University, June 21-30, 2008 16 Final Tips Start with the core messages you want to convey in the paper and expand your paper by following the core story Try to convey the core messages at different levels so that people with different knowledge background can all get them Try to write a review of your paper yourself, commenting on its originality, technical soundness, significance, evaluation, etc, and then revise the paper if needed Check out reviewer’s instructions, e.g., the following: http://nips07.stanford.edu/nips07reviewers.html (not necessarily matching your conference, but should share a lot of common requirements) http://nips07.stanford.edu/nips07reviewers.html Try to polish English as much as you can
2008 © ChengXiang Zhai Dragon Star Lecture at Beijing University, June 21-30, 2008 17 Good Luck!
2008 © ChengXiang Zhai Dragon Star Lecture at Beijing University, June 21-30, Introduction to IR Research ChengXiang Zhai Department of Computer.
2008 © ChengXiang Zhai Dragon Star Lecture at Beijing University, June 21-30, Prepare Yourself for IR Research ChengXiang Zhai Department of Computer.
Introduction to IR Research Methodology ChengXiang Zhai Department of Computer Science University of Illinois, Urbana-Champaign
2008 © ChengXiang Zhai Dragon Star Lecture at Beijing University, June 21-30, Frame an IR Research Problem and Form Hypotheses ChengXiang Zhai Department.
2008 © ChengXiang Zhai 1 Introduction to Research ChengXiang Zhai Department of Computer Science University of Illinois, Urbana-Champaign
2008 © ChengXiang Zhai 1 Introduction to IR Research ChengXiang Zhai Department of Computer Science Graduate School of Library & Information Science Institute.
IMSS005 Computer Science Seminar Lecture 2 Writing a Literature Review Writing a Research Proposal.
An article review is written for an audience who is knowledgeable in the subject matter instead of a general audience When writing an article review,
Research Methods and Techniques Lecture 8 Technical Writing 1 © 2004, J S Sventek, University of Glasgow.
Critical Reading Strategies: Overview of Research Process
A Quick Guide to beginning Research Where to Start.
How to read a scientific paper Kelly Hogan. What is a Scientific Paper ? A scientific paper is a written and published report describing original research.
2008 © ChengXiang Zhai Dragon Star Lecture at Beijing University, June 21-30, Pick a Good IR Research Problem ChengXiang Zhai Department of Computer.
How to write a professional paper. 1. Developing a concept of the paper 2. Preparing an outline 3. Writing the first draft 4. Topping and tailing 5. Publishing.
Writing tips Based on Michael Kremer’s “Checklist”, Caroline Hoxby’s “Structuring Your Term Paper” and John H. Cochrane’s “Writing Tips for Ph.D. Students”
Manuscript Writing and the Peer-Review Process Josephine Mauskopf, PhD C. Daniel Mullins, PhD.
Introductions and Conclusions CSCI102 - Systems ITCS905 - Systems MCS Systems.
Academic Writing Fatima AlShaikh. A duty that you are assigned to perform or a task that is assigned or undertaken. For example: Research papers (most.
How to Organize your thesis? & Structure of a Research Paper Advanced Research Methodology by Mr. Bilal Ahmad, Lahore Leads University PK.
Abstract An abstract is a concise summary of a larger project (a thesis, research report, performance, service project, etc.) that concisely describes.
Systematic Approaches to Literature Reviewing. The Literature Review ? “Literature reviews …… introduce a topic, summarise the main issues and provide.
WRITING A RESEARCH PROPOSAL. Content What is a proposal? Preparation Structure of a proposal Why research proposal unsuccessful?
Research Methods for Computer Science CSCI 6620 Spring 2014 Dr. Pettey CSCI 6620 Spring 2014 Dr. Pettey.
Literature Review From description to analysis. What is the purpose of a literature review in a research proposal? 1. To introduce the topic area(s) 1.
Writing an Effective Essay A tutorial with Examples.
Experimental Psychology PSY 433 Chapter 5 Research Reports.
Tutorial 1 Dr. Oscar Lin School of Computing and Information Systems Faculty of Science and Technology Athabasca University January 18, 2011.
1 First Workshop on Scientific Research Methodology, KASU, Kaduna February 17, 2010 Proposal Writing, Data Presentation and Report Writing: The Case of.
How to read and comment on a paper? 1.How to read English paper? 2.How to comment on a paper? 3.What are the bad practices you should avoid 4.Your feedback?
Sept 17, 2007C.Watters 1 Reviewing Published Articles.
Methodologies. The Method section is very important because it tells your Research Committee how you plan to tackle your research problem. Chapter 3 Methodologies.
Reading the Literature Psych 231: Research Methods in Psychology.
CS598CXZ (CS510) Advanced Topics in Information Retrieval (Fall 2014) Instructor: ChengXiang (“Cheng”) Zhai 1 Teaching Assistants: Xueqing Liu, Yinan Zhang.
Developing Smart objectives and literature review Zia-Ul-Ain Sabiha.
How Not to Get Your Paper Rejected Mainak Chaudhuri Indian Institute of Technology, Kanpur.
1 How to Present a Paper Jun Dong Cho, Sungkyunkwan University Jun Dong Cho, Sungkyunkwan University03/31/2007.
Writing a Research Proposal 1.Label Notes: Research Proposal 2.Copy Notes In Your Notebooks 3.Come to class prepared to discuss and ask questions.
Dr. Alireza Isfandyari-Moghaddam Department of Library and Information Studies, Islamic Azad University, Hamedan Branch
Getting Funded: How to write a good grant Xander HT Wehrens, M.D. Ph.D. Dept. of Molecular Physiology & Biophysics.
Approaching the Research Proposal Before you can start writing your proposal you need to clarify exactly what you will be doing, why, and how. This is.
© 2005 The McGraw-Hill Companies, Inc. All rights reserved. The Art of Critical Reading Mather ● McCarthy Part 4 Reading Critically Chapter 12 Evaluating.
Introductions & Conclusions. Introductions Reason #1 You never get a second chance to make a first impression. o argument o style o quality of your work.
MScSED THESIS WORKSHOP: 1 ST STEPS NUI Galway May 16 th, 2014.
Researching & Writing a Literature Review Karen Ciccone NCSU Libraries.
Dr. Noura Al-dayan. Problem/Question Observation/Research Formulate a Hypothesis Experiment Collect and Analyze Results Conclusion Communicate the Results.
A Template for Producing IT Research and Publication Hsinchun Chen.
Technical Writing for Computer Science Part 1: Content and Organization Research Careers Lecture Series July 13, 2009 Michael J. Lewis, Director Department.
© 2017 SlidePlayer.com Inc. All rights reserved.