Presentation on theme: "Status of Gender Identity Disorders By Dr Deenesh Khoosal FRCPsych."— Presentation transcript:
Status of Gender Identity Disorders By Dr Deenesh Khoosal FRCPsych
Alternative title? GENDER BENDERS
Terminology Used interchangeably: Gender Dysphoria Gender Identity Disorder Transsexualism
Definition ICD:10 (WHO 1992) definition of transsexualism (F64.0) A desire to live and be accepted as a member of the opposite sex Usually accompanied by a sense of discomfort with, or inappropriateness of one’s anatomic sex A wish to have hormonal treatment and surgery to make one’s body as congruent as possible with the preferred sex. The transsexual identity should have been present persistently for at least two years. It must not be a symptom of another mental disorder, such as schizophrenia or associated with any intersex, genetic or sex chromosome abnormality.
Differential Diagnosis F64.1 Dual Role Transvestism The wearing of clothes of the opposite sex for part of the individuals existence in order to enjoy the temporary existence of membership of the opposite sex but without any desire for a more permanent sex change or associated reassignment. No sexual excitement accompanies the cross dressing.
Differential Diagnosis F65.0 Fetishism Reliance on some non living object as a stimulus for sexual arousal and sexual gratification e.g. texture – plastics, leather, rubber, garment etc.
Differential Diagnosis F65.1 Fetishistic Transvestism The wearing of clothes of the opposite sex principally to obtain sexual excitement. The creation of the appearance of a person of the opposite sex also occurs e.g. wig, makeup etc. Clear association with sexual arousal and the strong desire to remove clothing once orgasm occurs exists. Commonly precedes the development of transsexualism.
Incidence MTF 1:21000 (Wilson et al (1999) British Journal of General Practice) FTM 1:90000 (Van Kesteren et al (1996) Archives of Sexual Behaviour) MTF/FTM 3:1 (DeGuypere et al (2007) European Psychiatry) UK TS people (estimate from Gender Identity Research & Education Society 2004)
Aetiology Unclear - Hermaphrodites – historical, Hijras - Psychosocial – gender identity (pink for girls, blue for boys) - Genetic – Kleinfelter’s, Turner’s Syndromes - Environmental – gender roles (boys = hunter gatherers) - Childhood psychological experiences – outward expression of gender behaviour - Neuro developmental – atypical effects produce sex reversal in bed nucleus of stria terminalis
Companions on Journey Patients themselves Parents often want opposite birth gender baby Parents often dress baby in opposite gender clothes Games of opposite birth gender Friends of opposite birth gender Ritual destruction of hoarded clothes
Companions on Journey Patients themselves Teased/bullied at school PE/games ordeal Shower room ordeal Profound confusion with puberty Stealing clothes of opp. birth gender e.g. washing line Getting caught by family
Companions on Journey Patients themselves Attempts to assimilate e.g. job choice Failed marriage (s) Dressing persists in private Going out fully dressed Internet, U tube, Television etc.
Companions on Journey General Practitioner Assessment History Physical exam Blood tests Referral to specialist services
General Practitioner Liaison with others Health issues e.g. smoking, diet, weight, alcohol, exercise etc Blood test/blood pressure monitoring General health reviews Prescription/administration/monitoring e.g. hormones funding Companions on Journey
General Practitioner Lifelong monitoring blood pressure/blood tests Lifelong hormones - prescription - administration - monitoring Health - prostate - breasts Health issues - smoking, alcohol - diet, weight - exercise Companions on Journey
Psychiatrist - Assessment - Diagnosis - “Gatekeeper to services” - “Right thing at right time” - Monitor real life experience - Support, counselling - Legal matters e.g. documentation, birth certificate - Holistic approach - Funding issues Companions on Journey
Style Therapist Deportment- standing - sitting - walking - social situations Hair- styles - wigs Make up- foundation - choices Clothes- age appropriate - occasion appropriate Safety- personal - public places Feedback- 1:1 +/- group - audio/video
Support Voluntary sector e.g. GIRES, Beaumont Society, WOBs, Mermaid Statutory sector e.g. Gender clinic groups Information leaflets Protocols for service delivery Opinions and second opinion Patient e.g support Group work From families Companions on Journey
Speech Therapist MTF - raise pitch - female type resonance - telephone - 1:1 +/- group work - audio/video feedback FTM - deeper voice - 1:1 +/- group work - audio/video feedback Companions on Journey
Surgical Centres London and new centre in Leeds
Leicester Gender Identity Clinic Programme Directors: KHOOSAL, Deenesh, Psych TERRY, Tim, Urologist Location:Leicester General Hospital (UK) Nuffield Hospital, Leicester (International) Date clinic was founded:1994 Total male to female procedures:517 Total female to male procedures: 42 Total orchidectomies: 62 No. of publications:10 Date Gender Governance started 1998
G3 Gender Clinics Belfast Edinburgh x Glasgow x Leeds Leicester Newcastle Northampton Nottingham x Sheffield York
What do user’s value (local research) 1. Easier access to services - Fiscal constraints 2. Professional – GP, Specialists, Nurses - User organisations – GIRES - Carers 3. Early age for surgery 4. Reduction in long term post op complications
Characteristics of our service users (local research) 1. They tend to be perfectionists 2. Even more preoccupied than eating disorder patients about body image 3. Seek to acquire classical hour glass figure so no confusion can arise
Outcome Green and Flemming (1990) Annual Review of Sex Research FTM: 97% success rate MTF: 87% success rate Smith et al (2005) 98%: no regrets after surgery 91.6%: satisfaction with overall appearance 8.4%:neutral regarding overall appearance
The Perfect Transwoman ?
The Perfect Transman ?
The Reality ?
The Actual Reality Funding variables - post code lottery Idiosyncrasies - some parts but not all Funding cake – resource competition Different processes – NICE/CCG/Local Tx Guidelines – WPATH, UKStandards Legal – IVF, Anti Discrimination laws
Conclusion Shifting goalposts make patients and professionals very angry
Conclusion Gender reassignment is an acceptable option for patients who meet the criteria. Just as IVF is for couples wanting children. Govt has now clarified the latter, so why not for GID? Shouldn’t dividing the cake fairly be the issue?