Presentation is loading. Please wait.

Presentation is loading. Please wait.

Ongoing Research on Software Engineering for Multi-Agent Systems Carlos José Pereira de Lucena Software Engineering Lab (LES) – PUC-Rio.

Similar presentations

Presentation on theme: "Ongoing Research on Software Engineering for Multi-Agent Systems Carlos José Pereira de Lucena Software Engineering Lab (LES) – PUC-Rio."— Presentation transcript:

1 Ongoing Research on Software Engineering for Multi-Agent Systems Carlos José Pereira de Lucena Software Engineering Lab (LES) – PUC-Rio October 2004 – SBES04

2 Software Engineering Lab (LES) – PUC-Rio 2 Presentation Overview Software Agents: Motivation Perspectives on Software Engineering for MASs MAS-SE at LES –MAS Modeling (two approaches) –Developing Method based on Aspects –Technology Evaluation –Technology Transfer Future research directions at LES Conclusions

3 Software Engineering Lab (LES) – PUC-Rio 3 The Scenario With the advances in network-based applications, the introduction of autonomous components in software systems has become usual Software systems will be –Everywhere –Always connected –Always active to perform something on the users behalf

4 Software Engineering Lab (LES) – PUC-Rio 4 New Characteristics of Software Systems 1 Situatedness –Components execute in the context of an environment, and they can influence and be influenced by it Openness –Systems have decentralized management and can dynamically change their structure Locality in control –Components represent autonomous and proactive loci of control Locality in interactions –Components interact with each other accordingly to local patterns 1 F. Zambonelli, H.V.D. Parunak. Towards a Paradigm Change in Computer Science and Software Engineering: A Synthesis. Knowledge Engineering Review, 2004.

5 Software Engineering Lab (LES) – PUC-Rio 5 Software Agents The complexity introduced by this new kind of software systems goes beyond the capabilities of traditional software engineering abstractions, such as objects and components Software Agent –An agent is an interactive computer system that is situated in some environment, and that is capable of autonomous action in this environment in order to meet its design objectives 2 2 M. Wooldridge, N.R. Jennings. Intelligent Agents: Theory and Practice. Knowledge Engineering Review 10(2), 1995, pp

6 Software Engineering Lab (LES) – PUC-Rio 6 O que são Sistemas Multi-Agentes? No ponto de vista de IA –Um sistema multi-agente é uma sociedade de agentes (agentes IA) individuais, que interagem por meio de troca de conhecimento e de negociação para alcançar um objetivo local ou global No ponto de vista de ES –Um sistema multi-agente é um sistema de software composto por diversos locos de controle (agentes ES) encapsulados e independentes, que interagem no contexto específico de uma aplicação

7 Software Engineering Lab (LES) – PUC-Rio 7 Agency Characteristics Characteristics of multi-agent systems include –Autonomy Capable of acting without direct external intervention –Interactivity Communicates with the environment and other agents –Adaptation Capable of responding to other agents and/or its environment to some degree –Pro-activity Goal-oriented - it does not simply react to the environment

8 Software Engineering Lab (LES) – PUC-Rio 8 Agency Characteristics (contd) Characteristics of multi-agent systems include –Learning Modify its behavior based on its experience –Rationality Able to choose an action based on internal goals –Mobility Able to transport itself from one environment to another

9 Software Engineering Lab (LES) – PUC-Rio 9 Evolution of SE Paradigms Time Abstractions determined by the machine architecture Abstractions determined by the problem domain Assembly Languages Functional Abstraction Structured Programming Object-Orientation Components Design Patterns... Software Agents

10 Software Engineering Lab (LES) – PUC-Rio 10 Todays Technological Environment The advances in Internet technologies increased the demand for the development of distributed, heterogeneous and complex systems The evolution of the Web towards a Semantic Web is creating contents that can be directly manipulated by processes Software agents embody distribution and heterogeneity and, thus, they are indicated as the new abstraction for the engineering of complex distributed systems

11 Software Engineering Lab (LES) – PUC-Rio 11 The Multi-Agent Paradigm The Multi-Agent paradigm offers –A decomposition model –An abstraction for software development based on the problem domain –A model of system development as a composition of organizational units –A decentralization model to reduce the unit coupling

12 Software Engineering Lab (LES) – PUC-Rio 12 Experimental Development since 1998 AulaNetLearning Management System 2BuyNete-Business (B2C) VBrokere-Business (B2C) VMarkete-Business (C2C) iDeale-Business (B2B) CommercePipee-Business (C2B) PortalWareKnowledge Management SkillOSkill Management WebClipperWeb Crawling

13 Software Engineering Lab (LES) – PUC-Rio 13 The State of the Art of SE-MAS Software Engineering for Multi-agent Systems at a very early stage –Several proposals, little agreement –AOSE/AAMAS, SELMAS/ICSE –JAAMAS Ad-hoc or proprietary development Lack of an assessment of the impacts of the agent technology on software development There is a need to develop a proper Software Engineering for the Agent Paradigm

14 Software Engineering Lab (LES) – PUC-Rio 14 Research Topics Agent-oriented requirements analysis and specification Best practice in agent-oriented development Engineering large-scale agent systems Experiences with field-tested agent systems Formal methods for agent-oriented systems, including specification and verification logics

15 Software Engineering Lab (LES) – PUC-Rio 15 Research Topics (contd) Implications of agent-oriented software on organizational and social structures within and between companies (e.g. changes in roles, responsibilities, transparency, business processes and decision schemes) Integration of agent-oriented software into existing business processes and implications on business process re-engineering Market and other economic models in agent systems engineering

16 Software Engineering Lab (LES) – PUC-Rio 16 Research Topics (contd) Methodologies for agent-oriented analysis and design Model checking for agent-oriented systems Model-driven architecture (MDA) for MAS Practical coordination and cooperation frameworks for agent systems Refinement and synthesis techniques for agent-based specifications Relationship of AOSE to other SE paradigms (e.g., OO)

17 Software Engineering Lab (LES) – PUC-Rio 17 Research Topics (contd) Re-use approaches for agent-oriented software, including design patterns, frameworks, components, and architectures Software development environments and CASE tools for AOSE Standard APIs for agent programming Standardizations for AOSE UML and agent systems Verification and validation techniques for agent-based systems

18 Software Engineering Lab (LES) – PUC-Rio 18 MAS-SE at LES MAS Conceptual Framework –TAO MAS Modeling –ANote –MAS-ML Developing Methods and Frameworks –Aspect-oriented agent patterns

19 Software Engineering Lab (LES) – PUC-Rio 19 MAS Conceptual Frameworks Describe the structure of the abstractions of MAS Examples –KAoS, d'Inverno and Luck, Yu and Schmidt Issues –The description of the interplay between these abstractions –The description of the other MAS abstractions surrounding the agent, such as environment and organization –The use of the abstractions to guide the creation of models

20 Software Engineering Lab (LES) – PUC-Rio 20 The TAO Conceptual Meta-model Defines a core set of MAS abstractions –The entities that may be described in MAS, their properties and the relationships associated with them (structural aspects of MAS) –The creation and destructions of entities and also defines domain-independent behavior (dynamic aspects of MAS) Defines a core set of MAS relationships TAO groups together the abstractions that are frequently described in the literature for MAS

21 Software Engineering Lab (LES) – PUC-Rio 21 The TAO 3 Abstractions –Agent, object, environment, organization and role Relationships –Inhabit, ownership, play, control, dependency, association, aggregation/composition and specialization 3 V. Silva et al. Taming Agents and Objects in Software Engineering. In: Garcia et al. (eds.) Software Engineering for Large-Scale Multi-Agent Systems, LNCS 2603, 2003, pp

22 Software Engineering Lab (LES) – PUC-Rio 22 MAS Modeling languages and methodologies MAS modeling languages that do not extend UML –Gaia, MaSE –ANote (Choren et al, SELMAS 2004), CAMLE (Shan and Zhu, SELMAS 2004) MAS modeling languages that extend UML –AUML, AORML –MAS-ML (Silva et al, LNCS 2940, 2004) Methodologies that use or extend MAS modeling languages –MESSAGE, Prometheus

23 Software Engineering Lab (LES) – PUC-Rio 23 MAS Modeling Languages that Do Not Extend UML Issues –Do not have a conceptual framework –Overuse or lack information on diagrams (scattered design of the system) –Miss the definition of the non-agent entities (environmental resources) –Do not explicitly show the agency properties such as adaptation or autonomy

24 Software Engineering Lab (LES) – PUC-Rio 24 MAS Modeling Languages that Extend UML Issues –Do not explicitly define the extensions applied to the UML meta-model –Do not define guidelines to implement the systems modeled using the language –Do not model the same of the structural aspects and dynamic aspects frequently described in MAS –Heavy

25 Software Engineering Lab (LES) – PUC-Rio 25 The ANote 4 Lightweight, agent-oriented notation language Focus –Specification of systems with distributed computing, agents and knowledge representation (ontology) Characteristics –Agent-centric / Agency features –Goal-oriented –Design views 4 R. Choren, C. Lucena. Modeling Multi-agent Systems with ANote. Journal of Software and Systems Modeling, 2004.

26 Software Engineering Lab (LES) – PUC-Rio 26 ANote Conceptual Meta-model

27 Software Engineering Lab (LES) – PUC-Rio 27 Views Each concept defines a perspective or view ANote defines seven views each of which has its own representation (diagram)

28 Software Engineering Lab (LES) – PUC-Rio 28 ANote Goal View Provides an initial identification of a tree of goals that outline the functions performed by the agents They are specified from elaborations, process descriptions and system problem (functional decomposition)

29 Software Engineering Lab (LES) – PUC-Rio 29 ANote Agent View Specifies the agent types of the multi-agent application solution and their relationships (system structural base) They are specified from the logical subdivision of the systems functional goals

30 Software Engineering Lab (LES) – PUC-Rio 30 ANote Ontology View Identifies the non-agent components of the system, specified with an ontology They are specified from the system environment resources, their relationships and functions (object- oriented approach) UML Class Diagram used as notation

31 Software Engineering Lab (LES) – PUC-Rio 31 ANote Scenario View Captures agent behavior in specific contexts Describe how goals can be achieved by an ordering of actions and events It specifies the normal course of action and the alternative paths of execution (emergent context) Shows the agents, interactions and plans involved in achieving a goal in a context (enterprise modeling) Scenario table used as notation

32 Software Engineering Lab (LES) – PUC-Rio 32 ANote Planning (Action) View Specifies the execution states, or actions, an agent has to perform to compute an action plan (derived from a scenario that illustrated a goal) It allows the modeling of the agents workflows

33 Software Engineering Lab (LES) – PUC-Rio 33 ANote Interaction (Message) View Shows the structural organization of agents that send and receive messages while executing an action plan It allows the modeling of the interaction protocols (conversation graphs)

34 Software Engineering Lab (LES) – PUC-Rio 34 ANote Organization View Specifies the multi-agent system implementation unit that offers services (set of goals), accessed by an interface (set of message protocols) There is no basic approach to split the agents into logical organizations (it is not a property of the abstraction, but a design decision)

35 Software Engineering Lab (LES) – PUC-Rio 35 ANote Diagrams in a Nutshell

36 Software Engineering Lab (LES) – PUC-Rio 36 ANote Diagrams in a Nutshell

37 Software Engineering Lab (LES) – PUC-Rio 37 Some Usage Examples Agent Marketplace Web-based Insurance System Basic Railcar Control System Trading Agent Competition (TAC)

38 Software Engineering Lab (LES) – PUC-Rio 38 Ongoing Research on ANote Tool support –Graphical tool –Internal XML representation –Eclipse Platform plug-in Translation (from model to code) support –MAS Framework (TAC) –Transformation from ANote models XML representations to MAS Framework

39 Software Engineering Lab (LES) – PUC-Rio 39 The MAS-ML 5 Extended UML notation language Focus –Specification of the structural and dynamic aspects of MAS through a conservative extension of UML Characteristics –Agent/organization-centric (based on TAO meta-model) –UML extension –Structural and dynamic aspects 5 V.T. Silva, C.J.P. Lucena. From a Conceptual Framework to a Multi-Agent System Modeling Language. Journal of Autonomous Agents and Multi-Agent Systems 9(1/2), 2004, pp

40 Software Engineering Lab (LES) – PUC-Rio 40 MOF Architecture Meta-model layer Domain model layer Meta-meta-model layer Instance layer MOF meta-meta-model ER meta-meta-model UML meta-model TAO meta-model MAS-ML meta-model instantiation MAS-ML models unification

41 Software Engineering Lab (LES) – PUC-Rio 41 The MAS-ML Meta-model

42 Software Engineering Lab (LES) – PUC-Rio 42 The MAS-ML Meta-model Class AgentClass ObjectRoleClassOrganizationClass AgentRoleClass EnvironmentClass define play 1 1..*0..* define 1 sub-org play 1..*1 play in 0..* 1..* 1 inhabit 1 0..* inhabit 1 0..* play 1 0..* 1 sub- org 0..*1 play in 0..* Relationship Directed Relationship Classifier Element Association DependencyOwnershipInhabitControlPlayGeneralization 1..* Meta-classes of UML meta-model New meta-classes Legend

43 Software Engineering Lab (LES) – PUC-Rio 43 MAS-ML Class Diagram Represents the relationships between the classes and other MAS entities Second-hand BooksImported Books Item Book Virtual Marketplace inhabit specialization association AgentA AgentB Organization A Object / Environment Agent Organization Legend:

44 Software Engineering Lab (LES) – PUC-Rio 44 MAS-ML Organization Diagram Models the organizations and the relationships between the organizations and other MAS entities

45 Software Engineering Lab (LES) – PUC-Rio 45 MAS-ML Role Diagram Models the roles and the relationships between the roles

46 Software Engineering Lab (LES) – PUC-Rio 46 MAS-ML Sequence Diagram Represents the interactions between the MAS instances and the intra-actions defined by each instance New elements to represent interactions –The concept of message was extended –New stereotypes associated with messages were created –Extensions to model protocols were defined New elements to represent intra-actions –Extensions to model the execution of plans and actions were defined

47 Software Engineering Lab (LES) – PUC-Rio 47 MAS-ML Sequence Diagram New pathnames and icons

48 Software Engineering Lab (LES) – PUC-Rio 48 Bob/buyerOfBooks/Bookfinder/Place-A : UserAgent/Buyer/ GeneralStore/VirtualMarketplace Search for organization Check_organization_goals Check_organization_roles Entering organization BrandNewBookstore/marketOfUsedBooks/Bookfinder/Place-A : Second-handBookstore/MarketOfUsedGoods/ GeneralStore/VirtualMarketplace Request (OrgGoals) Get_organization_goals Managing entrance Inform (OrgGoals) Request (OrgRoles) Get_organization_roles Inform (OrgRoles) Select_role_to_play Inform (RoleToPlay) Register_itself_in_organization Bob/buyerOfSecond-handBooks/Bookfinder/Place-A : UserAgent/BuyerOfSecond-handBooks/ GeneralStore/VirtualMarketplace > Inform (Buyer_of_second_hand_books) Entering organization Search_for_announcement Request (Announcement)... Place-A : VirutalMarketplace getOrganizations() Vector plan action message stereotype method invocation environment agent organization

49 Software Engineering Lab (LES) – PUC-Rio 49 Some Usage Examples Simple Matching System Agent Marketplace Paper Submission and Reviewing System Simple Supply-chain Management System

50 Software Engineering Lab (LES) – PUC-Rio 50 Ongoing Research on MAS-ML Preliminary approach to code generation Tool support –Graphical tool –Create the MAS-ML DTD based on the extended MAS-ML grammar –Transform XMI based on MAS-ML DTD into XMI based on UML DTD –MAS-ML Formalization –MAS-ML Analyzer

51 Software Engineering Lab (LES) – PUC-Rio 51 The Aspect-Oriented Agents 6 6 Garcia, A. F.; Lucena, C. J. P.; Cowan, D. D.; Agents in Object-Oriented Software Engineering. In Software: Practice & Experience, Elsevier, vol. 34, Issue 5, pp , May Agents with aspect-orientation Focus –Specification of an architecture and of a pattern language for agents using the aspect-oriented approach Characteristics –Aspect-oriented –Architectural Method (kernel and agenthood properties) –Pattern language

52 Software Engineering Lab (LES) – PUC-Rio 52 The Architectural Problem The agent properties are not orthogonal –Crosscut each other and the agents basic functionality Collaboration MobilityLearning Roles Interaction AdaptationAutonomy Basic Functionality architectural component

53 Software Engineering Lab (LES) – PUC-Rio 53 The Architectural Problem (contd) Multiple agent types heterogeneous architectures Collaboration Mobility Roles Interaction AdaptationAutonomy Basic Functionality A Reactive Information Agent Interaction AdaptationAutonomy Learning Roles A Cognitive User Agent Basic Functionality Need for a more flexible architectural approach

54 Software Engineering Lab (LES) – PUC-Rio 54 The Design Problem Collaboration Agent goals... addGoal() executePlan() … InterfaceAgent receiveInstruction() monitor()... InformationAgent search(Keyword) search(Keywords) … UserAgent getUser() checkPreference() … Role agents protocol Caller sendRequest() receiveResponse()... Answerer receiveRequest() sendResponse()... Plan goal preCond() posCond( ) … action1() action2()... Plan1 action1() action2() action3()... Plan2 Basic Functionality getName() addAgent() … caller answerer DBuserNameuser efectors adapters threads adapters move() returnHome() itinerary processInformation() LCs processInformation() LCs move() returnHome() startRole() itinerary remoteEnvironments roles processInf () startRole() LCs roles processInf () LCs sendMsg() receiveMsg() addAdapter() removeAdapter() notifyAdapters() makeDecision() startThread() roles startRole() addAdapter() removeAdapter() notifyAdapters() Mobility Collaboration Adaptation Autonomy Interaction Learning public Result searchKW(String KW) { adaptKnowledge(KW); processInformation(KW);... >... if (result = null) { this.move(KW) }

55 Software Engineering Lab (LES) – PUC-Rio 55 The Proposed Solution software architecture detailed design implementation Architectural Method Pattern Language Implementation Framework

56 Software Engineering Lab (LES) – PUC-Rio 56 The Architectural Method Step 1: define the agent kernel Belief Goal Plan Kernel Agent name goals plans … new() addBelief() setGoal() executePlan()... Garcia, A., Kulesza, U., Lucena, C. Aspectizing Multi-Agent Systems: From Architecture to Implementation. Software Engineering for Multi-Agent Systems III, Springer LNCS, State-of-the-Art Survey, December (prelo)

57 Software Engineering Lab (LES) – PUC-Rio 57 The Architectural Method (contd) Step 2: Define the agenthood properties Belief Goal Plan Kernel Agent name goals plans new() addBelief() setGoal() executePlan()... Interaction Goal Creation Autonomy Execution Autonomy Knowledge Adaptation Message Sending Message Reception Legend: aspectual component crosscutting interface normal interface

58 Software Engineering Lab (LES) – PUC-Rio 58 The Architectural Method (contd) Step 3: define the agent types Kernel InterfaceAgent receiveInstruction() monitor() memorize()... InformationAgent search(Keyword) search(Keywords) search(Sentences) … UserAgent getUser() checkPreference() … Agent name beliefs goals plans... addBelief() addGoal() executePlan() …

59 Software Engineering Lab (LES) – PUC-Rio 59 The Architectural Method (contd) Step 4: define the additional properties Kernel Information Gathering Learning InterfaceAgent receiveInstruction() monitor() memorize()... InformationAgent search(Keyword) search(Keywords) search(Sentences) … UserAgent getUser() checkPreference() … Collaboration Protocol Collaboration Legend: aspectual component crosscutting interface normal interface

60 Software Engineering Lab (LES) – PUC-Rio 60 The Pattern Language absent knowledge Environment AgenthoodAdditional Properties Autonomy Mobility Legend: Crosscuts new message incoming message new goal collaboration joining agent creation Kernel new event absent knowledge new event outgoing message Roles InteractionLearning Adaptation

61 Software Engineering Lab (LES) – PUC-Rio 61 The Adaptation Pattern The Adaptation concern –Observes events –Triggers the adaptation strategy –Adapts the agent knowledge or behavior Problem: how to separate the adaptation concern from the other agency concerns?

62 Software Engineering Lab (LES) – PUC-Rio 62 The Adaptation Pattern (contd) Collaboration Kernel AgentBeliefs name addAdapter() removeAdapter() notifyAdapters() PrimitiveBeliefs … CompositeBeliefs update() Observable addAdapter() removeAdapter() notifyAdapters() Adapter adapt() Observer goals plans adapters addAdapter() removeAdapter() notifyAdapters() addAgent() removeAgent() executePlan()... Role collaboratingAgents collaborationProtocol adapters addAdapter() removeAdapter() notifyAdapters() addAgent() … Chair papers submissionDeadline reviewDeadline addAgent() removeAgent() … Reviewer MyPaper new() coauthors keywords publisher status chair toReviewPapers reviewDeadline fillForm() updateForm() getChairName() … Legend: Adaptation Concern

63 Software Engineering Lab (LES) – PUC-Rio 63 The Adaptation Pattern (contd) Solution Behavior Adapation adapters adaptBelief() findPlan() adaptSpecificBelief() findSpecificPlan() Agent Belief knowledge elements observed Aspect newGoal_() failedPlan_() planFinal_() changedBelief_() newMsg_() Knowledge Adaptation executePlan() Plan Agent setGoal() Adapter adapt() Legend: _beforeAdvice afterAdvice_ _aroundAdvice_

64 Software Engineering Lab (LES) – PUC-Rio 64 Method Evaluation 4 qualitative studies and 1 quantitative study 3 prototypes in different application domains Portalware URL: ExpertCommittee URL: Aspect-oriented metrics suite –Cohesion, coupling, size, separation of concerns 1. Sant'Anna, C., Garcia, A., Kulesza, U., Lucena, C., Staa, A. Design Patterns as Aspects: A Quantitative Assessment. Proceedings of the SBES04, Brasília, Brazil, October Garcia, A. et al. Separation of Concerns in Multi-Agent Systems: An Empirical Study. In: "Software Engineering for Multi-Agent Systems II", Springer-Verlag, LNCS 2940, State-of-the-Art Survey, January 2004, pp SantAnna, C., Garcia, A., Chavez, C., Lucena, C., Staa, A. On the Reuse and Maintenance of Aspect-Oriented Software: An Assessment Framework. Proceedings of the SBES03, Manaus, Brazil, October Garcia, A., Chavez, C., Torres, V., Lucena, C. Engineering Multi-Agent Systems with Patterns and Aspects. Journal of the Brazilian Computer Society, SBC, Number 1, Volume 8, July 2002, pp

65 Software Engineering Lab (LES) – PUC-Rio 65 Ongoing Research on Aspect-Oriented Agents The generative approach More experimentation Refinement of patterns (ex: learning and mobility)

66 Software Engineering Lab (LES) – PUC-Rio 66 Technology Evaluation Trading Agent Competition The Trading Agent Competition (TAC) is an international forum designed to promote and encourage high quality research into the trading agent problem. The scenarios –TAC Classic - a "travel agent" scenario based on complex procurement on multiple simultaneous auctions –TAC SCM - a PC manufacturer scenario based on sourcing of components, manufacturing of PC's and sales to customers The TAC 2004 is the fifth event (Classic). The TAC research community: –USA, Canada, Mexico, Brazil, France, UK, Sweden, Netherlands, Germany, Turkey, Israel, Macau, China, Japan, Australia, etc.

67 Software Engineering Lab (LES) – PUC-Rio 67 TAC Classic

68 Software Engineering Lab (LES) – PUC-Rio 68 TAC – Trading Agent Competition PositionAgentAffiliation Average Score Games Played 1whitebear04Cornell University, USA WalverineUniversity of Michigan, USA LearnAgentsPUC-Rio, Brazil SICS02SICS, Sweden NNNHebrew University, Israel UMTac-04 University of Utrecht, Netherlands The Chinese University of Hong Kong, China RoxyBotBrown University, USA Final Scores for TAC CLASSIC (2004).

69 Software Engineering Lab (LES) – PUC-Rio 69 LearnAgents – A Multi-Agent System for the TAC Classic Corporate Knowledge Base Flight, Hotel, and Ticket Negotiators Flight, Hotel, and Ticket Sensors Flight and Hotel Price Predictor Ordering Agents (Flight & Hotels, Tickets) Allocator Master + Allocator Slaves Monitor Agent

70 Software Engineering Lab (LES) – PUC-Rio 70 LearnAgents – A Multi-Agent System for the TAC Classic CPU 1 Flight, Hotel, Ticket Sensors (3) –Update Prices in the Knowledge Base –Filter the events from the environment Flight and Hotel Price Predictor (2) –Flight: Maximum Likelihood –Hotel: Moving Average Allocator Master (1) –Calculates 50 allocations per minute –Integer Programming Ordering Agent (2) –Decide which allocation to use, and decides the next strategy. Flight, Hotel and Ticket Negotiators (28) –Negotiates based on the strategy defined by the Ordering Agent –Hotel: MiniMax, Neural Network, Temporal Difference Learning, LMS Learning CPU 2 Monitor Agent (1) –Stores important data from each agent –Monitor the Performance of each Agent and the Agency CPU 3 Allocator Slave (2) –Calculates Ticket Allocation –Calculates High Price –Integer Programming

71 Software Engineering Lab (LES) – PUC-Rio 71 Parameters of the Agents Tuning Monitor the Performance of each Agent Monitor the Performance of the Agency

72 Software Engineering Lab (LES) – PUC-Rio 72 Some Future Directions at LES The generative approach Law governing in Multi-agent systems Architectures –Component-based –ASF Framework (MAS-ML-based) Tool support Case study development

73 Software Engineering Lab (LES) – PUC-Rio 73 Technology Transfer: MindsatWork Ltda. Agent-Based WebClipper (instance of a Multi-Agent based Framework) A Multi-Agent Based Architecture for the Development of Control and Acquisition Systems (Petrobras, Biogenie)

74 Software Engineering Lab (LES) – PUC-Rio 74 Technology Transfer: Modulo Security Solutions S.A. A Multi-Agent System for Monitoring News about Information Security An Agent-Based Remote Analysis of the Vulnerability of a Computer System.

75 Software Engineering Lab (LES) – PUC-Rio 75 Conclusions Software Everywhere Development and adoption of agent technology We are in the infancy of SELMAS

76 Software Engineering Lab (LES) – PUC-Rio 76 References TAO Conceptual Framework V.T. Silva, A. Brandão, C. Chavez, C. Lucena, P.S.C. Alencar. Taming Agents and Objects in Software Engineering. In: A. Garcia, et al. (eds.) Software Engineering for Large-Scale Multi-Agent Systems. Lecture Notes in Computer Science, LNCS 2603, 2004, pp ANote R. Choren, C. Lucena. Modeling Multi-agent Systems with ANote. Journal on Software and Systems Modeling, R. Choren, C. Lucena. Agent-Oriented Modeling Using ANote. Proceedings of the 3rd International Workshop on Software Engineering for Large-Scale Multi-Agent Systems, SELMAS, 2004, pp

77 Software Engineering Lab (LES) – PUC-Rio 77 References (contd) MAS-ML V.T. Silva, C.J.P. Lucena. From a Conceptual Framework to a Multi- Agent System Modeling Language. Journal of Autonomous Agents and Multi-Agent Systems, 9(1/2), 2004, pp V. Silva, R. Choren, C. Lucena. Using the MAS-ML to Model a Multi- Agent System. In: C. Lucena et al. (eds.) Software Engineering for Multi-Agent Systems II. Lecture Notes in Computer Science, LNCS 2940, 2004, pp The Aspect-Oriented Architectural Method A. Garcia, C. Lucena, D. Cowan. Agents in Object-Oriented Software Engineering. Software: Practice and Experience, Elsevier, 2004, pp A. Garcia, et al. An Aspect-Based Approach for Developing Multi-Agent Object-Oriented Systems. Proceedings of the 15th Brazilian Symposium on Software Engineering, SBES, 2001, pp

78 Software Engineering Lab (LES) – PUC-Rio 78 References (contd) The Aspect-Oriented Agent Architecture A. Garcia, U. Kulesza, C. Lucena. Separation of Concerns in Open Multi- Agent Systems: An Architectural Approach. Proceedings of the 3rd International Workshop on Software Engineering for Large-Scale Multi-Agent Systems, SELMAS, 2004, pp Case Studies K. Silva, R. Choren, C. Lucena. Applying A Note to modeling Multi Agent Systems - A Case Study in E-Business. Proceedings of the IASTED International Conference on Software Engineering, SE, 2004, pp F. Melo, et al. Deploying Agents with the CORBA Component Model. In: W. Emmerich, A.L. Wolf (eds.) Component Deployment. Lecture Notes in Computer Science, LNCS 3083, 2004, pp

79 Software Engineering Lab (LES) – PUC-Rio 79 References (contd) Case Studies (contd) V. Silva, R. Choren, C. Lucena. A UML Based Approach for Modeling and implementing Multi-Agent Systems. Proceedings of the 3rd International Conference on Autonomous Agents and Multi-Agent Systems, AAMAS, A. Garcia, et al. Engineering Multi-Agent Systems with Aspects and Patterns. Journal of the Brazilian Computer Society, Special Issue on Software Engineering and Databases, 8(1), 2002, pp A. Garcia, et al. Separation of Concerns in Multi-Agent Systems: An Empirical Study. In: C. Lucena, et al. (eds.) Software Engineering for Multi-Agent Systems II. Lecture Notes in Computer Science, LNCS 2940, 2004, pp

80 Software Engineering Lab (LES) – PUC-Rio 80 References (contd) TAC Jose Alberto R. P. Sardinha, Ruy L. Milidiú, Carlos J. P. Lucena, Patrick M. Paranhos, Pedro Cunha. LearnAgents - A multi-agent system for the TAC Classic. Poster Session at AAMAS' Trading Agent Competition, New York, NY, July Jose Alberto R. P. Sardinha, Alessandro F. Garcia, Carlos J. P. Lucena, Ruy L. Milidiú. On the Incorporation of Learning in Open Multi-Agent Systems: A Systematic Approach. Sixth International Bi-Conference Workshop on Agent Oriented Information Systems(AOIS-2004) at CAiSE 2004, Riga, Latvia, Jun (to appear)

81 Software Engineering Lab (LES) – PUC-Rio 81 Thank You Prof. Carlos José Pereira de Lucena Software Engineering Lab (LES)

Download ppt "Ongoing Research on Software Engineering for Multi-Agent Systems Carlos José Pereira de Lucena Software Engineering Lab (LES) – PUC-Rio."

Similar presentations

Ads by Google