Presentation is loading. Please wait.

Presentation is loading. Please wait.

Cuba Water/Wastewater Infrastructure Assessment Committee Water and Wastewater Priorities and Cost- Benefit Considerations: A “Work-In-Progress” To:Association.

Similar presentations


Presentation on theme: "Cuba Water/Wastewater Infrastructure Assessment Committee Water and Wastewater Priorities and Cost- Benefit Considerations: A “Work-In-Progress” To:Association."— Presentation transcript:

1 Cuba Water/Wastewater Infrastructure Assessment Committee Water and Wastewater Priorities and Cost- Benefit Considerations: A “Work-In-Progress” To:Association for the Study of the Cuban Economy (A.S.C.E.) Miami, Florida August 1, 2009 By: Armando I. Perez, Roberto Cardona, Luis Locay and Helena Solo-Gabriele

2 Disclaimer   The opinions expressed in this presentation are those of the authors and do not necessarily represent the views of their employers or of their sponsoring engineering societies.   Authors’ knowledge of Cuba is based on limited information available mostly on the Internet and personal communication with Cubans now living in Florida.

3 Outline of Presentation   “Big Picture” water resources issues   Eight (8) Priority watersheds   Almendares/vento watershed issues – –Protection of water sources from wastewater – –Treatment and distribution of potable water   Cotorro case study: cost-benefit considerations   Conclusions

4 Source Water  Total water use (potential $1 to 4 billion/yr industry) –5.2 billion m3 (Cereijo ed. 1992) –1.6 billion m3/yr (11.5 M people at 100 gpd)  64% groundwater (Cereijo ed. 1992)  Groundwater predominates in western provinces, surface water in eastern provinces  Susceptible to saltwater intrusion  Use approaching “safe yield” (sustainable supply)

5 Eight (8) Watersheds of National Interest Source: Jorge Mario Garcia Fernández (Director Watershed INRH), “Cuban Experiences in the Institutionalization of Integrated Management of Watersheds, “Voluntad Hidráulica (INRH Journal), No. 98, pp Provinces (Some Straddling) 6 Have Watershed Councils (Handle Straddles) 15 % of Cuba’ Surface 40 % of Cuba’s Population 60% of Cuba’s Fundamental Economic Activity

6 Almendares-Vento (570K): Contamination of Almendares River (connection to groundwater supply). Erosion Ariguanabo (90K): Contamination of Rivers (connection to groundwater supply). Deforestation. Poor drainage. Cauto (1,170K): Contamination (652 sources). Poor drainage. Erosion Toa (12K): Ecological diversity. Contamination (29 sources). Deforestation. Erosion Guantanamo-Guaso (410K): Drought. Salt accumulation Hanabanilla (7K): Erosion Zaza (264K): Contamination (94 sources). Deforestation. Erosion Cuyaguateje (40K): Poor drainage, salt water intrusion. Erosion 1420 /km /km /km /km 2

7 Hierarchical Approach to Water Management Cycle Potable Water Distribution Wastewater Collection Wastewater Treatment Effluent Disposal Identify/ Protect Water Source Treat Water to Prevent acute illness long-term illness and improve aesthetics Treatment and Distribution Protect Water Source

8 Source Water: Almendares-Vento  Vento Aquifer serves 47% of Havana Population Located directly beneath the Almendares River ALMENDARES RIVER VENTO AQUIFER RESERVOIR

9 Major Contaminant Sources Almendares River Vento Aquifer Reservoir Papelera Nacional Cubana Near Puentes Grandes

10 Sanitary Sewer Networks 1946, Sewer Construction U.Miami Photo Archive Planta Quibu, Cubagua 2007 Alamar (96K) No Treatment Cotorro (20K -75K) No Treatment Lower Almendares (103K) No Treatment Maria del Carmen (23K) Primary and Secondary Central (945K) Primary Puentes Grandes ?(200K) No Treatment San Pedro Pump Station

11 Wastewater Priorities Repair and Expand Cotorro WW(75K) Domestic + Industrial BMP Agriculture Central (945K) Primary Rehabilitate & Expand Sewer Lines San Pedro Pump, 2008 San Pedro Pump Station, 2008 Antillana de Acero Maria del Carmen (23K  73K) Primary and Secondary Repair and Expand Calle 100 Landfill Investigate Puentes Grandes and Lower Almendares Networks Investigate Industry Pre-Treatment

12 Water Distribution Water Rations (Perez Martinez 2003) Water Distribution Map for Havana, 1899 Central (817K) 5,2 m 3 /d West (447K) 3.3 m 3 /d South (370K) 2.0 m 3 /d East (546K) 5,0 m 3 /d

13 Water Priorities Repair Chlorine Production Facility at Sagua la Grande Trucks/fuel to transport chlorine Repair leaks in transmission and distribution system. Adding valves and metering Improve interconnectedness of the networks. Back up electricity and pumps (with surge suppressors). Repair chlorination equipment.

14 Background: Cotorro, Cuba The town's population comprises approximately 74,500 inhabitants ~ 50% of land used for agriculture Approximate land area is 65.7 km 2

15 Location Of Proposed Wastewater Plant For Cotorro San Pedro Pump Station

16 4 Phase Design for Cotorro WWTP Phase 1 Repair Pump Station Phase 2 Screening Grit Removal Sedimentation Disinfection Phase 3 Biological Treatment Sedimentation Phase 4 Tertiary Treatment $2.3 Million$24 Million$18 Million$3 Million

17 Phase 2 Phase 3 Phase 4 Top View Schematic of Cotorro Plant

18 AlternativeDescriptionCost (U.S. $) Benefit to San Francisco River Benefit to Cojimar RiverComments ANo action (discharge without treatment to San Francisco River) $ 0 (but cost of alternative supply high) Status quo: threat to drinking water and ecology N/ANot acceptable BDiversion to Cojimar River without treatment $ 2.3 M ($330K for electric controls) Removal of public health threat Impairment: threaten even Class “C” uses (transit and irrigation), against “environmental justice” (dumping) Not acceptable CDiverison with Primary Treatment $ 26 MRemoval of public health threat Impairment: may not meet Class “C” uses, against environmental justice Acceptability questionable DDiversion with Secondary Treatment $ 44 MRemoval of public health threat Allow Class “B” uses: transit, irrigation, consumption of raw products, recreation Acceptable EDiversion with Tertiary Treatment $ 47 MRemoval of public health threat Allow Class “A” uses: Class “B” uses plus public water supply, industrial use for food processing Acceptable Cotorro Wastewater Costs and Benefits

19 Methodologies for Incremental Benefits to San Francisco River/Vento Aquifer Watershed BenefitMethodologyData Needed Removal of public health threat (value of work productivity loss avoided in “nuisance” case). Productivity loss avoided = average income*average work days*percent work days missed*area population*percent of population in work force (a) Income Work days per year Percent work days missed (from survey of experts) Area population served by Vento Aquifer Percent of population in work force (from demographic studies) Removal of public health threat (cost avoided of alternative supply in “extreme” case). Cost avoided of alternative water supply/treatment (potentially desalination)*probability of occurrence Flow supplied by Vento Aquifer to service population Cost of desalination facilities for that flow Probability of ruining aquifer (survey of experts) (a) Reference: “Cost-Benefit Analysis for Implementing the West Coast Sewerage Project Under a Public-Private Partnership Arrangement,” Final Report to Barbados Water Authority, CDM, May 2008.

20 Methodologies for Incremental Benefits to Cojimar River Watershed BenefitMethodologyData Needed Allow TransitAssign economic value to incremental transit activities (if any) enabled by diversion of flow List of current transit activities Estimate of additional transit activities from new flow Economic value of additional activities IrrigationCost avoided of use of potable water Irrigation demand in Cojimar watershed and quality required Comparison of demand vs. diversion supply and quality Cost of treating offset amount of potable water Consumption of Raw Products Assign economic value to products Number of days per year consumption would be prohibited (survey of experts) Economic value of raw water products (fisheries studies) RecreationEconomic value of beach closings avoided Number of days per year beach would be closed otherwise (survey of experts) Tourist visits and “willingness to pay” Resident visits and “willingness to pay” Public Water SupplyCost avoided of use of current potable water less cost of polishing this diversion flow Population and water demand in Cojimar watershed Comparison of demand with diversion flow Treatment costs for current supply and diversion flow Industrial Use for Food Processing Cost avoided of use of current potable water less cost of polishing this diversion flow Industrial demand and quality requirements in Cojimar watershed Comparison of demand with diversion flow Treatment costs for current supply and diversion flow

21 Conclusions and Recommendations   8 priority watersheds (15% of country’s area)   Almendares-Vento watershed (Havana) is best documented   Highest wastewater priorities: – –Upper Almendares cleanup: Protect water source – –Mid-Almendares: Repair Maria del Carmen Wastewater Plant – –Northern Coast: Rehab outfall pipe   Highest water priorities: – –Repair chlorine (disinfectant) facility at Sagua – –Upgrade electrical service (backups): Avoid pressure losses – –Repair chlorination equipment – –Upgrade pumps and surge suppressors – –Repair leaks (costly)   Improve benefit-cost analysis with local data: Guide to refine priorities

22 Questions? Acknowledgments  Juan Belt of USAID Pete Robinson of Hazen and SawyerPete Robinson of Hazen and Sawyer U.Miami Student Groups, Cristina Ortega, Karen Kajder, Reshma Ramoutar, Omar De Leon, Jose Cueto, Tommy Kiger, Bader AlessaU.Miami Student Groups, Cristina Ortega, Karen Kajder, Reshma Ramoutar, Omar De Leon, Jose Cueto, Tommy Kiger, Bader Alessa CA-ACE Board Members: Rod Rodriguez, Victor Pujals, Rafael Robayna, and Maria PorrataCA-ACE Board Members: Rod Rodriguez, Victor Pujals, Rafael Robayna, and Maria Porrata

23 Helena to Add Google Map Full Scale

24 Role of Committee Before and During a Political Transition COMMITTEE’S WORK DATA INTEGRATION PHASEANALYSIS PHASEADVISORY PHASE ADVICE BEFORE TRANSITIONTRANSITION … U.S. AGENCIES ONLY U.S. AND CUBAN AGENCIES

25 Purpose of Presentation   Summary of island-wide priorities   Focus on Havana area issues   Sample of cost-benefit methodology as guide for setting priorities   Conclusions on Havana area priorities


Download ppt "Cuba Water/Wastewater Infrastructure Assessment Committee Water and Wastewater Priorities and Cost- Benefit Considerations: A “Work-In-Progress” To:Association."

Similar presentations


Ads by Google