Presentation on theme: "New York State Department of Health SPARCS Training Improving and Expanding Race and Ethnicity Data Collection Albany, NY October 10, 2013."— Presentation transcript:
1New York State Department of Health SPARCS Training Improving and Expanding Race and Ethnicity Data CollectionAlbany, NYOctober 10, 2013
2Agenda Topic Presenter Welcome and Introductions Eric Niehaus Vice PresidentHealthcare Association of New York StateHealth and Health Care DisparitiesRace and EthnicityBarbara A. Dennison, MDDirector, Policy and Research Translation UnitDivision of Chronic Disease PreventionOffice of Public HealthNew York State Department of HealthSPARCS Data CollectionJohn M. SkerrittTechnical SpecialistSPARCS OperationsOffice of Quality and Patient SafetyQuestions & AnswersDr. Dennison and John Skerritt
3ObjectivesDescribe why improved race and ethnicity data will help in identifying disparities in health care quality.Identify national legislative/regulatory attention to race and ethnicity data.Describe steps to improve quality of data collection and expand race and ethnicity categories.Describe how to code the expanded race and ethnicity data categories.Thank you, Vice President NiehausGood Afternoon.Thank you for joining the first in a series of five Webinars and a Webcast focused on increasing health equity. Improving the quality and granularity of disparities data, such as race and ethnicity, is the first step.In this Webinar, we will briefly discuss the rationale for paying increased attention to health care disparities and whyNYS DOH, Am. Hospital Assn. IOM, AHRQ and other national organizations and experts are focusing on improving race/ethnicity data, using the stratified data to identify unequal health care, and then developing targeted interventions to reduce these disparities.We will also describe the technical and procedural steps needed to collect and code the enhanced race and ethnicity categorical data, and to update your IT system to capture and report these data.
4DefinitionsHealth Disparities: Differences in the incidence, prevalence, mortality, burden of disease and other adverse health conditions that exist among specific population groups. Source: National Institute of HealthHealth Care Disparities: Includes differences in treatment provided to members of different racial or ethnic groups that is not justified by the underlying health conditions or treatment preferences of patients.Source: Institute of MedicineAlthough disparities in health and health care can be inextricably tied to one another, distinguishing between them is important to understand the complexity of the problem.Health Disparities are “Differences in the incidence, prevalence, mortality, burden of disease and other adverse health conditions that exist among specific population groups.”They are related to multiple factors such as education, geography, income distribution, social capital, etc…. In an ideal world, even if we were to eliminate disparities in health care, we would still see disparities in health.Whereas, Health Care Disparities include differences in treatment provided to members of different racial or ethnic groups that is not justified by the underlying health conditions or treatment preferences of patients.We’re focusing on disparities that exist within the health care delivery system because hospitals and facilities have control over what happens in their environments.
5What are Disparities in Health Care Quality? Racial and ethnic minorities tend to receive a lower quality of health care than non-minoritiesLess likely to receive:Cancer screeningCardiovascular therapyKidney dialysisTransplantsCurative surgery for lung cancerHip and knee replacement Pain medicines in the ERThe IOM published 2 sentinel works in the last decade: Crossing the Quality Chasm and Unequal Treatment.These reports demonstrate that although the U.S. spends billions on healthcare, there is wide variation in the care that Americans actually receive and the care they SHOULD receive.Not only are patients not necessarily receiving the right care, but racial and ethnic minorities are less likely to receive medical procedures, and experience a lower quality of health care and services, even when insurance status, income, age, and severity of conditions are comparable, and one adjusts for access-related factors, and patient preference.These reports find that minorities, compared with non-minorities, tend to receive lower quality of health care in a number of areas, including:cancer screening, cardiovascular therapy, and pain medicines in the ER.These disparities probably exist in your hospital, but you won’t know unless you look.5
6Unequal Health CareThe health care system contributes to disparities in care:Increased medical errorsProlonged length of staysAvoidable admissions and readmissionsOver and under-utilization of proceduresStudies also show disparities in other areas – such as length of stay, hospital readmissions, and procedures –---these are factors that can affect the bottom line.---which supports the case that equitable, high quality care is not just the right thing to do,but it’s also good business practice.According to a recent Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality (AHRQ) report, 60% of disparities in the quality of have care have stayed the same or worsened for Blacks, Asians, Hispanics and for low-income populations.Source: Institute of Medicine. (2002). Unequal Treatment: Confronting Racial and Ethnic Disparities in Health Care. Washington, DC: National Academy Press.
7Growing U.S. Minority Population Population Projections, 2010 to 2050This graph provides information about our changing national demographics.The U.S. Census Bureau projects that the number of minorities living in the U.S. (shown in blue) will increase and exceed the number of non-Hispanic whites (shown in red) as early as 2040. Minorities will become the majority in America.This is one of the reasons why addressing disparities in health care is becoming even more pressing.Changes in the U.S. population already impact health care providers and the patients they care for, and it will continue.Have you noticed changes in your hospital/facility’s patient demographics?Is the change anecdotal or based on accurate patient data that you trust?Do you know how your hospital’s community demographics have changed in recent years?Source: U.S. Census Bureau, 2009 National Population Projections (Supplemental). Projections of the Population by Sex, Race, and Hispanic Origin for the United States: 2010 to 2050
8Minority Groups Will Be Majority This shows expected changes in the U.S. population between 2000 and 2050.There is expected to be a doubling in the percentage ofHispanics, shown in green (13% -> 24%)Asians, shown in purple (3.8% -> 8.0%)With a concomitant reduction in the percentage of Americans who are NH, white.Source: Eliminating Disparities: Why It’s Essential and How to Get It Done, American Hospital Association.
9New York Population, 2012This slide shows the population distribution in NYS, separately by race and ethnicity,so one can't strictly compare to the previous slide.Compared to the U.S. population, NYS has:More Hispanics ( 18% vs. 15%)More Asians (8% vs. 5%)Fewer Native Hawaiian & Other Pacific Islander (0.1% vs. 2%)
10Increasing Legislative and Regulatory Attention to Race and Ethnicity Data American Recovery and Reinvestment Act of 2009To be eligible for “meaningful use” incentive paymentsPatient Protection and Affordable Care Act of 2010If receiving federal moneyRevised Joint Commission StandardsNew requirementNYS SPARCS – All discharges effective January 1, 2014Expanded race and ethnicity categories (CDC Race and Ethnicity Code Set - Version 1.0)Increased attention to data qualityBesides shifting demographics, there are also legislative and regulatory forces that will impact your organization and provide additional reasons to take action.There have been 3 major national movements over the past few years related to health disparities and race, ethnicity and language data collection.1) The American Recovery and Reinvestment Act of 2009—better known as the stimulus bill—created financial incentives for physicians and hospitals to use electronic health records (EHR); the collection of race, ethnicity and language information were included in “meaningful use” criteria.2) The health reform bill —the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act of 2010—(also known as Obama Care) requires health care organizations that receive federal funds to collect self-reported patient race, ethnicity and language data.The Joint Commission revised its accreditation standards. Previously, organizations were required to provide written information appropriate to the language of the patient, and to provide interpretation services as necessary. The new standards, which began in 2012, require hospitals to collect and record in the patient’s record, information about the patient’s race, ethnicity, language and communication needs. NYS SPARCS – requires Hospitals and facilitiesExpand the race and ethnicity categories, effective January 1, 2014In addition, there is increased attention to the quality and accuracy of the data collected and reported
11“Although the collection of race, ethnicity and language “Although the collection of race, ethnicity and language* data does not necessarily result in actions that will reduce disparities and improve care, the absence of the data guarantees that none of that will occur.”While these national acts require collecting a patient’s preferred language, in addition to their self-reported race and ethnicity, it should be pointed out, that NY legislation requires race and ethnicity data be reported as part of SPARCS. But, at present, there is no such requirement for reporting preferred language.Of note, several other states have recently passed legislation/regs that require language data also be submitted.However, just collecting the data, won’t improve health care. One needs to use the data to identify populations at risk of receiving lower quality care within and across health care organizations.Source: IOM (Institute of Medicine) Race, Ethnicity, and Language Data: Standardization for Health Care Quality Improvement. Washington, DC.*Note: The language reference is part of a direct quotation. SPARCS collects race and ethnicity data, but not language data.
12Three Steps to Address Health Disparities Standardize collection of self-reported race and ethnicity dataStratify and analyze performance measures by race and ethnicityIdentify and develop quality improvement interventions targeted to specific patient populationsThe IOM identified 3 steps to address issues of equity and health disparities within a quality improvement framework.First, standardize the collection of data by using the same categories throughout the organization and allowing the patients to self-report. No more just looking at the patient and guessing.The second step is to stratify performance measures to determine if and where disparities exist.Third, is to use the stratified data to drive quality improvement efforts.In this webinar series we will discuss the standardized collection process, but this is just the beginning of addressing disparities.In the Public Health Live Webcast on Oct. 17th, Commissioner Shah, national experts, and NYS hospital leaders will outline the charge to hospitals and make the business case for improving data, quality and equity of healthcare to improve health outcomes.Subsequent Webinars will address staff training, and provide examples of how hospitals have improved collection of patient's race and ethnicity, analyzed their data, and improved care for all their patients.
13U.S. Hospital Survey82% of hospitals collect race and ethnicity data, but…Categories vary within and across hospitalsStaff collect data mostly by observationStaff at some hospitals trained to “not ask”Most hospitals do not use data for quality improvementOnly 17% use data to assess and compare health outcomes among different patientsA recent U.S. Hospital Survey found that most hospitals collect race and ethnicity data, but only a small percentage use the data to assess differences in care, and then to make improvements.In part, because they may doubt the quality or validity of their dataMany Staff report entering information based on appearance, educated guesses or secondary sources such as identification documents.Staff may be reluctant to ask patients their race and ethnicity47% Patient self-reports only41% Registrar observation AND patient self-reports8% Registrar observation onlySource: Hospitals, Language, and Culture: a Snapshot of the Nation, N = 60 U.S. Hospitals
14Some Anticipate Obstacles to Modifying Registration IT System Information technologyTraining/educating staffTimeCosts45% do not anticipate any obstaclesThis survey found that half of hospitals anticipated obstacles to modifying their registration IT system.The 4 most common concerns were:1) information technology, 2) training/educating staff, 3) time and 4) costs.Of all the barriers listed, training/educating staff can be the most challenging – but not insurmountable.And, as many of you know, training is an ongoing process.One of the upcoming Webinars will focus on staff training and provide resources, toolkits and materials.
15Registration Staff Face Challenges/Barriers to Race and Ethnicity Data Collection Patient reluctance to provide the dataStaff reluctance to ask the questionsInability of staff to communicate in patient’s preferred languageLack of staff training on data collectionPotential barriers faced by registration staff in collecting patient race and ethnicity data include:Presumed patient and/or staff reluctance, cited by 55% of hospitals.Lack of staff training in collecting R/E dataAnd, difficulty communicating to patients in their preferred language .
16Barriers/Challenges to Using Race and Ethnicity Data Accuracy of the dataLack of consistent data collection processLack of standardized data categoriesData systems and integration with QI practices41% reported no barriers or challengesPotential barriers to using patient race and ethnicity data include concerns with:the accuracy of the data currently being collectedthe lack of a consistent data collection processnot having/using standardized data categorieshow to integrate the race and ethnicity data with current data systems and quality improvement practices
17NYS Assessment of Hospitals and Ambulatory Surgery Facilities Policy or Procedure for collecting patient race and ethnicity information (74%)Provide staff training on R/E data collection (78%)Registration/Admissions Supervisors (13%)Outpatient Registration Staff (27%)Ambulatory Surgery Admissions Staff (24%)ER Registration Staff (21%)Admissions Clerks (32%)Registration Clerks (35%)Training offered only once to new employees (65%)In August 2013, a survey was sent to 20% of hospitals facilities and ambulatory surgery center in NYS (N=63). The response rate was 75%, thanks to you who completed our survey, and to the persistence of our colleagues at the SPH.The survey found that:Most facilities have a policy/procedure for collecting race.40% collected Race and ethnicity data at every visit and 40% collected R/E data only during the patients’ initial visit.Most hospitals provided training, though 65% only provided training to new employees.The type of staff trained varied across hospitals and facilities,though training of admission and registration staff were the most frequently reported.
18NYS Assessment of Hospitals and Ambulatory Surgery Facilities Frequency of collecting patient race and ethnicity information:Initial Visit (34-40%)Every Visit (42-53%)Don’t Know (5-25%)Method of collecting patient race and ethnicity information:Verbally asking the patient questions (87%)Getting patient information from existing records (53%)Having the patient fill out a form (40%)Observing the patient’s physical characteristics (34%)34-40% facilities indicated that race and ethnicity data is collected at every visit , 42-53% during the patients’ initial visit.Most hospitals/facilities reported they ask the patient questions, but 34% reported observing the patient.40% of facilities have patients fill out a form andIn 53%, the information comes from existing records
19NYS Assessment of Hospitals and Ambulatory Surgery Facilities Reported barriers to collecting patient race and ethnicity information:Patient declines to respond (64%)Staff have not been trained (15%)Question too sensitive (53%)Language or communication barriers (39%)There is not a good opportunity to collect (16%)Not enough time to collect (17%)No method to collect this information (2%)The NYS Assessment of Hospitals and Facilities found similar barriers to collecting R/E data as did the U.S. hospital survey.Lack of staff training was less commonly reported.Patient refusal, language barriers, and questions perceived as too sensitive were commonly reported.These issues will be briefly addressed in next week’s Webcast and then later in more detail in a Webinar specifically designed for Registration/Admission Supervisors and staff.
20Components of Standardized Race and Ethnicity Data Collection Use standardized categories across the organizationAsk patient to self-report ethnicity, then raceNo more “eyeballing” the patientData are collected from all patientsTell the patient why we are collecting his/her race and ethnicity and how the information will be usedWhat are the basic components of standardized data collection?The same categories for patient race and ethnicity should be used across the hospital, system or medical group. The patient needs to be asked to self-report his/her ethnicity, and then to self-report his race.And every patient needs to be asked – at least once, not necessarily at every visit.The patient also needs to be told why the information is being collected, and how the information will be used.
21Article 28 SPARCS Timeline May 31, 2013: Letter to Article 28 facilities from Office of Quality and Patient Safety.July 1, 2013: Health care facilities may begin submitting files in the expanded format.All discharges effective January 1, 2014Facilities must be fully transitioned to collect and report the expanded race and ethnicity categories.The Timeline:NYS Article 28 Facilities, that are required to report SPARCS data, were notified of the changes May 31, 2013-- 6 months prior to the effective date – All discharges on or after Jan. 1, 2014, need to report the expanded race and ethnicity data.On July 1, 2013, changes were made such that facilities can begin submitting and testing race and ethnicity files using the new format.
22Key Decision Points Who needs to be engaged? What system modifications need to be made?How will the registration process change?How will staff be trained on the new collection procedures?How will you monitor the data to ensure completeness and accuracy?As hospitals and other facilities set out to change your data collection system, there are many things that need to be considered. Some of the key decisions include:Deciding who needs to be involved, and then including all the playersDeciding what systems need to be modifiedIf your outpatient and inpatient health records are linked, and data will populate one system from the other, it may be more efficient in the long run, to change your entire system.Will there be changes to your registration or admission process?How and which staff need to be trained? With what frequency?How will you monitor race and ethnicity data and ensure that it is being collected correctly – i.e., patients are being asked? Data are being entered properly? That you don’t have high rates of unknown or other race or ethnicity?
23Quality Improvement Requires high-quality data. First Step: Helping hospitals gather data on patient race and ethnicity to obtain a more accurate and complete picture of their patients.Second Step: Use data to critically examine care delivered to learn whether they are providing equitable care.Third Step: Design Quality Improvement efforts to improve quality of care and reduce disparities.Source: Robert Wood Foundation, Expecting Success: Excellence in Cardiac Care ProgramHealth Care organizations must have good quality data on the race and ethnicity of those they serve in order to identify health care disparities, and then to make changes to ensure that they are providing high quality care to all.As mentioned, the upcoming Webcast and Webinars will be discussing Steps hospitals can take, and the advantages of doing so.Now, I’d like to turn this over to John Skerritt, who is a Technical Specialist, SPARCS Operations, NYSDOH,who will explain some of the more technical details of submitting the expanded datasets to SPARCS
24SPARCS Ethnicity Standards Are you Hispanic, Latino/a, or Spanish origin? (One or more categories may be selected)Current Data StandardExpanded Data StandardX12 ValueEthnicityE1Spanish/Hispanic OriginE1.02Mexican, Mexican American, Chicano/aE1.06Puerto RicanE1.07CubanSee: SPARCS Appendix RR for list of codes (CDC Code Set)Additional Hispanic, Latino/a, or Spanish Origin categoriesE2Not of Hispanic, Latino/a, or Spanish originE9Unknown
25Expanded Data Standard SPARCS Race StandardsRace StandardsWhat is your race? (One or more categories may be selected)Current Data StandardExpanded Data StandardX12 ValueRaceR1American Indian or Alaska NativeR2AsianR2.01Asian IndianR2.06ChineseR2.08FilipinoR2.11JapaneseR2.12KoreanR2.19VietnameseSee: SPARCS Appendix RR for list of codes (CDC Code Set)Additional Asian categories
26Expanded Data Standard SPARCS Race StandardsRace StandardsWhat is your race? (One or more categories may be selected)Current Data StandardExpanded Data StandardX12 ValueRaceR3Black or African AmericanR4Native Hawaiian or Pacific IslanderRNative HawaiianRGuamanian or ChamorroRSamoanSee: SPARCS Appendix RR for list of codes (CDC Code Set)Additional Pacific Islander categoriesR5WhiteR9Other Race
27How Will SPARCS Collect Data? X12-837, Version 5010 formatRepetition separator in ISADMG segment formatEdit reportsData dictionarySPARCS Appendix RR (CDC Race and Ethnicity Code Set - Version 1.0)
28SPARCS Data Collection The X file:Using Version 5010R: this is the only format supported.The race and ethnicity data elements are collected in the DMG segment and make use of the repetition separator.ISA 11 segment must contain the same character as DMG 05 separating multiple race values.ISA*00* *00*….. *^* <- ISA 11
29SPARCS Data Collection The DMG segment contains the race and ethnicity information.The race and ethnicity can repeat; up to 10 total in the segment.The repetition separator is used to identify each unique value.DMG*D8* *F**RET:R2.02^:RET:E5* <- DMG 05
30SPARCS Data Collection SPARCS edit reports have an error code for race and ethnicity:2010DMG5000 RACE and ETHNICITY CODEMost errors to date have been missing the repetition separator or missing the values completely
33New York State Department of Health Resources Data Dictionary Race and Ethnicity Addendum Pages: Appendix RR: Frequently-Asked Questions:
34Staff at the FacilityGet everyone at the facility on board from the top down.Standardize the collection process:Patient should self-identify/reportReport ethnicity(ies) first, then race(s)Data are collected on all patientsReview in-house security to protect data.Train all staff to collect data and answer the patient with the same response.
35Patients at the Facility Tell patients you are collecting the information before you collect it and explain why.Create forms, so they can self-identify.Assure them the data will be protected.Engage the community.
36ResourcesNYS Toolkit to Reduce Health Disparities: Improve Race and Ethnicity DataHealth Research and Educational Trust (HRET) Toolkit:On-line resource to help hospitals and facilities systemically collect race and ethnicity data from patients:
37Next Steps Collecting the Data: First Steps in Achieving Health Equity October 17, 2013, 9-10:30 a.m.Several Webinars for:Physicians, Hospital Executives, Quality Improvement Advisors, and Medical StaffRegistration and Admission Supervisors and StaffCommunity-Based Organizations and Community LeadersNYS Toolkit to Reduce Disparities: Improving Race and Ethnicity Data Collection
38Our Goal…Improve the quality of race and ethnicity data collected.Expand the granularity (number of categories) of race and ethnicity data.Questions?To truly eliminate disparities in health care, there must be fundamental changes to our health delivery system.
39SPARCS Operations John Skerritt, Trainer Website: Phone:(518)Fax:(518)