Presentation is loading. Please wait.

Presentation is loading. Please wait.

Huawei solutions for SAP HANA - Competition analysis.

Similar presentations


Presentation on theme: "Huawei solutions for SAP HANA - Competition analysis."— Presentation transcript:

1 Huawei solutions for SAP HANA - Competition analysis

2 1 Content Huawei VS. IBM converged solution Huawei solutions for SAP HANA summary Single node competition analysis Huawei VS. traditional solution 4 4

3 2 Complete offerings support various deployment options SAP HANA One RH2288H + FusionSphere certified SAP HANA Enterprise Cloud Coming In the CloudIn the DataCenter Single Host RH5885H V3 for Enterprise(XS/S/M/L/L+) RH2288H for SME- B1H,B1A Scale-out / HA cluster FusionCube with distributed storage or SAN storage SAP HANA One Enterprise Cloud Hosting On-premise P ublic P rivate Free |99ct | Premium Partner | SAP Partner SAP | Partner Manages Service

4 3 What Does Huawei Provide? Hardware OS Database Enterprise application Installation Hardware maintenance 1. What we sell is highlighted in Orange, including hardware, software, installation, and maintenance. 2. Software includes the SUSE OS (including three-year warranty) 3. Installation services: hardware, OS, and database installation 4. Installation is performed on site. 5. Huawei provides one-stop maintenance for all hardware. Integration development System maintenance Huawei/ Partner Optional: Provide by Huawei or Partner

5 4 Fastest Growing products in the server Market Source: Gartner 2013 analysis report No Shipment growth rate in global markets No world records in performance benchmark tests Best Performance Transaction Processing spec VMmark TPC Performance Council 2013 server shipments in China's market 2013 server shipments in global market No.4

6 5 Optimized for performance Pre-optimized and one-stop support ,000 times faster than a traditional database High Reliability & Outstanding Performance: Powered by RH5885H V3 with 53 reliability and service ability features #1 in SPECint and SPECfp Fastest write performance with 15% less latency and 20% more bandwidth Most complete SAP HANA offering Best scalability Scale Out : FusionCube SingleNode : RH5885H V3

7 6 Content Huawei VS. IBM converged solution Huawei solutions for SAP HANA summary Single node competition analysis Huawei VS. traditional solution

8 7 Huawei Solutions for SAP HANA– Single Node(Westmere) RH5885H V2 128GB(XS)->256GB(S)>512GB(M)->1TB(L)->2TB(L+) Business suite on HANA(SoH/OLTP) Business warehouse on HANA(BWoH/OLAP)

9 8 XSSML XL ( 2T) XXL(4T) Server ModelRH5885 V2 CPU2* E * E * E Memory128GB DDR3256GB DDR3512G DDR31024G DDR32048G DDR34096G DDR3 Log Volume800G ES3000 2*800G ES30002*1.2TB ES30004*1.2TB ES3000 Data Volume 8x600GB 10k 2.5 SAS HDD, RAID 5 8x 600GB 10k 2.5 SAS, RAID 5 8*600GB 10k 2.5 SAS HDD,RAID 5 2(8*600GB 10k 2.5 SAS HDD,RAID 5) 2(8*900GB 10k 2.5 SAS HDD,RAID 5) 24*900GB 10k 2.5 SAS OSSLES 11.2 for SAP HANA ServiceSAP HANA Installation Upgrade Options XS-> S->M->L ( easily upgrade by adding more resources ) Huawei Solutions for SAP HANA– Single Node(Westmere)

10 9 HuaweiIBMHPHitachiCiscoDellFujitsuNEC XS:128G√√√√√√√ S:256G√√√√√√√√ M:512G√√√√√√√ L:1T√√√√√√ SoH(1/2/4 ) 1/2/4 211 Upgrade Options XS-> S->M->L XS-> S(X3690) S->M->L(X3950) XS->S-MS->M->LNoXS->S-M XS-> S->M(RX600) Different model for L (RX900) No Log Latency(w/r) 8μs/49μs15μs/68μs15μs/47μs15μs/68μs 18μs/78μs Log IOPS/(w/r) 330K/600K250K/245K270K/270K230K/215K -/175K Log Volume ES GioDrive2 1.2TioDrive Duo 320GB ioDrive2 365 GB Need external storage AMS2100 for Data ioDrive2 365 GBioDrive2 785 GB XS->S->M:ioDrive2 785 GB L: ioDrive2 1.2T Virident FlashMax 300 GB 1.Most complete T-shirt sizes 2.Most flexible for scale-up 3.Best IO performance ES3000 : The world’s fastest PCIe SSD Huawei Solution Advantage – Single Node(Westmere)

11 10 RH5885H V3 128GB(XS)->256GB(S)>512GB(M)->1TB(L)->2TB(L+) Business suite on HANA(SoH/OLTP) Business warehouse on HANA(BWoH/OLAP) Best Performance/Price ratio  Best density, no additional JBOD needed  Smoothly Scale up  Fastest PCIe SSD card in the world : Huawei ES3000, optimized for SAP HANA  Low Cost configuration and High Performance configuration. ES3000 SSD HDD Data volumeLog volume … Huawei Solutions for SAP HANA– Single Node (IvyBridge) Certification :

12 11 XSSMLL+ Server ModelRH5885H V3 CPU2* IVB-EX E7-4880/4890 V2 4* IVB-EX E7-4880/4890 V2 Memory128GB DDR3256GB DDR3512GB DDR31024GB DDR32048GB DDR3 Log Volume 1T from 8*900GB 10k 2.5" SAS HDD, RAID 5 2* 800GB ES3000 Data Volume 3T from 8*900GB 10k 2.5" SAS HDD, RAID 5 14*900GB 10k 2.5" SAS HDD, RAID 50 OSSLES 11.3 for SAP HANA Upgrade Options 128G->256G>512G->1T->2T ( easily upgrade by adding more components ) XSSMLL+ Server ModelRH5885H V3 CPU2* IVB-EX E7-4880/4890 V2 4* IVB-EX E7-4880/4890 V2 Memory128GB DDR3256GB DDR3512GB DDR31024GB DDR32048GB DDR3 Log Volume2* 800GB ES3000 Data Volume 8*900GB 10k 2.5" SAS HDD, RAID 5 14*900GB 10k 2.5" SAS HDD, RAID 50 OSSLES 11.3 for SAP HANA Upgrade Options 128G->256G>512G->1T->2T ( easily upgrade by adding more components ) High performance configuration Basic configuration Huawei Solutions for SAP HANA– Single Node configuration

13 12 RH5885H V3 server performance Segment - Benchmark Partner/Platform Absolute Result Relative Improvemen t Importance Technical computing SPECfp_rate_ba se processor Huawei RH5885H V3 using Intel Xeon processor E v2 (37.5M cache.2.8GHz) 1730 baseline result 2.3x performance over Intel xeon processor E World Record 4-socket result Enterprise computing SPECint_rate_ba se processor Huawei RH5885H V3 using Intel Xeon processor E v2 (37.5M cache.2.8GHz) 2320 baseline score 2.1x performance over Intel xeon processor E World Record 4-socket result ( Tie ) Source: Intel Official Website Improve 64% for TPC-E

14 13 Better Performance of PCIe SSD Card FUSION-IOSTECOCZHuawei ModelioDrive2 Duo Kronos™ Turbo PCIe SSA Z-Drive R4 CM84/RM84 Z-Drive R4 CM88/RM88 ES3000 Flash granuleSLCMLC Capacity1.2 TB2.4 TB1.95 TB 300 GB, 600 GB, 1.2 TB 800 GB, 1.6 TB, 3.2 TB 800 GB, 1.2 TB, 2.4 TB DimensionsFH-HL HH-HLFH-3/4LFH-HL Bus interfaceGen 2 x8 Read bandwidth3.0 GB/s 2 GB/s 2.8 GB/s3.2 GB/s Read IOPS950k (512 B)892k (512 B)220k (4 KB)--760K (4 KB) Read latency47 µs68 µs---49 µs Write bandwidth2.5 GB/s 2 GB/s 2.8 GB/s Write IOPS935k (512 B) 200k (4 KB) 250k (4 KB) 160k (8 KB) 410k (4 KB) 275k (8 KB) 240K (4 KB) Write latency15 µs < 50 µs--8 µs8 µs

15 14 Color Theme Combination of two colors, main theme: company red ES3000 KPI: SSD DISK and HDD: general KPI data Item HuaweiIBMHPHitachiCiscoDellFujitsuNEC 128G~2T√√√xx√√x External JBODNOyes xxNOyesx JBOD Power Consumption NO100 watts xxNO100 wattsx Log VolumeES G SSD HDD with cache cadeSSD disk(2*800G)xx NVME SSD disk(2*400G) HDD(10*900G)x Log IOPS_w(4k)120K90K36kxx 280x Log IOPS_r(4K)570K200K75Kxx 400x Log Latency_w8μs65μs xx 70msx Log Latency_r49μs50μs xx 70msx Density(2T)4U6U xx4U12Ux Huawei Solution Advantage – Single Node(IvyBridge)

16 15 XSSMLL+ Server ModelRH5885H V3 CPU2* IVB-EX E7-4880/4890 V2 4* IVB-EX E7-4880/4890 V2 Memory128GB DDR3256GB DDR3512GB DDR31024GB DDR32048GB DDR3 Log Volume 1T from 8*900GB 10k 2.5" SAS HDD, RAID 5 2* 800GB PCIe SSD ES3000 Data Volume 3T from 8*900GB 10k 2.5" SAS HDD, RAID 5 8*900GB 10k 2.5" SAS HDD, RAID 5 14*900GB 10k 2.5" SAS HDD, RAID 50 OSSLES 11.3 for SAP HANA Upgrade Options 128G->256G>512G->1T->2T ( easily upgrade by adding more components ) XSSMLL+ Server ModelDL580 G8 CPU2* IVB-EX E7-4880/4890 V2 4* IVB-EX E7-4880/4890 V2 Memory256GB DDR3512GB DDR31024GB DDR32048GB DDR3 Log Volume 0.5T from 8x600GB 10k 2.5" SAS HDD, RAID 5 2*800GB SSD disk Data Volume 1.5T from 8x600GB 10k 2.5" SAS HDD, RAID 5 8x600GB 10k 2.5" SAS HDD, RAID 5 25x600GB 10k 2.5" SAS HDD, RAID 50 OSSLES 11.3 for SAP HANA Upgrade Options256G>512G->1T->2T VS Huawei Solution Advantage VS. HP DL580 G8

17 16 VS. + RH5885H V3 DL580 G8 JBOD Huawei Solution Advantage VS. HP DL580 G8 HuaweiHP Higher Density 4U6U(Additional JBOD) Upgrade smoothly No any change of chassis Additional JBOD for 2T size(change of power, rack size, cables, etc.) Better Log volume performance Huawei PCIe SSD card, Fastest PCIe SSD card in the world General SSD disk Lower power No Additional JBOD more than 100W for one JBOD(JBOD’s fans, power, controller, etc.)

18 17 XSSMLL+ Server ModelRH5885H V3 CPU2* IVB-EX E7-4880/4890 V2 4* IVB-EX E7-4880/4890 V2 Memory128GB DDR3256GB DDR3512GB DDR31024GB DDR32048GB DDR3 Log Volume 1T from 8*900GB 10k 2.5" SAS HDD, RAID 5 2* 800GB PCIe SSD ES3000 Data Volume 3T from 8*900GB 10k 2.5" SAS HDD, RAID 5 8*900GB 10k 2.5" SAS HDD, RAID 5 14*900GB 10k 2.5" SAS HDD, RAID 50 OSSLES 11.3 for SAP HANA Upgrade Options 128G->256G>512G->1T->2T ( easily upgrade by adding more components ) XSSMLL+ Server ModelPQ 2400 E/S/L CPU2* IVB-EX E7-4880/4890 V2 4* IVB-EX E7-4880/4890 V2 Memory128GB DDR3256GB DDR3512GB DDR31024GB DDR32048GB DDR3 Log Volume 0.5T from 10*900GB 10k 2.5" SAS HDD, RAID T from 15*900GB 10k 2.5" SAS HDD, RAID 50 Data Volume 384G from 10*900GB 10k 2.5" SAS HDD, RAID G from 10*900GB 10k 2.5" SAS HDD, RAID T from 10*900GB 10k 2.5" SAS HDD, RAID 50 3T from 10*900GB 10k 2.5" SAS HDD, RAID 50 6T from 15*900GB 10k 2.5" SAS HDD, RAID 50 OSSLES 11.3 for SAP HANA Upgrade Options128G->256G>512G->1T->2T VS Huawei Solution Advantage –VS. Fujitsu PQ2400

19 18 VS. + RH5885H V3PQ2400JBOD Huawei Solution Advantage –VS. Fujitsu PQ2400 HuaweiFujitsu Higher Density4U12U(Additional JBOD) Lower power No Additional JBODmore than 100W for one JBOD(JBOD’s fans, power, controller, etc.) 4U chassis10U chassis with more fans, power, etc. Better performance Huawei PCIe SSD card, Fastest PCIe SSD card in the worldGeneral HDD Stander 4 socket architecture 25%~30% performance drop of CPU by using 4CPU in 8 socket architecture CPU 1 CPU 2 CPU 4 CPU 3 4 socket CPU 1 CPU 2 CPU 4 CPU 3 CPU 5 CPU 6 CPU 8 CPU 7 8 socket Lack two QPI lines if use as 4 socket in 8 socket architecture 25~30% CPU performance

20 19 XSSMLL+ Server ModelRH5885H V3 CPU2* IVB-EX E7-4880/4890 V2 4* IVB-EX E7-4880/4890 V2 Memory128GB DDR3256GB DDR3512GB DDR31024GB DDR32048GB DDR3 Log Volume 1T from 8*900GB 10k 2.5" SAS HDD, RAID 5 2* 800GB PCIe SSD ES3000 Data Volume 3T from 8*900GB 10k 2.5" SAS HDD, RAID 5 8*900GB 10k 2.5" SAS HDD, RAID 5 14*900GB 10k 2.5" SAS HDD, RAID 50 OSSLES 11.3 for SAP HANA Upgrade Options 128G->256G>512G->1T->2T ( easily upgrade by adding more resources ) XSSMLL+ Server Model3850 X6 CPU2* IVB-EX E7-4880/4890 V2 4* IVB-EX E7-4880/4890 V2 Memory128GB DDR3256GB DDR3512GB DDR31024GB DDR32048GB DDR3 Log Volume 1T from 4x1.2TB 10k 2.5" SAS HDD, Flash cache RAID 5 1T from 13x1.2TB 10k 2.5" SAS HDD, Flash cache RAID 5 Data Volume 1.6T from 4x1.2TB 10k 2.5" SAS HDD, Flash cache RAID T from 13x1.2TB 10k 2.5" SAS HDD, Flash cache RAID 5 OSSLES 11.3 for SAP HANA Upgrade Options128G->256G>512G->1T->2T VS Huawei Solution Advantage –VS. IBM 3850 X6

21 20 VS. + RH5885H V33850 X6JBOD Huawei Solution Advantage –VS. IBM 3850 X6 HuaweiIBM Higher Density4U4U+2U Upgrade smoothlyNo any change of chassis Additional JBOD for 1T size(change of power, rack size, cables, etc.) Lower powerNo Additional JBODmore than 100W for one JBOD(JBOD’s fans, power, controller, etc.) Better performance Huawei PCIe SSD, special optimized for HANA log volumeIBM eXFlash as cache for log volume Memory bandwidth: PCIe SSD, no occupying of memory channel Memory bandwidth: Occupy memory channel, lost 20%~25% memory bandwidth Read mechanism: PCI interrupt with out else using of CPU Read mechanism: Additional resource use of CPU by polling technology Read latency: One copy from SSD controller Read latency: Two copy from SSD controller and Rush chip with more latency. ② CPU Driver APP RUSH ① ③ ④ FLASH eXFLASH DDR SSD controller ⑤ ⑥ ⑦ DDR Write bufferInternal buffer System memory ⑧ CPU internal DMA IBM eXFLASH ② CPUSystem memory DDR PCIE Driver APP ① ③ ④ ⑤ SSD controller FLASH PCIE SSD DDR Huawei PCIe SSD

22 21 Huawei Solution Advantage –VS. IBM 3850 X6 HuaweiIBM Higher Density4U4U+2U Upgrade smoothlyNo any change of chassisAdditional JBOD for 1T size(change of power, rack size, cables, etc.) Lower powerNo Additional JBODmore than 100W for one JBOD(JBOD’s fans, power, controller, etc.) Better performanceHuawei PCIe SSD card, Fastest PCIe SSD card in the worldGeneral HDD with Cache Cade(general SSD) VS. + RH5885H V X6 JBOD

23 22 RH8100H V3 128GB(XS)->256GB(S)>512GB(M)->1TB(L)->2TB(XL)->4TB(XXL)->6TB(XXXL) Business suite on HANA(SoH/OLTP) Business warehouse on HANA(BWoH/OLAP) ES3000 SSD HDD Data volumelog volume …… High performance and Scalable  Best density, no additional JBOD  Upgrade smoothly  Huawei PCIe SSD card, Fastest PCIe SSD card in the world, optimized for SAP HANA Huawei Solutions for SAP HANA –RH8100H V3(Ivybridge)

24 23 Content Huawei VS. IBM converged solution Huawei solutions for SAP HANA summary Single node competition analysis Huawei VS. traditional solution

25 24 IBM SAP HANA solution  Using Rack server: X5 or X6 system;  Using GPFS with local disk to create a shared file system;  HANA computing node and storage disks in a same server; 2T size rack view

26 25 Huawei FusionCube HANA Solution : separated architecture Management Nodes Inner interconnect network StandbyWorker Log Persistent Storage Layer ( SSD/HDD ) Data Persistent Storage Layer ( HDD ) 。。。 In-memory computing cluster Worker Storage Cluster 。。。 Huawei Separated architecture IBM Integrated architecture VS. Independent operation and maintenance

27 26 Level1Level2IBMHuaweidescription Performance IO E2E latency ( Log 4K ) ~500us<200us The latency is key factor for SAP HANA performance. Persistence efficiency ( Data 16k ) Overwrite : ~700MB/S ( using FusionIO ) Overwrite : >1400MB/S Huawei’s ES3000 PCIe SSD card is the fastest PCIe SSD in the world. --StorageReview test result. sysbench_oltp_benchmark Data load ( Data 16K ) Read : ~1250MB/S ( using FusionIO ) Read : 1430MB/S Density One rack6 nodes12 nodes IBM : 4U rack server , 6 nodes per rack is classic configuration for IBM Huawei : 1.5U blades , can support 12 nodes per rack. External switchyesNo, less 16 nodes Flexibility Storage capacity If need more storage, need to purchase more IBM X5 or X6 system and more GPFS license, need add GPFS nodes Using separate storage nodes, can extend the storage disk as customer needed. *IBM’s W/R data is analysis according to “ 《 IBM-GPFS-and-Fusion-IO-for-IOP-Performance 》 ” Huawei VS. IBM

28 27 SAP HA solution option system replication On top of this, SAP HANA System Replication provides the best protection against a variety of failures and downtime cases, and by far the best recovery solution, when considering recovery time, and disaster scenarios. It is therefore the recommended solution for highly critical business systems. Source: SAP HANA – High Availability FAQ HANA_HA_FAQ_2.0.pdf

29 28 IBM HA: Backup Although IBM have storage replication for SAP HANA HA solution, the RTO= hours and RPO= hours, which is not acceptable. Backup is not good choice for SAP HANA HA.

30 29 System replication: In production Primary system Production site HA secondary system System replication (sync) System replication is provided by SAP HANA software. Configure the system replication between the two sets of RH5885H V3. The service is provided by local SAP partner. The switch process includes the monitoring scripts,DNS or load balance configuration and switch scripts.

31 30 IBM HA – Manual operation needed 4. (on any active node) Transfer server license Applies to GPFS and later. Step 5 requires a node with a valid server license in the cluster. With GPFS a new "FPO license" was introduced which is incompatible to the server roles "quorum node" and "configuration server". If you want to put these roles on a active server with a FPO license, you need to move the "server license" to this node. Check the licenses with the command 1 # mmlslicense –L Source : operationsguide - IBM solutions for SAP hana, 108 pages

32 31 Content Huawei VS. IBM converged solution Huawei solutions for SAP HANA summary Single node competition analysis Huawei VS. traditional solution

33 32 Fastest HANA appliance in the world —— Huawei FusionCube ——SAP VP: Steve Lucas SAP FCOM Beijing , 2014 Optimized IO 5 XPerformance 20% Cost savings 75% Space savings Distributed storage PCIe SSD High speed network 2x faster1024 nodes 2x faster

34 33 Huawei VS. Traditional solution HuaweiHPHitachiCiscoDellFujitsuNEC IvyBridge√√ 1T size√√√√ Blade server√√√√ Rack server√√√√ Density per rack Blades , 12 nodes per rack 512G: Blades, 8 nodes/Rack ; 1T: Rack server 4 nodes/Rack Blades , 8 nodes/rack 4U rack server; 4 nodes/rack 4U rack server, 4 nodes/ rack 7U rack server Energy Cost(16T) 27KW30KW62KW56KW Log volume(SSD) √√ external switch NoYes One stop support services √√√√√

35 34 Huawei FusionCube for SAP HANA Management Nodes Internal switch StandbyWorker Log Persistent Storage Layer ( HDD/SSD ) Data Persistent Storage Layer ( HDD ) 。。。 In-memory computing cluster Worker Storage Cluster 。。。 1)Need not SAN storage, eliminate SAN storage bottlenecks 2)Need not centralized NFS controller 3)Support Shared Nothing Distributed Storage 4)Single set of distributed storage, simplified management. (there are several sets of storage in other traditional storage vendor’s solution )

36 35 Traditional : Complex integration The simplest deployment, the highest density 2 Terabyte/rack Other Vendor FusionCube Rear View Front View FusionCube 11 Terabyte/rack

37 36 Simplified Management Unified monitoring and alert Administrator Server Storage Network Separate Management Platform Administrator Converged infrastructure (server\network\storage) Unified monitoring and alert Traditional Infrastructure HANA DB Centralized management of hardware: servers, storages, IP and InfiniBand switches Centralized alerting and real-time monitoring One-stop hardware support services Unified Management HANA DB

38 37 FusionStorage— Best Scalability and Higher Performance VBS OSD HDD VBS Table Storage Controller Disk Layer... Server1 Server2ServerN HANA DB... SSD Storage Server1 Storage Server2 Storage ServerN Table High Performance High Reliability High Scalability

39 38 Closing the huge latency gap between different storage media Bottleneck 200ns 8μs8μs 40X Memory PCIe SSD 6ms Disk 750X DB write performance Recovery time? Delta data flush to disk time? Data load time? Huawei ES3000 PCIe SSD card is the fastest PCIe SSD card in the world !

40 39 Better Performance of SSD Card FUSION-IOSTECOCZHuawei ModelioDrive2 Duo Kronos™ Turbo PCIe SSA Z-Drive R4 CM84/RM84 Z-Drive R4 CM88/RM88 ES3000 Flash granuleSLCMLC Capacity1.2 TB2.4 TB1.95 TB 300 GB, 600 GB, 1.2 TB 800 GB, 1.6 TB, 3.2 TB 800 GB, 1.2 TB, 2.4 TB DimensionsFH-HL HH-HLFH-3/4LFH-HL Bus interfaceGen 2 x8 Read bandwidth3.0 GB/s 2 GB/s 2.8 GB/s3.2 GB/s Read IOPS950k (512 B)892k (512 B)220k (4 KB)--760K (4 KB) Read latency47 µs68 µs---49 µs Write bandwidth2.5 GB/s 2 GB/s 2.8 GB/s Write IOPS935k (512 B) 200k (4 KB) 250k (4 KB) 160k (8 KB) 410k (4 KB) 275k (8 KB) 240K (4 KB) Write latency15 µs < 50 µs--8 µs8 µs

41 40 FactorItemCISCOHuaweiComment(Huawei/CISCO) High performance Latency of Log Volume 6GB FC+ SSD (15us)56GB infiniband + NVDIMM(200ns)Huawei has the lowest latency Throughput of Data Volume 6GB FC+ Only two controller 56GB infiniband + FusionStorage distributed controller(more than 3) Huawei has the biggest bandwidth CPUWestmere CPUIvybridge CPU(new generation cpu) The latest CPU, 2~3 X performance than westmere cpu Speed of Data load 6GB FC+ Only two controller 56GB infiniband + FusionStorage distributed controller(more than 3) Huawei has 3-6x throughput of data load SAS(120M)SSD(read : 3.2GB/s)The faster persistency layer High reliability Storage self- recovering Rebalance time:< 12h/TRebalance time:<0.5h/T24x data recovery speed HA No SPOF, 2 rack switchNo SPOF, 4 switch modulesmore redundant Data storage: Raid 5Data storage: Raid10-like Low TCO Density of single rack 3.5T RAM* (NetAPP) (8*512G HANA nodes) 11T RAM ( 12*1T HANA nodes) Huawei has 3x density Density of 16 nodes 2 racks 1x 7.5T RAM15T RAM2x Power consumption 26KW/16*512G nodes27KW/16*1T nodesAbout 2x of power density Deployment difficulty complex cable connections among multi devices, need outer switch simple cable connection between chassis, no need outer switch The simpler deployment Unified management Different management Unified management of computing/storage/network Cloud supportyes Same 3.5T 11T, 3x Huawei VS. Cisco

42 41 FactorItemHPHuaweiComment(Huawei/HP) High performance Latency of Log Volume 6GB FC+ SSD (56us)56GB infiniband + NVDIMM(200ns)Huawei has the lowest latency Throughput of Data Volume 6GB FC 56GB infiniband + FusionStorage distributed controller(more than 3) Huawei has the biggest bandwidth CPUIvybridge CPU The latest CPU Speed of Data load SAS(120M) 6GB FC 56GB infiniband + FusionStorage distributed controller(more than 3) Huawei has 3-6x throughput of data load SAS(120M)SSD(read : 3.2GB/s)The faster persistency layer High reliability Storage self- recovering Rebalance time:< 12h/TRebalance time:<0.5h/T24x data recover speed HA No SPOF, 2 rack switchNo SPOF, 4 switch modulesMore redundant Data storage: Raid 5Data storage: Raid10-likeBetter reliability Low TCO Density of single rack 3T RAM* (4*1T HANA nodes, 3*Worker+1*Standby) 11T RAM ( 12*1T HANA nodes, 11*Worker+1*Standby) Huawei has 3.3x density Density of 16 nodes 4 racks2 racks2x 15T RAM 1x Power consumption 30KW/16*1T nodes27KW/16*1T nodesAbout 1.1x of power density Deployment difficulty complex cable connections among multi devices, need outer switch simple cable connection between chassis, no need outer switch The simpler deployment Unified management Different management Unified management of computing/storage/network Cloud supportyes Same 3T 11T,3.3x Huawei VS. HP

43 42 FactorItemDellHuaweiComment(Huawei/Dell) High performance Latency of Log Volume 6GB FC+ SSD (15us)56GB infiniband + NVDIMM(200ns)Huawei has the lowest latency Throughput of Data Volume 6GB FC+ Only two controller 56GB infiniband + FusionStorage distributed controller(more than 3) Huawei has the biggest bandwidth CPUWestmere CPUIvybridge CPU(new generation cpu) The latest CPU, 2~3 X performance than westmere cpu Speed of Data load 6GB FC+ Only two controller 56GB infiniband + FusionStorage distributed controller(more than 3) Huawei has 3-6x throughput of data load SAS(120M)SSD(read : 3.2GB/s)The faster persistency layer High reliability Storage self- recovering Rebalance time:< 12h/TRebalance time:<0.5h/T24x data recover speed HA No SPOF, 2 rack switchNo SPOF, 4 switch modulesMore redundant Data storage: Raid 5Data storage: Raid10-like Low TCO Density of single rack 2T RAM* (5*512G HANA nodes) 11T RAM ( 12 *1T HANA nodes) Huawei has 5.5x density Density of 16 nodes 4 racks2 racks2x 7.5T RAM15T RAM2x Power consumption 28KW/16*512G nodes27KW/16*1T nodes2x ofpower density Deployment difficulty complex cable connections among multi devices, need outer switch simple cable connection between chassis, no need outer switch The simpler deployment Unified management Different management Unified management of computing/storage/network Cloud supportyes Same 2T 11T,5.5x Huawei VS. Dell

44 Copyright©2012 Huawei Technologies Co., Ltd. All Rights Reserved. The information in this document may contain predictive statements including, without limitation, statements regarding the future financial and operating results, future product portfolio, new technology, etc. There are a number of factors that could cause actual results and developments to differ materially from those expressed or implied in the predictive statements. Therefore, such information is provided for reference purpose only and constitutes neither an offer nor an acceptance. Huawei may change the information at any time without notice. HUAWEI ENTERPRISE ICT SOLUTIONS A BETTER WAY

45 44 Q&A-1 1.How to upgrade from 1T to 2T, 4T or 6T smoothly?  The time window to upgrade is very short, so smoothly is not the most important thing.  The release of Intel CPU’s frequency is once a year. (see Q&A-4)  SAP HANA can not make two different generations of CPU running on the same system  Customer just have one year window to upgrade hardware which also faces old and new CPU architecture choices.(Performance have 50%~100% improved from new version to old version) (see Q&A-5)  There are no vendor have the perfect program of smoothly upgrade. 1.Same computing/storage/fans/power models with different chassis. (IBM x6)  High initial cost.(see Q&A-2)  Replace chassis.(see Q&A-2)  New CPU platform to choose.(see Q&A-5) 2.Same computing/storage/fans/power models with same chassis (Fujitsu, Huawei RH8100)  High initial cost (higher than program 1).(see Q&A-2)  Lower CPU performance(30% lower).( see Q&A-3)  New CPU platform to choose.(see Q&A-5) 3.Different architecture for 4-socket and 8-socket (HP, Huawei RH5885H V3)  Incompatible with 4 socket and 8 socket.  Best initial cost

46 45 1.How to upgrade of IBM or Fujitsu? Q&A-2 IBM: 128G~2T 4T~6T  High initial cost (CPU(8-way), chassis, blade, etc)  Replace Chassis, Add new models (CPU, memory, etc)  New CPU platform to choose ( E7 V3 will release at Q or Q )  there is no guarantee subsequent upgrades Maintenance upgrade 3850 X X6 Fujitsu 2800E : 128G~2T 4T~6T  High initail cost (4*CPU(8-way), chassis, blade, etc) upgrade  New CPU platform to choose ( E7 V3 will release at Q or Q )  Lower performance(4*CPU(8-way), lose two QPI lines,30% drop)

47 46 1.Why performance will be lower from using 4 CPU in 8socket architecture CPU1 CPU2 CPU4 CPU3 4 socket CPU1 CPU2 CPU4 CPU3 CPU5 CPU6 CPU8 CPU7 8 socket Lack two QPI lines if use as 4 socket in 8 socket architecture 25~30% CPU performance Q&A-3

48 47 Q&A-4 Intel® Microarchitecture Codename Nehalem TOCK New Micro- architecture Nehalem 45nm TICK Westmere 32nm New Process Technology Intel® Microarchitecture Codename Sandy Bridge TOCK Sandy Bridge 32nm New Micro- architecture TICK Ivy Bridge 22nm New Process Technology Intel® Microarchitecture Codename Haswell TOCK Haswell 22nm New Micro- architecture TICK Broad well 14nm New Process Technology Intel® Microarchitecture Codename skylake TOCK Skylake 14nm New Micro- architecture TICK Future 11nm New Process Technology GrantlyRomleyTylersburgPurely 1.What is the roadmap of Intel? SAP HANA can not make two different generations of CPU running on the same system

49 48 Q&A-5 1.Why new version CPU is popular?  There are 50%~100% performance improvement from new version to old version. So do you want to buy the old one when new version is released?


Download ppt "Huawei solutions for SAP HANA - Competition analysis."

Similar presentations


Ads by Google