Presentation on theme: "Dr. Dianne Cothran, Dr. Mickey Schafer, "— Presentation transcript:
1Taming the dissertation/thesis beast What we wish we had known and didn’t know to ask Dr. Dianne Cothran,Dr. Mickey Schafer,Dial Center for Written and Oral Communication
2There are 4 phases to the project Phase One – search for a project, write the proposalPhase Two – conduct literature review, begin “experimental” phasePhase Three – Freak out and Revise studyPhase Four – Write the dissertationNote: the formality of each depends on your field!
3Phase I: Write a Proposal/Prospectus Main objective – lay out the plan for the projectCommittee needs to know that:You know something about what you are doingYou have a workable RQYou have a planAnd yes, they do know all this may change.
4Proposals have 4 parts Part One – Exec Summary/Significance Short (1-2 paragraph) overview of topic, why it is significant, RQ, why RQ is significantPart Two – Lit Review2-5 page exploration of expert literature in topic areaPart Three – MethodologyLay out timeline, materials, cost, procedure,etc.Part Four – Tentative BibliographyDemonstrate you know your stuff
5Proposals vary in formality In some fields, the proposal is an extremely important document – it’s a step on the way to PhD candidacyIn other fields, the proposal is a planning step – the committee wants to see it in order to help youSome fields may not require a proposal at all – you should still write one for the purpose of planning procrastination!
6Phase 2: Research is driven by questions. Method – is how you answer the RQThe best way to get research done is to formulate a question – just one question!You may need smaller questions along the wayYour RQ answers grad students’ least favorite question: “What’s your thesis about?”RQ Wh-question, may be yes/no, but that takes some serious you-know-what-body-part
7Methodology is Discipline Specific. Humanities– lots of thinking, reading, more thinking, and some more readingNew Methods for Humanities Research --Digital Research Tools Kit --
8Method: SSB Social and Behavioral Sciences – IRB? Quantitative (stats driven)Qualitative (words/analysis driven)Mixed (umm, well, both!)Web Center for Social Research Methods --Digital Research Tools Kit --
9Methods: bio/phys Biological and Physical Sciences – P.I.’s project QuantitativeDiscipline-specific research protocolsBioexplorer.net --JOVE (Journal of Visualized Experiments) --
10Phase 3: Freak out and Revise If you don’t do this once, your committee gets worried that they have nothing to do!Seriously, it’s pretty normal to get part way through and hit a big, nasty existential crisis on the meaning/value/utility/ worthiness of your project. This seems to be a natural product of Deep Thought.
11Phase 4: Write the PaperLook at models in your department – get inspiration and direction from what others have doneDoing something that isn’t well represented by former graduate students? Look at published stuff.Hand-draw drafts of visuals
12More on writing:Start writing with what you know/are most comfortable withYou will need to pre-write!Make outlines and concept maps, paint a blackboard on your bedroom wall, use giant sticky pads, draw cartoon bubblesUse your proposal to guide the first couple of chapters
13One last slide: Make the Results section mirror Methods For the Conclusion, don’t re-hash the Results; interpret them!Write the abstract lastAbove all, BE CLEARThis may seem obvious, but your committee doesn’t live inside your head with you and you will really have to explain everythingDecide what needs to be published
14Use Visuals Effectively Use the terms “figure” and “table”Number figures/tables consecutively throughout the entire dissertation or thesisGive each visual a descriptive titleIn the text of your dissertation/thesis, discuss each table and figure
16Tips for Taming the Beast Be flexibleCommunicate with major professor/ committeeHave a plan for workKnow the rulesExpect things to go wrongBack up your workA collection of links for you at:
17In summary. . . Have a plan/schedule for writing Expect delays/obstacles/disastersField test your work as you go along with people other than your committeeRemember, others have made it, and SO WILL YOU!
18Defending your Dissertation Teaching the Beast to Behave
19What is a Defense?Purpose of the PhD process is to birth a colleague – ultimately, committee needs proof that you can “think” like a member of the discipline – this means demonstrating that you know:
20What makes your discipline unique; your discipline’s key ideas / concepts / contributionsthe kinds of questions your discipline asksthe methodology the discipline uses to answer questions
21How to be a member of the club. can design/work within discipline’s methodology/frame to critique within fieldthat you can use all of the above to innovate/practice in your field the defense especially tests the last 2 points: that you understand your discipline well enough to critique in the framework of your discipline and hypothesize at the boundaries of what you know in a way that is recognizably discipline-specific.
22Defending is not supposed to be easy. The high-stakes portion of your defense is supposed to push you to the point you “break” – i.e., that you cannot answer a question with content-knowledge, but must “guess” (remember, in academics we call intelligent guessing “hypothesizing”).
23You cannot possibly know everything. Get past the desire to be master of all content because…Content exists as a product of method/ approach/process.It is more important that you can demonstrate HOW your discipline works.
24What are you defending?“dissertation defense” may be a misnomer since there can be more than one thing that needs defending…ProposalQualifying ExamsDissertationAND different defenses can have different outcomes attached:High Stakes, Lower Stakes, No defenseAll But Dissertation
25Step One: Find out what you need to defend. What do you have to prepare?What do you have to produce?What do you have to defend?Note: dissertation defenses are usually public (they have to be advertised and are open to everyone) – however, proposal and quals defenses are often private.
26Step Two: Find out what options you have for defending. Is there a presentation preceding questions? (If this is an option, take it!)Are visuals allowed? What formats are permitted (.ppt, poster, handouts)?How long does the process usually take? (the longer the process, the more preparation is required)
27Step Three: Prepare the Defense Create a “map” of your proposal / quals / dissertation – whatever it is that you need to defend.For each section, list the main ideas. For each main idea, map out related literature (include author/s & dates, and page # in your work), related evidence (data: your stuff, too), and potential objections.“Potential Objections” are the KEY to controlling your defense. Think objectively about your work, your claims, the way you constructed arguments (if you cannot do this or there isn’t enough time, find someone in your department who will). Generate reasonable objections. Then, prepare answers to those objections.
28Prepare a Presentation (if an option) Think of this more like a conference presentation to colleagues rather than a defense.Incorporate the most important objections into your presentation, and (of course), provide your response.Keep to time limits – if only given 10 minutes, then hit the main points: topic/significance,“research question”, “method”, “results”, and contribution to field. Work in objections briefly, if time (if no time, then reserve that preparation for the Q/A period).If 20 minutes, that’s enough time to get across main points and address major objections.
29Step Four: Go Forth and Defend! Get out the “map” you made and have it handy – be familiar with it so you can find things easily – make sure it’s neat, legible, and usable.Even for a high stakes defense, keep it cordial. This is an academic conversation…you should remain calm. Let your committee members be the ones to argue (and they just might!). It helps if you’ve had sufficient sleep and decent food in the previous 24 hours!Typical academic questions to expect:
30Prepare for “other” questions Be prepared to answer “soft” questions – how you decided on this research question; what do you think is most important “take away” point; what do you think is the most damning problem; can you apply it/extend it; what should come next; if you could do it over, what would be different; what do you want to do next? (http://www.dissertationdoctor.com/advice/questions.html)Be mentally prepared for questions that just seem weird – maybe they are “left field” questions, maybe you don’t understand the significance of the question (even though you know the answer,), maybe it’s something so specific and nitpicky that you didn’t even identify it as a possible problem.Feel free to ask for clarification, e.g. “That’s an interesting question, but to make sure, [restate Q]– is that what you meant?”
31Prepare for disagreement, digression Be mentally prepared to disagree with a committee member, to actually “defend” your work. Remain civil and confident.The“A but B” strategy is an effective, academic-y way of dealing with conflict. “A” are the points of agreement, “but” is whichever logical connector works best (still, yet, however, nonetheless, despite, etc.), and “B” represents the counterpoints, e.g. “yes, while it’s true that X, Y, and Z are traditionally agreed upon, inconsistencies in the way that Y is defined weakens the likelihood that it can account for Z. Instead, if Y is broken down into U and V, then Z is a far likelier outcome”.Committee members may digress into their own conversation – enjoy the break!
32Hungry people make grouchy audiences! A Final suggestion…feed the beasts! And by “beasts” we mean your committee members, who are not at all beastly, yet may nonetheless appreciate food & drink.Fruit, cheese, bread/cracker platters can be eaten any time during the day.Bring coffee/juice/water. No alcohol!May bring home-cooked food but be smart about choice.Remember plates, forks/spoons, cups, napkins.Keep is simple and modest.Before including food, check with department.