Presentation on theme: "There’s more to sentiments than you think!"— Presentation transcript:
1There’s more to sentiments than you think! Guest lecture in Muhammad Abdul-Mageed’s S604: Social Media Mining, Indiana University, March 6, 2013By David Heise Rudy Professor of Sociology Emeritus, IU
2Sentiment analysis assesses people’s emotionality from texts that they produce. It answers the question: When talking about X, are people happy or unhappy?The trouble is…
3Emotions cover a lot more territory than just happy and unhappy! Pleasant vs. unpleasant; stillness vs. arousal; dominant vs. vulnerable.So if you assess just happiness and unhappiness, you’re missing a lot of what people are feeling and expressing in their texts.
4There are three affective dimensions: Badness versus Goodness (unpleasant-pleasant)Weakness versus Powerfulness (vulnerable-dominant)Quiescence versus Activation (stillness-arousal)Research projects in 30 different cultures have verified these dimensions.Osgood, Charles E., W. H. May, and M. S. Miron Cross-Cultural Universals of Affective Meaning. Urbana, IL: University of Illinois Press.Heise, D. R Surveying Cultures: Discovering Shared Conceptions and Sentiments. Hoboken, NJ, Wiley Interscience.Scholl, Wolfgang. 2013. The socio-emotional basis of human interaction and communication: How we construct our social world. Social Science Information, 52(1), 3–33.The three dimensions are a universal basis for how people affectively respond to all kinds of stimuli, including other people and their behaviors.
5Measuring affective response The affective meanings of words, phrases, pictures, sounds, or smells are measured with computerized scales, one for each dimension.I think stimulus is “being female”
6Measurement detailsEach stimulus gets a three-number profile, corresponding to measurements on Evaluation, Potency, Activity (EPA).Measurements range from -4 (bad, powerless, inactive) to +4 (good, powerful, active)Stimuli typically are rated by respondents, and averages over all respondents constitute the final EPA profile.
7Example EPA measurements of words by IU male students in 2002-2004 PeopleBehaviorsModifiersWordEPAchampion126.96.36.199rescuing2.61.9adventurous2.3grandparent2.71.5-1.0praying with1.81.7-1.3peaceful2.8-1.8child1.4-0.82.1lusting for1.00.2feminine0.6-0.40.0senior citizen1.2-0.9obeying-0.5cautious-0.2-0.7politicianfighting-1.62.0enraged-1.2executioner-2.0incarcerating0.7-0.6dogmatic0.3prostitute-1.9babbling topanicked-1.7victim-2.4stealing from-2.9cowardly-2.1±1 = slightly, ±2 = quite, ±3 = extremely
8GoodBadchampion, grandparent, child, senior citizen, rescuing, praying with, lusting for, obeying, adventurous, peaceful, feminine, cautiouspolitician, executioner, prostitute, victim, fighting, incarcerating, babbling to, stealing from, enraged, dogmatic, panicked, cowardlyThese words can be used as indicators of good (favorable) versus bad (unfavorable) in sentiment analyses of social media.The same words can be used as indicators of power versus weakness.PowerfulPowerlesschampion, grandparent, politician, executioner, rescuing, praying with, fighting, incarcerating, adventurous, peaceful, enraged, dogmaticchild, senior citizen, prostitute, victim, lusting for, obeying, babbling to, stealing from, feminine, cautious, panicked, cowardlyLivelyQuietchampion, child, politician, prostitute, rescuing, lusting for, fighting, babbling to, adventurous, feminine, enraged, panickedgrandparent, senior citizen, executioner, victim, praying with, obeying, incarcerating, stealing from, peaceful, cautious, dogmatic, cowardlyAnd the same words can be used as indicators of activation versus passivity.
9Setting up program Interact. Affect control theory uses the three dimensions and a mathematized theory to predict people’s behaviors.“ACT is one of the most encompassing and precise social-psychological theories, translating … qualitative, phenomenological approaches … into an exact quantitative system with point predictions that deliver astonishing plausible results” (Scholl, 2013: 21)Setting up program Interact.Predicting behaviors.Interact is at
10You can’t do all that with just one dimension! With three dimensions and a mathematized theory that people maintain their sentiments about self and other, we can predict behaviors, emotions, attributions, and labelings.With one dimension, we would know that the father should do some friendly act toward his daughter. But should he rescue her, pray with her, lust for her, obey her, or what?You can’t do all that with just one dimension!
11Where do you get the EPA data? Suppose you want to do three-dimensional sentiment analyses.Where do you get the EPA data?
12Getting EPAs for words in Interact. Available Cultures: Indiana Texas 1998 North Carolina 1978 Ontario Canada Ontario Canada 2001 N. Ireland 1977 Germany 1989 Japan China-PRC 1991 Deutsch Germany 1989 Deutsch Germany 2007malesfemalesinstitutionsUse of data noted here is free for researchers. Fees apply for commercial applications.
13Or download an Excel file of 5001 words rated in English.
14Have any 3-D sentiment analyses been done? Some related research. Heise, D. R. (1966). "Sensitization of verbal response-dispositions by n Affiliation and n Achievement." Journal of Verbal Learning and Verbal Behavior 5:Computed the distance between EPA profiles of 1,000 words and EPA profiles representing need-for-affiliation and need-for-achievement. Result: each word scored for each need.137 Ss wrote stories in response to four pictures. Need-scores of words in an S’s stories were averaged to score the individual on each need.Results. n-affiliation: Text-based scores correlated 0.64 with standard method of scoring needs. n-achievement: Text-based scores correlated 0.36 with standard method, and 0.30 with an experimental measure of the need. Significance: text analyses, p < .001; experiment, p < .05.Anderson, C. W., and G. E. McMaster, Computer assisted modeling of affective tone in written documents. Computers and the Humanities 16: 1-9.Literary tension = words’ Activity minus Evaluation.Plot of tension in Joyce Carol Oates’ Wonderland, chapter where son discovers his father has murdered whole family.Same pattern of bad-activation characterizes the dramatic peak in children’s stories like Peter Rabbit.sees murdersThat was my dissertation!
15The End! Recent ACT publications by Heise. This PowerPoint presentation can be downloaded from:Recent ACT publications by Heise.Heise, David R. (2007). Expressive Order: Confirming Sentiments in Social Actions. New York: Springer.Affect control theory, its research program, and its math model.Heise, David R. (2010). Surveying Cultures: Discovering Shared Conceptions and Sentiments. Hoboken, NJ: Wiley Interscience.Reviews research on EPA, and methodology of EPA measurement.MacKinnon, Neil J., & Heise, David R. (2010). Self, Identity, and Social Institutions. New York: Palgrave.Expansion of affect control theory to the topics in the title.Heise, David R. (2013). Modeling interactions in small groups, Social Psychology Quarterly. March issue.Application of affect control theory to small-group interactions.